Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Strategic Water quality Plan for Semer Water.

Student ID: 37649817 Word Count: 1997

1 Mission Statement

From the observations of Yorkshire National Park representatives and prior studies, including an infield investigation undertaken on the 11th March 2022, 2 distinct issues have been identified within Semer Water, a water body situated within the Raydale catchment, Yorkshire Dales (see Figure 1). These issues are: (i) Diffuse pollution with a specific focus on high concentration of total phosphorous within the water body of Semer Water which is currently failing to meet the WFD legislative standards (European Commission, 2000:2000/60/EC, 2008/105/EC and 2013/39/EU) and, (ii) High sediment delivery into Semer water in-turn affecting the biogeochemical and physical properties of the water body, furthermore impacting the water quality status (European Commission, 2000:2000/60/EC, 2008/105/EC and 2013/39/EU). Accordingly, failure to mitigate these threats could result in losses of: the catchments long standing SSSI status (47 years); critically under threat species, such as white clawed crayfish; various bird species; and potential economic losses from recreational use. Consequently, this report outlines an immediate action plan aiming to restore ‘good’ status across the catchments hydrology and ecology by 2030. Further, ensuring progress with England’s wildlife and ecosystem services strategy plan for ‘Biodiversity 2020’.

1


[Image: A map showing the WFD Water Body Raydale Catchment outlined in red. The map highlights Semer Water (a blue lake), major and minor waterways in blue, and the Yorkshire Dales National Park Boundary in green. An inset map shows the location of the catchment within the northern UK. A scale bar indicates a length of 4 Kilometers.]

Figure 1: Figure illustrating the location of Semer Water within Yorkshire National Park and the catchment boundary.

2


2 Literature review

2.1 Issues affecting lakes like Semer Water

Valley cattle farming catchments like Semer Water contain a mixture of farms: dairy, beef and sheep. Together presenting unique water quality issues (YDNP, 2022). The steep upper slopes (9.27°) and intensively grazed valley bottoms characterise much of the catchment area as high-risk sources of pollution (Pulley and Collins, 2021). This high-risk is particularly caused by diffuse pollution from cattle farming farmlands that are in close proximity to waterbodies as modern farming practices which use inorganic fertilisers, slurry/manure spreading (Figure 2), animal feed and veterinary products used on livestock to keep them pest free have negative impacts on the surrounding water quality without careful land management practices.

[Image: A photograph of a stone farm building in a green field with sheep. In the foreground, a stone wall separates the viewer from the field, which appears to have patches of dark slurry on the grass.]

Figure 2: Slurry on landscape.

Consequently, due to the high-risk source areas and diffuse pollution from modern farming practices, it is well identified that the catchment has issues with high total phosphorus levels within Semer Water (Gao et al., 2015; YDRT and YDNP, 2016; Pulley and Collins, 2021). The mobilisation of substances put onto the landscape or miss managed by farmers become solubilised and/or detached and then the delivery into nearby surface streams, lead to the influx of chemicals including phosphorus into water bodies causing eutrophication and worsening of water quality conditions (Haygarth

3


et al., 2005). In accordance with the YDNP (2022) the top five diffuse pollution risks include: lack of slurry and manure storage, peat erosion and grips, soil erosion from riverbanks, surface flow topsoil/poor land management, poor farm infrastructure (Figure 3). Within 2018 a sediment source project found that the majority of phosphorous was being delivered from the topsoils of farms within close proximity to Semer Water (YDNP, 2022).

[Image: A collage of five photographs labeled (a) through (e). (a) and (b) show farmyards with mud, standing water, and agricultural machinery. (c) shows a muddy field with heavy tire tracks. (d) shows a stream with eroded, muddy banks. (e) shows a large pile of manure/slurry behind a gate in an open field.]

Figure 3: (a)-(b) Poor farmyard infrastructure. (c) surface flow topsoil / poor land management due to heavy machinery soil compaction. (d)-(e) Lack of slurry and manure storage. Source: (a)-(c) YDNP, (d)-(e) myself.

Non-agricultural sources and pathways include the mobilisation of sediment from variable sources including: landslips, exposed hillslope topsoils (Figure 4) and peat + woodland (Pulley and Collins, 2021). These sources are typically mobilised during intense rainfall causing extensive erosion. This in tandem with efficient delivery during surface flows from source to nearest stream channel can be a significant contributing pathway (Collins and Walling, 2004).

The location of each source can have varying contributions as Figure 5 illustrates the sources are equally split contributing around ~ 25-35% each, with the exception of peat that contributes <15% across all periods. This is consistent across studies such as Chiverrell et al., (2008) which suggests historically the major source of sediment has been from landslips, fluvial incision and hillslope erosion.

4


[Image: Two photographs showing steep, grassy banks next to water that have collapsed or eroded, exposing raw soil.]

Figure 4: Examples of erodible banks within near proximity to tributary streams.

[Image: A bar chart titled "Semer Water" showing "Contribution (%)" on the Y-axis and various date ranges from Jan 2018 to Jul 2020 on the X-axis. The legend identifies four sources: Valley bottom farmland (blue), Hillslope topsoils (orange), Landslips and subsurface (grey), and Peat and woodland (green). The chart shows fluctuations in sediment contribution over time.]

Figure 5: Figure illustrating the contributions of sediment from each source (Pulley and Collins, 2021).

Sediment originating within the water body itself is also causing issues. The lake and sediment depth (within the lake) perturbs biochemical processes and consequently, can lead to phosphorus levels re-charging due to physical disturbances and from flood events. Sediment also causes issues within the catchment as it also brings phosphorous with it as well. This occurs as suspended sediments particles act as binding surface for the phosphorous (bio-accumulates) (Villa et al., 2019). This is therefore illustrating that sediment is a key issue (Gao et al., 2015; YDRT and YDNP, 2016; Pulley and Collins, 2021).

2.2 Pre-existing management practices

Working with local landowners has been crucial to understand the landscape and how best to manage it. An example of where cooperation has been undertaken is Natural England’s Catchment

5


sensitive farming (CSF) scheme (2019-ongoing). This scheme develops upon the YDRT Raydale Project which provided informed advice to the agricultural community to aid farmyard improvements including increasing slurry storage capacity. Directly providing benefits to minimise nutrient leaching. CSF successfully took this further by providing £47826 worth of advice and courses in order to help farmers better manage their land. The key focus was on manure, pesticides, and fertiliser management which was successful in lowering pesticide use by 25% when compared to 2006/07. Furthermore, decreasing the levels of sediment and phosphate by an average of 12% and 7% respectively. Resulting in less water standard breaches and visible improvements in aquatic ecology (YDNP, 2022).

Additionally, restoration across the peat bogs, utilising re-profiling, grip blocking and revegetation to provide more stability in the soils sediment as well as roughening the landscape to reduce surface hydrology flows and therefore, delivery of substances to the lower catchment. However, arguably this project has had no major direct benefit as limited sediment was being delivered from this region to the lake. This has been supported by multiple studies and models including SCIMAP (Chiverrell et al., 2008; Pulley and Collins, 2021). Highlighting, maybe this was not cost effective and could have been better utilised if modelled prior to implementation.

An assessment of the catchment using SCIMAP in 2009 (Figure 6) identified areas at risk to mobilisation of sediment to the nearest stream/river. It provided critical informed decisions, where best to implement mitigation strategies such as buffer strips, contour planting and additional mitigations which break up the connectivity between the mobilisation and delivery phases of pollution. It is suggested that the implementation of woodland buffers that account for 10% of the catchment area would effectively reduce sediment losses to around ~15% and reduce the rate of surface runoff provided the surface is roughened (Gao et al., 2015; Pulley and Collins, 2021). Additionally, it is noted that 20% coverage saw no additional benefits and therefore 10% would be more cost effective. Moreover, it is recommended that to maximise this coverage the buffer zones should be thin long bands adjacent to the stream channel (Gao et al., 2015).

6


[Image: A map of the catchment area with a color-coded network of lines following the waterways. Red lines indicate high risk of sediment mobilisation, while green/yellow lines indicate lower risk. The map is titled Figure 6: SCIMAP Model for the catchment.]

Figure 6: SCIMAP Model for the catchment. Red = high risk. Green = low risk

Summary

Despite implementation of successful schemes within the Semer Water catchment, issues are still ongoing and showing no evidence of favourable change. Therefore, there is argument to suggest that future plans should incorporate more targeted landuse and land modifying mitigations. However, it is acknowledged this will not be achieved without continued stewardship by farmers to learn new management practices to further minimise their part in the complex picture of diffuse water pollution within catchments.

7


3 Action Plan

[Image: A visual graphic containing three photographs. Top left: "Cooperation with farmers and landowners" showing people on a quad bike near sheep. Top right: "Target: 2030 Good Status" showing a wide view of Semer Water. Bottom center: "Implement optimized minimal change to catchment landscape" showing a fenced-off stream. Red arrows link these three concepts in a cycle.]

As the catchment has 2 key issues this plan addresses both equally as they have equal precedence upon both the hydrology and ecology within the catchment. Failure to do so may result in the missed opportunity to achieve an improved catchment (Collins et al., 2009; McGonigle et al., 2014).

As 2030 is a narrow timeline to change the water quality status for the catchment, this plan includes an assessment period midway through to ensure the project is running on time and assess that the implemented mitigation strategies are working. Thereby, allowing the opportunity to further refine the plan to achieve optimised outcomes for the target year 2030 (see, Timeline). During this review period, the lake chemical and ecological status will be assessed. Alongside, the amount of sediment being measured at 4 key sites to assess for reductions in sediment delivery (see, Figure 7).

Before implementation of solutions, Timeline outlines a 6-month period to engage with landowners to ask them: What they want from this plan? What previous plans have they engaged with? What are their thoughts on how they could minimise their own impacts? With the vision to collectively agree on a target plan, that all agreeing landowners would sign a declaration stating they are

8


willing to cooperate and partake in improving the Semer Water landscape through this plan. The implementation of a signed declaration is to make the landowners feel an equal ownership with the project (Vrain and Lovett, 2016). Therefore, instilling an element of stewardship and willingness to achieve the target goal as a matter of pride as opposed to a must. Additionally, this will hopefully, convince unsure landowners to get involved through indirect peer pressure.

Engagement with landowners will continue throughout the project with focus on yearly catch-up meetings with the Farming and Land Management Forum YDNP. Where update on plans and progress will be shared along with collective discussions on what appears to be going well and what is not, allowing for refining.

This plan takes the stance that although land management techniques are appropriate mitigations, Natural England CSF is still ongoing, and this plan will work in tandem to avoid adverse impacts from conflicting advice for farmers. Therefore, to maximise results this plan will predominantly provide optimised targeted land use and infrastructure mitigation strategies to tackle Semer water issues.

9


[Image: A detailed project timeline spanning from April 2022 to April 2030. Key milestones include:

  • 22 Apr 2022: Submission of initial proposed plan.
  • 01 May 2022: Begin engagement with catchment landowners.
  • 01 Nov 2022: Finalise initial plan; Signed landowner agreement.
  • 15 Jan 2023: Begin Phase 1 actions.
  • 01 Jun 2024: Begin Phase 2 actions.
  • 22 Apr 2026: Midpoint review; Take samples and assess status.
  • 15 Aug 2026: Implement adjustments.
  • 22 Apr 2030: Final review of Semer Water Conditions (Pass/Fail). The timeline also includes colored bars for Phase 1 and Phase 2. Legend items include: Install sediment traps, Implement 2m buffer, Start tree planting initiative, Expand fencing, and Joint CSF solution. Yearly landowner meetings are marked as blue dots along the central line.]

3.1 Mitigation options

There are varying mitigation that can be applied in order to address Semer Water issues and these are listed within Table 1.

Table 1: Table of potential solutions.

Plan numberMitigation action% of catchment being modifiedEconomic cost
1Buffer all OS classified minor waterways or above by 2m both sides.1.13%Loss of viable farming land valley floor farmers ~10% land lost. Only 3 farmland segments are predicted to be heavily encroach on visible farmland.
2Increase Tree cover in the catchment (currently 3%). Plant trees in gridded array 2m spacing = 567,500 trees (~2500 trees per acre). Implement in 6m by +100m strips in contour cultivation style alongside river channels in targeted regions2%~Approx £500,000 Assumption ~£0.90

11


3Adding fencing around all OS classified minor waterways or above to prevent both livestock, dogs and humans entering water streams. Realistically target highly vulnerable locations 1st then expand, aim to target 25% of the area by 2030Not necessarily area: 134km fencingAssume average priced fencing ~£6.50 per metre. If all fencing was applied: ~£871,000. Realistically: 25% target ~£217,750
4+30m Buffer margin for manure heaps from nearby water. Key sites targeted Cooperation with Natural England CSF and local policy pressures.0%No real cost simply requires farmer relocating on land.
5Improved slurry infrastructurenegligible; farm by farm basis.Type of stores: earth banked lagoons, £8-£12m³; a lagoon - an above ground metal tank, which costs about £47m³; or a shuttered concrete store, costing £59m³ (Business Wales, 2022) Funding streams through YDRT Raydale Project and CSF.

12


6Deepen Lake Semer water itself. Semi intensive dredging. Aim for +2m.0.63Dredging costs range £5 to £75 per m³. Totalling £4,000-60,000. logistical costs (including staff, disposal of material etc.) + initial maintenance costs ~750,000 (Jones et al., 2015). Overall expected to be around £1million.
7Install sediment traps that monthly get emptied and cleaned. 2 Benefits: can used for sampling + removes sediment from the system. Get emptied by local authority members or by agreement with local farmerssize dependent; negligibleDefined as low costs across all criteria (EA, 2012). Available for Countryside Stewardship Mid Tier, Higher Tier and Capital Grants; Natural England.

As the lowland grasslands contribute both the highest sediment and diffuse pollution from farmlands, it is best to apply finalised mitigations in these regions in order to deliver maximised cost-benefit outcomes (Pulleys and Collins, 2021). Using past models and simple GIS operations we identify 3 zones to prioritise implementation of solutions (see, Figure 7).

For these zones this plan would chose to implement both fences and a 2m buffer. We acknowledge this can be relatively costly however, some regions within these zones already have fences implemented and this study only wishes to fill the gaps ensuring no solution leaks (~£50,000-100,000). Arguably, this combined solution provides the most robust infrastructure solution to reduce the delivery of

13


[Image: A map of the Raydale catchment showing 3 numbered priority zones for tree planting (pink circles). Zone 1 (High priority - red) is near the center, Zone 2 (Med priority - orange) is to the south, and Zone 3 (Med priority - orange) is around the lake. Small purple hexagons represent proposed sediment traps. A 2m hydrology buffer is indicated by dark blue lines along the waterways.]

Figure 7: Map showing: sediment trap locations, areas that trees could be implemented ranked in accordance with priority.

agrochemical substances into the waterbody as it reduces the area these agrochemicals can be placed whilst further roughening the edges which perturbs the effectiveness of surface flows delivering the mobilised substances. Furthermore, the added benefit of fences means that, no cattle and or dogs can go for a drink/swim and directly input substances into the watercourse.

14


[Image: A high-resolution satellite imagery map showing a "Zoomed inset of Zone 1 from Figure 7". It shows green fields, hedgerows, and the river system. Proposed tree planting areas are overlaid in red (High priority) and orange (Med priority). A blue lake is visible at the top right.]

Figure 8: Zoomed inset of Zone 1 from Figure 7.

Additionally, this plan would also like to increase the percentage cover of trees within the landscape to 5%. However, realistically this is too costly to implement with fences and 2m buffers elsewhere in the catchment. However, this plan suggests that initially lets only plant trees in high prioritised zoned sites (red zones Figure 7). This lowers the cost to ~£220,000 which becomes more financially viable and highly cost beneficial. Lowering sediment delivery to ~15% in SCIMAP characterised high risk reaches. The planting of trees not only provides sediment benefits but also roughening of landscapes again perturbing the effectiveness of surface flows delivering the mobilised

15


substances. Furthermore, implementation in Zone 1 would improve water conditions for white clawed crayfish as the presence of trees the ideal coverage they require to thrive (Figure 9). Therefore, promising the expansion of their habitat in the catchment. Thereby, raising the WFD ecological standards as well as hydrological status.

[Image: A photograph of a shallow, rocky stream bed with clear water, surrounded by bare winter trees. The caption identifies it as a "Crayfish haven SSSI site."]

Figure 9: Crayfish haven SSSI site.

This study would not go down the route of deepening the lake as although it would reduce remobilisation of stored phosphorus it would simply be a significant logistical challenge and too costly to undertake. Likely spanning the length of the project. Thereby, allowing no assessment and refinement.

This plan estimates the optimum cost benefit plan to see improvements in Semer water would cost in range of £300,000-500,000. With additional further investment needed to solidify improvements beyond the target year 2030.

16


References

Buisness Wales, (2022) Evaluate cost-effective slurry storage and management options. Accessed from evaluate-cost-effective-slurry-storage-and-management-options 21/04/2022.

Chiverrell, R.C., Oldfield, F., Appleby, P.G., Barlow, D., Fisher, E., Thompson, R. and Wolff, G., (2008). Evidence for changes in Holocene sediment flux in Semer Water and Raydale, North Yorkshire, UK. Geomorphology, 100(1-2), pp.70-82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geomorph.2007.04.035

Collins, A.L., Anthony, S.G., Hawley, J. and Turner, T., (2009). The potential impact of projected change in farming by 2015 on the importance of the agricultural sector as a sediment source in England and Wales. Catena, 79(3), pp.243-250. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.catena.2009.05.007

Collins, A.L., Walling, D.E., (2004). Documenting catchment suspended sediment sources: problems, approaches and prospects. Prog. Phys. Geogr. 28, 159–196.

Defra (2007) Scoping study to assess soil compaction affecting upland and lowland grassland in England and Wales. Final report, BD2304, Cranfield University.

EA, (2012). Rural Sustainable DrainageSystems (RSuDS). Bristol, England: Environment Agency. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/291508/scho0612buwh-e-e.pdf

European Commission (2000) Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the council of 23rd October 2000 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, Official Journal 22 December 2000 L 327/1 European commission, Brussels.

Gao, J., Kirkby, M.J., Grayson, R. and Holden, J. (2015) Flood modelling and compaction studies for the Upper Ure. Final report to Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority, Project UUCP1/2015,

17


University of Leeds, Leeds.

Jones, P., Keating, K. and Pettit, A., (2015). Cost estimation for channel management–summary of evidence. Bristol, England: Environment Agency.

McGonigle, D.F., Burke, S.P., Collins, A.L., Gartner, R., Haft, M.R., Harris, R.C., Haygarth, P.M., Hedges, M.C., Hiscock, K.M. and Lovett, A.A., (2014). Developing demonstration test catchments as a platform for transdisciplinary land management research in England and Wales. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts, 16(7), pp.1618-1628.https://doi.org/10.1039/C3EM00658A

Pulley, S. and Collins, A.L., (2021). Can agri-environment initiatives control sediment loss in the context of extreme winter rainfall?. Journal of Cleaner Production, 311, p.127593. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127593

Villa, A., Fölster, J. and Kyllmar, K., (2019). Determining suspended solids and total phosphorus from turbidity: comparison of high-frequency sampling with conventional monitoring methods. Environmental monitoring and assessment, 191(10), pp.1-16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-019-7775-7.

Vrain, E., Lovett, A.A., (2016). The roles of farm advisors in the uptake of measures for the mitigation of diffuse water pollution. Land Use Pol. 54, 413–422. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2016.03.007.

Yorkshire Dales River Trust (YDRT) and Yorkshire Dales National Park (YDNP), (2016). The Wensleydale Project. Development of a catchment plan.

18