The name probably comes from the use of Millstone Grit to make quern stones for grinding corn in the distant past. Like the other two peaks, Ingleborough and Pen-y-ghent, Whernside has a cap of this tough stone.
Whernside's rounded 'whale-back' shape is the result of land slippage, which has masked the stepped layers of rock underneath. A landslide scour on the north-east slope was the site of one of the last glaciers in the Yorkshire Dales. The natural bowl trapped snow, and the build-up of ice scoured it out further. When the ice finally melted, it left behind the boggy area of Greensett Moss and its small tarn.