Routes in the Extension Areas of the Yorkshire Dales National Park
(with possible or proven public mechanically propelled vehicular rights)
Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority
October 2016
IMAGE: Cover page bearing the title “ROUTES IN THE EXTENSION AREAS OF THE YORKSHIRE DALES NATIONAL PARK (with possible or proven public mechanically propelled vehicular rights)”, the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority logo, and the date “October 2016”.
Introduction
The Yorkshire Dales National Park was extended on 1 August 2016 to include new areas in Cumbria and Lancashire. These new areas of Cumbria and Lancashire include 36 byways and unsurfaced unclassified roads. These routes have been managed by the county councils – in the case of Cumbria County Council through its Hierarchy of Trail Routes. Maps of these routes is in Appendix 4.
The Findings of the Cumbria Hierarchy of Trail Routes
Cumbria County Council has used volunteers to survey routes to assess how sustainable the use of the route is, and which “colour” each route should be. People can then access this information from their website. The definition of the colour coding system is:
Red: Route has a lot of use, proceed with great care and follow advice or signs explaining special controls in place. These routes are under the greatest pressure or conflict between different users and the environment.
Amber: Route has moderate use, proceed with special care - there may be a lot of other users or land management issues. It may not be passable in all weathers.
Green: Proceed with caution - the route is passable at all times and there may be no management in place.
In the new area of the National Park 16 routes have been assessed. Many of the other routes are either very short or cul-de-sacs. Of the assessed routes, 13 are green, two are amber and one red. The survey forms are contained in Appendix 1.
The ‘red’ route is Ravenstonedale Common (BOAT) and the ‘amber’ routes are Bank Head (BOAT) at Crosby Ravensworth and The High Way (BOAT).
Sensitivity Assessment
The Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority used a Sensitivity Assessment process in 2006 to prioritise which byways and unsurfaced unclassified roads should be looked at in detail. The detailed reports then formed the evidence on which decisions about the management of any ‘green lane’ could be based.
The 2006 assessment methodology is still fit for purpose. This combined the potential demand to use a route by motor vehicles with an assessment of four other factors: nature conservation, heritage, route surface and tranquillity.
The methodology for the Sensitivity Assessment is contained in Appendix 2. It should be noted that this is a desk top exercise and does not involve any field work. The basic model for this work is shown below.
Trigger Factors Assessment Sensitivity Evaluation
IMAGE: Diagram showing the assessment process. The trigger factors are nature conservation, heritage, surface and tranquillity. These feed into an “Assessment of sensitivity”, producing RED, AMBER or GREEN sensitivity ratings, followed by “Ground truth survey, and further data collection and evaluation (in line with the Green Lanes Framework)”.
All 36 unsurfaced unclassified roads and byways have been assessed using this methodology. The findings of the Sensitivity Assessment are in Appendix 3. Five routes potentially have high sensitivity to motor vehicle, one was found to be moderate sensitivity and the rest have low potential sensitivity.
The five routes with high potential sensitivity are:
- Bank Head at Crosby Ravensworth (BOAT 319004)
- A UUR at Smardale Mill close to Waitby (U3302)
- BOAT running north from Waitby village
- Ravenstonedale Common (BOAT)
- The High Way (BOAT)
As can be seen there is good correlation with the Cumbria HoTR.
Next steps
There is a need to ground truth the findings of the Sensitivity Assessment, particularly for the two routes which do not match the Cumbria HoTR findings. From both methods it is clear that the most vulnerable route is the byway across Ravenstonedale Common.
Appendix 1
IMAGE: Appendix 1 contains scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” documents for individual routes. The forms record route numbers, OS maps, grid references, lengths, locations, CCC classifications, surveyors, dates, surface types, surface conditions, weather sensitivity, ecological and farming considerations, route descriptions, access conditions, vehicle accessibility and width. The scanned forms are not legible in the supplied parsed text.
Appendix 2
1. Methodology used for the Yorkshire Dales National Park assessment of unsealed routes
1.1 Demand for the use of the route
Mapping potential demand of individual routes is important to ensure that management decisions take into account wider network considerations. Long routes with good links into other parts of the network of unsurfaced routes and the wider road network are likely to have a high potential demand for recreational motor vehicle users, whereas short isolated routes or ones that are effectively dead ends for motor vehicles would be expected to attract little use.
The level of potential demand will therefore inform appropriate management responses. A popular route in a highly sensitive area is likely to require a different approach to management than a route, in the same area, which is a short dead-end not used by motorised vehicle users.
In considering this factor the level of use of a route by walkers, cyclists, horse riders and carriage drivers is also taken into account, together with use as part of a promoted recreational route.
The potential demand/level of use of a route is also necessary to inform the sensitivity of a route with the different factors to be considered. Clearly the impact of motor vehicles on nature conservation, heritage, the route surface and tranquillity is likely to depend on the number of motor vehicles using the route. Routes which are unattractive to recreational motor vehicle users and have low levels of use/potential demand, are likely to be less sensitive.
Potential route demand has been assessed using the criteria in the table below.
| Evidence potential demand/level of use | Potential Demand |
|---|---|
| Route with poor connectivity to the rest of the network with little value to recreational motor vehicle users (eg. joins road link to a footpath). Routes with little history of use by recreational motor vehicles. | LOW |
| Routes with moderate connectivity and/or moderate potential demand. Includes short linking routes and long no through routes for motor vehicles. | MODERATE |
| Route with high levels of connectivity, and/or high appeal to motorised users and/or other non-motorised users (joins two road links or joins road link to another unsurfaced route). | HIGH |
1.2 Ecological sensitivity of the route
Nature designations provide useful initial criteria for assessing the sensitivity of a habitat to the potential physical impacts of motorised vehicles. National Nature Reserve and Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) carry the highest national designations for nature conservation with international designations Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) and Specially Protected Areas (SPAs) carrying even higher protection. In addition nature designations including and Local Nature Reserve could provide important information on the relative sensitivity of these sites to pressure from users. In the National Park there are also areas with a high ecological sensitivity that are not covered by local, national or international designations but are still important habitats and have sensitive species particularly of breeding birds.
Where a route passes through a designated area, it does not automatically mean that the presence of motor vehicles will damage the wildlife of the site. This would depend on the reasons for the designation, or wildlife interest, the level of use, and the nature of the route surface. In addition areas where there is no formal wildlife designation, can have ecological sensitivity eg because of the numbers of national important breeding birds.
Ecological sensitivity has been assessed using the criteria in the table below.
| Evidence on ecological sensitivity | Ecological sensitivity |
|---|---|
| Low sensitivity. | GREEN |
| Moderate or unknown. Land in ESA agreements or of botanical interest. May have national or European designations but not thought to have highly sensitive features. | AMBER |
| High sensitivity. National or European designations which may have vulnerable features. Highly sensitive features such as blanket bog or flushes. Important and sensitive species. | RED |
1.3 Heritage sensitivity of a route
Assessment of the sensitivity of heritage features along a route relates directly to the records of scheduled monuments. In developing the criteria for heritage features, proximity to the route is an important factor, together with the potential sensitivity of the feature to disturbance through the impacts of motor vehicles.
Heritage sensitivity has been assessed using the criteria in the table below.
| Heritage sensitivity | Heritage sensitivity |
|---|---|
| Low sensitivity. No vulnerable heritage features identified. | GREEN |
| Moderate or unknown sensitivity. | AMBER |
| High sensitivity. sensitivity heritage features along route, or in close proximity. | RED |
1.4 Surface sensitivity of a route
The ability of a route to sustain use by motor vehicles is considered to largely dependent on the existing route surface, topography and drainage of the route. The route surface can vary from deep peat, through grassland on top of limestone, to a stony track. On some routes, extensive changes have been made to the drainage and surface through engineering works.
The Surface sensitivity of the routes was then scored according to the following criteria:
| Evidence of surface sensitivity | Surface sensitivity |
|---|---|
| Good quality surface and drainage eg stone track with good surface water run-off. | GREEN |
| Moderate quality surface with good drainage and topography, or good quality surface but the drainage is a significant factor. Routes where extensive engineering work has been carried out. | AMBER |
| Vegetation surface eg acid grassland over peat, or moderate quality surface where drainage and/or topography are significant factors. | RED |
1.5 Tranquil area assessment
Tranquillity has been identified as one of the key special qualities that affect the recreational experience in the National Park. An assessment of the tranquil areas of the National Park was carried out using a model developed by the Council for the Protection of Rural England (CPRE). This involves identifying major sources of noise generation in and around the National Park such as major roads, quarries and railways and mapping these. Buffers are then drawn around these noise sources which will then show the parts of the National Park expected to have the highest levels of tranquillity. Details of the features that were identified are in Appendix 1.
The mere fact that a route is in a tranquil area, is not in itself sufficient to say that it is highly sensitive. This has to be combined with the level of use a route receives, in the same way that the impact on nature conservation, heritage or surface condition would be dependant on level of use. Clearly one motor bike a month using a route, will have much less effect on tranquillity than 5 a day. The key issue is determining what ‘threshold’, of recreational motor vehicle use, disturbs tranquillity.
The DEFRA and Countryside Agency, ‘Report of a research project on motor vehicles on byways open to all traffic - Defra (2005)¹, found that the average daily flow of motor vehicles across all BOATS studied was 4.2 motor vehicles (see page 103). This figure must be treated with caution as it includes motor vehicular use to access property or for land management along the routes. This research quantified, light, moderate and heavy use:
- 5% of byways carried no motor vehicle traffic;
- 35% of byways carried light traffic, and had an average daily flow of 0.6 [0.2] motor vehicles which varied from 0.1 to 1.1 motor vehicles. The highest recorded daily flows averaged 11 [4] motor vehicles;
- 50% of byways carried moderate traffic, and had an average daily flow of 5.0 [1.9] motor vehicles which varied from 1.5 to 11.4 motor vehicles. The highest recorded daily flows averaged 37 [14] motor vehicles; and
- 10% of byways carried heavy traffic, and had an average daily flow of 13.4 [5.1] motor vehicles which varied from 11.9 to 14.9 motor vehicles. The highest recorded daily flows averaged 82 [31] motor vehicles.
These figures are for all motor vehicle traffic, and only 38% of the vehicular traffic recorded was believed to be recreational in nature (see page 111). So the figures above, shown in square brackets, are to show the proportion of recreational motor vehicles.
In addition the research also found, that on average there was no motorised traffic on 40% of days.
The tranquillity of the routes is assessed according to the following criteria:
| Evidence on tranquillity | Tranquillity sensitivity |
|---|---|
| Route close to significant noise sources with less than 30% of the route in tranquil area and moderate use/potential demand, or 30% to 80% of route in tranquil area with light use/potential demand. | GREEN |
| 30% to 80% of route in tranquil area with moderate use/potential demand, or less than 30% in tranquil area with heavy levels of use/potential demand, or more than 80% of route in tranquil area and with light level of use/potential demand. | AMBER |
| 30% to 80% of route in tranquil area with heavy use/potential demand or more than 80% of route in tranquil area and with moderate or heavy level of use/potential demand. | RED |
¹ Report of a research project on motor vehicles on byways open to all traffic - Defra (2005)
See http://www.defra.gov.uk/wildlife-countryside/cl/mpv/pdf/researchrep-veh.pdf
Appendix 3
| Type | Name | Start | End | Parishes | Notes | CCC hierarchy class | Length (m) | SSSI | SAM | Surface | Tranquillity | Potential demand | Sensitivity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UUR | Wickerslack | NY 607 156 | NY 608 151 | Crosby Ravensworth | green | 525.00 | no | no | grass/gravel | 100% | Low | Low | |
| BOAT | NY 674 161 | NY 677 157 | Hoff | green | 529.00 | no | no | stone | 100% | Low | Low | ||
| BOAT | NY 673 155 | NY 682 159 | Hoff | cul-de-sac | green | 1260.00 | no | no | stone | 100% | Low | Low | |
| BOAT | Slack Randy | NY 621 140 | NY 620 137 | Crosby Ravensworth | cul-de-sac | 353.00 | no | no | 100% | Low | Low | ||
| BOAT | Bank Head | NY 629 139 | NY 637 130 | Crosby Ravensworth | amber | 1250.00 | no | no | grass | 100% | Moderate | High | |
| BOAT | NY 691 126 | NY 689 121 | Asby | cul-de-sac | 520.00 | no | no | 100% | Low | Low | |||
| BOAT | NY 674 124 | NY 677 124 | Asby | short | green | 354.00 | no | no | 100% | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Newclose Lane | NY 717 110 | NY 713 092 | Crosby Garrett | cul-de-sac | 1900.00 | no | no | 80% | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Smardale Mill | NY 741 093 | NY 743 098 | Waitby | green | 480.00 | no | no | stone | 100% | Moderate | High | |
| BOAT | NY 755 094 | NY 752 083 | Waitby | green | 1190.00 | no | Adjacent | stone | 85% | Moderate | High | ||
| BOAT | Knots Lane | NY 641 084 | NY 639 080 | Orton | cul-de-sac | 535.00 | no | no | 100% | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Park Lane | NY 612 089 | NY 611 084 | Orton | cul-de-sac | 550.00 | No | no | 0% | Low | Low | ||
| BOAT | NY 636 065 | NY 656 058 | Orton | green | 2400.00 | No | no | tarmac/stone | 50 | Moderate | Low | ||
| UUR | NY 644 052 | NY 645 050 | Orton | cul-de-sac | 134.00 | no | no | 0% | Low | Low | |||
| BOAT | NY 772 045 | NY 780 030 | Wharton, Mallerstang | green | 2305.00 | no | no | grass | 75 | Moderate | Moderate | ||
| BOAT | Ravenstonedale Common | NY 666 073 | NY 694 061 | Ravenstonedale | red | 3155.00 | Yes | no | Soft | 100 | Moderate | High | |
| BOAT | NY 724 043 | NY 725 041 | Ravenstonedale | short | 305.00 | no | no | 0 | Low | Low | |||
| BOAT | NY 686 050 | NY 686 048 | Ravenstonedale | cul-de-sac | 165.00 | no | no | 0 | Low | Low | |||
| UUR | NY 724 023 | NY 726 022 | Ravenstonedale | cul-de-sac | 205.00 | no | no | 100 | Low | Low | |||
| BOAT | The High Way | NY 783 004 | SD 786 969 | Mallerstang | amber | 3880.00 | Yes | no | grass/gravel | 95 | Moderate | High | |
| UUR | Murthwaite | SD 718 991 | SD 715 987 | Ravenstonedale | cul-de-sac | 560.00 | no | no | 0 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Uldale | SD 729 971 | SD 731 969 | Ravenstonedale | cul-de-sac | 260.00 | no | no | 100 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Stangerthwaite | SD 623 897 | SD 619 892 | Killington | cul-de-sac | 590.00 | no | no | 100 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Aikrigg | SD 605 884 | SD 609 885 | Killington | cul-de-sac | 415.00 | no | no | 100 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | Low Lane | SD 620 857 | SD 620 850 | Middleton | cul-de-sac | green | 750.00 | no | no | grass/stone | 0 | Low | Low |
| BOAT | SD 622 846 | SD 625 845 | Middleton | short | green | 405.00 | no | no | 0 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR/BOAT | Fell Lane | SD 596 834 | SD 603 837 | Mansergh | 915.00 | no | no | tarmac | 100 | Moderate | Low | ||
| UUR | Chapel Lane north | SD 603 837 | SD 602 830 | Mansergh | green | 780.00 | no | no | grass/stone | 100 | Low | Low | |
| UUR | Chapel Lane | SD 601 828 | SD 605 817 | Mansergh | green | 1215.00 | no | no | grass/stone | 100 | Low | Low | |
| UUR | SD 628 822 | SD 627 822 | Barbon | 190.00 | no | no | 100 | Low | Low | ||||
| UUR | Bull Pot Farm | SD 663 815 | SD 662 818 | Casterton | cul-de-sac | 285.00 | Yes | no | 100 | Low | Low | ||
| UUR | SD 628 799 | SD 633 802 | Casterton | cul-de-sac | 525.00 | no | no | 70 | Low | Low | |||
| UUR | SD 625 788 | SD 624 787 | Casterton | cul-de-sac | 160.00 | no | no | 0 | Low | Low | |||
| UUR | Devil’s Bridge | SD 613 783 | SD 616 782 | Kirkby Lonsdale | 290.00 | no | yes | tarmac | 0 | None | Low | ||
| UUR | Leck Fell Lane | SD 657 776 | SD 652 759 | Leck | 1910.00 | no | no | stone | 80 | Moderate | Low |
Appendix 4
IMAGE: Map titled “Northern area”, at scale 1:75000 and compiled on 18 October 2016. It shows the northern extension area around Crosby Ravensworth, Orton, Hoff, Great Asby, the M6 and surrounding routes.
IMAGE: Map titled “Northern area 2”, at scale 1:75000 and compiled on 18 October 2016. It shows the area around Orton, Tebay, Ravenstonedale, Smardale, Ravenstonedale Common and the Howgill Fells.
IMAGE: Map titled “Southern area”, at scale 1:75000 and compiled on 18 October 2016. It shows the southern extension area, including Sedbergh, Killington, Middleton, Mansergh, Barbon, Casterton, Kirkby Lonsdale and Leck. The map marks the route network and the Yorkshire Dales National Park boundary.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for BOAT 343004, location Lady Ann’s Highway. The form records OS Maps 91 and 98, grid references from 784 003 to 786 969, total and unsurfaced lengths of 3.8, a route classification marked amber, surveyor Ian Knowles, organisation or interest TRF, date 30/09/07, a surface of 70% crushed stone and 30% grass, and observations including “Crushed stone lane, repaired to a high standard, over open fell land”, “2 shallow stream crossings, several gates”, and “Continues into Yorkshire at southern end (Hell Gill)”.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for Ravenstonedale BOAT 357087, location Ravenstonedale Moor. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 667 073 to 694 061, total and unsurfaced lengths of 3.3 km, a red CCC classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a grass/moor surface, an SSSI crossing, and a warning that the soft surface can be damaged during or after wet weather.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3247, location Wickerslack. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 608 157 to 608 151, total length 1.29 and unsurfaced length 0.5, a green classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a surface of 50% crushed stone and 50% grass, and observations describing a grass track by woodland leading to a metalled track.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3250 and BOAT 319004, location south of Crosby Ravensworth. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 629 139 to 638 130, total length 2.59 and unsurfaced length 1.28, an amber classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a 100% grass surface, and the observation “Open crossing of unfenced pasture”.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3254 and BOAT 330005, location near Rutter Force. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 673 156 to 684 160, total length 1.59 and unsurfaced length 1.33, a green classification, surveyor Ian Knowles, date 01/09/07, a surface of 5% tarmac and 95% crushed stone, and the observation “Good gravel track leading onto tarmac and ford”.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3280 and BOAT 355021, location Fawcett Mill. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 636 065 to 656 058, total length 2.43 and unsurfaced length 1.2, a green classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a surface of 20% tarmac, 70% crushed stone and 10% grass, and observations describing an open tarmac/stone track, rutted grass and puddles.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3302, location Smardale Mill. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 743 097 to 742 093, total and unsurfaced lengths of 0.5, a green classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a 100% crushed stone surface, and the observation “Hedged lane with good surface, grass in middle”.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3306 and BOAT 371008, location Waitby. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 751 082 to 755 094, total and unsurfaced lengths of 1.32, a green classification, surveyor S. Pighills, date 04/08/07, a 100% crushed stone surface, and observations describing a hedged lane with a grassed middle and puddles in tractor ruts.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3417 and BOAT 359017, location Fell End. The form records OS Map 98, grid references from 724 994 to 727 992, total and unsurfaced lengths of 0.52, a green classification, surveyor Ian Knowles, date 30/09/07, a surface of 50% crushed stone and 50% rocky ground, and the observation “Short walled lane going into long ford which has a slippery and rocky surface”.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for U3419 and BOAT 343023, location Birkett Common. The form records OS Map 91, grid references from 772 046 to 780 030, total and unsurfaced lengths of 2.3, a green classification, surveyor Ian Knowles, date 30/09/07, a surface of 95% grass and 5% mud, and observations describing a farm gate leading onto an open grassy track with mud and puddles.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for route 5378, location Hawkin Hall. The form records OS Map 97, grid references from 619 857 to 619 850, total length 0.7 and unsurfaced length 0.6, a green classification, surveyor J. S. Pighills, date 23/08/07, a surface of 50% crushed stone and 50% grass, and observations describing a hedged lane used mainly for farm access.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for route 5386, location Mansergh. The form records OS Map 97, grid references from 602 830 to 603 837, total and unsurfaced lengths of 0.5, a green classification, surveyor J. S. Pighills, date 23/08/07, a surface of 20% crushed stone and 80% grass, and observations describing a narrow, overgrown single track between hedges.
IMAGE: Scanned “Cumbria Countryside Access — UCR and BOAT Survey Form” for route 5388, location Mansergh. The form records OS Map 97, grid references from 601 827 to 605 816, total length 1.25 and unsurfaced length 0.94, a green classification, surveyor J. S. Pighills, date 23/08/07, a surface of 50% crushed stone and 50% grass, and observations describing a wide hedged track leading through a field.