Enforcement Register
Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority
Development Management Enforcement Register
2009
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ER/52/34 & ENF/40 | Enforcement Notice | Land lying to the southwest of Bainbridge (OS Field 0809) | YDNPA | 23/03/2009 | 23/03/2009 | Change of use of the land from use from agricultural to use for mixed purposes namely (1) use for agriculture and (2) use for the siting of caravans for storage purposes unrelated to the agricultural use of the land | i) Stop using any part of the land for stationing caravans used for storage or other non-agricultural purposes. ii) Remove from the land all caravans referred to in paragraph 3 with their associated fixtures and fittings) | 04/05/2009 | Three months | N/A |
| ES/03/219 & ENF/42 | Breach of Condition Notice | Land at rear of Spedding House, Millthrop, Sedbergh LA10 5SP | YDNPA | 24/07/2009 | 24/07/2009 | Non-compliance with Condition 10 of planning permission S/03/41E. | Complete the stone facing of all the external walls of the storage building in accordance with the details of the planning permission | 24/07/2009 | 84 days | N/A |
| EC/47/13 & ENF/43 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Building known as Yeamans Cottage, Kirkby Malham, Skipton, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 13/08/2009 | 13/08/2009 | The conservatory is of a wholly inappropriate scale, form, materials and design, and is of significant harm to the character of the listed building | Demolish the conservatory making good any damage caused to the listed building by the said demolition by using materials to match those of the remaining part of the building | 24/09/2009 | Six months | Appeal Dismissed 10.05.10. and listed building enforcement notice upheld. Listed building consent refused for the retention of the works carried out |
| ER/56/46 & ENF/45 | Enforcement Notice | Land at East Hill Top, Countersett, Leyburn, North Yorkshire DL8 3DD | YDNPA | 13/11/2009 | 13/11/2009 | The following unauthorised operational development: (i) creation of a hardcore track; (ii) works to the Barn comprising: the creation of an opening in the north elevation of the barn and insertion of wooden double doors; and the removal of wooden boarding to the existing opening on the upper level of the south elevation of the barn and insertion of window frame and glazing | i) Remove the double doors in the north elevation of the barn and block up the opening created by using stone to match the remaining stonework of the barn. ii) Remove the window frame and glazing inserted in the opening on the upper level of the south elevation of the barn and reinstate the wooden boarding. iii) Dig up the hardcore track and reinstate the affected area by covering with topsoil and reseeding with grass | 29/12/2009 | Six months | Appeal Withdrawn 11.06.10 |
| EC/48/9C & ENF/46 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Station Road, Langcliffe (OS Field 1646), Settle, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 10/12/2009 | 10/12/2009 | Change of use of the land from use for agricultural purposes to use for mixed purposes namely (1) use for agriculture and (2) use for the stationing of a caravan and trailer for storage purposes unrelated to the agricultural use of the land | i) Stop using any part of the land for the stationing of a caravan and trailer used for storage or other non-agricultural purposes. ii) Remove from the land the caravan and trailer referred to in paragraph 3 above | 21/01/2010 | Three months | N/A |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2009 Development Management Enforcement Register, listing enforcement notices, breach of condition notices and listed building enforcement notices with their dates, locations, alleged breaches, requirements and compliance information.
2010
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/45/18 | Section 215 Notice | Land at 3 Blea Moor Cottage, Ribblehead, Chapel le Dale, Lancashire LA6 3ET | YDNPA | 12/02/2010 | 12/02/2010 | Storage of equipment | Remove from the land the following items: (i) One caravan; (ii) Five disused oil tanks; (iii) Two shipping containers; (iv) one Daihatsu Fourtrak 4x4 vehicle (registration no. C22 NJR); (v) One red Kawasaki Mule vehicle; (vi) Two trailers (one registration no. JIB 1494); (vii) Miscellaneous household waste including a sofa and two wardrobes; (viii) One cement mixer; (vix) Three vehicle engines; (x) Numerous tyres and wheels for vehicles; (xi) One small yellow digger; (xii) One scrap rotary saw; (xiii) Numerous concrete blocks and fence posts | 19/03/2010 | Three months | N/A |
| EC/50/21 & ENF/6 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Fell View Cottage, Linton, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 07/05/2010 | 07/05/2010 | (1) the erection of an extension to the southwest elevation of the building consisting of (i) a UPVC double glazed conservatory and (ii) a stone porch including a UPVC door and frame and a roof clad with artificial stone tiles; and (2) the replacement of two existing windows on the ground and first floor of the south west elevation of the main building (Fell View Cottage) with white UPVC double glazed units | 5.1 Demolish the extension (comprising of the conservatory and porch) and make good the damage caused to the south west elevation of the main dwelling with stone materials and pointing to match those parts of the elevation undisturbed by the unauthorised works; and 5.2 Remove the UPVC windows in the south west elevation of the main building and replace with windows with the following specification: (i) First Floor - white painted soft wood frame, single glazed and recessed 100-150mm and having a horizontal top hinged casement in the top quarter; (ii) Ground Floor - white painted soft wood frame single glazed and recessed 100-150mm, having two equal vertical lights, one fixed and one side hung; OR 5.3 Carry out the works specified in listed building consent ref no. C/50/84C/LB ("the Consent"), including adherence to the following details pursuant to conditions 5 and 6 the Consent: 5.3.1 Condition 5 - the conservatory shall consist of timber frames painted white with outward facing surfaces of component members not exceeding the following widths: 5.3.1.1 Vertical corner pots - 100mm max; 5.3.1.2 Other structural members - 60mm max; 5.3.1.3 all other members, including glazing bars - 20mm max; 5.3.2 Condition 6 - use of white paint | 18/06/2010 | Five years | The Appeal succeeds to a limited degree on ground (h) only. The Listed Building Enforcement Notice is varied by deleting the word two ' before the word months ' in part 6 of the notice (TIME FOR COMPLIANCE) and by substituting therefor the word `six '. The appeal is dismissed and the Listed Building Enforcement Notice is upheld as varied above and Listed Building Consent is refused for the retention of the works carried out in contravention of section 9 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 as amended - 13/11/14 |
| Aug-97 | Enforcement Notice | The Chantry, Ravenstonedale, Kirkby Stephen, Cumbria CA17 4NQ | Eden DC | 14/05/2010 | 14/05/2010 | The unauthorised erection of a raised terraced structure at the above property | (a) You are required to demolish the unauthorised raised terraced structure including the terrace floor, steps, walls and remove all material used in the creation of the terraced platform from the land | 21/06/2010 | 12 weeks | Appeal Dismissed 04.02.11. and Enforcement Notice Upheld |
| ER/03/20 & ENF/54 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Building known as Bankheads West at Low Row, Richmond, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 02/07/2010 | 02/07/2010 | Without listed building consent, the erection of a brown uPVC conservatory attached to the rear elevation of the property detriment to the character of the listed building | Demolish the conservatory making good any damage caused to the listed building by the said demolition by using materials to match those of the remaining part of the building | 13/08/2010 | Six months | N/A |
| EC/64/13C & ENF/55 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Ingle-Byre, Main Street, Stainforth BD24 9PE | YDNPA | 07/10/2010 | 07/10/2010 | Change of use of the building situated on the land and known as `Ingle-Byre' from use as a single dwelling to use as two separate self-contained dwellings | i) Stop using Ingle-Byre as two separate self-contained dwellings | 07/12/2010 | Three months | N/A |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2010 register showing a Section 215 notice, listed building enforcement notices and an enforcement notice concerning the subdivision of Ingle-Byre into two dwellings.
2011
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/71/27A & ENF/57 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Wood Nook Caravan Park, Skirethorns, Threshfield, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5NU | YDNPA | 13/01/2011 | 13/01/2011 | Condition 1 of planning permission ref: YD5/71/40 has not been complied with. Condition 1 states that the number of units that shall use the site at any one time shall not exceed fifty, or which, not more than thirty shall be caravans | Stop siting caravans in excess of the permitted thirty units on the Land at any one time | 24/02/2011 | Two months | Appeal Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is upheld 17/08/11 |
| EC/44/72A & ENF59 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Penyghent Cottage, Selside, Settle, North Yorkshire BD24 0HZ | YDNPA | 14/02/2011 | 14/02/2011 | Change of use of the land from use from a single dwelling to use as two separate dwellings comprising one, two bedroomed dwelling and one, one bedroomed dwelling | i) Stop using the Land as two separate dwellinghouses | 28/03/2011 | 40 weeks | Appeal Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is upheld 31/08/11 |
| ER/59/6B & ENF/56 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Outgang, Thornton Rust Hall, Thornton Rust, North Yorkshire comprising two semi-detached dwellings known as "Oakwood Cottage" and "Woodcutter Cottage" | YDNPA | 07/03/2011 | 07/03/2011 | Non-compliance with Conditions 2, 4, 12 & 13 of planning permission R/59/14E for the erection of two, 3 bedroomed semi-detached cottages | (i) (ii) Height of Building and Roof Pitch. Remove the existing roof structure and upper courses of masonry and replace with a roof that ensures the following: (a) An overall ridge height of not more than 7.4m from existing ground level; (c) An eaves height of not more than 5.1m from existing ground level; (v) A roof pitch of not more than 30 degrees. (iii) Windows. Remove the window opening and frame from the second floor of the north west gable elevation of the building and infill the opening with masonry to match the existing wall. Paint all remaining window frames in a solid white or off white paint finish. iv) Landscaping. Implement and complete the landscaping and operations | 19/04/2011 | Six months | Appeal allowed on ground (g) and direct that the notice be varied by the deletion of 6 months and the substitution of 9 months as the period of compliance subject these corrections and variation - uphold the enforcement notice and refuse to grant planning permission on the application 05/09/11 |
| EC/45/35 & ENF61 | Enforcement Notice | Land at the Station Inn, Ribblehead, North Yorkshire LA6 3AS | YDNPA | 30/06/2011 | 30/06/2011 | The unauthorised erection of a wooden open-sided shelter on a concrete base and concrete ramp adjoining the front elevation of the Station Inn, Ribblehead | i) Dismantle and remove the shelter from the land. ii) Dig up the concrete base and ramp and repave that part of the land affected which is in alignment with existing paving with stone to match the adjoining paving and tarmac the remainder of the land affected | 11/08/2011 | Three months | The Enforcement Notice be corrected by the deletion of the word "unauthorised" from Section 3 of the notice (the allegation). Subject to that correction, the appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld as corrected 13/01/12 |
| ES/01/125 & ENF/62 | Enforcement Notice | Land west of Barth Bridge, Gawthrop, Dent | YDNPA | 05/09/2011 | 05/09/2011 | Change of use of the land from agriculture to a mixed use for (1) agriculture and (2) as a recreational campsite including as part of such use the erection of a timber platform to facilitate the siting of a yurt and the construction of wooden steps adjacent to the access gate to the land | i) Stop using the land as a recreational camp site. ii) Remove from the land the tents, yurt, gazebo, portable toilets and other equipment associated with the use of the land as a recreational camp site. iii) Dismantle and remove from the land the timber platform used as a base for the yurt and the steps at the field gate entrance and reseed the affected areas with grass following the removal of those structures | 10/10/2011 | Forty two days | The Enforcement Notice is upheld, subject to variations outlined in the decision 15/02/12 |
| EC/48/30 & ENF/63 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Tara, 5 Main Street, Langcliffe, Settle, North Yorkshire BD24 9NB | YDNPA | 29/09/2011 | 29/09/2011 | The unauthorised erection of a single storey extension with glazed roof on the side and rear elevation of the dwelling situated on the land | (a) Dismantle and remove the extension from the land | 10/11/2011 | Three months | Appeal Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is upheld 17/02/12. Planning permission is refused. |
| ER/91/31C & ENF/64 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Field OS number 6900, Chantry Caravan Site, West Witton | YDNPA | 19/10/2011 | 19/10/2011 | The change of use of the land for the stationing of caravans for residential purposes, including as part of such use the construction of hard-standings | (a) Cease use of the land for the stationing of caravans used for residential purposes. (b) Remove the caravans from the land together with equipment associated with the use of the land for stationing caravans used for residential purposes. (c) Dig up and remove from the land the hard standings and re-seed the affected areas with grass following removal of these structures | 30/11/2011 | Eighty Four days | Appeal Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is upheld 17/02/12. |
| EC/46/74 & ENF/65 | Enforcement Notice | Land opposite Wears Fold, Kettlewell | YDNPA | 25/10/2011 | 25/10/2011 | The unauthorised creation of hard standing on the land | (a) Dig up and remove the hard standing from the land. (b) Cover the affected area with topsoil and seed with grass | 06/12/2011 | Three months | The Appeals are allowed on ground (f) and the enforcement notice is varied by the deletion of (b) cover the affected area with topsoil and seed with grass' and the substitution of the following requirement (b) restore the land to its previous condition'. Subject to this variation the Enforcement Notice is upheld and planning permission is refused 21/08/12 |
| EC/46/77 & ENF/66 | Enforcement Notice | Land opposite 1 Fold Cottages, Kettlewell | YDNPA | 27/10/2011 | 27/10/2011 | The unauthorised creation of hard standing on the land | (a) Dig up and remove the hard standing from the land. (b) Cover the affected area with topsoil and seed with grass | 08/12/2011 | Three months | Appeal Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is upheld 24/02/12 |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2011 register containing enforcement notices concerning caravan sites, dwelling subdivisions, building alterations, recreational camping and hard standings.
2012
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/54/36B & ENF/68 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Prior Hall, Malham, Skipton, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 07/02/2012 | 07/02/2012 | Change of use of the land from use as a single dwelling to use as two separate self contained dwellings | i) Stop using the land as two separate self contained dwelling houses | 20/03/2012 | Three months | Appeal Dismissed and Enforcement Notice upheld 17/08/12 |
| EC/55/4A & ENF/67 | Section 215 Notice | Land to the rear of Capon Hall, Malham Moor | YDNPA | 28/12/2012 | 28/02/2012 | Siting of two tanks | Remove from the land the two tanks | 19/04/2012 | Three months | N/A |
| EC/45/35A & ENF/70 | Enforcement Notice | Land at The Station Inn, Ribblehead | YDNPA | 09/03/2012 | 09/03/2012 | Change of use of the land to a use for the stationing of a caravan for residential purposes | i) Stop using any part of the land for the stationing of a caravan for residential purposes. ii) Remove the caravan from the land | 20/04/2012 | Six months | N/A |
| EC/33/45D & ENF/71 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Wisp Hill, Grassington, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5LU | YDNPA | 02/08/2012 | 02/08/2012 | NOTICE A: The alteration (and retention) of a building on the land (being development not in conformity with the term of planning permission ref C/33/365B). NOTICE B: The construction of a concrete block wall horse enclosure | Demolish the building referred to in 3 above and remove from the land all rubble and material resulting from the said demolition. Demolish the concreted block wall enclosure referred to and remove from the land all rubble and material resulting from the said demolition | 17/09/2012; 17/09/12 | Nine months; Nine months | Appeal Withdrawn 13/11/12 |
| EC/45/31B & ENF/72 | Enforcement Notice | Land adjacent to White Scar Caves (Water View), Ingleton, Carnforth LA6 3AW | YDNPA | 10/08/2012 | 10/08/2012 | Change of use of the land to use for the storage of a caravan | i) Stop using any part of the land for the storage of a caravan. ii) Remove the caravan from the land | 14/09/2012 | Three months | N/A |
| EC/46/71 & ENF/69 | Enforcement Notice | Land opposite the water works, Kettlewell | YDNPA | 14/09/2012 | 14/09/2012 | Change of use of the land to use for the storage of scrap, waste and other materials | i) Remove any scrap, waste and other materials stored on the land. ii) Stop using any part of the land for storing scrap, waste and other materials | 26/10/2012 | Two months | The Appeal succeeds to a limited extent on ground (f) only. Otherwise the Appeal is dismissed and the notice is upheld as varied 17/06/13. For further information please contact the YDNPA |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2012 register listing notices concerning residential subdivision, tanks, caravans, a building and horse enclosure, and storage of scrap and waste.
2013
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ES/01/128 & ENF/74 | Enforcement Notice | Land at OS Field No. 2240 Birchentree Farm, Cowgill, Dent LA10 5RQ | YDNPA | 26/02/2013 | 26/02/2013 | The unauthorised erection of a polytunnel | Dismantle and remove the polytunnel from the land | 02/04/2013 | Eighty four days | N/A |
| EC/04/21C & ENF/78 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Pant Head, Pant Lane, Austwick LA2 8BH | YDNPA | 30/10/2013 | 30/10/2013 | Change of use of the land for use for storage of building equipment and materials and waste materials (including top soil) | (a) Cease use of land for storage of builder's equipment and materials and waste materials including soil. (b) Remove the building equipment, building materials, waste materials including excavated soil from the land. (c) Reinstate the affected area by covering with topsoil and reseeding with grass | 11/12/2013 | Two months | N/A |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2013 register showing enforcement notices concerning an unauthorised polytunnel and storage of building equipment, materials and waste.
2014
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/31/9A & ENF/79 | Enforcement Notice | Fieldcase Field, Giggleswick, Settle, North Yorkshire BD24 0AX (also known as Fiddlecase Field) | YDNPA | 19/02/2014 | 19/02/2014 | Change of use of the land for the storage of building equipment and materials including thereby the erection of a shed | i) Stop using any part of the land for storage of building equipment and materials. ii) Remove the building equipment and materials from the land. iii) Dismantle and remove the shed from the land | 02/04/2014 | Two Months | N/A |
| EC/45/40 & ENF/87 | Section 225A | Storrs Pasture Field Number 6154 Ingleton, Carnforth, Lancashire | YDNPA | 01/05/2014 | 01/05/2014 | Advertisement sign mounted on a trailer | Remove the same from the land | Not specified | 28 days | N/A |
| EC/64/28A & ENF/86 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Coach House, Taitlands, Stainforth, Settle, North Yorkshire BD23 9NZ | YDNPA | 14/05/2014 | 14/05/2014 | The erection of an extension to the North elevation of the building comprising of a marquee attached to the building by a plywood link | Demolish the extension making good any damage caused to the building using stone materials and pointing to match those parts of the elevation undisturbed by the unauthorised works | 25/06/2014 | Two Months | N/A |
| ER/03/31 & ENF/81 | Enforcement Notice | Swale Hall Lane, Grinton, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 06/06/2014 | 06/06/2014 | Change of use of the land from use for agricultural purposes to a mixed use for (1) agricultural purposes (2) the stationing of a caravan and use of the barn situated on the land for residential purposes and internal alterations to the barn to facilitate the change of use | i) Stop using the caravan for residential purposes; ii) Stop using the barn for residential purposes; iii) Remove the caravan from the land; iv) Remove the domestic style window frames from the barn and replace with timber framed single pane openings; v) remove the domestic style doors and replace with vertically boarded unpainted timber doors without any glazing panels; vi) Remove the artificial tiles and external flue, lower the ridge and eaves height of the building to that which existed previously and replace the tiles with natural stone slate tiles; vii) Dismantle and remove all internal fixtures and fittings within the barn which facilitate the residential use, including kitchen units and appliances and stove | 18/07/2014 | Six Months | The Appeals A and B succeed to the limited degree on grounds (f) and (g) only. The notice was varied by deleting requirement No. (vi) and inserting a new requirement to remove the external flue and lower the ridge and eaves height. The compliance period was changed from six to nine months. Otherwise both appeals were dismissed; the enforcement notice was upheld as varied and planning permission was refused - 13/11/14 |
| ER/51/31A & ENF/90 | Section 225A Notice | Aysgarth, North Yorkshire at the A684 junction with C49 Westholme Bank | YDNPA | 05/11/2014 | 05/11/2014 | Four display structures | Remove the same from the land | Not specified | 28 Days | N/A |
| ER/79/5D & ENF/91 | Enforcement Notice | Middlefields Farm, Melmerby, Leyburn, North Yorkshire DL8 4TW | YDNPA | 17/12/2014 | 17/12/2014 | Erection of an agricultural building | (i) Demolish the building and remove the resultant rubble and materials from the land OR (ii) Reduce the height of the building so that the ridge height of the building does not exceed 8.11 metres (being the height of the previous building that was erected on the land) | 28/01/2015 | Twelve Months | Appeal A: The appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld. Planning permission is refused on the application deemed to have been made under section 177(5) of the 1990 Act as amended. Appeal B: The appeal is dismissed - 19/11/15 |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2014 register showing enforcement, Section 225A and listed building enforcement notices relating to storage, advertisements, extensions, residential use of agricultural buildings and an agricultural building.
2015
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/47/19 & ENF/92 | Enforcement Notice | Tullochvenus Farm, Kirby Top, Kirkby Malham, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 4BY | YDNPA | 23/01/2015 | 23/01/2015 | Condition 1 of C/47/50D stated that `The residential caravan hereby permitted shall be removed from the site and the land restored on or before 13th October 2012'. The Condition has not been complied with. | Remove the caravan from the land, including any associated fixtures and fittings | 07/03/2015 | Three months | The appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld - 06.05.16. |
| EC/46/91 & ENF/94 | Enforcement Notice | Land adjoining 2 Town Head, Kettlewell, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5RL | YDNPA | 21/04/2015 | 22/04/2015 | NOTICE A: Change of use of the land to use for residential purposes ancillary to the dwelling 2 Town Head, Kettlewell (more particularly the parking of cars) including as part of such use the creation of a hard standing | i) Stop using the land for residential purposes ancillary to 2 Town Head, Kettlewell. ii) Dig up and remove the hard standing from the land. iii) Cover the affected area with topsoil and seed with grass | 03/06/2015 | Two months | The appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld - 06.05.16. |
| EC/46/91 & ENF/94 | Enforcement Notice | Land adjoining 2 Town Head, Kettlewell, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5RL | YDNPA | 21/04/2015 | 22/04/2015 | NOTICE B: The creation of hard standing on the land | (i) Dig up and remove the hard standing from the land. (ii) Cover the affected area with topsoil and seed with grass | 03/06/2015 | Two months | The appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld - 06.05.16. |
| EC/46/49C & ENF/95 | Enforcement Notice | Land adjoining Brightwaters, Kettlewell, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5RL | YDNPA | 29/05/2015 | 29/05/2015 | Change of use of the land to use for residential purposes ancillary to the dwelling Brightwaters, including as part of such use the creation of a patio area and installation of railings built within Kettlewell Beck | i) Remove the patio area and railings from the land and restore the land to its previous condition and ii) Stop using any part of the land for residential purposes ancillary to Brightwaters, Kettlewell | 11/07/2015 | Three months | Appeal Withdrawn 19.02.16. following grant of planning permission C/46/69F on 11.02.16. |
| ER/55/31 & ENF/96 | Enforcement Notice | Land to the north of River Ure, Carperby (Field OS 7745) | YDNPA | 24/06/2015 | 24/06/2015 | Change of use of the land from use for agriculture to a use for mixed purposes, namely 1) agriculture and 2) the siting of a fishing hut for purposes unconnected with agriculture | i) Stop using any part of the land to site a fishing hut for purposes unconnected with agriculture and ii) Remove the fishing hut from the land | 27/07/2015 | Fourteen days | Appeal Withdrawn 26.11.15. following grant of planning permission R/55/108 on 27.10.15. |
| ER/51/39 & ENF/90 | Section 225A Notice | Land at Aysgarth, North Yorkshire in the vicinity of the A684 junction with C49 Westholme Bank | YDNPA | 15/07/2015 | 15/07/2015 | Aluminium composite sign mounted on timber posts advertising Westholme Lodges & Hendersons Bar/Bistro | Remove the same from the land | Not specified | 22 days | N/A |
| EC/33/108A & ENF/98 | Enforcement Notice — NOTICE A | Field No 8527, Fletchers Brow, Mill Lane, Grassington, North Yorkshire BD23 5BX | YDNPA | 17/09/2015 | 17/09/2015 | Change of use of the land from use for agriculture to a use for mixed purposes, namely 1) agriculture and 2) the storage of a container and 3) the siting of a caravan for residential purposes | i) Remove the caravan referred to in 3 together with all other domestic items. ii) Stop using the land for the siting of a caravan for residential purposes. iii) Remove the container referred to in 2 from the land. iv) Stop using the land for the storage of a container. v) Dismantle and remove the fence from the land. vi) Dig up and remove from the land the aggregate used to form the track, cover the affected area with top soil and reseed with grass. vii) Demolish the retaining wall, fill in the excavated area with soil to levels that existed prior to the excavation works and reseed with grass. vii) Dig up the soil and rubble used to create the extended raised level surface area referred to in 3(iii) and reduce the ground levels to levels that existed prior to the unauthorised engineering operations and reseed the affected area with grass | 12/11/2015 | 5 i) = One month & 5 ii)-iv) inclusive = Six months | NOTICE A - Upheld - Appeal Dismissed |
| EC/33/108A & ENF/98 | Enforcement Notice — NOTICE B | Field No 8527, Fletchers Brow, Mill Lane, Grassington, North Yorkshire BD23 5BX | YDNPA | 17/09/2015 | 17/09/2015 | NOTICE B: Operational development i) Engineering operations to create an excavated level surfaced area measuring approximately 16 metres squared and construction of a stone retaining wall to the rear of the excavated area; ii) The laying of aggregate to create a track measuring approximately 22.5 metres in length and 3.5 metres in width; iii) Engineering operations to create an extended raised level surface area; iv) The erection of a vertically boarded timber fence on the levelled area referred to in iii) above | i) Dismantle and remove the fence from the land. ii) Dig up and remove from the land the aggregate used to form the track, cover the affected area with top soil and reseed with grass. iii) Demolish the retaining wall, fill in the excavated area with soil to levels that existed prior to the excavation works and reseed with grass. iv) Dig up the soil and rubble used to create the extended raised level surface area referred to in 3(iii) above and reduce the ground levels to levels that existed prior to the unauthorised engineering operations and reseed the affected area with grass | 12/11/2015 | 5 i) = One month & 5 ii)-iv) inclusive = Six months | NOTICE B - Enforcement Notice Quashed 28.04.16. |
| EC/45/41 & ENF/99 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Storrs Common, Ingleton, Via Carnforth, North Yorkshire LA6 3AN | YDNPA | 08/10/2015 | 08/10/2015 | Change of use of the land to use for the stationing of a cabin/caravan for residential purposes | i) Stop using any part of the land for the stationing of a cabin/caravan for residential purposes. ii) Remove the cabin/caravan and any other items and materials associated with the residential use from the land | 19/11/2015 | One month | N/A |
| ES/03/273 & ENF/100 | Section 225A Notice | 26 Main Street (Café Nova), Sedbergh | YDNPA | 20/10/2015 | 20/10/2015 | A rectangular projecting double sided sign, fixed onto the gable-end wall of the building, advertising Café Nova Patisserie and Bistro, measuring approximately 1m wide x 2m high | (i) Enter on to the land; and (ii) Remove the Display Structure and any fitments and dispose of them; and (iii) Recover from you the expenses reasonably incurred in so doing unless you satisfy the Authority that you were not responsible for the erection of the Display Structure and its maintenance | Not specified | 28 days | N/A |
IMAGE: Tabular register pages for 2015 showing notices concerning caravans, hard standings, advertisements, a fishing hut, a container, engineering works and a residential cabin or caravan.
2016
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/64/31 & ENF/104 | Enforcement Notice | Bargh House, Stainforth, Settle, North Yorkshire | YDNPA | 05/01/2016 | 05/01/2016 | Condition 1 of planning permission C/64/109A granted on 20/01/07 has not been complied with as the caravan has not been removed and still remains on the land after 29th January 2010 and no further application for its retention has been approved in writing by the Authority | i) Remove the caravan from the land. ii) Stop using the land for the siting of a residential caravan for residential purposes. iii) Reinstate the land to its previous condition by re-seeding the affected area with grass | 16/02/2016 | Six months | N/A |
| EC/45/41 & ENF/99 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Storrs Common, Ingleton, Via Carnforth, North Yorkshire LA6 3AN | YDNPA | 13/01/2016 | 13/01/2016 | Change of use of the land to use for the stationing of a cabin/caravan for residential purposes | I) Stop using any part of the land for the stationing of a cabin/caravan for residential purposes. ii) Remove the cabin/caravan and any other items and materials associated with the residential use from the land | 24/02/2016 | One month | N/A |
| EC/33/65G & ENF/105 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Building known as Grassington House Hotel at 5 The Square, Grassington, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5AQ | YDNPA | 13/01/2015 | 13/01/2015 | An extraction system incorporating an extraction unit and air intake unit has been attached to the northern elevation of Grassington House Hotel. The said works are to the detriment of the character of the listed building | i) Dismantle and remove from the building the extraction unit and air intake unit including any fittings used to attach the said units to the building. ii) Repair and make good any damage caused to the building by the removal of the said units and fittings using materials to match exactly those of the remaining part of the building | 24/02/2016 | Three months | N/A |
| 15019 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | Underley Hall, Kirkby Lonsdale LA6 2DZ | SLDC | 15/09/2016 | 15/09/2016 | I. A significant area of the main building roof has had its original slates removed. The existing slate consisting of random diminished coursing local blue/grey slates has been replaced with regular cut and size, in non-diminishing courses of green Brazilian slates being a different colour, texture and design to that of the remainder of the roof's existing slates. II. Inserting modern lay in grid, suspended ceilings to a suite of rooms. III. Removal of internal original panelled solid Oak doors. iv. Dismantling and removal of part of the inner stable courtyard canopy including glazing, glazing bars and structural sections from the inner stable courtyard canopy | Works to (1) Roof (2) Suspended ceiling (3) Doors (4) Inner stable courtyard canopy. For further information contact the YDNPA | 19/10/2016 | (1) 15 months (2) 13 months (3) 6 months (4) 18 months | N/A |
| EC/26/58 & ENF/111 | Listed Building Enforcement Notice | The Garth, 37 Pasture Road, Embsay, Skipton BD23 6RQ | YDNPA | 27/10/2016 | 27/10/2016 | Works to cellar | 1. Reinstate the flagstone floors in rooms 1 and 2. 2. Reinstate the timber lath and plaster ceilings in rooms 1 and 2. 3. Backgill the foundations area. 4. Reinstate the two natural local stone shelves. 5. Reinstate local natural stone keeping shelf, support and table. 6. Repair the west wall external window cill and stonework below. 7. Repair lime plastered walls damaged throughout the cellar due to works to the ceiling, floor and walls. 8. Reinstate three no ceiling meat hooks in the original locations. For further information contact the YDNPA | 07/12/2016 | 12 months | N/A |
IMAGE: Tabular register pages for 2016 covering caravans, a listed hotel extraction system, works at Underley Hall and restoration works to a cellar.
2017
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/60/6B | Enforcement Notice | Land at Green Farm, Green Lane, Rylstone BD23 6LN | YDNPA | 13/03/2017 | 13/03/2017 | NOTICE A Condition 2 of planning permission C/60/54L not complied with - 6 rooflights per bay per side instead of 4 of the cattle housing building | 5.1 Reduce the number of roof lights installed on the cattle housing building so that the roof light configuration complies with the details specified by New Dairy Cubicles drawings no. JS-PM001 (namely four roof lights per bay per side of the building). 5.2 Implement and complete the approved landscaping scheme referred to in said condition No. 8 in accordance with the further details prescribed by the said condition No 8 | 24/04/2017 | Six months | Appeal A - Notice A - Appeal A is allowed in part and dismissed in part. Notice A is varied and upheld 12/02/18. 5.1 remove the bottom (lower) line of rooflights adjacent to the eaves, on both sides of the roof of the cattle housing building to leave just 4 rooflights per bay |
| ER/57/20 | Enforcement Notice | Mystified Bungalow, Bishopdale Lane, Bishopdale, Leyburn, North Yorkshire DL8 3TG | YDNPA | 14/03/2017 | 14/03/2017 | The property has been subdivided into two self contained dwellings. An additional dwelling has been created from former annexe accommodation to the original single dwelling. The additional dwelling is being used and occupied as a dwelling for short term holiday accommodation. Policy C4 of the adopted Yorkshire Dales Local Plan (2015-2030) aims to ensure that all additional dwellings created through subdivision will be restricted to meet local needs. No such local need restriction has been placed on the additional dwelling. | (i) Stop using the land as two separate dwelling houses. (ii) Stop using or permitting the use of the area hatched blue on the plan as a separate self contained unit of residential accommodation | 25/04/2017 | Six months | Appeals A and B are dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld 12/02/18. Planning permission is refused for the application deemed to have been made under section 177(5) of the Act as amended, in relation to Appeal A |
| ER/60/3D | Enforcement Notice | The Forbidden Corner, Tupgill Park Estate, Coverham, Leyburn, North Yorkshire DL8 4TJ | YDNPA | 10/08/2017 | 10/08/2017 | The construction of a partially completed building consisting of the following: 1. a square gatehouse with parapet walls around a viewing platform; 2. a spiral staircase tower attached to the northern side of the gatehouse; 3. a rectangular tower attached to the northern side of the spiral staircase tower. The height of the building referred to above extends above the height of the paved level walking surface of the adjoining structure known as "The Long Walk" by approx 8.5 metres in the case of the parapet walls of the gatehouse and by approx 6.8 metres in the case of spiral staircase tower and rectangular tower | (i) Demolish the building to the extent that no part of the building extends more than three metres above the paved level walking surface of the adjoining structure known as "The Long Walk". (ii) Remove the resultant rubble and materials from the land | 10/10/2017 | Three months | The appeal succeeds to a limited degree on ground (g) only. The enforcement notice be varied by deleting the word three' and by substituting therefor the word Nine'. Otherwise the appeal is dismissed and the notice is upheld as corrected and varied 20/08/18 |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2017 register showing notices relating to rooflights and landscaping, subdivision of a dwelling, and a partially completed building at The Forbidden Corner.
2018
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E/11/1 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Rayne Cottage Farm, Gaisgill CA10 3UD | YDNPA | 10/01/2018 | 10/01/2018 | Non-compliance with Condition Nos. 1 & 2 of planning permission 13/0444 for the erection of a cabin for temporary farm accommodation. Condition 1 has been breached because use of the cabin has not been discontinued and Condition 2 has been breached because the cabin has not been removed from the land and the land has not been restored to its former condition | 5.1 Discontinue use of the cabin. 5.2 Remove the cabin from the land. 5.3 Restore the land to its former condition by covering the affected area with topsoil and seeding with grass | 21/02/2018 | Six months | Appeal Dismissed 05/02/21 |
| EC/71/52 | Enforcement Notice | High Winds, Wharfeside Avenue, Threshfield, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5BS | YDNPA | 09/04/2018 | 09/04/2018 | Construction of a dormer extension on the south west rear roof slope of the building | 5.1 Remove the dormer extension. 5.2 Reinstate the roof slope using tiles to match those on the existing roof slope | 20/05/2018 | Three months | N/A |
| EC/26/60A | Enforcement Notice | 5 Brackenley Lane, Embsay, Skipton BD23 6NW | YDNPA | 16/05/2018 | 16/05/2018 | The construction of a raised patio area to the rear of the building | Lower the raised patio area so that no part of the patio exceeds 30cm in height | 27/06/2018 | Three months | N/A |
| ER/55/18D | Enforcement Notice | Land at Manor Grange Farm, Low Lane, Carperby, Leyburn, North Yorkshire DL8 4DP | YDNPA | 11/09/2018 | 11/09/2018 | Change of use of the building (or part thereof) situated on the land to use for residential purposes | Stop using the building (or any part thereof) for residential purposes | 22/10/2018 | Six months | N/A |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2018 register showing notices concerning a temporary farm accommodation cabin, a dormer extension, a raised patio and residential use of a building.
2019
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ER/56/137B | Enforcement Notice | Land at Bainbridge Ings Caravan Site, Old Gayle Lane, Hawes | YDNPA | 18/02/2019 | 18/02/2019 | Non-compliance with Condition 2 of planning permission R/56/10G in respect of: a) Eight pods of a different design, style and form from those specified; b) Timber fencing; c) The Pods have been stationed in a different layout; d) hardstanding | 5.1 Remove the eight camping Pods referred to in para 3 above (together with their associated fixtures and fittings) from the land. 5.2 Dismantle and remove from the land the timber fencing referred to in para 3 above. 5.3 Dig up the hardstanding referred to in para 3 above, cover the affected area with topsoil and reseed with grass | 29/03/2019 | Three months | The Appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld with corrections and variations relating to landscaping 02.01.20. |
| EE/03/6 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Snowdrop Barn, Brackenslack Lane, Maulds Meaburn, Penrith, Cumbria CA10 3HX | YDNPA | 12/03/2019 | 12/03/2019 | Without planning permission: i) Installation of a window in the north gable of the building; ii) Engineering operations to create a level hardstanding; iii) Erection of four timber sheds | 5.1 Remove the window in the north gable and block up the opening using stonework to match the existing stonework on the north gable. 5.2 Demolish the retaining walls, dig up the hardsurfaced area and reconfigure the ground levels to the levels that existed prior to the unauthorised engineering operations, and reseed the affected area with grass. 5.3 Dismantle and remove from the land all four timber sheds | 23/04/2019 | Six months | Appeal A succeeds in part and permission is granted in part, and the enforcement notice is upheld as corrected and varied 06.01.20. Appeal B succeeds in part and the enforcement notice is upheld as corrected and varied 06.01.20. |
| EC/48/35 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Cowside Barn, Langcliffe, Settle, North Yorkshire BD24 9PZ | YDNPA | 14/05/2019 | 14/05/2019 | Change of use of the building situated on the land (known as "the Old Dairy" to use as a self contained dwelling house including as part of such change of use the erection of timber decking and fencing around the said building and internal alterations to the building to facilitate the change of use including the installation of domestic kitchen units and appliances and bathroom fittings | i) Stop using the building as a self contained dwelling house. ii) Dismantle and remove from the land the timber decking and fence. iii) Dismantle and remove all internal fixtures and fittings within the building which facilitate the residential use, including kitchen units and appliances and bathroom fittings | 25/06/2019 | Six months | Appeal against the Enforcement Notice is dismissed and the Enforcement Notice upheld as corrected 17.08.20 |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2019 register covering camping pods, hardstanding and sheds, and an unauthorised dwelling created in the Old Dairy.
2020
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Notice Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| None Issued in 2020 |
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2020 register page stating “None Issued in 2020”.
2021
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ES/03/303 | Enforcement Notice | 59 Main Street, Sedbergh, Cumbria LA10 5AB | YDNPA | 16/11/2021 | 16/11/2021 | The change of use of the two outbuildings situated on the land to use as a commercial laundry | 5.1 Stop using the outbuildings (or any part thereof) situated on the land as a commercial laundry. 5.2 Remove from the land the laundry machines and all other equipment associated with the use of the outbuildings as a commercial laundry | 28/12/2021 | One month | Appeal Dismissed 07.10.22. Six months given for compliance instead of one month |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2021 register showing one enforcement notice concerning use of two outbuildings as a commercial laundry.
2022
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/02/34 | Enforcement Notice | Land near Dibbles Bridge lying to the South-West of Fancarl House, Greenhow Hill, Harrogate HG3 5JL | YDNPA | 11/01/2022 | 11/01/2022 | Creation of a hardstanding and erection of a telecommunication mast and associated equipment | a) Remove the telecommunication mast and all associated equipment from the land. b) Dig up the hardstanding and remove resultant rubble and materials from the land. c) Restore the land to its former condition by covering the affected area with topsoil and reseed with grass | 22/02/2022 | One month | N/A |
| EC/65/32 | Enforcement Notice | Land to the west side of Bog Lane, Stirton, Skipton | YDNPA | 30/03/2022 | 30/03/2022 | The placement of a metal container on the land | 5.1 Remove the container from the land | 11/05/2022 | One month | N/A |
| ER/56/137C — NOTICE A | Enforcement Notice | Land at Bainbridge Ings Caravan Site, Old Gayle Lane, Hawes | YDNPA | 05/04/2022 | 05/04/2022 | Use of Field 0040 other than for camping in breach of Condition No. 3 of R/56/10G, laying of tracks and hardstanding in breach of Condition No. 2 of R/56/10G and siting of static caravan and timber cabin also in breach of Condition No. 2 of R/56/10G | 5.1 Stop using the land for the siting of touring caravans and campervans/motorhomes for residential purposes. 5.2 Remove all touring caravans and campervans/motorhomes from the land. 5.3 Stop using the land for the siting of a static caravan for residential purposes. 5.4 Remove the static caravan from the land and all associated fixtures and fittings. 5.5 Stop using the land for the siting of a timber cabin used as a guest washroom and staff facility. 5.6 Remove the timber cabin from the land and all associated fixtures and fittings. 5.7 Dig up the areas of hardstanding and hardcore tracks referred to in para 3 above, cover the affected areas with topsoil and reseed with grass | 17/05/2022 | Six months | N/A |
| ER/56/137C — NOTICE B | Enforcement Notice | Land at Bainbridge Ings Caravan Site, Old Gayle Lane, Hawes | YDNPA | 05/04/2022 | 05/04/2022 | Change of use of the land to use for the stationing of touring caravans in accordance with the terms of a Certificate of Lawful Use dated 6th June 1996 and the stationing of four cabins for residential purposes including as part of such use the creation of hardstandings (upon which the said cabins are stationed) erection of fencing around said cabins and installation of hot tubs | 5.1 Stop using the land otherwise than in accordance with the Certificate. 5.2 Stop using the land for the stationing of cabins for residential purposes. 5.3 Remove the cabins from the land together with their associated fixtures and fittings. 5.4 Dig up the hardstandings and remove the hardcore rubble from the land. 5.5 Dismantle and remove the fencing and hot tubs from the land. 5.6 Reinstate the land to its former condition by covering the affected area with topsoil and reseeding with grass | 17/05/2022 | Six months | N/A |
| ER/56/137C — NOTICE C | Enforcement Notice | Land at Bainbridge Ings Caravan Site, Old Gayle Lane, Hawes | YDNPA | 05/04/2022 | 05/04/2022 | The laying of hardcore to create areas of hardstanding and access track | 5.1 Dig up the areas of hardstanding and hardcore track referred to in para 3 above. 5.2 Remove any resultant rubble/materials from the land. 5.3 Cover the affected areas with topsoil and reseed with grass | 17/05/2022 | Six months | N/A |
| EE/12/12 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Fell End Chapel, Kirkby Stephen, Ravenstonedale CA17 4LP | YDNPA | 18/07/2022 | 18/07/2022 | Non-compliance with Condition No. 2 of E/12/69 in relation to: (i) An area of hardstanding for car parking has been created in a different location; (ii) The package treatment plant has been installed in a different location; (iii) An access to the highway has been created in a different location; (iv) Engineering and building operations have been carried out on the land to the south and west of the barn | 5.1 Dig up the hardstanding used to create the car parking area and reinstate the affected area to its former condition by covering with topsoil and reseeding with grass. 5.2 Remove the package treatment plant from the land and reinstate the affected area to its former condition by covering with topsoil and reseeding with grass. 5.3 Block off the access referred to in paragraph 3(iii) by reinstating the dry stone walling using materials to match the adjoining dry stone walling. 5.4 Remove the pre cast concrete blocks and associated walling referred to in paragraph 3(v) above from the land. 5.5 Reinstate the land to the west and south of the barn referred to in paragraph 3(iv) above by reconfiguring the ground levels to those existing prior to the unauthorised engineering operations and reseed the affected areas with grass | 30/08/2022 | Six months | Appeal should not succeed and enforcement notice upheld with corrections and a variation and refuse to grant planning permission on the application deemed to have been made under Secton 177(5) of the 1990 Act as amended 16.11.23. |
IMAGE: Tabular register pages for 2022 showing notices concerning a telecommunications mast, a metal container, caravan-site uses, cabins, hard standings, access tracks and works around Fell End Chapel.
2023
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EC/46/103C | Enforcement Notice | Land at Low Hall Farm, Kettlewell, Skipton, North Yorkshire BD23 5QZ | YDNPA | 08/08/2023 | 08/08/2023 | Change of use of the land to use for the siting of touring caravans (including campervans) and tents for residential holiday purposes ("a Camping and Caravan Site") | 5.1 Stop using the land for the siting of touring caravans (including campervans) and tents for residential holiday purposes other than in accordance with permitted development rights under the GPDO. 5.4 Remove from the land any caravans (including campervans) and tents associated with the unauthorised use referred to in paragraph 3(i) above | 18/09/2023 | Twenty-eight days | Appeal A - It is directed that the notice is corrected in section 3.1 by the deletion of the words "use for the siting of touring caravans (including campervans) and tents for residential holiday purposes ("a camping and caravan site")" and the substitution of the words "a mixed use for the siting of touring caravans (including campervans) and tents for holiday purposes ("a camping and caravan site") and agriculture." Subject to the correction, the appeal is dismissed and the enforcement notice is upheld. Appeal B - The appeal is dismissed. |
IMAGE: A tabular page of the 2023 register showing one enforcement notice concerning a camping and caravan site at Low Hall Farm.
2024
| Case Reference | Notice Type | Address of the land to which the Notice relates | Name of Issuing Authority | Date of issue | Date of service | Summary of the breach of planning control alleged | Requirements of the Notice | Date specified in Notice as date to take effect | Timescale for Compliance | Appeal or other outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ER/56/129A & ENF/134 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Moorcock Inn, Garsdale LA10 5PU | YDNPA | 17/05/2024 | 17/05/2024 | NOTICE A: 3. Material change of use of the building hatched red on Plan A from use as a public house to use as a single dwelling house (Use Class C3) including internal alterations to the building comprising the erection of two partition walls on the ground floor and additional staircase to facilitate the change of use. NOTICE B: The material change of use of the building hatched red on Plan A to the following uses: (i) Use of that part of the building hatched blue on the attached plan marked Plan B as a Tea Room; (ii) Use of that part of the building hatched red on Plan B as a self-contained unit of residential accommodation for short term holiday letting purposes (Use Class C3), including associated development comprising the erection of timber fencing adjacent to the northern and western elevations of the building to create separate enclosed seating areas for the uses referred to above | NOTICE A: (i) Stop using the building as a single dwelling house. (ii) Remove the two partition walls and staircase constructed to facilitate the change of use and referred to in paragraph 3. (iii) Remove from the bar and public areas of the ground floor of the building all fixtures and fittings associated with the use of the building as a single dwellinghouse. (iv) Remove from the land all materials and waste resulting from compliance with requirements (ii) and (ii). NOTICE B: (i) Stop using that part of the building hatched blue on Plan B as a Tea Room. (ii) Stop using that part of the building hatched red on Plan B as a self-contained unit of residential accommodation. (iii) Remove from the building all fixtures and fittings associated with use of part of the building as a Tea Room. (iv) Dismantle and remove the fencing from the land | 01/07/2024 | Six months | NOTICE A: The Appeal is Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is Upheld 14.04.25. NOTICE B: The Appeal is Dismissed and the Enforcement Notice is Upheld 14.04.25. |
| EE/12/18 & ENF/136 | Enforcement Notice | Land at Old Dairy Barn, Rigg End, Newbiggin on Lune, Kirkby Stephen, Cumbria CA17 4NB | YDNPA | 21/05/2024 | 21/05/2024 | I. Material change of use of the land to use for residential purposes ancillary to the use of the dwelling known as the Old Dairy Barn. II. The construction of a raised patio area (including the installation of a hot tub and erection of fencing to enclose the raised patio area) on the land | 5.1 Stop using the raised patio area for residential purposes ancillary to the use of the dwelling known as Old Dairy Barn. 5.2 Dismantle and remove the hot tub from the land. 5.3 Dismantle and remove from the land the fencing enclosing the patio area. 5.4 Demolish the raised patio area and reconfigure the ground levels to the levels that existed prior to the unauthorised engineering operations | 03/07/2024 | One month for 5.1; Three months for 5.2, 5.3 & 5.4 | It is directed that the enforcement notice is corrected by: the substitution of the word green for the word red in paragraph 2 which is headed “The Land To Which The Notice Relates”; and the substitution of the plan annexed to this decision for the plan attached to the enforcement notice. Subject to the correction the appeal is dismissed, the enforcement notice is upheld and planning permission is refused on the application deemed to have been made under section 177(5) of the 1990 Act as amended. |
IMAGE: Tabular register pages for 2024 showing enforcement notices concerning changes of use at the Moorcock Inn and Old Dairy Barn, including requirements to stop uses, remove fixtures, fencing and a raised patio.
2025
| Case Reference | Notice Type |
|---|---|
| None Issued in 2025 |
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2025 register page stating “None Issued in 2025”.
2026
| Case Reference | Notice Type |
|---|---|
| None Issued in 2026 so far |
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2026 register page stating “None Issued in 2026 so far”.
2027
The register contains no issued notices.
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2027 register page with no enforcement entries.
2028
The register contains no issued notices.
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2028 register page with no enforcement entries.
2029
The register contains no issued notices.
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2029 register page with no enforcement entries.
2030
The register contains no issued notices.
IMAGE: A blank tabular 2030 register page with no enforcement entries.