Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Semerwater SSSI Literature Review and Action Plan 2022 (PBA Ecology, 2022)

Providing Ecological Solutions PBA applied ecology

Semerwater SSSI Literature Review and Action Plan 2022

[Image: A landscape photograph showing the surface of Semerwater lake under an overcast sky. The water is dark and choppy with small waves reaching a stony shoreline in the foreground. Hills are visible in the background under a heavy cloud layer. The entire image has a blueish-cyan tint.]

PBA Applied Ecology Ltd, New Croft, Stackhouse Lane, Giggleswick, Settle, North Yorkshire, BD24 0DL 01729 822063 | enquiries@pba-ecology.co.uk | www.pba-ecology.co.uk


PBA Applied Ecology Ltd | BT/2022/v1

Document Information

  • Project Title: Semerwater SSSI
  • Report Type: Literature Review and Action Plan
  • Report Date: 18/05/2022
  • Author: D. Chadwick
  • Client: YDNPA
  • PBA Ref: PC21078/LRAP/1.4

Quality Control | Version | Status | Originated/Revised | Checked | Approved | Date | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | 1.1 | Draft | D. Chadwick/L. Eagle | B. Goldsmith | | 14/03/2022 | | 1.2 | Review | D. Chadwick/L. Eagle | B. Goldsmith | | 21/03/2022 | | 1.3 | Final | D. Chadwick/L. Eagle | B. Goldsmith | P. Bradley | 31/03/2022 | | 1.4 | Resubmission | D. Chadwick | P. Bradley | P. Bradley | 18/05/2022 |

Declaration of Compliance This report has been undertaken in accordance with British Standard 42020:2013 “Biodiversity: Code of practice for planning and development” (BSI 2013), the CIEEM’s Code of Professional Conduct (CIEEM 2019) and Guidelines for Ecological Report Writing (CIEEM 2017).

PBA Applied Ecology Ltd. New Croft, Stackhouse Lane, Giggleswick, Settle, North Yorkshire, BD24 0DL t. 01729 822063 e. enquiries@pba-ecology.co.uk www.pba-ecology.co.uk

© PBA Applied Ecology Ltd.


PBA Applied Ecology Ltd PC21078/LRAP/1.4

CONTENTS Executive Summary .................................................................................................. 4

  1. Introduction .................................................................................................... 5 1.1. Terms of reference ................................................................................................ 5
  2. Literature Review ........................................................................................... 5 2.1. Semerwater and the Raydale catchment .............................................................. 5 2.2. Pressures facing Semerwater ............................................................................... 8 2.2.1. Sediment ............................................................................................................ 8 2.2.2. Phosphorus ........................................................................................................ 9 2.2.3. Nitrogen ............................................................................................................. 9 2.3. Pathways of pollution within the Raydale catchment .......................................... 10 2.4. Zones of impact within Semerwater lake ............................................................. 14 2.5. Existing initiatives within the Raydale catchment ................................................ 17 2.6. Management options and constraints for shallow lakes ...................................... 19 2.7. Knowledge gaps and data deficiencies ............................................................... 21
  3. Action Plan .................................................................................................. 21 3.1. Prioritisation of management actions and recovery timeline and options ........... 21 3.1.1. Short to medium term (1 – 5 years) ................................................................. 22 3.2. Pathways to improving the condition of Semerwater SSSI (c. 5 – 30 years) ...... 24 3.3. Cost:benefit exercise ........................................................................................... 27
  4. Conclusion ................................................................................................... 29
  5. References .................................................................................................. 30

PBA Applied Ecology Ltd PC21078/LRAP/1.4

Figures Figure 1: Bathymetric map of Semerwater showing water depths (m), adapted from Barlow (1998). ... 7 Figure 2: Bathymetric map of Semerwater showing water depths (m), adapted from Chiverrell et al. (2008). ... 7 Figure 3: Total phosphorus as P for Semerwater from Environment Agency online dataset, spanning 2012-2022 ... 11 Figure 4: Total nitrogen as N for Semerwater from Environment Agency online dataset, spanning 2012-2022 ... 12 Figure 5: Maps of a) sediment risk areas mapped through YDNPA (2022) data and b) phosphorus risk areas ... 13 Figure 6: Summary of indicative legacy of the retention and recycling of phosphorus (P) stores ... 14 Figure 7: Map of Yorkshire Peat Partnership work ... 16 Figure 8: Evidence of high nutrient loading and dense algal mats forming in the River Bain outflow during summer 2021 ... 16 Figure 9: Contemporary coverage (2020) of a) land use and b) agri-environmental schemes ... 18 Figure 10: Indictive flow diagram of the interlinkages of restoration objectives ... 20 Figure 11: Proposed timeline for management actions within the Raydale catchment ... 26

Tables Table 1: Land use change in the Raydale catchment from 1994 – 2020. ... 6 Table 2: Macrophyte community composition within Semerwater lake ... 15 Table 3: Cost:benefit of existing and proposed management strategies ... 27


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Semerwater SSSI and the Raydale catchment are significant features within the ecological, cultural and economic landscape of Wensleydale. The condition of Semerwater has deteriorated over the previous 50+ years, and there is renewed interest and political pressure to restore the lake to a more sustainable, resilient and healthy state. Through the review of information on Semerwater lake and the Raydale catchment, an assessment of the status of Semerwater is provided with consideration of direction of biological and chemical factors and the ambition to improve the condition of Semerwater to at least Recovering WFD/SSSI condition. Nitrogen does not appear to be a significant pressure within Semerwater, and concentrations have remained consistent within Semerwater over the previous decade. Macrophytes remain present within Semerwater, but have declined in both species diversity and abundance. Native white-clawed crayfish also are persisting in lotic components of the catchment, and at a low population level within Semerwater. Efforts to restore natural functioning to the upland peats and reduce both point source and diffuse pollution from agriculture have been undertaken within the catchment, although the available evidence suggests these have not yet delivered recovery within Semerwater. Biological and chemical data indicate that internal conditions have not responded to these interventions over the previous 10-20 years, and may be driven by internal nutrient loadings.

Actions to ultimately improve the condition of Semerwater should focus around understanding the source and volumes of P and sediment entering the lake from the Raydale catchment, but are currently impaired by a lack of modern accurate data. Further, the process by which current and future actions are recorded and collated does not support cohesive efficient working, and hinder the evidence-based decision making which is key to successful management. This should be addressed through a centralised repository for works on Semerwater, as a necessary means for tracking what is being done, identifying evidence gaps and reducing duplication of effort. Recommendations contained within this report outline the benefits of addressing these issues and provide a pathway through which to define and initiate bespoke recovery targets for Semerwater via appropriate means and timescales, likely beyond the previously considered 2030 objective. To achieve realistic recovery targets requires cooperation and coordination of all catchment partners including landowners, and as such maintaining established relationships and involving stakeholders throughout this process is vital. The defining and uptake of a collaborative vision for Semerwater and the Raydale catchment may further strengthen these relationships and provide additional clarity and direction to future management actions.

Short term (ca. 1 – 5 years) management options

  • nutrient budget to understand input volume, source location, residence time within and release from Semerwater;
  • sediment budget to understand input volume, source location, residence time within and release from Semerwater;
  • macrofossil study of Semerwater sediments to define realistic and appropriate recovery targets;
  • creation of a central repository for recording work done within the catchment and Semerwater Steering Group for an efficient, collaborative approach;
  • establishment of a collaborative, ambitious, evidence-based vision for Semerwater;

Additional management options that will further support improvement of Semerwater are:

  • updated high resolution bathymetric survey of the lake;
  • fish population assessment of the community in Semerwater, to produce an estimate of planktivorous fish biomass;
  • continued macrophyte surveys to evidence status and direction of Semerwater condition.

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1. TERMS OF REFERENCE

PBA Applied Ecology Ltd. was commissioned by the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA) to produce a literature review and action plan for Semerwater SSSI. Semerwater is nationally recognised for its ecological, agricultural and cultural significance, but also for anthropogenic pressures that are impacting the condition of the lake. A review of the available literature, including grey literature sources, and subsequent action plan based on findings of this review is required. The overarching target for Semerwater is currently ‘Good Ecological Status’ by 2030 as defined by the Water Framework Directive. The challenges, potential approaches and achievability of this target are considered within this document.

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

A review of the scientific literature was conducted using the databases Web of Science and Google Scholar. Search terms included ‘Semerwater’ and ‘Semer water’, to capture any relevant published literature using the most common variations. Gibbons (1990) was considered relevant, but a copy could not be sourced despite personal enquiries to and cooperation from the host institution. Additionally, grey literature including postgraduate theses, commercial datasets and reports, and previously commissioned surveys were consulted as part of this exercise. To be in scope, these documents were required to contain any quantitative or supporting information relevant to the condition of Semerwater. This information primarily comprises data on the water quality, sediment transfer and associated processes, hydrological regime, and biological communities within Semerwater. The broader catchment of Raydale is outside the scope of this systematic review process, however the upper catchment and tributaries in particular have relevance to the condition of Semerwater, and as such these information sources are included where appropriate.

2.1. SEMERWATER AND THE RAYDALE CATCHMENT

Semerwater (SD 91954 87223) is the second largest natural lake in the Yorkshire Dales, with the largest being Malham Tarn SAC. Semerwater lies within the Raydale catchment of Wensleydale which spans some 4,361 hectares. Crooks Beck is the primary inflow of Semerwater, formed through the confluence of the three main tributaries of Bardale/Marsett Beck, Raydale Beck and Cragdale Water which flow from their sources in the upper catchment in the southwest through localised agricultural land. An additional smaller inflow, Little Ings Sike, enters Semerwater on the eastern shore, as well as several gills on the western and eastern shores. The River Bain is the outflow of Semerwater, which runs for approximately 3.8 km where it meets the main River Ure (SD 93544 90777). The water is calcareous as a result of the limestone geology of the catchment, being alkaline (mean pH 8.01; EA, 2022) with high levels of alkalinity (mean 82 mg/L CaCO3) peaking in the summer months (range 33-130 mg/L CaCO3).

Semerwater is the remains of a glacial lake that formed at the end of the last ice age when glacial material blocked the outflow. Historically, the lake level was lowered in 1937 by 55 cm (SSSI citation, 2016) and the old shoreline is still visible, with areas of the western shore now dominated by fen vegetation. The Semerwater SSSI encompasses the lake as well as areas of neutral grassland, fen, upland mixed ash and yew woodland. First notified in 1975 and revised in 1984 the SSSI covers an area of 101.4 hectares. It contains 17 units of which in the last condition assessment 20% were in Favourable condition, 48% in Unfavourable – recovering condition and the remaining 32% Unfavourable – no change or Unfavourable – declining (2008 to 2016).

Land use in the catchment has been relatively consistent over the last three decades (Table 1). Limited urbanisation is present in the Semerwater catchment, with land cover currently (and historically) dominated by upland rough grazing on acid grassland (32%) and heather moorland (including drained bog; 29%), to more intensive dairy and livestock farming (Table 1). Soils comprise largely of peats of varying depths with thick peat confined to the moorland plateau, fine loamy soils to the eastern slopes...


...of the watershed, fine loamy soils over clay along the western slopes of the watershed and fine loamy soils with peat along the lower southern slopes and in the flat dale bottom (SSP, 2009). All have a tendency to be seasonally waterlogged. Hamlets and farms in the catchment appear to be under private septic tanks treatment plants or individual systems. Lower Raydale that surrounds Semerwater itself is mainly managed as semi-intensive grassland with some small areas of plantation and native woodland. Grasslands and meadows are cut for silage and haylage. Land management across the whole Raydale catchment is a focus for regulatory bodies and government. The catchment is viewed as a high Countryside Stewardship Water Priority Area (RPA, 2021), a high Phosphate Issues Priority Area, a high Surface Water Nitrate Issues Priority Area, and a high Sediment Issues Priority Area. In addition, some areas of the catchment are classified as high priority flood Risk Management Priorities Area. Consistent with this 84% of the catchment is under agri-environmental schemes with a range of activities including tree planting, riparian and field margins, nutrient management plans. The whole catchment falls under a Higher Level Stewardship Target Area (NE, 2018), although currently less than half of the land under agri-environmental schemes in holdings that fall at least in part within the catchment are in higher level stewardship. A Catchment Sensitive Farming Priority Area covered the catchment for the period 2011 – 2015. Catchment sensitive farming advice measures were provided to 22 large land holding farmers within the catchment from 2011. These measures covered farm infrastructure, livestock management, fertiliser management, manure management and soil management. There is evidence to suggest only nine of these land holders have actioned any of these recommendations to this stage, although the status, timeframe and auditing process of these actions remains unclear (YDNPA, 2022).

Table 1: Land use change in the Raydale catchment from 1994 – 2020. Data sources are - 1 Barlow 1998, 2 Morton et al. 2014, and 3 Morton et al. 2021.

Broad Land Use ¹1994 ¹ (%)Land Cover ²2007 ² (Hectares)2007 ² (%)2020 ³ (Hectares)2020 ³ (%)
Woodland4.7Deciduous woodland71.371.5124.630.52
Coniferous woodland173.563.68199.924.24
Grassland for Grazing/ Hay25.6Arable7.630.160.01<0.01
Improved grassland748.0015.85358.667.60
Calcareous grassland0.000.001195.1825.33
Rough Grazing69.7Rough grassland293.566.22NANA
Acid grassland1431.7530.331521.8532.25
Heather263.945.590.18<0.01
Heather grassland1094.2523.18205.234.35
Bog434.319.201152.3124.42
Montane habitats152.693.24NANA
Inland rock1.380.036.400.14
Freshwater29.000.6129.630.63
Urban0.000.001.170.02
Suburban18.68750.4023.520.50

[Image: Figure 1: A bathymetric map of Semerwater adapted from Barlow (1998). It shows depth contour lines within the lake's perimeter. The deepest part is indicated by a "10" meter contour in the center-right. A north arrow and a 100m scale bar are included.]

[Image: Figure 2: A bathymetric map of Semerwater adapted from Chiverrell et al. (2008). It shows a series of numbered sampling locations (1-15 and SL1, SL2, T3) and depth contours (1m, 3m, 5m, 7m, 9m, 10m). A 500-meter scale bar is provided.]


2.2. PRESSURES FACING SEMERWATER

Semerwater has a catchment-to-lake ratio of 150.4:1 (CEH, 2022), being very high for an upland waterbody, and as such is vulnerable to chemical and physical disruption from catchment level processes. Pulley & Collins (2021) characterised the Raydale catchment land use between 2018-2020 as Hillslope topsoils (59%), Valley bottom farmland (18%), Blanket peat (18%), and Woodland (5%), and noted its steep gradient (mean 9.27º). The broader Raydale catchment was assessed as Moderate condition throughout Cycle 1 and 2 of the Water Framework Directive (WFD), with the exception of Poor condition in 2014. The broader Raydale catchment condition assessments are, however, based primarily off limited and dated data...

2.2.1. SEDIMENT

Erosion and deposition are natural fluvial processes that transport sediments within aquatic systems. The volume and source of these sediments largely dictates the effect on the recipient systems, with natural amounts of material transportation important for driving channel form and function. However, anthropogenic increases or alterations to sediment transport can negatively impact waterbodies, particularly in low energy systems such as lakes where sediment turnover is reduced. Sediment inputs can negatively impact lakes through incremental reductions to water depth, decreasing the thermal and chemical buffering capacity of lakes. Excessive sediment influx can also increase turbidity within the water column, reducing light availability for macrophyte growth.

Semerwater is reported as a very shallow lake (mean depth <3 m, CSM, 2015), being generally no deeper than 2 m for the majority of the lake, asides from a deep glacial hole of 10-12 m in the centre of the lake (Figure 1 & Figure 2). Summer mean depths can be as low as 0.3 m in marginal areas of the lake (SSSI citation, 2016), remaining shallow (≤0.9 m) up to 50 m out from the shoreline. However, Semerwater is contrastingly considered as a ‘deeper’ mesotrophic lake under the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology’s Lakes Portal with a mean depth of 3.5 m (Hughes et al., 2004). This has relevance to chemical targets.

Data on the source and volume of sediments being recruited into Semerwater however are scarce, being primarily observational data. However, Bennion et al. (2008), following sampling and analysis of the sediments via piston coring, estimated annual deposition rates of 0.15 cm, with annual catchment erosion rates of 92.9 kg/ha and annual sediment inputs into the lake of 405 m³. A second study by Chiverrell et al. (2008) reached a broad consensus with these values, reporting estimated annual deposition rates of 0.2 cm, with annual catchment erosion rates of 123.9 kg/ha and annual sediment...


...inputs into the lake of 540 m³. However, additional cores from this study analysed using an alternative approach extended this rate to almost 1.0 cm of deposition per year. This broad range is supported through earlier analyses detailed in Barlow (1998) who suggest average sediment accumulation rates of 0.37-0.90 cm per year since the 1950s, with a mean influx into the lake of 0.62cm per year. Barlow also noted the depth and high deposition rates found within the valley bottom upstream of Semerwater lake itself, stating accumulation at rates of 0.23 cm per year over the preceding ca. 4500 years, 10-20 times greater than many British sites. Taken together, all previous sedimentation rate works conclude that a 2-3 times increase in accumulation rates has occurred since the 1950s within Semerwater lake.

2.2.2. PHOSPHORUS

Eutrophication, being human driven increases in P and N, is a prevalent pressure in UK waters... Due to the closer ratio of the lakebed area and the volume of the lake, shallow lakes are disproportionally affected by eutrophication as compared to deep lakes. Nutrient rich surface sediments can act as large repositories for P and N...

Semerwater is considered as a mesotrophic lake, but also has chemical characteristics consistent with a hard water lake... If classified as a ‘very shallow’ lake, maximum mean annual TP targets are set at 20 µg/L for mesotrophic lakes, with 15 µg/L set for either hard waters or both lake types if ‘deeper’ (mean depth > 3 m). Semerwater has consistently been in excess of the less stringent mesotrophic target, with the only long-term data set (EA, 2012-2022) reporting mean concentrations of 41 µg/L throughout the monitoring period at the north-eastern shore monitoring point, with a range of 19.4 – 117.0 µg/L (Figure 3). Reaney et al. 2013 provided additional P data for the major tributaries... Marsett Beck had a mean TP concentration of 29 µg/L... Raydale Beck had a mean TP concentration of 28 µg/L... Cragdale Water had a mean TP concentration of 40 µg/L... Little Ings Sike... had the highest mean TP concentration of the inflows being 48 µg/L... Reaney et al. also report P data for the River Bain outflow, with a mean TP concentration of 35 µg/L. These data are broadly consistent with the most recent data for Semerwater lake itself. The TP values are elevated around 30-50 µg/L and consistently in excess of the target 15 µg/L threshold indicating a chronic pressure.

2.2.3. NITROGEN

Nitrogen levels within the lake are recorded as consistently below the CSM (2015) target (annual mean TN concentration of ≤1.5 mg/L) and an agreed site-specific target of 1.3 mg/L, having been recorded in excess of this on only four occasions (Figure 4). Nitrogen is not often considered a primary cause of...


...deteriorating condition in lakes, as P is much more commonly the limiting factor. Total nitrogen (TN) to total phosphorus (TP) ratios range from in the region of 100:1 for highly inorganic substrates such as unfertilised field runoff through to <3:1 in eutrophic sediments, septic tank effluence and sewage (Downing & McCauley, 1992). The TN:TP ratio of Semerwater, using the EA dataset, has a reported mean of 23.2 TN:TP (range 9.5-42 TN:TP), consistent with exports from agricultural watersheds with the lowest TN:TP ratio consistent with seepage from cattle manure.

2.3. PATHWAYS OF POLLUTION WITHIN THE RAYDALE CATCHMENT

Phosphorus and sediment modelling within the Raydale catchment through data provided by YDNPA (2022) has enabled rapid visual assessment of key sources and locations of pollution into Semerwater (Figure 5)... SCIMAP applies a risk mapping framework to identify where in the landscape diffuse pollution in the form of sediment is most readily originating. This was applied in the Raydale catchment identifying a number of inflows and tributaries as high risk of sediment transport... Principally these are found along the north-western slope and south-eastern slope of the catchment flowing into the lowland valley area upstream of Semerwater and directly into the lake (Figure 5)...

Further, recent analyses by Tejero (2015) modelled areas of high risk for the transport of P laden soils within the Raydale catchment. This analysis focussed on runoff potential... Tejero tested soil samples, reporting that all samples contained moderate to high P loadings (ca. 25-45 mg kg⁻¹; Figure 5). Tejero also noted slurry storage limitations within several of the studied farms, and direct recruitment of highly P loaded faeces from runoff over areas of hardstanding... Peat erosion in the upper Raydale catchment has also been recognised, bringing sediment and more modest nutrient loadings into Semerwater (Figure 5)...

Sediment source fingerprinting analyses were undertaken in the Raydale catchment in 2018-2020... Sources of sediments within Raydale were reported as being approximately equally apportioned between the Hillslope topsoils (59% coverage), Valley bottom farmland (18% coverage) and from Landslips and subsurface inputs. Low inputs were reported for both Blanket peat and Woodland sources, with disproportionally high sediment inputs reported from the Valley bottom despite it only covering 18% of the catchment (Pulley & Collins, 2021). In addition to these existing channel bed deposits and landslips that were recognised in these analyses, sewage treatment (including private installations) was recognised as potential sources of inputs into the catchment...


[Image: Figure 3: A scatter plot titled "Semerwater total phosphorus (EA, 2012-2022)". The y-axis shows "Total P (TP) µg/L" from 0 to 140. The x-axis covers dates from Oct 2012 to July 2022. Black dots represent individual data points. A black dotted line shows a moving average. A horizontal red dashed line represents the "Average TP value in Semerwater" at approximately 41 µg/L. A horizontal green dot-dash line represents the "'Deeper' mesotrophic TP threshold" at 15 µg/L. The data points frequently spike above the average and are consistently well above the 15 µg/L threshold.]


[Image: Figure 4: A scatter plot titled "Semerwater total nitrogen (EA, 2012-2022)". The y-axis shows "Total N (TN) mg/L" from 0 to 2.5. The x-axis covers dates from Oct 2012 to July 2022. Black dots represent individual data points. A black dotted line shows a moving average. A horizontal dark-blue dashed line represents the "Average TN value in Semerwater" at just under 1.0 mg/L. A horizontal green dot-dash line represents the "Semerwater specific TN target" at 1.3 mg/L. Most data points are below the 1.3 mg/L target.]


[Image: Figure 5: Two maps of the Raydale catchment area outlined in red. Map (a) shows "sediment risk areas". The catchment is overlaid with a grid of blue shades representing sediment risk levels (0-50). Watercourses are highlighted in colored lines: green for "Channel Risk 0.00 - 0.50", orange for "Channel Risk 0.50 - 0.75", and red for "Channel Risk 0.75 - 1.00". Red lines (highest risk) are concentrated in the tributaries entering the lake from the northwest and south. Map (b) shows "phosphorus risk areas" with shaded polygons representing "P Availability Index" from low (16-25, light pink) to high (71-100, dark red). Several numbered orange and red circles (1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10) are placed at specific points, likely representing high-risk soil sample locations or farm sites.]


2.4. ZONES OF IMPACT WITHIN SEMERWATER LAKE

Estimates place the retention of P applied to agricultural land at around 70-80%, shared in part between soils, groundwater and lake sediments (Jarvie et al., 2013). The chronic release of this stored P can impact water quality both within waterbodies and their downstream system for decades after external P reductions are implemented (Figure 6). Surface sediments within Semerwater itself are likely to be highly enriched with P, and provide a large, readily mobilised source of P during physical disturbances such as wind and floods, and more passively through flux at the sediment:water interface (May et al., 2020). This impact upon water clarity is twofold, in that enriched surface sediments remove the P limitation of phytoplankton promoting growth and reducing light penetration, and the physical volume of sediment being recruited into the waterbody results in bioturbation levels that prevent macrophyte establishment even when chemical conditions are improved enough to permit growth.

Macrophyte species community composition and coverage within the lake has been periodically assessed in line with CSM guidance... Macrophyte community... is in an Unfavourable condition. General trends from this data for Semerwater indicate declines in all surveyed species (ENSIS, 2016; Table 2), reporting failing numbers (2 of ≥8 required) and distributions (≤3% of ≥60% samples required) of mesotrophic characteristic species (Table 2) and an absence of the hard water Chara spp. characteristic species since 1995 (Bennion et al., 1997; Pentecost, 2009)... Survey work reports maximum recorded depths supporting colonisation of macrophytes (Zv) of only 0.8 m, substantially below CSM targets for mesotrophic (Zv ≥3.5 m) and hard waters (Zv ≥5 m). This is further complicated by the brown water conditions which also limit light.

[Image: Figure 6: An infographic showing the legacy of phosphorus (P) stores. It uses a pyramid-like structure of boxes to show storage areas and their approximate cycling times: "Soil/hill slope (c. 5-30 yr)", "Groundwater (<1-50 yr)", "In-channel (<1 yr)", "Riparian/floodplain (<1-1000 yr)", and "Lakes (c. 5-30 yr)". Arrows indicate the flow and cycling of phosphorus between these environments, illustrating how legacy P can persist in the system for decades.]


Table 2: Macrophyte community composition within Semerwater lake, noting characteristic flora for mesotrophic (bold) and hard water (underlined) lakes (data sources 1 Bennion et al., 1997 and 2 ENSIS CSM surveys 2005-2016).

Submerged and floating vegetationDAFOR 1995 ¹2005 ² % Freq (n=54)2010 ² % Freq (n=58)2013 ² % Freq (n=120)2016 ² % Freq (n=125)
Callitriche hamulata2211
Callitriche sp.R207
Chara sp.O
Eleocharis acicularisO4624113
Elodea canadensisR21
Elodea nuttallii2
Fontinalis antipyreticaF511
Limosella aquatica7311
Nitella flexilis agg.22
Nuphar luteaR37291313
Potamogeton alpinus+1
Potamogeton berchtoldii21
Potamogeton crispus+1
Potamogeton pectinatusF61
Zannichellia palustris7
Species richness710897

White-clawed crayfish Austropotamobius pallipes are listed under Annex II and V... The population of white-clawed crayfish found within the River Ure and surrounding waterbodies, including Semerwater, are of national importance. However, crayfish plague Aphanomyces astaci was confirmed as present upstream of Aysgarth Falls in the main River Ure during summer 2020 (PBA, 2020). The upstream spread of this epizootic is of major concern... sections of bedrock steps in the River Bain may prevent the upstream spread of plague and thus Semerwater could possibly sustain white-clawed crayfish beyond the current epizootic. However, white-clawed crayfish require high water quality... and as such the impact of the sedimentation pressures identified within Semerwater may be impacting the condition of this metapopulation.

The summation of these compound stressors also contributes to high levels of nutrients and sediment within the River Bain, the outflow of lake Semerwater. Algal matts have been reported forming in summer, during periods of warmer lower flows and peak nutrient delivery (Figure 8).


[Image: Figure 7: A map of the Yorkshire Dales National Park and Nidderdale AONB showing various shaded regions representing different peat restoration project areas. A black arrow points to an area labeled "upstream of Semerwater" in the upper Raydale catchment.]

[Image: Figure 8: A color photograph of the River Bain outflow. The water surface is almost entirely covered by thick, bright green mats of filamentous algae. Trees and vegetation line the banks of the river.]


2.5. EXISTING INITIATIVES WITHIN THE RAYDALE CATCHMENT

In England and Wales, concerns regarding non-compliance with WFD targets owing to diffuse water pollution from agriculture (DWPA) resulted in the Catchment Sensitive Farming (CSF) initiative. Since inception in 2009, CSF initiatives have been ongoing through a collaborative approach between the Yorkshire Dales National Parks Authority (YDNPA), Natural England (NE) and the Yorkshire Dales Rivers Trust (YDRT). A primary target of this scheme was to reduce the risk of diffuse water pollution from agriculture. Additionally, almost 90% of the actively farmed land within Raydale is under Environmental Stewardship Scheme (ESS) agreements (Figure 9). The advice for likely sources of pollutants and management opportunities within the Raydale catchment provided by the Catchment Sensitive Farming Officers (CSFOs) has been generally well targeted (Pulley & Collins, 2021)...

Further work was delivered through the Semerwater and Upper Lune Catchment Partnership (SULCP), summarised in a final report from 2015. The SULCP... delivered targeted advice to farmers on the management of manure, soil and fertilisers, and nutrients, securing the award of over £600,000 of Capital Grant Scheme (CGS) funding to make improvements to tackle DWPA (2012-2015). These include roofing of muck middens and livestock yards, renewals of infrastructure such as concrete yards, and watercourse fencing.

Programmes such as the Raydale Project (2009) sought to determine and plan for future risk, focussing on catchment level response to climate change. Run by the Yorkshire Dales Rivers Trust (YDRT)... nutrient management plans and manure management plans were developed and implemented (DWP, 2014). Additionally, ca. 1 km of riparian fencing was installed, with tree planting and wet woodland establishment undertaken where appropriate.


[Image: Figure 9: Two maps of the Raydale catchment. Map (a) "land use" shows colored regions corresponding to a legend including "Broadleaved woodland", "Coniferous woodland", "Improved grassland" (light green), "Neutral grassland", "Calcareous grassland", "Acid grassland" (brownish-green), "Heather grassland", "Bog" (teal), etc. Acid grassland and Bog dominate the area. Map (b) "agri-environmental schemes" shows a large portion of the catchment covered with a hatched pattern, labeled in the legend as "Country and Env Stewardship". This illustrates that almost 90% of the catchment area is under such schemes.]


2.6. MANAGEMENT OPTIONS AND CONSTRAINTS FOR SHALLOW LAKES

Management options for addressing eutrophication of shallow lakes fall broadly under four distinct categories: 1) control and reduction of external inputs, 2) reductions in internal loadings, 3) biomanipulation and 4) hydrological manipulation (Figure 10; Abell et al., 2020)...

Jeppesen et al. (2005) noted declines in the annual mean TP in 86% of studied lakes (5-35 years, mean 16 years), with declines typically occurring in shallow lakes 10-15 years after; this biogeochemical lag is common following targeted management of external nutrient loadings due to residual internal loadings. The preparation of a lake nutrient budget is an important management step for assessing controls on external nutrient loads in shallow lakes... Diffuse and point source control of nutrient sources to reduce the overall external loading is ultimately a fundamental requirement... However, the costs associated with the required changes... can be prohibitive. Achieving the required improvements to external load reductions through ‘best management practices’ (BMPs) alone is considered infeasible (Osgood, 2007)... who reported reductions in P load of >80% can be required to restore eutrophic lakes, of which only ca. 50% reductions are achievable through BMPs... Time scales for recovery towards baseline conditions have been estimated at 15 – 31 years...

Reductions in internal nutrient loads can be approached through both physical and chemical means. Dredging is undertaken to remove nutrient rich surface sediments... However, this practice is highly damaging to benthic fauna and flora... Capping is also used to treat nutrient-rich surface sediments... This practice however also impacts benthic fauna and flora, poses biosecurity risks... Chemical removal of internal nutrient loadings is commonly undertaken through adsorption of P, often coupled with flocculants... The response within waterbodies can be rapid... however the effectiveness of the treatment can be impaired in very shallow lakes due to how readily sediments are resuspended. Best practice in lake management stresses the need to address external problems, particularly nutrients, before resorting to major within-lake restoration measure such as sediment removal (Mainstone et al., 2016).


[Image: Figure 10: An indicative flow diagram of the interlinkages of restoration objectives. The diagram shows how "External load control" and "Sediment removal" lead to "Reduce TP," which then triggers a cascade of biological changes: "Reduce phytoplankton" -> "Increase plant cover" -> "Increase plant diversity" -> "Increase stability of cover" -> "Promote P sensitive taxa" and "Re-establish biotic mechanisms". Another entry point is "Biomanipulation" which leads to "Increase zooplankton" -> "Reduce phytoplankton". The bottom of the diagram points to a "Mixed age/feeding guild fish community."]

Biomanipulation has been undertaken in many shallow lakes, generally aimed at either zooplanktivorous or benthivorous fishes. Targeting zooplanktivores such as rudd Scardinius erythrophthalmus and roach Rutilus rutilus is often achieved through physical removal... and through stocking of predatory fishes such as pike Esox lucius... Removal of these fishes does however require frequent intervention... and the results... have been inconsistent...

A management option... is to reverse these changes, enabling the waterbody to return to a more natural hydrological state. The lowering of Semerwater in 1937 through the removal of glacial till within the outflow is likely to have accelerated the declining ecological status of the lake. Reinstatement of these materials would lead to a rise in the water level of Semerwater... Material could be reinstated over a long period (10+ years), perhaps in the form of a ‘leaky boulder’ addition to the outflow... This would require specialist hydrological modelling...


2.7. KNOWLEDGE GAPS AND DATA DEFICIENCIES

Modern surveys of Semerwater and its catchment would enable management efforts to be more accurately and meaningfully interpreted... Contemporary data on the bathymetry of Semerwater, the ecological communities present in the lake including fishes, and the status of the main tributaries is lacking. Further, macrofossil studies including plant remains and Cladocera within Semerwater are scarce...

More broadly, there has been repeated recognition of the value that would be provided through both nutrient budgets and sediment budgets of the Raydale catchment... These analyses would help to understand the input volume and source locations of sediments and nutrients... and the residence time and distribution...

Whilst a number of management actions have been undertaken within Raydale, no cohesive approach to recording these land-based initiatives and schemes, including their actions and outputs, exists. In the absence of this repository, coordination of efforts becomes difficult and risks inefficiencies... the available water quality data (2012-2022) indicate no change in the nutrient loadings of the lake itself throughout this time period. In the absence of centralised records... it would appear that the P loading in the lake is operating independently of these actions, suggesting a biogeochemical lag and that nutrient cycling is internally driven.

3. ACTION PLAN

3.1. PRIORITISATION OF MANAGEMENT ACTIONS AND RECOVERY TIMELINE AND OPTIONS

The timescale for the recovery period of lakes is primarily driven by a range of key pressures and lake-specific factors... restoration can take longer to achieve than the period of disturbance and degradation that caused it... For example, surveys of macrophyte community composition... have provided evidence of biogeochemical lags of 20-30 years in studied lake systems (May et al., 2020) even following external P reductions of 95% (Sand-Jensen et al., 2008).

As noted by Reaney et al. (2013), the baseline evidence over the now past four decades points to a consistent set of pressures acting on Semerwater... being phosphorus and sediment... The WFD requires GES by 2030...


...adding further complexity through delivery schedule requirements imposed by these legislative drivers, and as a SSSI Semerwater is required to be in at least a Recovering condition if not Favourable. The limited empirical evidence available... suggest that efforts so far to reduce external loadings have yet to demonstrate an improvement in the chemical (Figure 3 & Figure 4) or biological (Table 2) condition of Semerwater lake. This is not to reduce the importance of these efforts, as some historic data suggest that TP concentrations in Semerwater have been as high as 125 µg/L in 1990 (mean TP 80 µg/L; Gibbons, 1990 in Bennion et al., 1997)... Solutions are therefore sought that facilitate the retention of well managed agriculture, whilst allowing Semerwater SSSI to recover its biogeochemical condition.

Ultimately, it is a fundamental requirement to reduce the combined external diffuse and point source nutrient and sediment loadings to below that which is released from the lake to address the root causes of degradation and deliver sustainable improvements (Abell et al., 2020). The rate and likelihood of recovery could be meaningfully enhanced through targeted interventions to internal loadings of nutrients and sediments once excess external recruitment is addressed... It is, however, the opinion of the authors that Semerwater cannot reach Good Ecological Status by 2030, and that well considered management over appropriate timescales offers the greatest opportunity for recovery. Actions that are recommended... comprise 1) targeted surveys and analyses to provide novel data identified by knowledge gaps, 2) continuation or revisiting of monitoring and survey work, and 3) consolidation of existing management activities (Figure 11).

3.1.1. SHORT TO MEDIUM TERM (1 – 5 YEARS)

Novel information for management

To focus resources and increase likelihood and timeframe of success, a detailed nutrient budget should be undertaken for Semerwater and the wider Raydale catchment... identifying the input volumes and source locations of primarily P... quantifying residence times of P would inform likely timescales for effectiveness of secondary management interventions (Zhang et al., 2020). A particular focus... should be a full audit of domestic sewage treatment within Raydale... ideally ground-truthed with site visits... The authors are aware of 5 consented discharges able to influence conditions within Semerwater (Appendix 1)... Under modelled external P export for Raydale (Wilson, 1995) the Crooks Beck inflow concentration was 42-141 µg/L TP and the Semerwater lake itself was 28-77 µg/L TP... Agricultural sources accounted for >80-90% of this... split between organic (20-21%) and inorganic fertilisers (64-71%). Wilson recommended... a 20% reduction in both stocking density and inorganic fertiliser application, alongside establishment of 20 m riparian buffer zones would reduce Crooks Beck and Semerwater to within...


...mesotrophic target levels. These figures are however now outdated...

Likewise, undertaking sediment fingerprinting of Semerwater and the Raydale catchment, to apportion sediment sources into the lake forming a sediment budget, would directly inform secondary management and make best use of resources. Installation of sediment traps... as well as within Semerwater may also provide estimates of accretion rates within the lake. Further, determining the current contributions of peat will aid understanding of ‘natural’ turbidity conditions within Semerwater...

To further clarify restoration targets... paleo studies of plant macrofossils including seeds and other remains and Cladocera sub-fossils should be undertaken. The analyses of these cores would inform what Semerwater likely looked like in terms of chemical, biological and ecological condition prior to enrichment...

Updated surveys and monitoring

...the most contemporary and detailed bathymetry data (Figure 1 & Figure 2) available from the literature are of low resolution... Additionally, there are contrasting opinions... as to whether Semerwater is indeed ‘Very shallow’ as defined by CSM or is in fact ‘Moderately Deep’ (being either side of the mean 3 m depth threshold); this is of particular importance as it dictates appropriate nutrient thresholds... Accurate and detailed bathymetric surveys should therefore be conducted, to provide a modern baseline...

It is clear that Semerwater fully fits into neither a mesotrophic waterbody or a hard water lake, having elements of both. As such, target driven management... risks pursuing unrealistic or inappropriate conservation objectives... Through the undertaking of macrofossil work, a greater understanding of past conditions could be gained which would inform more achievable and representative restoration targets.

The CSM macrophyte surveys comprise one of the strongest empirical biological datasets for Semerwater... Periodic CSM compliant macrophyte surveying should be continued, to provide information on distribution and status of the macrophyte community in Semerwater, and therefore any likely direction in biological response to restoration efforts.


Whilst direct biomanipulation of resident fish populations at this stage would yield highly uncertain results, a detailed understanding of the fish community within Semerwater would be a suitable and valuable first step... Determining species compositions, as well as estimates of biomass, would inform whether removal of either zooplanktivorous or benthivorous species would result in benefits to water quality...

Given the ongoing epizootic of crayfish plague in the upper River Ure... Semerwater and its tributaries are of high strategic interest for the persistence of white-clawed crayfish in this system. Population assessments of white-clawed crayfish in the lake and tributaries should be conducted, using a highly precautionary biosecure method... A review of biosecurity procedures for Semerwater should be conducted... Specific attention should be assigned to invasive non-native species (INNS) that may further degrade and exacerbate the stresses on the lake, such as Himalayan balsam Impatiens glandulifera... and New Zealand pygmyweed Crassula helmsii... primarily the crayfish plague epizootic, it is recommended that citizen science is not utilised in the aquatic environment for Semerwater.

Coordination and recording of management activities

This document provides a foundation for the third set of short-medium term recommended actions. However, there exists both past work that is only partially captured here due to the absence of a centralised recording system... Documents collected for this review fell into several broad areas: 1) empirical datasets, 2) published literature, 3) interviews and meeting summaries, 4) grey literature on specific holdings, and 5) grey literature on larger summaries. These broad categories could well serve as a primary structure for a coordinated repository... Contributors... should include all relevant stakeholders, namely YDNPA, EA and NE, local trusts such as YDRT and Yorkshire Wildlife Trust, and any CSFOs... Further, a strategic action group should be considered, such as a Semerwater Steering Group (SSG)... to provide oversight and collaborative direction to management efforts.

3.2. PATHWAYS TO IMPROVING THE CONDITION OF SEMERWATER SSSI (CA. 5 – 30 YEARS)

Providing the nutrient and sediment budgets... can be actioned within 2022/23... Confirmation of the source, comparative volumes of the sediments and likely associated P loads... allow for efficient, targeted management. The next stages following on from this process would also need to fully involve local sources of P and sediments, such as those identified from farms and forestry. Without stakeholder buy-in and compliance, substantial and sustained reductions in pollutants into...


...Semerwater will not occur. This may include not only reductions in inputs or stocking densities, but simply alterations to timing or locations of activities...

Given the likelihood that internally derived P loads are contributing to the enriched condition... physical or chemical management of the sediments may be appropriate. However, the Raydale catchment is very large... and as such it could be expected that there is a fast rate of water turnover from periodic flushing of Semerwater lake, with a reported mean hydraulic residence time of 15.8 days (Wilson, 1995). If the identified external nutrient and sediment inputs could be controlled to a sufficient extent, these natural processes could enable Semerwater to become a net source and relinquish both P and sediments, rather than a sink. This approach would however depend on both sufficient reductions in external loading, and also stakeholder and legislative acceptance of the likely longer recovery timeframe...

Finally... it is suggested that a ‘vision’ for Semerwater is formed between these stakeholders, that sets evidence-based targets for the recovery of Semerwater within its current and historical context... It brings together the evidence, best practice, policy and partnerships that are required to achieve the conservation goals at the site into a single, integrated statement. This could set objectives surrounding the specific nature of Semerwater, such as to restore the near-natural functioning of the upland peatlands... Schemes and legislation such as Farming in Protected Landscapes (FiPL) and the Farming Rules for Water (2018) could provide guidance and potential funding sources...


[Image: Figure 11: Proposed timeline for management actions within the Raydale catchment. The timeline is divided into three sections along a central arrow:

  1. Modern ‘baseline’ - Current status (2022): Under "External factors," it lists pressures from sediment and P input and data deficiencies. Under "Internal factors," it lists potential high internal P loading, degraded communities (macrophyte/crayfish), shallow lake profile, and data deficiencies. Condition is "Unfavourable – No change."
  2. Management - Short term improvements to condition (ca. 1-5 years): Under "External factors," it lists Nutrient budget, Sediment budget, Central repository, and Biosecurity review. Under "Internal factors," it lists Bathymetric survey, Fish assessment, Macrophyte monitoring, and Macrofossil study.
  3. Recovery - Medium to long term improvements to condition (ca. 5-30+ years): Under "External factors," it lists targeted reductions in P and sediment and stakeholder engagement. Under "Internal factors," it lists combination of catchment reductions, natural recovery via flushing, and chemical/physical management of sediments. The target condition is "Unfavourable – Recovering / Favourable."]

3.3. COST:BENEFIT EXERCISE

Analysis of the comparative cost:benefit of recommended actions is a useful tool... Contemporary catchment-scale information on sediment and nutrient loadings are considered essential pre-requisites for cost:benefit analyses...

A high-level cost:benefit analysis... is provided below... The annual costs are considered through broad (estimated) categorisations of low (L), medium (M) and high (H) costs, representing £1-10,000, £>10,000-50,000, and £>50,000 respectively. Estimated benefits are similarly categorised... Where the data do not currently support an assessment... this is indicated (?). Ranking is calculated through multiplying cost (Low scoring 3 points, High scoring 1) by benefit (Low scoring 1 point, High scoring 3) to achieve an overall priority rank (1-3 Low, 4-6 Medium, >6 High)...

Table 3: Cost:benefit of existing and proposed management strategies within the Raydale catchment with the aim of improving the condition of Semerwater lake in the short and/or medium-long term.

ActionRecipientTimescaleAnnual CostBenefitSupporting evidenceOverall priority rank
Peat gripping/blocking upper catchmentUpper Raydale catchmentOngoingM?Sediment and nutrient loadings in Semerwater not reduced (2012-2022).?
CSF led agricultural improvementsLand-users across Raydale catchmentOngoingH?Sediment and nutrient loadings in Semerwater not reduced (2012-2022).?
Engagement with land-users to encourage...Land-users across Raydale catchmentOngoingM?Sediment and nutrient loadings in Semerwater not reduced (2012-2022).?

Action (continued)RecipientTimescaleAnnual CostBenefitSupporting evidenceOverall priority rank
...best practice (e.g. timings)
Commission of review of current information and resources on SemerwaterSemerwater lake & Raydale catchmentOngoingLMData gap identification and vision plan for lakes initiated recovery (e.g. Llangorse, Hatchmere).M
Centralised repository for data and reports and SSGSemerwater lake & Raydale catchmentShort term (ca.1-5 years)LM - HIdentifies evidence gaps and reduces duplication of effort, high level strategyM - H
Biosecurity catchment reviewSemerwater lake & Raydale catchmentShort term (ca.1-5 years)LMEpizootic identified in Ure catchment. No biosecurity review for Ure catchment to date.M
Continuation of CSM aquatic macrophyte surveysSemerwater lakeShort term (ca.1-5 years)LMLongest standing biological dataset from which to gauge improvement.M
Macrofossil workSemerwater lakeShort term (ca.1-5 years)LHSet realistic recovery targets.H
Bathymetric surveySemerwater lakeShort term (ca.1-5 years)LMM
Fish community assessmentsSemerwater lakeShort term (ca.1-5 years)LLDetermine likelihood of impact of future fish removals.L
Nutrient budgetSemerwater lake & Raydale catchmentShort term (ca.1-5 years)MHEssential to determine efficacy of current and future management.M - H
Sediment budgetSemerwater lake & Raydale catchmentShort term (ca.1-5 years)MHM - H
Establishment of Semerwater ‘vision’Semerwater lake & Raydale catchmentShort term (ca.1-5 years)LM - HData gap identification and vision plan for lakes initiated recovery (e.g. Llangorse, Hatchmere).M - H

Action (continued)RecipientTimescaleAnnual CostBenefitSupporting evidenceOverall priority rank
Chemical treatment of enriched surface sediments e.g. PhoslockSemerwater lakeMid-long term (ca. 5-30+ years)M - HM – HEffective in other enriched waterbodies (e.g. Hatchmere; Spears et al., 2018). Ineffective if catchment sources not controlled.L - M

4. CONCLUSION

Semerwater SSSI and the Raydale catchment are significant features within the ecological, cultural and economic landscape of Wensleydale. The condition of Semerwater has deteriorated over the previous 50+ years... Through the review... an assessment of the status of Semerwater is provided... to improve the condition... to at least Recovering.

Nitrogen does not appear to be a significant pressure... concentrations have remained consistent... Macrophytes... have declined in both species diversity and abundance. Native white-clawed crayfish also are persisting... at a low population level... Efforts to restore natural functioning to the upland peats and reduce... pollution from agriculture have been undertaken... although the available evidence suggests these have not yet delivered recovery... Biological and chemical data indicate that internal conditions have not responded... and may be driven by internal nutrient loadings.

Actions to ultimately improve the condition of Semerwater should focus around understanding the source and volumes of P and sediment entering the lake... but are currently impaired by a lack of modern accurate data. Further, the process by which current and future actions are recorded and collated does not support cohesive efficient working... This should be addressed through a centralised repository for works on Semerwater and establishment of the SSG, as a necessary means for tracking what is being done, identifying evidence gaps and reducing duplication of effort.

Recommendations... outline the benefits of addressing these issues and provide a pathway through which to define and initiate bespoke recovery targets... beyond the previously considered 2030 objective. To achieve realistic recovery targets requires cooperation and coordination of all catchment partners... the defining and uptake of a collaborative vision... provide additional clarity and direction to future management actions.


5. REFERENCES

Abell. J. M., Özkundakci, D., Hamilton, D. P. & Reeves, P. (2020). Restoring shallow lakes impaired by eutrophication: Approaches, outcomes,and challenges. Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology.

Barlow, D. (1998). A Lake Sediment Study of Particulate Flux in the Humber Catchment Using Magnetic Techniques. PhD Thesis. University of Edinburgh.

Bennion, H., Monteith, D. T. & Appleby, P. G. (1997). Nutrient Reconstructions in Standing Waters: Final report to English Nature. Contract No. FS0-11-02 ECRC Report 37, UCL. London.

Bennion, H., Clarke, G., Davidson, T., Rose, C., Rose, N., Turner, S. and Sayer, C. (2008). Using novel paleolimnological techniques to define lake conservation objectives (Phase 1). Environmental Change Research Centre. Report Number 126. Final report to Natural England.

Carpenter, S. R. (2005). Eutrophication of aquatic ecosystems: Biostability and soil phosphorus. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 102(29), 10002–10005.

Carvalho, L. and Moss, B. (1995). The current status of a sample of English Sites of Special Scientific Interest subject to eutrophication. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, 5, 191-204.

CEH (2022). Centre for Ecology and Hydrology Lakes Portal. Semerwater.

Chiverrell, R. C., Oldfield, F., Appleby, P. G., Barlow, D., Fisher, E., Thompson, R. and Wolff, G. (2008). Evidence for changes in Holocene sediment flux in Semer Water and Raydale, North Yorkshire, UK. Geomorphology, 100(1-2), 70-82.

CSM (2011). Site condition assessment on Semer water for Natural England. CSM report.

CSM (2015). Common Standards Monitoring Guidance for Freshwater Lakes, Interagency Freshwater Group, JNCC, Peterborough.

Downing, J. A. & McCauley, E. (1992). The nitrogen:phosphorus relationship in lakes. Lmnol. Oceanogr. 37(5), 936-945.

DWP, (2014). Semer Water Diffuse Water Pollution Plan. Diffuse Water Pollution, YDNPA.

ENSIS, (2016). CSM lake surveys 2005-2016. B. Goldsmith & E. M. Shilland.

Environment Agency (2019) Phosphorus and Freshwater Eutrophication Pressure Narrative.

Gibbons, T.L. (1990). A limnological survey of Lake Semerwater. Institute of Environmental and Biological Sciences. University of Lancaster.

Habitats Directive, (1992). EU Directive on the Conservation of Habitats, Flora and Fauna.

Haddaway, N., Mortimer, R., Christmas, M. & Dunn, A. (2015). Water chemistry and endangered white clawed Crayfish: a literature review and field study... Knowledge and Management of Aquatic Ecosystems. 416.

Hughes M., Bennion H., Kernan M., Hornby D. D., Hilton J., Phillips G. & Thomas R. (2004). The development of a GIS-based inventory of standing waters in Great Britain...


...prioritisation protocol. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution: Focus. 4 (2-3), 73-84.

Jarvie H. P., Sharpley, A. N., Spears, B., Buda, A. R., May, L., & Kleinman, P. J. A. (2013). Water Quality Remediation Faces Unprecedented Challenges from “Legacy Phosphorus”. Environ. Sci. Technol. 47 8997-8

Jeppesen, E. R. I. K., Sondergaard, M., Jensen, J. P., Havens, K. E., Anneville, O., Carvalho, L., ... Winder, M. (2005). Lake responses to reduced nutrient loading–an analysis of contemporary long-term data from 35 case studies. Freshwater Biology. 50(10), 1747–1771.

May, L., Olszewska, J., Gunn, I. D. M., Meis, S. & Spears, B. M. (2020). Eutrophication and restoration in temperate lakes. IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 535.

Mainstone, C., Hall., R. & Diack, I. (2016). A narrative for conserving freshwater and wetland habitats in England. Natural England Research Reports, Number 064.

McCrackin, M., Jones, H., Jones, P., Moreno, & Mateos, D. (2017). Recovery of lakes and coastal marine ecosystems from eutrophication: A global meta-analysis. Limnology and Oceanography, 62(2), 507–518.

Morton, R. D., Rowland, C. S., Wood, C. M., Meek, L., Marston, C. G., and Smith, G. M. (2014). Land Cover Map 2007 (25m raster, GB) v1.2. NERC Environmental Information Data Centre.

Morton, R. D., Marston, C. G., O’Neil, A. W., and Rowland, C. S. (2021). Land Cover Map 2020 (10m classified pixels, GB). NERC EDS Environmental Information Data Centre.

NE, (2018). Natural England. Environmental Stewardship Scheme Agreements.

Osgood, R. A. (2017). Inadequacy of best management practices for restoring eutrophic lakes in the United States: Guidance for policy and practice. Inland Waters. 7(4), 401–407.

PBA, (2020). Summary presentation to the Environment Agency for commissioned survey and report on status and distribution of white-clawed crayfish and crayfish plague in the upper Ure catchment.

Pentecost, A. (2009). The marl lakes of the British Isles. Freshwater Reviews. 2, 167-197.

Phillips, G., Bennion, H., Perrow, M. R., Sayer, C. D., Spears, B. M. & Willby, N. (2015). A review of lake restoration practices and their performance in the Broads National Park, 1980-2013. Report for Broads Authority, Norwich and Natural England.

Pulley, S. & Collins, A. L. (2021). Can agri-environment initiatives control sediment loss in the context of extreme winter rainfall? Journal of Cleaner Production. 311, 127593.


Reaney, S., Deasy, C., Perks, M., Quinton, J., Ockenden, M. (2013). Site Characterisation Report for Semerwater catchment... Natural England Report. Durham University and Lancaster University.

RPA, (2021). Rural Payments Agency. Countryside Stewardship Scheme 2016 Management Areas (England).

Sand‐Jensen, K., Pedersen, N. L., Thorsgaard, I., Moeslund, B., Borum, J., & Brodersen, K. P. (2008). 100 years of vegetation decline and recovery in Lake Fure, Denmark. Journal of Ecology, 96(2), 260-271.

SCIMAP, (2022). SCIMAP Diffuse Pollution and Flood Water Source Mapping Tool.

Sharpley, A., Jarvie, H. P., Buda, A., May, L., Spears, B., Kleinman, P. (2013). Phosphorus legacy: Overcoming the effects of past management practices to mitigate future water quality impairment. J. Environ. Qual.

Søndergaard, M. (2007). Nutrient dynamics in lakes – with emphasis on phosphorus, sediment and lake restorations. Doctor’s dissertation (DSc). National Environmental Research Institute, University of Aarhus, Denmark.

Spears, B. M., Andrews, C., Banin, L., Carvalho, L., et al. (2018). Assessment of sediment phosphorus capping to control nutrient concentrations in English lakes. Project SC120064/R9.

SSP, (2009). Semerwater Strategic Partnership. Semerwater Catchment Appraisal. England Catchment Sensitive Farming Delivery Initiative.

SSSI, (2016). Semerwater SSSI citation.

SULCP, (2015). Semerwater and Upper Lune Catchment Partnership. Final Report. Compiled by Briony Davey.

Tejero, G. R. (2015). The Potential of P Loss from Livestock Farms to Watercourses in Wensleydale; A Risk Mapping Approach. Forest Res. 4: 135.

Wildlife and Countryside Act, (1981). Bern Convention 79/409/EEC; 92/43/EEC.

Wilson, H. M. (1995). An evaluation of alternative management strategies for shallow eutrophicated lakes and reservoirs. Doctoral theses. University of Plymouth.

YDNPA, (2022). Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority. ‘KURC – CSF advice Raydale’.

YPP, (2021). Yorkshire Peat Partnership. Annual Report April 2020 – March 2021.

Zhang, X., Davidson, E. A., Zou, T., Lassaletta, L., Quan, Z., Li, T., & Zhang, W. (2020). Quantifying nutrient budgets for sustainable nutrient management. Global Biogeochemical Cycles. 34.


Appendix 1. Known consented discharges within Raydale, denoting the 5 discharges (labelled) capable of influencing Semerwater (source: YDNPA, 2022).

[Image: A detailed topographical map of the Raydale catchment area. The catchment boundary is marked by a heavy black line, and the SSSI boundary by a red dashed line. The map shows watercourses (blue lines) and various points of "consented discharges". The legend identifies different outlet types: green dots for "Agriculture", yellow dots for "Sewage - water company", and orange dots for "Sewage - not water company". Five specific locations are labeled with their permit numbers (e.g., 27/22/0154, 27/22/0085, NPSWQD002129, 2423, C4386) to indicate discharges capable of influencing the lake. The map title is "SSSI Diffuse Water Pollution Plans, Figure 5 Discharge Consents".]