Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority - Item 6

Planning

20 May 2025

List of Applications for Permission to Develop

Attached to this report are details of applications for permission to develop, together with Officers’ recommendations.

For Members’ information:

  1. The plans and information submitted with each application, together with consultee and neighbour/interested party responses are available to Members and the public on the Authority’s website.
  2. Late representations will be available on the Authority’s website after 5.30pm on the Friday before the Committee meeting.
  3. The time period for responses to consultations/publicity carried out on individual applications may not have expired before the date of the Committee meeting. Any responses received after the meeting will be taken into account in drafting conditions/reasons for refusal. If such responses received within the specified period are contrary to the Committee's resolution and raise new matters, the application will be presented for reconsideration by the Planning Committee at a future meeting.
  4. All applications that are recommended for approval will have the appropriate time limit conditions attached, to comply with Sections 91-94 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
  5. All location plans are reproduced from Ordnance Survey Maps with the permission of Her Majesty's Stationery Office. Crown Copyright Reserved. Licence Number LA08905L-0001.

Richard Graham Head of Development Management

Background documents: Some or all of the following comprise the list of background papers unless they contain Exempt Information:

  • Application forms, plans, covering letter, and certificates.
  • Other material submitted with the application.
  • Further correspondence with the applicant/agent.
  • Details of consultation and neighbour notification.
  • Consultation replies.
  • Other representations received.
  • Site notes.

Index of Applications

LIST NOPARISHAPPLICATION NOAPPLICANT(S)LOCATION
1HawesR/56/139EWest Shaw Farm LtdWest Shaw Farm, Beggarmans Road, Gayle, Hawes, North Yorkshire, DL8 3SF
2BainbridgeR/52/243AMr J ReedThorns Farm, Marsett Lane, Countersett, DL8 3DE
3DentS/01/352AMr D Oversby & Ms Z JacksonLow Hall Farm Barn (GR:370879,487266), Hall Lane, Dent
4SedberghS/03/770Mr J & Ms T RobertsMain Street Gallery, 25 Main Street, Sedbergh, LA10 5BN
5TebayE/15/9BNew Roots Holding Company LtdBrockholes Farm, Tebay, Penrith, CA10 3XT

Item 1 - Application No: R/56/139E

Planning Committee - 20 May 2025

Applicant: West Shaw Farm Ltd Parish: Hawes Officer: Nicola Dinsdale Site Address: West Shaw Farm, Beggarmans Road, Gayle, Hawes, North Yorkshire, DL8 3SF Proposal: Full planning permission for conversion of redundant agricultural building to local occupancy house/holiday let, together with installation of package sewage treatment plant (amended red site).

Purpose of Report

  1. That Members APPROVE planning permission for the above development in accordance with the recommendations below.

Reason for Committee Consideration

  1. This application is reported to the Committee for the following reason: in the opinion of the Head of Development Management it is in the best interests of the National Park Authority that the application is considered by the Committee.

Application Site

  1. West Shaw Farm is located on Beggarmans Lane to the south of Gayle. The former farmstead, positioned on both sides of the minor road, consists of the farmhouse, stone barns, modern sheds used for stabling and is established as a stud farm. This application relates to the large traditional barn set on the south side of the road opposite the main farmstead. The building has a stone lean-to with corrugated tin roof attached to the southwest gable, with a small lean-to to the northeast largely covered with corrugated tin and abuts a former milk stand.
  2. The barn has a large cart door opening and several existing openings facing the north, which open onto the highway, with several openings to the rear that would overlook a small enclosed unsurfaced walled yard area. The access and parking area has been amended and is now positioned to the northeast of the building within the confines of the existing yard area. The land to the south rises steeply within the allotment behind and continues upwards towards the open access land of Wether Fell.

Proposal

  1. This application seeks planning permission for the conversion of the barn to form a dwellinghouse for local occupancy and short stay holiday lets. The existing openings are to be largely used with some alterations to the openings within the rear (southeast) elevation, along with the installation of rooflights. The large opening will be fitted with glazing that will be deeply recessed within the stone reveals. The lean-to attached to the southwest gable elevation will be retained utilising the existing openings with the roof completed in slate to match the main building. The northeast lean-to will be retained and will be partially walled and will be finished with timber boarding fronting the highway and covered with a matching slate roof. The garden will be enclosed by the existing boundary wall, with a new boundary wall to the east.
  2. The conversion will be served by a new package treatment plant that will be installed within the land directly to the southeast of the site.

Relevant Planning History

  1. The following applications are relevant:
    • R/56/139B: Full planning permission for change of use of cattle building to stables, installation of a horse walker on land adjacent to the building and change of use land to equestrian use. Approved - Conditional 09/07/2019.

Consultations

  1. The comments of statutory and non-statutory consultees are summarised below:
    • Head of Visitor Services: No response received.
    • Chief Technical Officer: No response received.
    • Wildlife Conservation Officer: No objection. The barn has been assessed as having moderate suitability to support bats. A habitat assessment concludes that habitats adjacent to the barn are only likely to be used occasionally by commuting and foraging bats. There was no evidence of Barn owls. Natural England Development Licence required prior to building works. The mitigation and compensation measures set out in the Bat Report are recommended.
    • Fire Officer: No objection.
    • Environmental Health: Concern regarding the potential for contaminated land, and suggest a Contaminated Land Condition.
    • Highways: Objection. The required visibility splay is 2.4 metres by 215 metres. The available visibility is well below the required standard. Consequently, the Local Highway Authority recommends that Planning Permission is REFUSED.
    • Hawes & High Abbotside PC: Concerns were raised regarding parking as the access is very narrow and is off a very fast road. Following amendments, the Council still has concerns regarding traffic accessing the property.
    • Trees & Woodlands: No objection subject to protective fencing during construction.

Public Responses

  • Public responses received at the time of writing: 1
    1. One public response has been received from Richmondshire Ramblers requesting any adjacent footpaths are kept clear and usable at all times.

Assessment

Key Issues:

  • Principle of development
  • Design and Impact on the Locality
  • Highways
  • Ecology and Biodiversity Enhancement
  • Parish Council comments
  • Equality Act

Principle of Development

  1. The Yorkshire Dales Local Plan (2015-30) aims to achieve the conservation and enhancement of traditional buildings (heritage assets) by allowing them to be adapted or converted to new uses.
  2. The barn is considered to be a non-designated heritage asset. Policy L1 and L2 allow for such buildings to be changed to local occupancy residential or short-stay holiday lets in suitable roadside locations. The barn is suitable for conversion subject to a S106 legal agreement.

Design and Impact on the Locality

  1. The proposal has been amended to position access and parking to the north. The principal elevation fronting the highway is largely retained. Openings will be fitted with deeply recessed glazed units to help maintain the building’s traditional character. The amended proposal re-uses the existing yard and sheep fold, minimizing impact on the character and appearance of the traditional building.

Highways

  1. The Highway Authority recommended refusal due to visibility splays. However, due to the narrow and winding nature of the road and the proximity of buildings, speeds are typically low. On balance, officers consider the proposed development unlikely to have a significant impact on highway safety.

Ecology and Biodiversity Enhancement

  1. A Bat Survey identified a common pipistrelle day roost. A development licence will be required from Natural England. The proposal meets the requirements of Local Plan policies W1 and W2 subject to mitigation.

Conclusion

  1. The proposed conversion is acceptable in accordance with Local Plan policy L2. The alterations are relatively minor and would not harm the character of the building or its landscape setting. Subject to a S106 legal agreement, the proposal is consistent with policies.

Recommendation

  1. It is recommended that permission is GRANTED subject to a S106 legal agreement and conditions including:
    • Time Limit 3 years
    • Accordance with approved plans
    • Materials (roof slate, timber windows deeply recessed, etc.)
    • Ecology mitigation
    • Contaminated land condition

Item 2 - Application No: R/52/243A

Planning Committee - 20 May 2025

Applicant: Mr Jonathan Reed Parish: Bainbridge Officer: Katie Towner Site Address: Thorns Farm, Marsett Lane, Countersett, DL8 3DE Proposal: Full planning permission for works comprising: conversion of two existing conjoined agricultural buildings for use for the purposes of gallery/studio for craft, art and cultural events by invitation; erection of two new buildings that contain a workshop, a staff accommodation unit (2 bed) and three short stay visitor accommodation units (each 2 bed); landscaping works, biodiversity enhancements, access alterations and car parking, all in association with the gallery/studio enterprise, (part-retrospective).

Purpose of Report

  1. That Members APPROVE planning permission for the above development in accordance with the recommendations below.

Reason for Committee Consideration

  1. This application is reported to Committee for the following reason: this type of application is not within the scope of the powers delegated to the Head of Development Management.

Application Site

  1. The main development area is a former farm complex on the north side of Semerwater on Marsett Lane. Work has already been undertaken on the conversion of two adjoined agricultural sheds.
  2. A second area 200 metres away is an agricultural field corner proposed for parking.

Proposal

  1. The project involves:
    • Conversion of buildings to a gallery/studio.
    • Building C: workshop, 1 staff apartment, and 1 guest unit.
    • Building D: 2 guest units.
    • Car park with 14 spaces.
    • Extensive landscaping.
  2. The vision is to create a high-end venue for arts and culture inspired by the natural environment, supporting the diversification of the Wood End Estate.

Consultations

  • Highways: No comments received.
  • Bainbridge Parish Council: No comments received.
  • Area Ranger: Notes a public right of way (footpath) runs through the site and would require legal diversion.
  • Wildlife Conservation Officer: Notes the proposal is an improvement over previous agricultural use regarding effluent. No objection subject to the package treatment plant details.
  • Environmental Health: No objection in principle subject to conditions.

Public Responses

  • Public responses received at the time of writing: 3
    1. Three objections (including Friends of the Dales) raised concerns about the retrospective nature, design (large glazed windows), impact on local employment, traffic increase, and impact on tranquility.

Assessment

Key Issues:

  • Principle of development
  • Landscape and Visual Impact
  • Nature Recovery
  • Sustainability

Principle of Development

  1. The scheme does not fit neatly into a single policy but aligns with the wider goals of business diversification (Policy BE2) and tourism support. The conversion of modern agricultural buildings is supported as they are surplus to requirements and appropriate for the surroundings.

Landscape and Visual Impact

  1. The site is screened by gradient and trees. Additional planting is proposed. The design is high quality and retains the agricultural character.

Conclusion

  1. The proposal provides a unique visitor facility. While some elements (staff/visitor housing) conflict with standard policy on their own, they are an integral part of the business vision which brings significant benefits.

Recommendation

  1. It is recommended that permission is GRANTED subject to conditions including:
    • Holiday let occupancy restrictions.
    • Staff accommodation remains ancillary.
    • Provision of a Package Treatment Plant.
    • Contaminated land assessment.
    • Dark Skies conditions.

Item 3 - Application No: S/01/352A

Planning Committee - 20 May 2025

Applicant: Mr D Oversby & Ms Z Jackson Parish: Dent Officer: David Jones Site Address: Low Hall Farm Barn (GR:370879,487266), Hall Lane, Dent Proposal: Full planning permission for demolition and reconstruction of a 20th century field barn to provide new build local occupancy accommodation for the applicants.

Purpose of Report

  1. That Members REFUSE planning permission for the above development in accordance with the recommendations below.

Reason for Committee Consideration

  1. The Parish Council recommendation is contrary to the decision which the Head of Development Management proposes to take.

Application Site and Proposal

  1. The site comprises a 20th-century agricultural building made of metal sheets, brick, and blockwork.
  2. The proposal is to demolish this building and erect a new three-bedroom detached dwellinghouse. The design would "mimic" the form of the existing barn using local stone and profile metal sheeting.
  3. Occupation would be restricted to local occupancy and the house would be a self-build project.

Consultations

  • Dent with Cowgill Parish Council: Strongly supportive; believes it helps a young local farmer stay in the dale and maintains the look of the existing building.
  • Highways: No objections.
  • Environmental Health: No objection in principle.
  • Wildlife Conservation Officer: No objection.

Public Responses

  • One response in support (young couple committed to the area) and one in objection (tradition in Dentdale avoids building on the flat bottom of the valley).

Assessment

Principle of Development

  1. The site is in open countryside where new housing is tightly restricted. The application does not meet the "essential need" criteria for rural workers under Policy C3, nor is the building a heritage asset that qualifies for conversion under Policies L2/L3.
  2. The proposed design does not meet the "exceptional quality" threshold required by the NPPF for isolated homes in the countryside.

Design and Visual Impact

  1. The proposal would create a visually isolated dwelling in a high-quality pastoral landscape. The introduction of modern domestic paraphernalia and light spill would detract from the natural beauty and dark sky character of the area.

Conclusion

  1. The development represents a new dwelling on an isolated site without sufficient justification for an exceptional need. It would set an undesirable precedent for replacing modern agricultural buildings with permanent dwellings.

Recommendation

  1. It is recommended that permission be REFUSED.

Item 4 - Application No: S/03/770

Planning Committee - 20 May 2025

Applicant: Mr James & Theresa Roberts Parish: Sedbergh Officer: Nicola Dinsdale Site Address: 25, Main Street Gallery, Main Street, Sedbergh, LA10 5BN Proposal: Full planning permission for change of use of west part of Main Street Gallery at basement and ground floor to be a dwelling.

Purpose of Report

  1. That Members APPROVE planning permission for the above development in accordance with the recommendations below.

Reason for Committee Consideration

  1. The Parish Council recommendation is contrary to the decision which the Head of Development Management proposes to take.

Application Site and Proposal

  1. The property is currently an art gallery in the Sedbergh Conservation Area.
  2. The proposal is to convert the western part of the basement and ground floor into a separate one-bedroom residential dwelling, while retaining a smaller retail unit.

Consultations

  • Sedbergh Parish Council: Objection; believes the loss of retail space potentially leaves the remaining space unviable.
  • Highways: No objections.
  • Area Ranger: No objection subject to keeping the adjacent footpath clear.

Assessment

Principle of Development

  1. The shop covers 45m². Policy BE7 allows for the loss of employment uses where it doesn't harm community vitality. The unit has been marketed for two years with no offers to buy. The reduction in retail space is considered acceptable to secure a viable future use.
  2. The site is in a "Local Service Centre," identified as a sustainable location for new housing.

Impact on Conservation Area

  1. The development involves minor physical alterations that will not harm the historic significance of the Sedbergh Conservation Area or the setting of the adjacent Grade I listed St Andrews Church.

Conclusion

  1. The development provides a local occupancy dwelling in a sustainable location and is of a scale that does not harm the economic vitality of Sedbergh.

Recommendation

  1. It is recommended that permission is GRANTED subject to a Section 106 agreement for local occupancy.

Item 5 - Application No: E/15/9B

Planning Committee - 20 May 2025

Applicant: New Roots Holding Company Ltd Parish: Tebay Officer: Nicola Dinsdale Site Address: Brockholes Farm, Tebay, Penrith, CA10 3XT Proposal: Full planning permission for creation of 'Into the Wilds' visitor attraction and wild animal reserve (part retrospective).

Purpose of Report

  1. That Members REFUSE planning permission for the above development in accordance with the recommendations below.

Reason for Committee Consideration

  1. In the opinion of the Head of Development Management, it is in the best interests of the Authority that the application is considered by the Committee.

Application Site

  1. Brockholes Farm is 17.8 hectares of agricultural land with a farmhouse and 5 holiday lets. It is located in the Lune Valley, close to the M6 and the Lake District National Park boundary.

Proposal

  1. The application seeks to create a visitor attraction where guests encounter native animals (originally exotic species were proposed but later removed). It includes:
    • Three shepherd huts.
    • Conversion of a cottage to a café.
    • Welcome centre / ranger station.
    • Stables and a car park for 55 cars.
  2. Unauthorised works have already been undertaken, including the creation of a large hardstanding "rhino turnout" area and access tracks.

Consultations

  • Tebay Parish Council: Objection; poor access from A685 and negative landscape impact.
  • Lake District National Park Authority: Objection; adverse visual impact on the setting of the LDNP.
  • Senior Historic Environment Officer: High archaeological potential; recommends a geophysical survey which has not been provided.
  • Highways: No objection following a speed survey, provided the access is widened.
  • Public Responses: 26 individual objections and 1,044 generic objection letters from "Campaigns for Freedom for Animals."

Assessment

Landscape Impact

  1. The site is in a "large scale, dramatically enclosed landscape." The proposed buildings, large car park, and formalised tracks would be highly visible and discordant. The natural undeveloped character would be undermined.

Unauthorised Development

  1. Multiple elements have been built without permission. The Authority has advised the applicants to cease works and an enforcement investigation is open.

Archaeology

  1. Engineering operations are likely to affect archaeological features on the site. Without a survey, the impact cannot be fully assessed.

Conclusion

  1. The development would form a prominent and visually discordant feature in an underdeveloped pastoral landscape. It harms the intrinsic character of the area and the setting of the adjacent National Park and World Heritage Site.

Recommendation

  1. It is recommended that permission be REFUSED based on significant harm to the landscape, unsatisfactory access safety, and potential harm to archaeological features.