Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

YDNP Demographic Forecasts final October 2019

Yorkshire Dales National Park Demographic Evidence October 2019

[Image: The cover features a modern design with the "edge analytics" logo in the bottom left—a red circle containing the word "edge" in white, followed by "analytics" in black text. To the right is a vertical decorative pattern of connected dots and lines in grey, black, and red, resembling a network diagram. The title "Yorkshire Dales National Park" is in orange, with "Demographic Evidence" in grey below it.]

Nexus | Discovery Way | University of Leeds | Leeds | LS2 3AA 0113 819 5087 | www.edgeanalytics.co.uk


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence i October 2019

Acknowledgements

Demographic statistics used in this report have been derived from data from the Office for National Statistics licensed under the Open Government Licence v.3.0.

The authors of this report do not accept liability for any costs or consequential loss involved following the use of the data and analysis referred to here; this is entirely the responsibility of the users of the information presented in this report.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence ii October 2019

Contents

Acknowledgements.................................................................................................................................. i Contents.................................................................................................................................................. ii 1 Introduction..................................................................................................................................... 1 Context............................................................................................................................................. 1 Approach.......................................................................................................................................... 2 2 Area Profile ...................................................................................................................................... 3 Geography ....................................................................................................................................... 3 Population Change 2001–2017........................................................................................................ 4 Housing Growth............................................................................................................................... 9 Commuting Flows.......................................................................................................................... 11 3 Growth Scenarios........................................................................................................................... 13 Approach........................................................................................................................................ 13 Scenario Development................................................................................................................... 14 Scenario Outcomes........................................................................................................................ 15 Age Structure................................................................................................................................. 17 4 Summary........................................................................................................................................ 19 Context........................................................................................................................................... 19 Growth Outcomes ......................................................................................................................... 19 Appendix A: POPGROUP Methodology ............................................................................................. 22 Appendix B: Population Age Profiles – Sub-district Areas ................................................................ 24 Appendix C: Commuting Statistics – Sub-district Areas.................................................................... 26 Appendix D: Scenario Outcomes – Sub-district Areas....................................................................... 28


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 1 October 2019

1 Introduction

Context

1.1 The Yorkshire Dales National Park (YDNP) Authority, together with funding from Craven, Richmondshire and North Yorkshire County Councils, has commissioned the development of a ‘Social, Economic and Housing Study of the National Park’. There are two core outputs of the study: (i) a Socioeconomic Wellbeing Assessment (SEA), undertaken by Edge Economics; (ii) a Strategic Housing Market Assessment (SHMA), undertaken by Arc4. The study will inform a new Local Plan for the National Park, coordinating and collaborating with its surrounding local planning authorities in the process.

1.2 A key focus of the study will be an examination of the social and economic challenges that are facing the National Park. The YDNP Authority has identified its concerns with regard to the National Park’s ageing and declining population, the potential diminution of local services and the challenge of maintaining the economic vitality of its local communities.

1.3 The study will consider the socio-economic opportunities and threats that exist within and outside the YDNP boundaries, providing key evidence to support: its long-term, sustainable planning objectives; housing growth targets in line with the latest National Planning Policy Framework^1 (NPPF) and Planning Practice Guidance^2 (PPG); and its desire to attract and retain younger population cohorts within the National Park.

1.4 A robust examination of the demographic evidence is a key component of the study, informing both the SEA and the SHMA in considering both the historical profile of population change and the prospects for future growth. In November 2015, Edge Analytics provided a range of evidence to the YDNP Authority^3, informing and validating its Local Plan^4 housing growth objective for the 2015-2030 plan period. Since the Local Plan evidence was produced in 2015, the geographical extent of the YDNP has grown by approximately 24% (417km²), with the addition of land within the districts of Lancaster, Eden and South Lakeland. Furthermore, a range of new statistical evidence has been published, including:

  • Mid-year population estimates, plus birth and death statistics to mid-year 2017
  • 2014-based and 2016-based sub-national population projections (SNPP) from the Office for National Statistics (ONS)

^1 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-planning-policy-framework--2 ^2 https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/revised-national-planning-policy-framework ^3 Yorkshire Dales National Park. Demographic Forecasts. November 2015 ^4 Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority. Yorkshire Dales Local Plan 2015-2030. October 2015


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 2 October 2019

  • 2014-based and 2016-based sub-national household projections (SNHP) from the Ministry for Housing Communities and Local Government (MHCLG)
  • Updated NPPF and PPG guidance (February 2019)
  • Labour market analysis from the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR)

1.5 This report draws together the latest evidence to produce an updated profile of demographic change in the YDNP, plus a suite of population, housing and labour force growth outcomes under different conditions and assumptions, that can provide the basis for further SEA and SHMA analysis.

Approach

1.6 The YDNP now intersects five districts: Craven, Eden, Lancaster, South Lakeland and Richmondshire. The new demographic evidence and forecasts have been compiled and presented for the YDNP geographical portions that reside in each of the five districts. The proportional split of each district has been accomplished using a combination of Output Area (OA) populations, plus Royal Mail Postcode Address File (PAF) property distributions.

1.7 POPGROUP technology (see Appendix A) has been used to develop a range of growth scenarios for the YDNP in aggregate and for the geographical portions that fall within each of the five districts. All scenarios are based on historical evidence for the period 2001–2017 and have a 2040 forecast horizon. Household growth assumptions have been drawn from MHCLG’s 2014-based SNHP, scaled for consistency with the YDNP geography.

1.8 Section 2 of this report presents a profile of demographic change in the YDNP, considering the extended geographical area, its constituent parts and the components of change that have driven population change since 2001. The changing age-structure of the National Park, plus economic indicators of employment and commuting are presented as context for the scenario analysis.

1.9 Section 3 provides a description of the suite of growth scenarios that have been formulated and presents population, household, dwelling and labour force outcomes for each, illustrating how the age profile of the YDNP is likely to change under each scenario.

1.10 A concluding section draws the evidence together, to summarise the findings and to present the key demographic evidence for consideration in the formulation of the SEA and SHMA analyses and their assessment of the socio-economic outlook for the YDNP.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 3 October 2019

2 Area Profile

Geography

2.1 On 1st August 2016, the YDNP was extended to include new areas in Cumbria and Lancashire, increasing its size by approximately 24%. Originally straddling the three local authority districts of Craven, Richmondshire and South Lakeland, additional land has been included within South Lakeland, plus territory in Eden and Lancaster (Figure 1). Major transport links surround the borders of the Park, with the M6 to the west, the A65 and A59 to its immediate south-west and south respectively and the A66 to the north.

[Image: Figure 1: YDNP – old and new boundary. A map showing the Yorkshire Dales National Park boundaries. It highlights the pre-2016 boundary in dark green and the post-2016 extension areas in light green. The map shows the park intersecting the districts of Eden, Richmondshire, South Lakeland, Lancaster, and Craven. Neighboring areas like Penrith, Kendal, and Skipton are shown, along with major A-roads, motorways (M6), and railway lines.]

Contains Ordnance Survey Data © Crown Copyright and database rights 2019.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 4 October 2019

Population Change 2001–2017

2.2 The population of the YDNP was estimated as 23,488 at mid-year 2017. This total has been derived using OA populations, apportioned to the YDNP geography based upon PAF property distributions.

2.3 Since 2001, the YDNP population estimates suggest only limited growth, with a rise in population numbers to 2008, reducing as the recession set in thereafter. Since 2012, growth has been positive but below 1% over the six-year period (Figure 2).

[Image: Figure 2: YDNP – population totals 2001–2017. A bar chart showing the population of the YDNP each year from 2001 (23,345) to 2017 (23,488). The population peaked in 2008 at 24,195, declined until 2012 (23,354), and has since shown a slight recovery.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

2.4 When compared to local authority districts in England & Wales, the modest population growth in the National Park places it towards the lower end of the spectrum, 2.9 percentage point below the national average (Figure 3).

[Image: Figure 3: England & Wales Local Authority Districts – population growth 2012–2017. A bar chart ranking all local authorities by population growth percentage. The YDNP is marked at 0.9% growth, far to the left of the "E&W average 3.8%" line, indicating it is among the slowest-growing areas.]

Source: ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 5 October 2019

2.5 Within the YDNP, Craven district contributes the majority of the population (42%) with the smallest share living in Lancaster (1%). Richmondshire, South Lakeland and Eden account for 27%, 20% and 10% of population respectively (Figure 4).

[Image: Figure 4: YDNP – share of population by district 2017. A pie chart showing population distribution: Craven (in YDNP) = 9,881 (42%); Richmondshire (in YDNP) = 6,253 (27%); South Lakeland (in YDNP) = 4,703 (20%); Eden (in YDNP) = 2,373 (10%); Lancaster (in YDNP) = 278 (1%). Total Population = 23,488.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

2.6 Examination of the component parts of the YDNP geography, indicates that the Craven and Richmondshire portions have generally followed the National Park trend in population change. Annual change in South Lakeland, Eden and Lancaster portions is more variable, with the small numbers associated with each of these areas being a contributory factor in this variation (Figure 5).

[Image: Figure 5: YDNP – population growth index (2001=100). A line graph showing the population growth index for the five district portions from 2001 to 2017. Eden shows the highest relative growth (peaking near 113), while Lancaster shows high volatility due to small sample size. Craven and Richmondshire remain relatively flat near the 100 index mark.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

2.7 The growth and decline of the YDNP population are reflected in the ‘components-of-change’ profile for the 2001–2017 period (Figure 6). Natural change is the annual balance between births and deaths; net migration is the balance of the inflow and outflow of population moving to and from the YDNP. With an ageing population, natural change has resulted in a consistent population decline since 2001,


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 6 October 2019

with the largest deficit post-2014. Net migration had its most significant impact pre-2008, with the net inflow recorded since 2012/13 countered by the relatively high natural change deficit.

[Image: Figure 6: YDNP – components of change 2001/2–2016/17. A bar chart showing "Natural Change" (green bars, consistently negative) and "Net Migration" (grey bars, mostly positive). The bars show that since 2008, negative natural change has often outweighed positive net migration, leading to population decline or stagnation.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

2.8 International migration has had an impact upon demographic change within the National Park, supporting the local economy, particularly the hospitality industry. The Department for Works and Pensions (DWP) records National Insurance Number (NINo) registrations associated with foreign workers. The NINo statistics are not a direct measure of migration as they do not include a comparable measure of ‘return’ migration, however they do give an indication of the impact of foreign workers based on place of residence at the time of registration (Figure 7).

[Image: Figure 7: YDNP – NINo registrations 2002–2018. A stacked area chart showing registrations by origin. The vast majority of registrations are from the EU (blue area), peaking in 2006-2007 at over 120 registrations and declining to around 60 by 2018. Other categories (Other Europe, Asia, Rest of the World) represent a very small fraction.]

Source: DWP

2.9 There have been 1,200 NINo registrations in the YDNP since 2002, peaking in 2006-07 and averaging approximately 70 per year since 2009. The overwhelming majority of registrations have been from migrant workers from within the European Union (EU). Over 52% of NINo registrations have been associated with migrant workers resident in the Craven portion of the YDNP, 25% in the Park’s portion of the Richmondshire district.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 7 October 2019

Population Age Profile

2.10 The low-growth profile of the YDNP is reflected in its changing age structure. In 2001, 21% of its population was aged 65+; by 2017, this had increased to 30%. The Park’s age-pyramid is becoming increasingly ‘top-heavy’, with a striking imbalance between younger and older age-cohorts (Figure 8).

[Image: Figure 8: YDNP – population age profile 2001–2017. Two population pyramids comparing 2001 and 2017. The 2017 pyramid shows a significantly wider top (older age groups 60-85+) and a narrower base (younger age groups 0-44) compared to the 2001 pyramid, illustrating the ageing population trend.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS. Accompanying sub-district profiles are provided in Appendix B

2.11 An illustration of growth rates by age-group since 2001 emphasises the variations that exist in the younger and older cohorts (Figure 9). The size of the core labour-force population has reduced by 7% since 2001. In contrast the size of the 65+ age-group has increased year-on-year, achieving a 45% growth rate over the sixteen-year period.

[Image: Figure 9: YDNP – population age profile 2001–2017 (Growth Index). A line graph showing growth indices for different age groups. The 65+ (Retirement) group shows a steep upward trend to an index of 145. All other groups (16-64 Labour Force, 11-15 Secondary, 5-10 Primary, and 0-4 Pre-School) show downward trends, with the 0-4 group dropping most significantly to an index of 70.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

2.12 Pre-school, primary school and secondary school age-group populations have all declined since 2001 and particularly since 2010. At mid-year 2017, pre-school populations were at approximately 70% of their 2001 totals, with primary and secondary totals at 80%.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 8 October 2019

2.13 The latest statistics from the Department for Education (DfE) indicate that there are 23 mainstream primary schools in the YDNP, two mainstream secondaries, plus four independent schools (Table 1).

Table 1: YDNP Schools

School NameDistrictNumber on Roll 2014Number on Roll 2019Change
Austwick CofE VA Primary SchoolCraven53585
Burnsall VA Primary SchoolCraven3424-10
Clapham CofE VC Primary School*Craven3728-9
Cracoe and Rylstone VC CofE Primary SchoolCraven4639-7
Embsay CofE VC Primary SchoolCraven2082091
Grassington CofE VC Primary SchoolCraven6259-3
Kettlewell Primary SchoolCraven26304
Kirkby in Malhamdale United VA Primary SchoolCraven44517
Long Preston Endowed VA Primary SchoolCraven566913
The Boyle and Petyt Primary SchoolCraven598627
Threshfield SchoolCraven6258-4
Asby Endowed SchoolEden2118-3
Crosby Ravensworth CofE SchoolEden3834-4
Orton CofE SchoolEden68724
Leck St Peter's CofE Primary SchoolLancaster39401
Arkengarthdale CofE Primary SchoolRichmondshire316-25
Askrigg VC Primary SchoolRichmondshire32375
Bainbridge CofE Primary and Nursery SchoolRichmondshire49523
Gunnerside Methodist Primary SchoolRichmondshire71912
Hawes Primary SchoolRichmondshire95972
Reeth Community Primary SchoolRichmondshire53530
West Burton CofE Primary SchoolRichmondshire3921-18
Dent CofE VA Primary SchoolSouth Lakeland3830-8
Sedbergh Primary SchoolSouth Lakeland170160-10
Mainstream Primary Total1,3671,350-17
Upper Wharfedale SchoolCraven2962960
Settlebeck SchoolSouth Lakeland16419733
Mainstream Secondary Total46049333
Wharfedale Montessori SchoolCraven224826
Casterton, Sedbergh Preparatory SchoolSouth Lakeland16419834
Sedbergh SchoolSouth Lakeland48054767
Underley Garden SchoolSouth Lakeland315524
Independent Total697848151

* Clapham CofE VC Primary School is situated just outside the YDNP boundary. Source: DfE

2.14 In total, mainstream primary school numbers on roll (NOR) have fallen only slightly since 2014 but there have been significant reductions in numbers in some localities, notably West Burton and


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 9 October 2019

Arkengarthdale. Secondary NOR has grown by a class size since 2014, whilst the independent school total has increased by +151.

Housing Growth

2.15 With the recent extension of the YDNP geography, a definitive set of statistics on historical housing completions within all five sub-district areas is not yet available. However, data for the Craven, South Lakeland and Richmondshire components of the National Park suggest a ten-year average of just less than 30 completions per year (Table 2).

Table 2: YDNP – housing completions

Sub-DistrictCompletions Last 5 YearsCompletions Last 10 Years
Craven84139
South Lakeland1950
Richmondshire3197
Total134286

Source: YDNP Planning Authority

2.16 In addition, evidence on barn conversion activity, reveals that a total of 146 housing units have been added to the housing stock since 2002 (Figure 10), which would increase the average completion rate over the last ten years to approximately 38 per year. A further 52 barn units are under-construction, with another 85 in the pipeline.

[Image: Figure 10: YDNP – barn conversions 2002–2019. A horizontal bar chart showing the status of barn conversions. Completed 2002-19: 146 units; Started: 52 units; Not-Started: 85 units.]

Source: YDNP Planning Authority

2.17 These average housing growth statistics hide the large variation between pre-2009 and post-2009 completions. The previous demographic analysis completed for the YDNP Authority^5 indicated that there in excess of 85 new homes built within the YDNP in each of 2006/07, 2007/08 and 2008/09, contrasting to sub-40 units per year thereafter.

2.18 An alternative perspective on housing growth is provided by the Royal Mail’s Postcode Address File (PAF) which provides a record of the total number of residential ‘addresses’. A comparison of 2012


^5 Yorkshire Dales National Park. Demographic Forecasts. November 2015


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 10 October 2019

and 2019 PAF evidence reveals how growth rates have differed between the sub-district areas of the YDNP and how they compare with the district geographies which sit outside the YDNP boundary (Figure 11).

[Image: Figure 11: YDNP – address growth 2012–2019. A map of the National Park with labels for each district showing address growth "Inside YDNP" vs "Outside YDNP". Eden: Inside +5.4%, Outside +5.6%. South Lakeland: Inside +2.1%, Outside +3.7%. Lancaster: Inside +1.3%, Outside +4.6%. Richmondshire: Inside -0.2%, Outside +5.1%. Craven: Inside +3.2%, Outside +4.4%. The map uses the same color scheme as Figure 1.]

Contains Ordnance Survey Data © Crown Copyright and database rights 2019. Source: Royal Mail’s PAF

2.19 Residential address growth in the Park averages 2.2% for the 2012-2019, seven-year period, highest in Eden and lowest in the Richmondshire YDNP geographies (Table 3). Evidence for Eden suggests its growth was concentrated in the period to 2017, with little growth thereafter.

Table 3: YDNP – housing growth 2012–2019

Sub-districtEstimated Address Count (PAF) 2012Estimated Address Count (PAF) 2019Change%
Craven4,9345,0941603.2%
Richmondshire3,8443,836-8-0.2%
South Lakeland2,3282,377492.1%
Eden1,2081,274665.4%
Lancaster10510611.3%
TOTAL12,42012,6882682.2%

Source: Royal Mail’s PAF


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 11 October 2019

2.20 The YDNP area has a distinct mix of properties that are both primary residencies and second or holiday homes. A ‘vacancy rate’, defined as the ratio between the number of properties and the number of resident households has been derived from the 2011 Census, the most definitive source of evidence on small-area housing and household statistics.

Table 4: YDNP – 2011 vacancy rates

Sub-districtInside YDNPOutside YDNP
Craven16.1%7.3%
Eden16.4%8.6%
Lancaster7.0%4.8%
Richmondshire30.7%7.0%
South Lakeland15.6%12.7%
TOTAL20.7%8.2%

Source: 2011 Census

2.21 These data reveal an average vacancy rate in excess of 20% across the YDNP geography, varying between just 7% in the very small portion of the Park that sits within the Lancaster district, to over 30% in the Richmondshire sub-district area.

Commuting Flows

2.22 The 2011 Census provides an illustration of the number of employed people living in the YDNP in 2011, together with a count of the level of employment that was evident. The balance between the two provides an indication of the Park’s commuting balance (Table 5).

Table 5: YDNP – 2011 travel-to-work statistics

Yorkshire Dales National Park2011 Census
Resident Workers12,022
Workplace-based Employment11,077
Commuting Ratio1.09

Source: 2011 Census. Accompanying sub-district profiles are provided in Appendix C

2.23 The Census recorded 12,022 workers aged 16+ living in the YDNP and 11,077 people aged 16–74 working within the National Park borders. The higher number of resident workers compared to the workplace-based employed results in a net out-commute, at a ratio of 1.09.

2.24 Closer inspection of these commuting flows, illustrates that over 60% of people who live in the Park also work there, and nearly a quarter work outside the National Park but still within the districts of Craven, Richmondshire, South Lakeland, Eden and Lancaster (Figure 12).


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 12 October 2019

[Image: Figure 12: YDNP – travel-to-work dynamics. Two pie charts.

  1. "Where do people who live in the Yorkshire Dales work?": Yorkshire Dales NP (60.9%), Rest of Craven, S Lakeland, Richmondshire, Eden and Lancaster (23.4%), Elsewhere (15.7%).
  2. "Where do people who work in the Yorkshire Dales live?": Yorkshire Dales NP (66.1%), Rest of Craven, S Lakeland, Richmondshire, Eden and Lancaster (21.5%), Elsewhere (12.4%).]

Source: 2011 Census. Accompanying sub-district profiles are provided in Appendix C

2.25 Of those working within the Park, the majority (66.1%) also live within its borders, with the remaining workers coming from the rest of Craven, Richmondshire, South Lakeland, Eden and Lancaster (21.5%) or from elsewhere (12.4%). Further detail on the commuting flows associated with the sub-district areas of the YDNP is provided in Appendix C.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 13 October 2019

3 Growth Scenarios

Approach

3.1 Every two years, ONS publishes its national and sub-national population projections (SNPP), setting key assumptions on the long-term effects of fertility, mortality and migration to estimate population growth outcomes. The 2016-based SNPP is the latest projection released by ONS, using demographic assumptions derived from a pre-2016, 5–6-year historical period and incorporating national assumptions on fertility, mortality and international migration to formulate a 25-year (2016–2041) projection for each local authority area. The 2016-based Principal and variant projections provide an updated population growth outlook to the previous 2014-based population projection, which covered the 2014–2039 time-period and based its assumptions on the 5–6-year period pre-2014.

3.2 ONS population projections inform its household projections, providing key assumptions on the future number of households, average household size and household formation by age group and sex. The ONS 2016-based household projections are underpinned by the associated population projections and incorporate a number of methodological changes, compared to previous household projections published by the MHCLG.

3.3 The 2016-based projections reflect more recent trends, but it is the 2014-based household projections which remain the starting point in the assessment of future housing need within local authority areas; generally estimating an overall higher level of household growth over the 25-year forecast horizon.

3.4 The latest PPG and NPPF, provide a ‘standard methodology’ to calculate the minimum housing need for local authorities in England using the average annual household growth under the 2014-based household projections for a ten-year period, together with the latest affordability ratio as its starting point.

3.5 For National Parks, where strategic policy-making authority boundaries do not align with local authority boundaries and where ONS population and household projections are not routinely available, the PPG provides alternative guidance for local housing need assessment.

“Where strategic policy-making authorities do not align with local authority boundaries (either individually or in combination), or the data required for the model are not available such as in National Parks and the Broads Authority, where local authority boundaries have changed due to reorganisation within the last 5 years or local authority areas where the samples are too small, an alternative approach will have to be used. Such authorities may continue to identify a housing need figure using a method determined locally, but in doing so will need to consider the best available information on anticipated changes in households as well as local affordability levels.” PPG Paragraph: 014 Reference ID: 2a-014-20190220

3.6 The YDNP now intersects five districts: Craven, Eden, Lancaster, South Lakeland and Richmondshire. In compiling the demographic evidence and forecasts presented in this report, it has been necessary


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 14 October 2019

to identify the YDNP geography that resides in each of the five districts, achieving the proportional split using a combination of OA populations, plus PAF property distributions.

3.7 POPGROUP technology (see Appendix A) has been used to develop a range of growth scenarios for the YDNP in aggregate and for the geographical portions that fall within each of the five districts. All scenarios are based on historical demographic evidence for the period 2001–2017 and have a 2040 forecast horizon. Household growth assumptions have been drawn from MHCLG's 2014-based SNHP (consistent with PPG guidelines), scaled for consistency with the YDNP geography.

Scenario Development

3.8 The preceding demographic analysis of the YDNP has indicated a relatively low growth profile since 2001, coupled with a rapid ageing of the population. Five trend scenarios consider how the YDNP’s population profile might evolve under different migration assumptions:

  • SNPP-2014: this scenario uses the ONS 2014-based SNPP for each of the five intersecting local authorities and applies its growth assumptions to the YDNP geography;
  • SNPP-2016: this scenario uses the ONS 2016-based SNPP for each of the five intersecting local authorities and applies its growth assumptions to the YDNP geography;
  • PG-Short Term: this scenario considers the most recent mid-year population evidence, to derive a trend scenario based upon migration histories from the last six years (2011–2017);
  • PG-Long Term: this scenario considers a longer-term history of evidence, drawing its migration assumptions from the 2001–2017 time-period;
  • Net-Nil: this scenario is included to provide an indication of demographic change that would result from a situation where migration is having no overall net effect upon the YDNP’s annual population growth/decline, whilst continuing to affect age-group differences.

3.9 To mitigate the ongoing effects of low population growth and rapid ageing of the population, the YDNP will require a change to its net migration profile, maintaining and attracting younger age cohorts. Longer-term alterations to the migration profile will invariably be underpinned by suitable housing provision. To complement the trend scenarios and to consider how different levels of housing provision might alter the demographic profile of the YDNP, a series of ‘dwelling-led’ scenarios have been formulated:

  • Dwelling-led +10: this scenario evaluates the impact of a housing growth trajectory of +10 new homes per year;

Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 15 October 2019

  • Dwelling-led +30: this evaluates the impact of a housing growth trajectory of +30 new homes per year;
  • Dwelling-led +50: this evaluates the impact of a housing growth trajectory of +50 new homes per year;
  • Dwelling-led +70: this evaluates the impact of a housing growth trajectory of +70 new homes per year.

3.10 These ‘dwelling-led’ scenarios evaluate the demographic implications of a defined housing growth trajectory, matching dwelling numbers to household numbers using a vacancy rate and matching households to population using household representative rates and communal population statistics.

Scenario Outcomes

3.11 The 2001–2040 population growth trajectories for all scenarios are presented in Figure 13. In Table 6, each of the scenarios is summarised in terms of population, household and net migration change, with an estimate of the change in dwelling numbers that would result over the 2017–2040 forecast period.

3.12 The Net-Nil scenario indicates the degree to which the YDNP’s population would decline in the absence of annual migration effects, with a 15.5% reduction estimated by 2040. All other scenarios record a positive annual impact of migration, with a range of population growth outcomes from -10% under the SNPP-2016 scenario to +5.3% under the Dwelling-led +70 scenario.

3.13 A 9% decline in population is projected by 2040 under the SNPP-2014 which, under MHCLG’s standard methodology, provides the starting point for the assessment of future housing need. The PG-Short Term and PG-Long Term scenarios, using more recent historical evidence, estimate relatively similar growth outcomes to the SNPP-2014 but with a less severe decline in the housing requirement, with the maintenance of a slightly more youthful migration profile.

3.14 With its relatively old age profile, the process of population ageing will accelerate in the YDNP over the course of the plan-period, to 2040. The Dwelling-led scenarios indicate the potential effects that different levels of housing provision might have, not only on population growth but also on the maintenance of a more youthful population profile through net in-migration to the YDNP.

3.15 The current age-profile of the YDNP means that its population growth outlook will always be constrained, indicated by the fact that even with housing growth of +70 per year, population change is estimated at a modest 5.3% between 2017–2040.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 16 October 2019

[Image: Figure 13: YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. A line graph showing historical population (2001-2017) and projected population for nine scenarios through 2040. The Dwelling-led +70 scenario shows the only significant growth. All SNPP and trend scenarios (PG-Long/Short) show significant declines, with Net Nil showing the steepest drop toward 20,000 people.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

Table 6: YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePopulation Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Average Net MigrationAverage Dwellings
Dwelling-led +701,2465.3%1,28211.9%22470
Dwelling-led +503231.4%9168.5%18650
Dwelling-led +30-601-2.6%5505.1%14930
Dwelling-led +10-1,525-6.5%1831.7%11210
PG-Long Term-1,945-8.3%600.6%934
SNPP-2014-2,116-9.0%-193-1.8%102-15
PG-Short Term-2,204-9.4%20.0%730
SNPP-2016-2,353-10.0%-196-1.8%73-14
Net Nil-3,646-15.5%-1,105-10.2%0-60

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS. Note: Scenario profiles for each YDNP district sub-area are provided in Appendix D.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 17 October 2019

Age Structure

3.16 The ageing population profile of the YDNP is a key factor in planning future housing within the National Park and in considering its future economic vitality and development. The changing population age profiles associated with each of the nine scenarios is illustrated below (Figure 14).

[Image: Figure 14: YDNP – population change by 5-year age group 2017–2040. Nine bar charts (one for each scenario). In all scenarios, the age groups from 70-74 to 90+ are shown in orange, indicating that the 2040 population in these cohorts is HIGHER than 2017. Most age groups below 70 are shown in grey, indicating the 2040 population is LOWER than 2017. Even in the "Dwelling-led +70" scenario, most youth/working age cohorts remain grey or only slightly orange.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 18 October 2019

3.17 Under all scenarios, growth of the older-age population is immutable, emphasising the impact that further ageing of an already relatively old age-profile has upon the YDNP. What does alter under each of the scenarios is the change in the younger, 0–70 age-groups, depending upon the degree to which in-migration (driven by higher housing growth) influences the scenario.

3.18 None of the scenarios revert to a strong growth profile in the 0–70, although the higher migration variants do dampen the decline by ensuring that a more youthful population is maintained within the YDNP, avoiding the extreme profile of decline evident in the Net Nil scenario outcome, for example.

3.19 The changing population age profiles under each of the scenarios have been combined with age-specific rates of economic activity (also known as participation rates), to provide an indication of the changing size of the YDNP’s resident labour force (Figure 15). The base economic activity rates have been drawn from the 2011 Census but have been updated and projected forward to take account of the OBR’s latest long-term outlook for labour force participation. The OBR outlook considers both changes to state pension age (SPA), higher female participation rates and the trend towards higher rates of participation in older age-groups.

[Image: Figure 15: YDNP – labour force growth trajectory 2017–2040. A line graph showing the projected labor force size. Only the Dwelling-led +70 scenario manages to maintain the labor force near its 2017 level (approx. 12,300). All other scenarios show a decline, with the Net Nil scenario labor force dropping below 9,500 by 2040.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

3.20 Under the Net Nil scenario, the current labour force estimate of almost 12,500, declines to approximately 9,500 by 2040. In contrast, the highest housing growth scenario, Dwelling-led +70, maintains a labour force of approximately 12,500 throughout the forecast period.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 19 October 2019

4 Summary

Context

4.1 The YDNP Authority, together with funding from Craven, Richmondshire and North Yorkshire County Councils, has commissioned the development of Social, Economic and Housing Study, providing critical evidence to inform a new Local Plan for the National Park. The Park is challenged to maintain the economic vitality of its local communities, in the face of an ageing and declining population. The study will support long-term, sustainable planning objectives, including housing growth targets that are in general compliance with specific NPPF/PPG guidance for National Park Planning Authorities and that seek to attract and retain younger population cohorts.

4.2 Informing the core SEA and SHMA reports which underpin the Social, Economic and Housing Study, this analysis has considered both the historical profile of population change within the Park and the prospects for future growth. The demographic evidence and forecasts have been compiled and presented for the newly extended YDNP geography, encompassing portions of the Craven, Eden, Lancaster, South Lakeland and Richmondshire districts.

4.3 Since 2001, ONS population estimates suggest only limited growth within the YDNP, with a rise in population numbers to 2008, reducing thereafter. Since 2012, growth has been positive but below 1%, in total, to 2017. Low growth or population decline has become a characteristic of the majority of the National Park areas.

4.4 In the absence of definitive statistics on past housing growth from the newly extended areas of the Park, PAF statistics have been used to illustrate a growth of approximately 38 new addresses per year across the YDNP, with approximately 60% of this growth within the Craven district portion. Second homes proliferate across the YDNP, with ‘vacancy’ rates in excess of 30% in the Richmondshire area, 15–16% in Craven, Eden and South Lakeland.

4.5 The low-growth profile of the YDNP is reflected in its changing age structure. Pre-school, primary school and secondary school age-group populations have all declined since 2001 and particularly since 2010. In addition, the size of the core labour-force population has reduced by 7% since 2001. In contrast the size of the 65+ age-group has increased year-on-year, achieving a 45% growth rate over the sixteen-year period. In 2001, 21% of the Park’s population was aged 65+; by 2017, this figure had increased to 30%. Without intervention these trends are projected to continue.

Growth Outcomes

4.6 POPGROUP technology has been used to develop a range of growth scenarios for the YDNP in aggregate and for the geographical portions that fall within each of the five districts. All scenarios


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 20 October 2019

have been based on historical demographic evidence for the period 2001–2017 and have a 2040 forecast horizon. Household growth assumptions have been drawn from MHCLG's 2014-based SNHP, scaled for consistency with the YDNP geography.

4.7 Five trend scenarios have been formulated to consider how the YDNP’s population profile might evolve under different migration assumptions. In addition, ‘dwelling-led’ scenarios have been presented which evaluate the demographic implications of fixed housing growth trajectories, matching dwelling numbers to household numbers using a vacancy rate and matching households to population using household representative rates and communal population statistics.

4.8 In summary, scenario outcomes are presented here for 2023-2040, a plan-period that is consistent with the YDNP’s new Local Plan. Population change under each scenario (Figure 16) is presented alongside estimated dwelling growth (Figure 17).

[Image: Figure 16: YDNP – population change (%) 2023–2040. A bar chart showing percentage population change. Only Dwelling-led +70 (+4.6%) and Dwelling-led +50 (+1.8%) show growth. All others show decline: Dwelling-led +30 (-1.1%), Dwelling-led +10 (-4.0%), SNPP-2014 (-7.0%), PG-Long Term (-7.5%), SNPP-2016 (-7.9%), PG-Short Term (-8.1%), Net Nil (-12.8%).]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS

[Image: Figure 17: YDNP – average annual dwelling growth 2023–2040. A bar chart showing the required average annual dwellings for each scenario. Ranging from 70 for the +70 scenario down to -83 for the Net Nil scenario.]

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 21 October 2019

4.9 Population decline is a characteristic of all but the Dwelling-led +50 and Dwelling-led +70 scenarios, with higher housing growth associated with higher net in-migration to the YDNP. The higher net-migration outcomes, underpinned by higher housing provision, will support the maintenance of the Park’s resident labour force and help to dampen the increasing imbalance between younger and older age-groups.

4.10 The YDNP combines a unique landscape with an increasingly challenging socio-economic profile. The Park is characterised by a rapidly ageing population profile coupled with a large number of holiday letting properties, supporting its critical tourist industry. Whilst maintaining the unique identity of the YDNP is a key objective of the Planning Authority, a desire to promote economic vitality of its local communities and to maintain a more youthful population profile in the face of rapid population ageing, are likely to require particular policy interventions related to new housing provision. The evidence in this report is provided to inform appropriate socio-economic strategies and policies within and around the YDNP geographical area.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 22 October 2019

Appendix A: POPGROUP Methodology

A.1 Evidence is often challenged on the basis of the appropriateness of the methodology that has been employed to develop growth forecasts. The use of a recognised forecasting product which incorporates an industry-standard methodology (a cohort component model) removes this obstacle and enables a focus on assumptions and output, rather than method.

A.2 Demographic forecasts have been developed using the POPGROUP suite of products. POPGROUP is a family of demographic models that enables forecasts to be derived for population, households and labour force, for areas and social groups. The main POPGROUP model (Figure 18) is a cohort component model, which enables the development of population forecasts based on birth, death and migration inputs and assumptions.

[Image: Figure 18: POPGROUP population projection methodology. A circular flowchart titled "POPGROUP v.4 Population Projection Methodology". It shows a cycle: 1. Single age/sex values set to base year. 2. Births & deaths calculated/added/subtracted. 3. Migrants calculated/added/subtracted. 4. Special populations added back in. 5. Check if it's the final year or if there's a constraint (like housing). If not, it loops back. If finished, it outputs report workbooks.]


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 23 October 2019

A.3 The Derived Forecast (DF) model (Figure 19) sits alongside the population model, providing a headship rate model for household projections, and an economic activity rate model for labour force projections.

[Image: Figure 19: Derived Forecast (DF) model. A technical diagram showing the relationship between "Population 'at risk' forecast by age and sex" and "Derived Category Rates by age and sex" (e.g. headship & economic activity rates). These flow into a "Derived Category Forecast" to produce the final output. The mathematical formula $D{a,s,u,y,d,g} = \frac{P{a,s,u,y,g} \cdot R_{a,s,u,y,d,g}}{100}$ is shown below.]

A.4 For further information on POPGROUP, please refer to the Edge Analytics website: https://www.edgeanalytics.co.uk/


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 24 October 2019

Appendix B: Population Age Profiles – Sub-district Areas

[Image: Page 27 contains six population pyramids comparing 2001 (left side) and 2017 (right side) for three sub-areas:

  1. Craven-YDNP: Shows a clear shift from a relatively balanced distribution in 2001 to a top-heavy structure in 2017, with a notable bulge in the 50-70 age range.
  2. Eden-YDNP: Similar shift, with a significantly reduced base (ages 0-39) and increased proportion of residents aged 60+.
  3. Lancaster-YDNP: Highly irregular shapes due to very small population size (total ~278), making the data less robust, though still showing an older-skewed profile in 2017.]

Note: the Lancaster-YDNP area is very small, making its data less robust.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 25 October 2019

[Image: Page 28 contains four population pyramids for the remaining two sub-areas:

  1. Richmondshire-YDNP: In 2017, this area shows a very thin base for young adults (ages 20-34) and a very large concentration of residents in the 50-75+ age groups.
  2. South Lakeland-YDNP: Exhibits the same general trend of a narrowing base and expanding top, indicating a high proportion of elderly residents.]

Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 26 October 2019

Appendix C: Commuting Statistics – Sub-district Areas

Craven-YDNP

Craven (in YDNP)2011 Census
Resident Workers4,978
Workplace-based Employment4,317
Commuting Ratio1.15

[Image: Pie charts for Craven-YDNP commuting. 54.0% of residents work in the YDNP. 61.9% of those who work in the Craven portion of the YDNP also live there.]

Eden-YDNP

Eden (in YDNP)2011 Census
Resident Workers1,329
Workplace-based Employment1,290
Commuting Ratio1.03

[Image: Pie charts for Eden-YDNP commuting. 58.8% of residents work in the YDNP. 59.5% of those who work in the Eden portion of the YDNP also live there.]

Lancaster-YDNP

Lancaster (in YDNP)2011 Census
Resident Workers150
Workplace-based Employment144
Commuting Ratio1.04

[Image: Pie charts for Lancaster-YDNP commuting. 49.3% of residents work in the YDNP. 53.5% of those who work in the Lancaster portion of the YDNP also live there.]


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 27 October 2019

Richmondshire-YDNP

Richmondshire (in YDNP)2011 Census
Resident Workers3,288
Workplace-based Employment3,195
Commuting Ratio1.03

[Image: Pie charts for Richmondshire-YDNP commuting. 68.8% of residents work in the YDNP. 71.0% of those who work in the Richmondshire portion of the YDNP also live there.]

South Lakeland-YDNP

South Lakeland (in YDNP)2011 Census
Resident Workers2,277
Workplace-based Employment2,131
Commuting Ratio1.07

[Image: Pie charts for South Lakeland-YDNP commuting. 66.7% of residents work in the YDNP. 72.1% of those who work in the South Lakeland portion of the YDNP also live there.]


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 28 October 2019

Appendix D: Scenario Outcomes – Sub-district Areas


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 29 October 2019

Craven-YDNP

[Image: Figure 20: Craven-YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. A line graph showing that most scenarios for Craven result in a population decline or flatlining, with only the Dwelling-led +70 and +50 scenarios showing significant growth.]

Table 7: Craven-YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePop Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Net MigrationDwellings
Dwelling-led +707988.1%54212.2%11728
Dwelling-led +503984.0%3878.7%10120
SNPP-2014370.4%1573.5%928
Dwelling-led +30-20.0%2325.2%8512
SNPP-2016-64-0.6%1974.4%8110
PG-Short Term-169-1.7%1172.6%686
Dwelling-led +10-402-4.1%771.7%694
PG-Long Term-632-6.4%-2-0.1%590
Net Nil-1,718-17.4%-688-15.5%0-36

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 30 October 2019

Eden-YDNP

[Image: Figure 21: Eden-YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. A line graph where nearly all scenarios project a decline from the 2017 population level of approx 2,400. Only Dwelling-led +70 shows growth.]

Table 8: Eden-YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePop Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Net MigrationDwellings
Dwelling-led +70863.6%13512.9%157
Dwelling-led +50-10-0.4%979.2%115
PG-Long Term-39-1.6%878.3%105
Dwelling-led +30-105-4.4%585.5%73
Dwelling-led +10-201-8.4%191.8%31
SNPP-2014-213-9.0%-36-3.4%5-2
SNPP-2016-221-9.3%-25-2.4%3-1
Net Nil-311-13.1%-25-2.4%0-1
PG-Short Term-328-13.8%-43-4.2%-2-2

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 31 October 2019

Lancaster-YDNP

[Image: Figure 22: Lancaster-YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. Because the population is so small (~278), the projection lines are volatile. SNPP scenarios show massive percentage growth projections that contrast sharply with dwelling-led scenarios.]

Table 9: Lancaster-YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePop Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Net MigrationDwellings
SNPP-201420873.4%10084.8%95
SNPP-201611545.7%5452.1%53
PG-Short Term8932.1%4538.6%52
Net Nil186.6%1815.1%01
PG-Long Term114.1%2118.2%11
Dwelling-led +70-7-2.5%1310.7%01
Dwelling-led +50-15-5.3%97.7%00
Dwelling-led +30-23-8.1%54.6%00
Dwelling-led +10-30-10.9%21.6%-10

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS. Note: the Lancaster-YDNP area is very small, making its data and forecasts less robust.


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 32 October 2019

Richmondshire-YDNP

[Image: Figure 23: Richmondshire-YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. All scenarios show a significant downward trend for the population (starting around 6,100), with only the Dwelling-led +70 scenario ending slightly above the 2017 level.]

Table 10: Richmondshire-YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePop Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Net MigrationDwellings
Dwelling-led +70490.8%33810.6%5021
Dwelling-led +50-177-2.8%2417.6%4115
Dwelling-led +30-403-6.4%1454.6%319
PG-Long Term-581-9.3%732.3%235
Dwelling-led +10-629-10.1%481.5%223
PG-Short Term-926-14.8%220.7%111
Net Nil-965-15.4%-232-7.3%0-15
SNPP-2016-1,492-23.7%-359-11.2%-16-22
SNPP-2014-1,543-24.4%-383-11.9%-14-24

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS


Yorkshire Dales National Park - Demographic Evidence 33 October 2019

South Lakeland-YDNP

[Image: Figure 24: South Lakeland-YDNP – population growth trajectory 2001–2040. Shows population decline in most scenarios from a 2017 level of ~4,700, with Dwelling-led +70 and +50 being the exceptions.]

Table 11: South Lakeland-YDNP – demographic scenario outcomes 2017–2040

ScenarioPopulation ChangePop Change %Households ChangeHouseholds Change %Net MigrationDwellings
Dwelling-led +703216.8%25412.6%4113
Dwelling-led +501262.7%1829.0%349
Dwelling-led +30-69-1.5%1095.4%266
Dwelling-led +10-264-5.6%361.8%182
SNPP-2014-605-12.6%-31-1.5%10-2
Net Nil-669-14.2%-178-8.8%0-9
SNPP-2016-691-14.5%-63-3.1%1-3
PG-Long Term-704-15.0%-118-5.9%0-6
PG-Short Term-869-18.5%-138-6.9%-9-7

Source: Edge Analytics, ONS