Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Search for potential housing sites: landscape sensitivity study

Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority

Part 2

Richmondshire District

IMAGE: Cover page for the report, showing the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority logo, the title “Search for potential housing sites: landscape sensitivity study”, “Part 2”, and “Richmondshire District”.

Contents

  • Introduction — 3
  • Study scope and objectives — 3
  • Fit within the overall development allocation process — 3
  • Methodology — 4
  • Landscape sensitivity assessment — 4
  • Judging landscape sensitivity — 4
  • Summary landscape sensitivity scores — 8
  • Overall landscape sensitivity scores per settlement — 8
  • Richmondshire — 9
  • Swaledale & Arkengarthdale — 9
  • Local Service Centres
    • Reeth — 11
  • Large Villages
    • Grinton — 18
    • Hudswell — 20
    • Langthwaite — 22
    • Low Row/Feetham — 24
  • Wensleydale, Bishopdale & Coverdale — 27
  • Local Service Centres
    • Hawes and Gayle (overall map) — 28
    • Gayle — 29
    • Hawes — 31
  • Large Villages
    • Askrigg — 35
    • Carlton — 40
    • Carperby — 42
    • East Witton — 46
    • Newbiggin (Bishopdale) — 48
    • Thorably — 51
    • West Witton — 54

Introduction

Study scope and objectives

The Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA) commissioned a landscape sensitivity assessment of potential sites for residential development to inform its preliminary ‘sift’ of possible development sites. The National Park designation recognises that the scenic beauty of the Yorkshire Dales is nationally important and the YDNPA therefore places emphasis on a landscape-led approach to the process of identifying suitable development sites. Landscape sensitivity assessment enables landscape considerations to be a key component of the balance of factors to be taken into account in making decisions about where new housing should be sited.

The 139 sites assessed during the sensitivity assessment were identified by YDNPA as suitable for preliminary consideration via:

  • 66 sites submitted by landowners through a ‘call for sites’ process; and
  • a further 73 sites identified by YDNPA on a speculative basis.

Some of the 139 sites (in both of the above categories) are the subject of an existing Local Plan designation, whether that be housing, employment or open space. The objective was to consider the widest possible range of sites at the preliminary stage. The report is split into three parts:

  • Part 1 - Sites within Craven District
  • Part 2 - Sites within Richmondshire
  • Part 3 - Sites within South Lakeland, Lancaster and Eden Districts.

Fit within the overall development allocation process

This report presents the results of the landscape sensitivity assessment. It is the first step in the sequential process of identifying possible sites for allocation in the Local Plan.

The National Park Authority will use its conclusions to inform an initial sift of the 139 sites being considered. Once the sites have been sifted, the residual number will be subjected to more rigorous assessment. This will factor in a range of other development constraints that were beyond the scope of the initial landscape sensitivity assessment, such as highways/access, archaeology, wildlife, trees and flood risk.

Further landscape analysis will also be undertaken in the form of a ‘whole settlement analysis’ of those settlements that could see the greatest development pressures. This will consider the wider landscape setting and townscape of these settlements and will take account of the potential housing development sites identified following the sifting process. It will be presented as a separate report, but will rely, in part, upon the work undertaken during this first phase of landscape sensitivity assessments.

Methodology

Landscape sensitivity assessment

Landscapes can be described and understood in terms of their physical characteristics, their land uses, their ecological habitats, their heritage and also by the way they make us feel. The combinations of these different landscape characteristics and qualities contribute to our perceptions of local identity and sense of place. An assessment of landscape sensitivity seeks to identify the aspects of landscape character that we value so that we can measure their resilience to change. It is typically undertaken when there is a need to judge the potential effects that could result from a defined type of change and this study has been commissioned to consider the sensitivity of a selection of specific sites in relation to residential development. It will be used by the YDNPA to understand the potential changes to the landscapes of the YDNP if development were to take place.

National guidance for landscape sensitivity assessment¹ explains that the process of sensitivity assessment requires an assessment of the susceptibility of landscape and visual character (the baseline) to a specific change (in this case residential development) in combination with an assessment of the values of the landscape and its visual characteristics.

The assessment provides a consistent, systematic score for the landscape and visual sensitivity of each of the assessed sites to residential development. It is a high level judgement which has been undertaken without detailed topographic data and which assumes a mix of residential development across the whole area of each site. It does not take account of the potential influence of design (ie. the layout and form of buildings and landscape) and assumes that the height and density of buildings would vary depending on whether the site has an urban or a rural context.

The landscape sensitivity assessment will guide and inform the YDNPA’s strategic allocation of sites for new housing in the YDNP by helping to direct development to areas where it would be least damaging to valued landscapes. In general, sites with a relatively low landscape sensitivity score can be expected to accommodate housing development without the loss of valued landscape characteristics whereas those with a relatively high landscape sensitivity score would not.

The landscape sensitivity scores for each site can contribute to this decision-making process and identify opportunities and constraints for development, but they do not provide a direct judgement of suitability for development. This is because there are many other factors to consider including socio-economic benefits, vehicular access, drainage, provision of utilities (electricity, water, gas, sewerage) and archaeological or heritage constraints. It is also because the assessment does not take account of the influence of design and management, which may in some locations enable successful housing development in sites which are assessed as having relatively high landscape and visual sensitivity.

The study has been undertaken in two stages. The first stage (Dec 2021-March 2022) was a desk-top exercise which made reference to Ordnance Survey base mapping, aerial photography (Google Earth), the YDNP Landscape Character Assessment, historic maps, biodiversity and heritage designations and mapping of heritage assets provided by YDNPA. It was also informed by a selection of site photographs supplied by YDNPA. The first stage assessment was tested through fieldwork during June-July 2022, which led to some adjustment of the landscape sensitivity scores.

Judging landscape sensitivity

The criteria selected for judging landscape sensitivity are based on the attributes of landscape that are most likely to be affected by residential development. They take account of both ‘landscape’ and visual’ characteristics and aspects of landscape value, including the special qualities of the YDNP. The five landscape sensitivity criteria are set out in Table 2 (page 6). For each criterion Table 2 also identifies indicators of relative susceptibility to the changes associated with residential development by describing how the landscape, visual, and value related criteria may be affected to a greater or lesser extent by the key attributes of residential development.

Using the criteria and susceptibility indicators in Table 2 as a constant reference, the landscape sensitivity of each site to residential development was assessed against each criterion on a five point scale (as shown in Table 1). The sensitivity scores reflect the degree to which the landscape of each site would be susceptible to change. An overall sensitivity judgement is also included, recognising that some attributes or elements of the landscape may be more important in defining character than others and may be more sensitive.

Table 1 – Criteria for judging landscape and visual sensitivity

SensitivityDefinition
HighResidential development would be very likely to give rise to significant adverse landscape and/or visual effects.
Moderate-highResidential development would be very likely to give rise to adverse landscape and/or visual effects, and there is some potential for these to be significant.
ModerateResidential development would be likely to give rise to some adverse landscape and/or visual effects, but these may be limited in extent.
Low-ModerateResidential development may give rise to some minor adverse landscape and/or visual effects, but these would be unlikely to be significant.
LowResidential development would be very unlikely to give rise to significant adverse landscape and/or visual effects.

It is important to note that the criteria for judging landscape and visual sensitivity set out in Table 1 are on a relative scale which is applied within the context of a national park landscape that is inherently highly sensitive to development.

The judgement is based on transparent professional analysis rather than a mechanical process of addition. This enables the assessment to highlight any particularly sensitive landscape features or qualities, and factors that would need to be taken into account should the site be developed.

This is a high level assessment and the overall landscape sensitivity scores apply to the whole of the site that has been submitted for assessment. However, it does take some account of the scope to mitigate potential adverse landscape and visual impacts of development, as follows:

  • Where relevant, the narrative within the assessment tables incorporates advice on how the design and/or layout of development schemes could mitigate potential adverse landscape and visual impacts and the sensitivity scores take account of this mitigation potential.
  • The overall landscape sensitivity scores for some sites are marked with an asterisk* to indicate that a carefully designed layout that focuses built development on part of the site would reduce the risk of adverse landscape and visual effects and would reduce the overall sensitivity score (which is based on the whole site assessment).

Maps are indicative. Please note that there is a discrepancy between the mapping of the potential housing sites and the OS base because the site boundaries were digitised at a more detailed scale.

¹ An approach to landscape sensitivity assessment - to inform spatial planning and land management, June 2019, Christine Tudor, Natural England.

Table 2 - Landscape and visual sensitivity assessment criteria

Physical and natural character

This criterion considers landform, land cover and landscape elements in relation to the scale of potential development, with particular reference to the Special Qualities of the YDNP that relate to natural beauty and wildlife (e.g. dales with distinctive stepped profiles; spectacular waterfalls; significant glacial/post glacial features; flower-rich hay meadows and pastures; broadleaf woodland/ancient woodland). It considers possible impacts of development on the scale, coherence, condition and intactness of the physical landscape, as well as the presence/absence of natural heritage designations and the extent to which the area is representative of distinctive landscape character. Areas with a smooth or relatively flat topography are likely to be less sensitive to development than areas with more distinct landform features. In addition, areas with a relatively uniform landscape pattern and few natural features will be less sensitive to development than areas with a higher density of natural features which could be vulnerable to loss from development. Areas designated for their natural heritage or which are considered to be exemplars, representative of distinctive or rare landscape characteristics or features are likely to be more vulnerable to development than landscapes with a relatively nondescript character.

Sensitivity levelDescription
Lower sensitivitySite landscape is degraded and detracts from local landscape character – e.g. land cover has been largely lost and any landscape features are fragmented and/or in poor condition and would not be degraded by development. Landform itself is of low sensitivity to development i.e. simple, smooth or flat landforms. No direct contribution to YDNP Special Qualities (distinctive natural beauty and wildlife features).
Moderate sensitivitySite landscape has some limited characteristics that contribute to local landscape character – e.g. the landscape has reasonable hedgerow boundaries but is indistinctive in terms of landform or land cover. It may be a typical example of a locally commonplace landscape type. Some indirect contribution to YDNP Special Qualities (distinctive natural beauty and wildlife features). Scope to integrate carefully designed development.
Higher sensitivitySite landscape makes a strong contribution to local landscape character – e.g. it has a distinctive landform, an intact, natural landscape with hedgerows, trees and other features of interest, such as ponds or watercourses which could be damaged by development. Strong landform features such as slopes, scarps and valleys are likely to be more sensitive to development. Direct contribution to YDNP Special Qualities (distinctive natural beauty and wildlife features).
Settlement form and setting

This considers the extent to which development would contribute to the identity and distinctiveness of a settlement, in terms of the important landscape elements and features that structure the way it is perceived – e.g. gateway views; views to distinctive local features and landmarks; and longer contextual views which express the specific relationship between settlement and its surrounding landscape. It also considers the character of settlement edges, the presence and role of boundary features and the extent to which development on the site would relate to settlement form and pattern, including possible contribution to a perceived gap between settlements (the loss of which would increase coalescence).

Sensitivity levelDescription
Lower sensitivitySite landscape detracts from the distinctive character of the settlement or does little to contribute positively to settlement identity and distinctiveness. Site is strongly associated with an existing settlement and would not, if developed, be perceived as an extension of the settlement into the countryside. An exposed settlement edge with no landscape features to integrate the settlement/rural fringe will be less sensitive and may offer opportunities for development to enhance the settlement edge and integration.
Moderate sensitivitySite landscape makes a limited positive contribution to the distinctive character and form of the settlement, but does not contribute directly to key gateway or longer contextual views or to views to distinctive local features/landmarks. Development would be perceived as settlement advancement into the countryside but would not represent a step-change in settlement form. It would not cross a distinctive boundary feature. Development would not have a strong effect on the perception of separate settlements.
Higher sensitivitySite landscape contributes to the distinctive character of the settlement, either as valued undeveloped land within the settlement or because it is important in relation to its setting for key gateway or longer contextual views or for views to distinctive local features/landmarks. Development would have a poor relationship with existing settlement form, crossing a boundary feature and/or extending into an area with a distinctly different landscape – e.g. beyond a ridge crest or into a valley. Site landscape is important in the perception of a gap between distinct settlements; a well-integrated settlement edge by virtue of landscape structure or landform variation will be more sensitive.
Views and recreational experience

This takes into consideration the visual character of the site and the extent to which development would be visible, including the extent of openness or enclosure, skyline character, the degree to which the landscape contributes to views from sensitive viewpoint locations and/or whether development would intrude on sensitive views. Locations such as tourist attractions, promoted viewpoints and national trails will be more sensitive to development than local footpaths. Locations used for recreation, such as country parks or local public green space, are more sensitive than passing views from rights of way, and private views have less sensitivity than public viewpoints. Visually prominent landscapes which are inter-visible with adjacent landscapes are likely to be more sensitive to development than areas that are visually contained and less widely visible. Distinctive and/or undeveloped skylines, or skylines with landmark features are likely to be more sensitive to development.

Sensitivity levelDescription
Lower sensitivitySite landscape is enclosed and well screened from public or private view, is not visually prominent in the landscape and does not form a visually distinctive or important undeveloped skyline.
Moderate sensitivitySite landscape is semi-enclosed and is likely to have some inter-visibility with surrounding areas. There may be some visually distinctive or important undeveloped skylines. Site landscape makes some positive contribution to local views from public rights of way, but little intrusion on public views from the wider landscape.
Higher sensitivitySite landscape is open, visually prominent in the wider landscape and/or forms a visually distinctive skyline or an important undeveloped skyline. There is clear visibility from sensitive receptor locations where the undeveloped character of the landscape contributes to the quality of the view.
Perceptual qualities

This considers perceptual qualities, including scenic value, intact rural character, sense of remoteness and tranquillity. The criterion also considers the degree a site may contribute to key perceptual features noted as contributing to the distinctive landscape of each landscape character area in the YDNP LCA. Landscapes that are relatively remote or tranquil (landscapes with a lack of human activity or disturbance, or landscapes with perceived naturalness and traditional rural feel) tend to have higher levels of sensitivity to development compared to landscapes that contain signs of modern development or those with a high level of human disturbance/activity. High scenic value and dark night skies also increase sensitivity in relation to this criterion.

Sensitivity levelDescription
Lower sensitivitySite landscape has a disturbed landscape, strongly influenced by development/activity/intrusion.
Moderate sensitivitySite landscape has scenic qualities and/or some rural character, separation or isolation, but with some distinct intrusive elements – e.g. road noise or an abandoned character resulting from a lack of management.
Higher sensitivityA highly tranquil and scenic site landscape with relatively dark skies and a natural and/or traditional rural character which lacks intrusive elements. It contributes to the distinctive perceptual features of local YDNP landscapes.
Cultural and historical associations

This considers the extent to which the landscape has ‘time-depth’ – a sense of being a historic landscape, with particular reference to the Special Qualities of the YDNP that relate to historic and cultural heritage (e.g. the stone built field barns that are part of traditional pastoral landscapes; prominent archaeological landscapes in the form of strip lynchets and prehistoric field systems; ancient and historic parklands; remnant sites of former industrial landscapes; and conservation areas which define historic settlements with distinctive traditional architecture and/or the Settle-Carlisle Railway line. This part of the assessment considers historical associations in relation to landscape character and is not a heritage assessment. Landscapes with strong and visible historic and cultural heritage are more likely to be sensitive to development than those with limited time depth.

Sensitivity levelDescription
Lower sensitivitySite landscape has limited cultural or historical influence or associations. It does not contribute to landscape patterns or features that have historic value.
Moderate sensitivitySite landscape with visible historic elements or cultural associations which has some historic character, but which is not part of a wider historic landscape; or a site with little historic character but which forms part of an area that does have some historic character.
Higher sensitivitySite landscape with a strong, intrinsic historic character that is not diminished by modern human influence. Direct contribution to YDNP Special Qualities (historic and cultural heritage features).

Summary landscape sensitivity scores

Overall landscape sensitivity scores per settlement

The table below provides a quick reference summary of the overall sensitivity scores for each of the assessed settlements within Richmondshire.

Note that these scores are based on the Stage 1 desk-based assessment part of the study and are subject to review when the judgements are tested on site during the stage 2 field survey part of the work.

District / Sub areaSettlementREF.Overall landscape sensitivity
Richmondshire — Swaledale & ArkengarthdaleReethREE 1Moderate-high*
REE 2Moderate-high*
REE 3Low-moderate
REE 4High
REE 5Moderate-high
REE 6Low-moderate
GrintonGRI 1Moderate*
HudswellHUD 1Low-moderate
LangthwaiteLTW 1High
Low Row/FeethamLOW 1High
LOW 2High
Richmondshire — Wensleydale, Bishopdale & CoverdaleGayleGAY 1Moderate
GAY 2Moderate
HawesHAW 1Moderate*
HAW 2Moderate-high*
HAW 3Moderate
HAW 4Low-moderate
AskriggASK 1Moderate-high
ASK 2Low-moderate
ASK 3Moderate
ASK 4Low-moderate
CarltonCAR 1Moderate-high*
CarperbyCPY 1Moderate-high*
CPY 2Moderate-high
CPY 3Moderate-high
East WittonEWT 1Moderate*
NewbigginNEW 1Moderate-high
NEW 2Moderate
ThoralbyTHO 1Moderate-high
THO 2Moderate-high
West WittonWWT 1Moderate*
WWT 2Moderate*

Richmondshire District

Landscape Sensitivity Assessment

Swaledale & Arkengarthdale

Local Service Centres

Reeth

Large Villages

Grinton

Hudswell

Langthwaite

Low Row/Feetham

Wensleydale, Bishopdale & Coverdale

Local Service Centres

Hawes and Gayle

Large Villages

Askrigg

Carlton

Carperby

East Witton

Newbiggin (Bishopdale)

Thoralby

West Witton

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed housing sites around Reeth, labelled REE 1 through REE 6. The map identifies possible site allocations on the edges of Reeth and nearby Arkengarthdale Road, Silver Street, Back Lane and the Reeth Dales Centre.

Reeth

REE 1 — Land east of Arkengarthdale Road and north of Hill Close, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

The site is a sloping, irregularly shaped walled pasture on the lower western slopes of Arkengarthdale. It is a component of the historic network of walled pastures on the lower slopes of the fells which, in this relatively exposed and rugged Arkengarthdale landscape, reveal the inherent connection between underlying geology, landform and land use with exceptional clarity and thus contribute to the special qualities of the YDNP. The strong contrasts in landscape pattern, between the deeply incised, wooded Arkle Beck, the pastures on the lower fell slopes and the rocky upland moors are highly sensitive to change and development across this site would erode part of this network at a point where it is particularly visible and already squeezed so that there are only a few fields separating the eastern edge of Reeth from the Arkle Beck.

Settlement form and setting — High

The village of Reeth has a compact form, with buildings concentrated around the central village green. The landscape setting to the east and north of the village is formed by the dramatic, enclosed moorlands and rock-strewn ledges of Arkengarthdale and contrasts with the more spacious U-shaped pastoral landscapes of Swaledale to the south and west. The site contributes to the evocative landscape setting of north east Reeth because, together with the small roadside green which marks the northern edge of the village, it draws the Arkengarthdale landscape right up to the road, enabling stunning views into and out from the village and separating the existing settlement from the small clusters of buildings to the north (at Townend Hall and Jenny Hill). Development here would result in perceived coalescence of the village and the Town End Hall cluster in the elevated long views from the lanes and by ways on Fremington Edge to the east and would screen the views to and from the Arkengarthdale Road, degrading the sensitive and scenic landscape relationship between Reeth and the Arkle Beck in Lower Arkengarthdale.

Views and recreational experience — High

The village of Reeth is a visitor destination and gateway to the dales so the dense network of public rights of way and lanes that connect the village and the surrounding fells are well used. The site is highly visible in views westwards from the eastern slopes of Arkengarthdale and Fremington Edge, where the curve of its walled pasture accentuates the steep contours of the dale and contributes to the landscape setting of north east Reeth. It is also visible at close quarters from the public footpath between the village centre and Town End Hall. Development would erode this striking and distinctive landscape pattern and would also screen one of the most important and scenic views in Reeth. Travelling southwards downslope into Reeth along the Arkengarthdale road, the views to the buildings on the northern edge of the village are set against stunning long views across Lower Arkengarthdale, revealing the contrasts between the network of walled lower fell slope pastures, the ladder pattern of walls leading upslope and the rugged rocky moors on the ridgetop summits. Development on this site would screen this view.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate-high

There is a distinctive contrast between the verdant and spacious pastoral landscape of Swaledale and the rocky moorlands of Arkengarthdale. This site is at the cusp of these two landscapes at a point where long views to both are accessible from a public road and village open space within the village. There is a narrowing down of the landscape setting at the northern edge of Reeth, which is perceived as the gateway to Arkengarthdale and the undeveloped, small irregular walled pastures that structure the views between village road and river, to and from this gateway should be conserved.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate-high

The irregular stone wall enclosures on the slopes of Arkengarthdale are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across the dale and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. The site also contributes to the landscape setting of the Grade II listed Townend Hall Farmhouse, which dates from the mid 16th century; the walled pasture (of the site) and the adjacent small roadside green separate the historic building from the village and provide an intimate, small-scale sequence of curving walls and tracks that lead the eye and structure views to Town End Hall from the road (particularly northwards from the edge of the village). Development on the site would compromise the landscape setting of this heritage asset and would erode a particularly visible part of Arkengarthdale’s historic field pattern.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high*

The site is at a particularly sensitive gateway - to Reeth and to Arkengarthdale. Development here would erode the distinctive character and quality of the Reeth’s relatively narrow and sensitive landscape relationship with the Arkle Beck and the wider landscape setting to the north east of the village. It would increase the perceived coalescence between the village and the cluster of buildings at Townend Hall, also compromising the setting of this historic building. Most importantly, development on this site would screen the stunning expansive views south eastwards from the Arkengarthdale Road across Lower Arkengarthdale, which are a distinctive and striking component of Reeth’s landscape setting and which contribute to the special qualities of the YDNP. The sensitivity score could be lowered if only the southern part of the site is considered for development, alongside Hill Close, where native planting could integrate buildings while conserving the important views.

IMAGE: Site-location inset map for REE 1, showing the site east of Arkengarthdale Road and north of Hill Close, Reeth.

REE 2 — Land south of Silver Street (B6270) and west of Quaker Close, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Moderate

The site is a rectangular open walled pasture on the lower slopes of Calver Hill and on the western fringe of Reeth. The land slopes smoothly down to the River Swale. It is an open field, enclosed by low drystone field walls and is bordered to the east by existing housing. There are no relevant ecological designations. However, the site is a component of the historic network of walled fields which extends across the fell slopes throughout Swaledale and which has evolved in response to the underlying geology and topography. The most sensitive components of the site are its intact boundary stone walls and the distinct, smooth ridge in the north west corner of the field, where the land rises towards a roadside barn. This roll in the local landform, and the overall fall of the slope from Silver Street, reflects the huge, sweeping scale of the surrounding fells. Development could be accommodated with care, provided the boundary stone walls and the crest of the higher land on the ridge to the north west are conserved intact.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

Development here would be a logical continuation of Reeth’s existing pattern of growth, across the lower fell slopes and above the Swale floodplain. This is a large site in relation to Reeth as a whole and there is a risk that development across the whole site would seem over-scaled as Reeth has a fairly compact settlement form and seems small in relation to its expansive and scenic landscape setting. This is also a sensitive gateway site, which is prominent in views eastwards from the B6270 and northwards from the elevated fell slopes to the south. The sequence of gateway views from the B6270 is structured by a local ridge, a traditional roadside stone barn on the downslope and the village school on the upslope side of the road. The site provides a foreground to open views eastward from the B6270, but the existing settlement edge (west edge of Quaker Close) forms an abrupt interface with surrounding fields and development on the southern part of the site (conserving the setting of the traditional buildings and elevated landform) could provide an opportunity to create a softer, more varied built edge, with trees along an access road forming a backdrop to eastward gateway views.

Views and recreational experience — High

Development on this site would be prominent in views from all of the roads and public rights of way to the west and south of Reeth, including the elevated panoramic views from Swale Hall Lane and the Maiden Castle Fort to the south of Reeth. These stunning accessible views across the sweeping, expansive landscape of Swaledale and Arkengarthdale capture the essence of the Dales’ scenery and contribute to the special qualities of the YDNP. Development on this site would be visible in these long views and the oblique, elevated perspective would limit the scope for mitigating the potential visual impacts of new built development. In addition, there is a public right of way across the site, which connects the village with Skelgate Lane on the slopes of Calver Hill and, at a local scale, to the village school on Silver Street just north west of the site.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate-high

In long views across Swaledale, this open walled field (the site) feels part of the network of fields on the surrounding lower fell slopes which anchor the village within its distinctive dale-side setting. It is a prominent and highly sensitive site. However, at a local scale and in gateway views from the B6270, the site is perceived as the foreground to views to the western edge of Reeth where the existing built edge seems exposed, abrupt and nondescript. There is an opportunity to enhance this gateway view with a carefully designed development, which conserves the perceived connective network of field stone walls and a sense of the spacious foreground slope in views downslope from the ridge to the north west of the village.

Cultural and historical associations — High

This walled pasture is within the designated Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area and is noted (in the Historic Environment Record and on Lidar) as an area with remnant medieval field systems, including lynchets and ridge and furrow. The site is a well preserved part of the historic landscape character (small irregular fields, earthwork remains of ridge and furrow and lynchets) of this area. The landscape setting of the two barns in the field to the west of the site is also an important factor and any development should be set well back from these traditional buildings.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high*

Reeth’s quintessential Yorkshire Dales landscape setting is visible in multiple panoramic views from the slopes of Harkerside Moor to the south. This is a highly sensitive site which contributes to the quality of these views and to the special qualities of the YDNP. However, it is at a natural gateway to the village and, if heritage considerations do not preclude development, it is possible to envisage built development across this slope which fits with the existing pattern of the settled dale. Any such layout would need to be sensitively designed, with built frontages that complement the compact vernacular architectural character of the village and form a contrasting but soft interface with Reeth’s lower fell slope landscape setting. A gateway development that is set well back from the road (to conserve the slope of the slightly ridged landform adjacent to Silver Street and the landscape setting of the traditional barns) and a pattern of open space and tree planting (including trees along the access road) that ‘knits’ the settlement into the wider fell slope landscape pattern, could potentially be accommodated.

REE 3 — Land west of B6270 and north of Back Lane, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Low-moderate

This is a brownfield site on the edge of the village centre and at the principal gateway to Reeth from Reeth Bridge and Swaledale. It is a gently sloping site, enclosed by a curved stone wall which comprises a mix of hard standing, scrub and trees in the northern and central parts of the site and a derelict house and sheds in the southern part and along its boundary with Back Lane. The enclosing curved stone walls and robust, large stone gateposts are the most sensitive physical components of the site, which could be conserved as part of a new development scheme.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate

The site marks the principal gateway to Reeth Green from the south east. The road from Reeth Bridge curves around the site before entering the green and so this is potentially a landmark development site, where the frontage (buildings/trees) would define a significant gateway sequence of views. Historic maps indicate that this site may have been part of the former yard for the Reeth Union Workhouse and that it has not previously been developed. This is a landmark site which is prominent in the local townscape and requires a sensitive, high quality architectural scheme. However there is an opportunity for a housing development that contributes positively to the frontages along the B6270 and Back Lane and which conserves the existing curving stone wall and gate posts.

Views and recreational experience — Low-moderate

The site currently detracts from the quality of local views at an important gateway to Reeth and there is an opportunity for much improvement. The gateway sequence of views ensures that the whole of the frontage to Back Lane and the B6270 is prominent, with particular emphasis on the visual character of the south east corner, which is the focus for views on the approach to the historic village centre. These important views apply to both drivers of vehicles and pedestrians, including visitors to the YDNP.

Perceptual qualities — Low

The existing site is derelict and under used. It is unsightly and is perceived as being unsafe, with easy access via the open gateway. Given the central location of this site within Reeth, it is surprising that it has been left undeveloped for so long and there would be clear benefit in demolition and clearance of the existing derelict building and structures and implementation of a sensitively designed scheme.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site is not designated as part of Reeth’s Conservation Area but is associated with two listed buildings to the south west and west, which are the former Reeth Union Workhouse (now divided into two properties) and The Old Mortuary. Both are grade II listed buildings. The Reeth Union Workhouse occupied a former mansion, which was purchased for £700 in the mid 19th century and converted to accommodate up to 60 inmates¹.

¹ https://www.workhouses.org.uk/Reeth/

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Low-moderate

This is a derelict site in a gateway location which is prominent in the sequence of views from the principal approach to Reeth Green from the south east. It would benefit from a high quality scheme which contributes positively to the frontages along the B6270 and Back Lane and which conserves the existing curving stone wall and gate posts.

REE 4 — Land west of Arkengarthdale Road and opposite Moor Garth, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

The Arkengarthdale Road is aligned to follow the contours on the slopes of Reeth High Moor and, on the northern edge of the village, it follows a slight terrace of land with steeper, rugged slopes to the west (upslope) and to the east (downslope) of the road. The site is part of a pasture with an elongated shape which is partially enclosed by low field stone walls. It has a lumpy, uneven landform and is backed to the west by an abrupt steep short scarp of rough grass and scrub. The site is alongside the road, at the point where the terrace narrows and the steep part of the fell slope comes close to the road - the shape of the field narrows to the north of the site as the road swings closer to the scarp slope. The rugged steep scarp is a distinctive landscape feature which forms a backdrop to accessible views at the northern gateway to Reeth. The narrow shape of the walled enclosure, the scattered mature trees, the natural pattern of scrub on the scarp slope and the pastoral character of the site are also valued landscape features which contribute to the distinctive character and scenic quality of the landscape at a local scale. Development here would erode this valued combination of landscape elements in a place where they are particularly accessible.

Settlement form and setting — High

The site is a short distance from the northern edge of the village, where there is a narrow gap between houses on the edge of Reeth and the small cluster of buildings associated with Townend Hall Farm and Moor Garth. Outside and to the north of the village of Reeth, such small linear hamlets and groups of roadside buildings are a characteristic settlement form in the Upper Arkengarthdale. Given the narrowness of the existing gap and the visibility of the buildings of Townend Hall Farm and Moor Garth in views from the edge of the village, there is a risk that development on this site would be perceived as part of Reeth. Such perceived coalescence would have an urbanising effect at a sensitive threshold where the natural landscape of Arkengarthdale predominates.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

There is a sense that this point along the Arkengarthdale Road, where the road swings close to a steep section of the fell slope, is the gateway to Arkengarthdale from Swaledale. Travelling north, it is the point at which the wild, exposed landscape character of Arkengarthdale dominates views from the road; travelling south, it is the gateway to the village of Reeth, with tamer, long views across the pastoral landscapes of Lower Arkengarthdale and Swaledale. Development on this site would dilute the striking contrast in landscape character at this distinctive transition. Given Reeth’s importance as a tourist centre and gateway to the northern dales, this adverse effect would have widespread impact.

Perceptual qualities — High

As the steep scarp section of the fell slope comes into close view, the colours and textures of the rough grassland, scrub are suddenly apparent and the physical, natural character of the upland Arkengarthdale landscape is experienced at first hand. Development on this site would screen local views to this steep scarp, diluting the contrast between the landscape of the settled, pastoral dale and that of the exposed upland moors.

Cultural and historical associations — High

The irregular stone wall enclosures on the slopes of Arkengarthdale are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across the dale and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. The relatively small scale and narrow elongated shape of the enclosure on this site reflects the steepening fell slope towards the narrower upper dale and, with the expansion of Reeth, is unusual within the local landscape context. It also contributes to the historic character of the Arkengarthdale Road between Reeth and the small walled village pound, which is adjacent and to the north of the site. Development on the site would have severe adverse and unmitigatable effect on the landscape setting of this historic feature and would damage a particularly visible and distinctive component of Arkengarthdale’s farming heritage.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — High

This is a sensitive gateway site, which is beyond the northern edge of Reeth and separated from the village edge by a short gap. It is also at the threshold between Arkengarthdale and Swaledale, where there is a change from pastoral dale to the raw, natural landscape of exposed moorland. The narrow shape of the walled field enclosure reflects the form of the contours and development here would obscure this subtle, but evocative landscape transition. It would also damage the sensitive time-deph of the Arkengarthdale Road on the northern edge of Reeth and the historic relationship between Reeth and its village pound.

REE 5 — Land west of Arkengarthdale Road and opposite Townend Green, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

The Arkengarthdale Road is aligned to follow the contours on the slopes of Reeth High Moor and, on the northern edge of the village, it follows a slight terrace of land with steeper, rugged slopes to the west (upslope) and to the east (downslope) of the road. The site is a small pasture, enclosed by low field stone walls, alongside the road, at the point where the terrace narrows and the steep part of the fell slope comes close to the road. The site has a lumpy, uneven landform and is backed to the west by an abrupt steep short scarp of rough grass and scrub which curves at the entrance to Arkengarthdale. This distinctive landscape feature is locally important as a backdrop to accessible views at the northern gateway to Reeth. The irregularly shaped walled enclosure, a local mounded landform, the scattered mature trees, the natural pattern of scrub on the scarp slope and the pastoral character of the site are also valued landscape features which contribute to the distinctive character and scenic quality of the landscape at a local scale. Development here would erode this valued combination of landscape elements in a place where they are particularly accessible.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

The village of Reeth has a compact form, with the historic settlement concentrated around the central large village green. Development is generally contained within the historic pattern of walled fields which typically comprises enclosures with an irregular-rounded shape in response to the gentle slopes of the broad terrace of land at the confluence of Arkengarthdale and Swaledale. However, on the north side of the village, the field pattern changes as enclosures become more elongated in response to the steeper slopes and narrowing of the dale. This site is the last of the rounded enclosures to the west of the Arkengarthdale Road and its development would continue the logical pattern of settlement growth. However, development here would reduce the existing gap between the existing village edge and the small cluster of buildings at Townend Hall Farm and Moor Garth by continuing development along the west side of the road. It would have an urbanising effect at a sensitive threshold where built development should peter out and where the natural landscape should predominate.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

There is a sense that this point along the Arkengarthdale Road, where the road swings close to a steep section of the fell slope, is the gateway to Arkengarthdale from Swaledale. Travelling north, it is the point at which the wild, exposed landscape character of Arkengarthdale dominates views from the road; travelling south, it is the gateway to the village of Reeth, with tamer, long views across the pastoral landscapes of Lower Arkengarthdale and Swaledale. There are already houses along the west side of the road and development on this site would continue this pattern of buildings, without screening the scenic long views along Arkengarthdale to the east of the road. However, development would screen the close views to the scarp slope which are of local value and would increase the perceived coalesence of built development in views from Fremington Edge.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate-high

As the steep scarp section of the fell slope comes into close view, the colours and textures of the rough grassland, scrub are suddenly apparent and the physical, natural character of the upland Arkengarthdale landscape is experienced at first hand. Development on this site would screen local views to this steep scarp, diluting the contrast between the landscape of the settled, pastoral dale and that of the exposed upland moors.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate-high

The irregular stone wall enclosures on the slopes of Arkengarthdale are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across the dale and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. The relatively small scale of the enclosure on this site reflects the steepening fell slope towards the narrower upper dale and, with the expansion of Reeth, is unusual within the local landscape context. It also contributes to the historic character of the Arkengarthdale Road between Reeth and the small walled village pound, which is located some 10m to the north of the site. Development on the site would erode a particularly visible and distinctive part of Arkengarthdale’s historic field pattern.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high

The contrasts between the natural, organic pattern of landform and vegetation on the steep scarp and field, the small, irregularly shaped walled pasture and the village townscape form a distinctive gateway to Reeth/Arkengarthdale. The combination of steep scarp and historic walled field enclosures is not unusual within the local area, but it is valued at this particular site because it is a highly accessible gateway to Reeth and forms part of the landscape setting of the village. Development here would degrade but not close down the key views along Arkengarthdale and would continue the existing pattern of settlement growth. However, it would erode the distinctive natural character and quality of the landscape at a sensitive gateway to the village and the perceived threshold between Arkengarthdale and Swaledale.

REE 6 — Land north of Reeth Dales Centre, Reeth

Physical and natural character — Low-moderate

The site is part of the broad terrace of gently sloping land on the lower slopes of Swaledale. It is at the ‘turn of the valley at the confluence of Swaledale and Arkengarthdale and at the foot of a steeper section of the fell slope, which forms a backdrop to views. It comprises a large field to the north of the Reeth Dales Centre and to the west of existing housing. It is partially enclosed by stone walls. The most distinctive and sensitive natural landscape feature is the steep fell slope to the north west of the site; the natural pattern of rough grassland and scrub on this slope is accentuated by the alignment of historic stone walls and contrasts with the surrounding pastures. The slope wraps around the north west part of Reeth, including the site. However the site does not impinge on this steep slope and its character is strongly influenced by the adjacent built development. It does not have particularly distinctive physical or natural characteristics that would be sensitive to development.

Settlement form and setting — Low-moderate

The village of Reeth has a compact form, with the historic settlement concentrated around the central large village green. Development is generally contained within the historic pattern of walled fields on the gentle slopes of the broad terrace of land at the confluence of Arkengarthdale and Swaledale. This site is part of this terrace of land and its development would continue the logical pattern of settlement growth within an area that is not overlooked in publicly accessible views. The distinctive steep fell slope to the north west of the site is of sufficient scale and height to dominate the landscape setting of Reeth regardless of whether development takes place on this site or not.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

Development on this site would be visible in long elevated views to Reeth from Harkerside Moor to the south and Fremington Edge to the east. These are important, scenic views that are accessible from local lanes and enjoyed by visitors to the YDNP. However, such development would be seen within the context of the existing village and is unlikely to have a detrimental impact.

Perceptual qualities — Low-moderate

This site is relatively well hidden from local close views within Reeth and development here would be perceived as an integrated part of the village.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The stone wall enclosures on the slopes of Swaledale and Arkengarthdale are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across both dales and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. The stone walls that partially enclose of this site are not intact and its historic character is compromised by adjacent built development, but part of the site is noted (in the Historic Environment Record) as an area with remnant medieval lynchets.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Low-moderate

This site is perceived within the context of the existing village townscape and, assuming vehicular access would be via the Reeth Dales Centre, there are no compelling constraints to its development from a landscape and visual perspective. The steep slope to the north west of the site, which forms a backdrop to long views to Reeth across Swaledale and Arkengarthdale would contain and integrate development on this site. It would be visible in these sensitive and accessible views, but would be perceived as a minor, logical addition to the existing settlement. The eastern boundary of the site is more sensitive as it is slightly more elevated and close to the frontage with existing development; single storey buildings would be more appropriate here.

Grinton

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed site GRI 1, east of Croft Farm in Grinton, near the River Swale, Grinton Bridge and Ox Hill earthworks.

GRI 1 — Land east of Croft Farm, Grinton

Physical and natural character — Moderate

This brownfield site is a former farm yard which comprises two single storey long sheds and an area of hard-standing on the eastern edge of Grinton and on the southern fringes of the Swale floodplain. The eastern part of the site is partially enclosed by mature trees and there is also a line of ornamental trees and shrubs along the southern boundary. It abuts an a prominent earthworks known as Ox Hill. The broad meandering floodplain of the River Swale is partially fringed by curving bands of mature woodland with individual farmsteads or historic halls enclosed by woodland. The northern edge of the site, which fronts onto the meandering floodplain, is inherently sensitive and the mature trees on the eastern site boundary are valuable landscape features, which contribute to the natural character of the river corridor landscape. There are no relevant environmental designations and the site already has large (albeit single storey) buildings; a development of two storey houses, softened with native tree planting and retaining the existing mature boundary trees to the north and east could be integrated without eroding the sinuous large scale pattern of the river corridor and its natural, deeply rural landscape character.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

The village of Grinton has developed at a historic bridge crossing over the River Swale and is one of the few settlements in Swaledale where buildings are adjacent to the river. The existing sheds on the site are visible in the gateway north western views from the B6270 to the east of the village, but their low roofs are relatively unintrusive and are partially screened and enclosed by mature trees. A large block of two storey houses could be prominent and seem over-scaled in this location, which is on the outer fringes of the village at a point where the terraces of roadside village buildings are interspersed with farmland and woodland and where buildings are subordinate. Only a relatively low density development, enclosed by existing trees and i new native tree planting, could be integrated without damage to Grinton’s sensitive and small-scale riverside landscape setting.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

The river corridor is bordered by bands of woodland at this point and the existing buildings within the village of Grinton are well integrated within their landscape setting. Two storey buildings on this site would be visible, although the views would be softened by existing trees, in the gateway views north westwards from the B6270 and would be glimpsed in views south-eastwards from the historic river bridge and southwards from parts of the riverside public right of way along the north bank of the river, particularly in winter when the riverside trees do not provide an effective screen. Development here would also partially visible in southward views from the lanes to the north - ‘Hard Stiles’ and the lane to Marrick Priory. Grinton is a popular visitor destination at the gateway to Swaledale and a low density ‘village scale’ development, enclosed and integrated by existing trees and new tree planting, would conserve the scenic rural quality of local views that are enjoyed by many.

Perceptual qualities — Low-moderate

Grinton’s listed buildings are grouped close to the historic river bridge and there is a risk that built development here would be perceived as impinging on the rural character of the river floodplain and ‘competing’ with the historic settlement pattern and the distinctive Ox Hill earthworks on the floodplain fringe, which is an intriguing and evocative local landscape feature. However, these influences should be balanced by the relatively nondescript existing character of the site; the long low sheds are perceived as agricultural buildings and the degraded hard standing areas are not generally visible. Residential development could fit within this well treed, village edge and brownfield site setting.

Cultural and historical associations — High

The Ox Hill earthworks are not designated by Historic England but a geophysical survey (2021) identifies a series of defensive ditches and stone banks which enclose ‘a number of possible structures’. The survey also identifies possible trackways and ditches and concludes that the surviving earthworks reflect the remains of a significant fortified settlement. The earthworks site has been compromised by the former use of the area as a golf course but is nevertheless a distinctive and valuable heritage asset. Built development on this site would damage the landscape setting and historic integrity of the Ox Hill earthworks site. The site and surrounding landscape is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area and contributes to the heritage value of the pastoral landscape across the whole of the dale.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate*

The existing large, long sheds do not contribute positively to the local landscape but their low roof line and temporary, agricultural character means that they are not dominant within the landscape setting of Grinton. A relatively low density housing development with a layout that conserves the existing boundary trees and supplements them with additional informal native tree planting would be partially visible, but could be integrated with the existing pattern and scale of the village landscape. The built edge would need to be set well back from the landscape setting of the evocative historic Ox Hill earthworks, which are thought to be the remains of a defensive settlement at a strategic riverside crossing.

Hudswell

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed site HUD 1 north of Hudswell Lane and west of ‘Westryton’, on the southern edge of the wooded River Swale valley.

HUD 1 — Land north of Hudswell Lane and west of ‘Westryton’, Hudswell

Physical and natural character — Low-moderate

The site is on the southern edge of the deeply incised, wooded valley of the River Swale and forms part of the pattern of ridgetop small linear paddocks and house plots alongside Hudswell Lane which contrast with the distinctive linear field pattern which is aligned across the contours of the valley slope. The steep valley slopes to the north form a distinctive landscape setting, with elevated panoramic views. There are no constraints to development in this location, provided the mature trees along the site boundaries are conserved to ensure that buildings are integrated and the overall scale and form of the distinctive valley slope landscape pattern is unchanged.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate

The village of Hudswell has a linear form, with buildings strung out along Hudswell Lane. The historic village core is c. 220m to the east of the site and the houses adjacent and to the east of the site are predominantly bungalows, with occasional farm houses and agricultural barns. There is a new residential development to the south and west of the site. The groups of houses are interspersed with gardens, paddocks and groups of trees and there are frequent long views northwards between the houses across the Swale valley. Development on this site would fit with the existing linear form of the village but buildings on this site would extend and emphasise the linearity of the settlement form and would result in the loss of a scenic long view from the road which contributes to the landscape setting of the village.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

Although views through the village along Hudswell Lane are channelled between the existing houses, the focus of views is always to the north, where there are framed views between the buildings across the scenic Swale Valley. The site provides an opportunity for a pause in the line of roadside buildings and for a broad panoramic view which, although not unique, contributes to the quality of local public views and the experience of being on the ridgetop of a deep wooded river valley. Built development on this site would partially block this view and would continue the existing alignment of adjacent roadside houses to create a more nondescript settlement form. Built development here would be visible on the skyline in views from two public rights of way that connect the village with the river valley. It would be seen alongside other houses in these views, but would have a slight urbanising influence.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

Development on this site would have an adverse influence on the scenic quality of local cross valley views but would generally fit within the overall pattern of settlement, fields and woodland in this distinctive steep river valley landscape. It would erode the rural character of the settlement at a point where existing buildings are interspersed with fields towards the western edge of the village, resulting in a more dense settlement form and a more abrupt village edge.

Cultural and historical associations — Low-moderate

Development on this site would not have a direct effect on designated heritage assets and would fit within the distinctive historic linear field pattern that is aligned to reflect the steep valley slope topography. The historic (grade II listed) Church of St Michael and All Angels is to the west of the site and buildings on the site would be visible in local views from the footpath approach to the church from the valley below.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Low-moderate

Development on this roadside site would result in some erosion to the rural character of the village of Hudwell and would result in the loss of one of the few remaining open cross-valley views from Hudswell Lane. However, there would not be a fundamental change to the character and pattern of the village landscape and there are similar views across the Swale Valley from other parts of the road and from local footpaths and public open spaces to the north of the road.

Langthwaite

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed site LTW 1 north of the Methodist Chapel in Langthwaite, beside Arkengarthdale Road and Arkle Beck.

LTW 1 — Land north of Methodist Chapel, Langthwaite

Physical and natural character — High

Arkengarthdale has an asymmetrical topography; the slopes of Reeth High Moor and Arkengarthdale Moor (to the west of the dale) have a relatively low profile compared to the steep, rugged cliff-like slopes of Fremington Edge and Langthwaite Scar to the east. The site has a dramatic and distinctive landscape setting on the lower western dale slopes, overlooking the deep, semi-wooded ravine of Arkle Beck and the steep slopes of Langthwaite Scar. It is a relatively flat site within a walled roadside pasture on the northern fringes of Langthwaite. There are no relevant biodiversity designations and scattered groups of roadside cottages and farms are part of the Arkengarthdale landscape pattern, but development here could seem over-scaled and could detract from the deeply rural landscape setting.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

Langthwaite is the largest of the small, scattered hamlets in Arkengarthdale. The historic core of the village is at the river bridge crossing, with additional small groups of buildings around a triangular green just off the main dale road and around the historic Victorian church further to the north along the road. Development on this site would continue this settlement pattern but it would be beyond the principal existing settlement and would ‘fill in’ part of the gap between the church and the hamlet. This is also a sensitive built environment as the site is between the former Methodist Chapel, the roadside war memorial and St Mary’s Church. Although not a listed building, the former Methodist Chapel is a distinctive historical building, which merits its own landscape setting and development should also respect the much broader landscape setting of St Mary’s Church to the north.

Views and recreational experience — High

Development on this site would be a prominent roadside component of this much visited hamlet and would form part of the gateway view to the north side of Langthwaite on a stretch of road between two historic buildings. This is a highly sensitive site from a visual perspective. Langthwaite is a YDNP visitor destination and the principal Arkengarthdale Road is a popular accessible route for motorists and cyclists (NCR 71). In addition, development on this site would be prominent in views from the elevated public rights of way on both sides of the dale.

Perceptual qualities — High

This is an exceptionally dramatic and scenic landscape setting and built development here would form part of the composed views northwards to the church and southwards to the former Methodist Chapel on the edge of Langthwaite. These are evocative views which capture the essence of the Arkengarthdale landscape.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate-high

The stone wall enclosures on the slopes of Arkengarthdale are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across the dale and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. This site is also part of the setting of the historic former Methodist Chapel on the edge of Langthwaite and a component of the broader historic landscape setting of St Mary’s Church, a grade II listed building to the north east.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — High

This is a highly sensitive gateway site on the fringes of a small settlement, between historic buildings and with a dramatic and scenic upland landscape setting. A residential development, together with its vehicular access, parking and lighting, would damage this evocative upland landscape setting and would be prominent in views from the elevated public rights of way on both sides of Arkengarthdale.

Low Row/Feetham

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed sites LOW 1 and LOW 2 around Low Row and Feetham. LOW 1 is to the rear of Brass Nappa Hall/Melbecks House; LOW 2 is between Ling Garth and Home View.

LOW 1 — Land to the rear of Brass Nappa Hall/Melbecks House, Low Row

Physical and natural character — High

The site is part of two open walled pastures on the fell slopes above the linear village of Low Row. This is a highly distinctive and sensitive traditional Swaledale landscape in which the topography is accentuated by a network of walled pastures and individually spaced field stone barns. The walled fields form a patchwork across the broad fell slopes, with broken rows of terraced cottages and farm houses aligned along the contours on the lower slopes just above the floodplain. Buildings are often sheltered by lines/groups of trees, typically along tributary becks and slope indentations. The site is on an open part of the slope, close to a steep, partially wooded gill and adjacent to a traditional barn. Development across this site would be more elevated than the main village and would be over-scaled in this delicately balanced and open settled Swaledale landscape.

Settlement form and setting — High

The village of Low Row comprises discontinuous lines of buildings which follow the slope contours above and below the B6270. There are few houses fronting onto the road and the buildings on the northern (upslope) side of the road are typically ‘perched’ above it, accessed by long tracks that traverse the steep slopes. There are also isolated groups of farm buildings and cottages in sheltered sites above the village, but buildings are generally below the 245m contour. This is an exceptionally open and deeply rural settled landscape in which groups of buildings ‘step up’ and are integrated with the patchwork of pastures across the farmed slopes. A standard block of development across this site would be over-scaled and intrusive and could not be integrated within this open and sensitive landscape setting, in which the pattern of the rural settlement is laid out in views from the slopes to the south of Swaledale. There is also a risk that vehicular access cutting across the slope could be prominent and potentially intrusive.

Views and recreational experience — High

This open site is prominent in multiple scenic views, including particularly the elevated cross-dale views from High Lane and the network of public rights of way on the slopes of High Carl to the south of Swaledale. Buildings on this site would also form the skyline in some views from the B6270 and would be visible in the downslope views from the rural lanes and public rights of way on the northern fell slopes above Low Row. These rural routes through Swaledale are popular recreational routes and there is a risk that standard development on this site would detract from the special qualities of the YDNP, including a ‘highly legible landscape’, ‘traditional pastoral landscape, ‘expansive views’ and ‘distinctive traditional architecture.’ In addition, there is a public right of way across the most accessible part of the site, which would ensure close views to all aspects of a development.

Perceptual qualities — High

This is a scenic and evocative landscape in which the dispersed, ‘broken linear’ landscape pattern reflects centuries of settlement, farming and industry. This is an exceptionally prominent site where built development would be visually intrusive and over-scaled.

Cultural and historical associations — High

The pattern of field stone walls and barns on the slopes of Swaledale (and this site) are part of a relatively intact network of walled pastures which continues across the dale and is designated as part of the Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Barns and Walls Conservation Area. The site is not within the landscape setting of listed buildings but incorporates a field stone barn. There is a risk that development across this site would erode the intrinsic time depth of this particularly visible traditional settled Swaledale landscape.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — High

This is a prominent and highly sensitive site in a rural settlement which has an exceptionally distinctive low density linear form. Given the characteristic discontinuous linear pattern of settlement in this part of Swaledale, the site is over-scaled, elevated above the main settlement and development would be intrusive and would result in significant adverse landscape and visual effects.

LOW 2 — Land between Ling Garth and Holme View, Feetham

Physical and natural character — High

The site is a sloping walled croft with a roughly pentagonal shape to the south of the B6207. It is partially surrounded by a small group of traditional farm houses/cottages which form a small hamlet partially enclosing this central croft. This is a highly distinctive and sensitive traditional settled Swaledale landscape and a variation from the linear dispersed pattern that is typical of the Low Row landscape. The fell slopes are typically quite open in the Low Row area, but the slopes just above (and north of) the site are well wooded, so this site has a fairly sheltered landscape character, with views directed southwards across the relatively open dale floor. This walled enclosure, which has a distinctive curved (and slightly irregular) shape has an unusual form and it is clear that the walled croft stands alone in relation to the property boundaries of the adjacent cottages. It is of historic significance and is an exceptionally distinctive component of the local landscape pattern that should be conserved and not developed.

Settlement form and setting — High

The villages of Low Row and Feetham typically comprise discontinuous lines of buildings which follow the slope contours above and below the B6270. There are few houses fronting onto the road and the groups of buildings are highly dispersed and interlaced with the patchwork of pastures across the farmed slopes. This part of Feetham is unusual and historically significant in that dwellings and farm buildings are sited around an enclosed former communal green in an arrangement that was designed to protect local livestock. A block of development that ‘fills in’ this site would cause significant damage to this historic rural settlement pattern and should not even be considered.

Views and recreational experience — High

This site is prominent in multiple scenic views, including particularly the elevated cross-dale views from High Lane and the network of public rights of way on the slopes of High Carl to the south of Swaledale; plus several routes along the lower dale, such as Low Lane. These are popular Swaledale recreational routes and the visibility of this site means that the distinctive layout of the whole hamlet, with the historic communal green and surrounding historic buildings, is clearly visible. There is a risk that development on this site would detract from the special qualities of the YDNP, including a ‘highly legible landscape’, ‘traditional pastoral landscape, ‘expansive views’ and distinctive traditional architecture.’

Perceptual qualities — High

This site feels as if it is more part of the settlement than of the fell slope farmland, yet it is clearly a component of both. The indented, slightly irregular shape of the walled enclosure is a distinctive and evocative landscape feature which should be conserved intact; reference to historic maps indicates that the straight eastern site boundary results from a more a recent division. The unusual and distinctive local landscape pattern reflects centuries of settlement and farming and has an exceptionally strong time depth.

Cultural and historical associations — High

This site is a former enclosed communal green and is a significant and highly valued historic landscape feature, which probably dates from the middle ages (since the buildings surrounding it date from the 17th century). The relatively high wall around the green itself, as well as the deliberate construction of the hamlet all around the green, was designed to protect the local herds, and is a distinctive arrangement seen elsewhere in Swaledale. In Feetham the historical arrangement has remained almost unchanged for the last few centuries. The site is adjacent to two grade II listed buildings and forms part of their landscape setting. Given the close historical connections between building and landscape, the site contributes to the significance of both listed buildings. This is a significant historical site and development here would damage the historic relationships between building and enclosure in a particularly visible and distinctive component of Swaledale’s settled farmland landscape.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — High

This site is a highly distinctive enclosed communal green which is of historical significance as an example of an integrated layout of buildings and pastoral farmland that has been conserved over the centuries. It is also prominent in many cross-dale views from public rights of way. This site should be conserved and should not be developed.

Wensleydale, Bishopdale & Coverdale

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed sites around Hawes and Gayle, labelled GAY 1, GAY 2, HAW 1, HAW 2, HAW 3 and HAW 4.

Gayle

GAY 1 — Land north of Marridales, Gayle

Physical and natural character — Moderate

The site is on the undulating lower north facing slopes of Wether Fell Side and on the fringes of Gayle. To the north, the local topography is shaped by a series of smooth, rolling drumlins, that separate the villages of Gayle and Hawes. The roll of the landform is accentuated by the curving network of low stone walls, which enclose each of the irregularly-shaped and relatively small fields that are on the fringes of the settlements. The site is bordered to the south by a line of bungalows which are elevated in relation to the lane and to the west by existing houses and contemporary farm buildings. There is a small historic stone barn, sited at an angle to the road on the site. Development here would fit within the existing historic field pattern and would continue the alignment of built development along Marridales/Old Gayle Lane but it would erode the traditional and distinctive rural ‘stone barns and walls’ character where it is juxtaposed with the built form of the village.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

This site is on a back lane which connects the twin villages of Hawes and Gayle and is at a local gateway to Gayle. The historic village of Gayle developed around Gayle Mill at Gayle Beck, with clusters of cottages and some outlying farmsteads along back lanes, such as Old Gayle Lane. There are attractive views northwards to St Margarets Church in Hawes. Development of this site would extend built development along the lane, consolidating the existing groups of buildings to create a corridor of development, with buildings on both sides of the road rather than the existing semi-rural, one-sided built form. While this form of development would continue the existing pattern of settlement growth, there is a risk that it would disrupt the sensitive landscape setting of Gayle. The density of the existing groups of buildings (including agricultural barns) off Old Gayle Lane increases to the west of Blackburn Farm but the rural, sweep of the farmland setting to Gayle predominates and there is a risk that development on the site would increase the perceived coalesence between existing buildings and create a ribbon of roadside development that feels over-scaled within the sensitive farmland landscape setting of this part of Gayle.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

Development here would be visible in glimpsed views south eastwards from Gayle Lane, in views southwards from the Pennine Way between Gayle and Hawes. It would be prominent in views from Old Gayle Lane (which is used by pedestrians and cyclists to link circular walks), from the elevated public right of way on the fell slopes to the south and from the public right of way that connects the A684 in Hawes with Gayle (which crosses the northern part of the site and would require a footpath diversion). It would also be visible in the long cross dale views southwards from the Sedbusk area in which it would be seen against the backdrop of the existing bungalows to the north of Old Gayle Lane. Given the importance of Hawes and Gayle as a tourist destination within the YDNP, this network of footpaths is well used. Only a relatively low density residential layout, which incorporates stone wall boundaries, open space and extensive native planting could be integrated here in order to conserve the traditional pastoral landscape setting of the village of Gayle and its attractive rural landscape setting.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

The approach to Gayle from Old Gayle Lane is an attractive, rural route; the walled narrow lane has a mix of properties alongside, but is predominantly farmland, with attractive views northwards across the undulating drumlins that separate the villages of Hawes and Gayle and southwards to the slopes of Burtersett High Pasture and Wether Fell Side. A solid block of development would detract from the rural setting and a low density ‘rural’ scheme with ‘soft’ irregular built edges, trees and stone wall boundaries would be more appropriate.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

Old Gayle Lane has a historic character, which threads between a lower fell slope landscape of walled fields and barns. The site is outside the Gayle Conservation Area but contributes to its setting and a dense form of development on this site would detract from the traditional pastoral setting of the village. The small historic roadside stone barn contributes directly to the historic character and strong time-depth of this gateway to Gayle. These issues are balanced against the line of modern houses opposite the site, which are relatively prominent and elevated above the lane.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate

This is a sensitive site where there is a risk that development could erode the traditional and distinctive ‘stone barns and walls’ character of Marridales/Old Gayle Lane at a point where it contributes to the landscape setting of Gayle and the gateway to the Gayle Conservation Area from the east. This back lane route has a strong sense of history and an extension of the existing line of development further along the lane could tip the balance of built development : walled pastures to the point where it feels over-developed. This site is also visible from multiple public rights of way, including the Pennine Way and Old Gayle Lane is a popular recreational route. However, a sensitively designed scheme, which conserves the historic barn, provides a positive frontage to Old Gayle Lane and incorporates attractive, soft boundaries (greenspaces, stone walls and native tree planting) that interface with the surrounding farmland could be integrated here.

GAY 2 — Land north of Garris and west of Gayle Lane, Gayle

Physical and natural character — Moderate

The site is in a part of Mid Wensleydale where the local topography is shaped by glacial drift deposits which have been moulded into smooth, undulating landforms and drumlins. The site is on gently sloping farmland to the south of a drumlin that is known locally as ‘Cross Rigg’. It comprises two walled pastures on the western fringes of the village of Gayle which are part of the wider network of traditional rolling ‘walls and barns’ pastures that are characteristic of Wensleydale. The site is on the edge of the village and is bordered to the south and east by a mix of houses, village lanes and farm buildings. Development here would result in the loss of part of the network of traditional walled pastures that surround the village but this change would be within the context of a landscape that is strongly influenced by existing housing and would not damage a particularly unusual or distinctive landscape.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate

This site is off a small walled back lane within a part of Gayle known as ‘West End’. Historic maps and the National Heritage List indicate that this area was developed with a mix of large houses (including two Grade II listed properties) and cottages from the late 17th century. More recent development, including a large housing estate off Gayle Lane and smaller groups of houses off Garris has created a relatively dense settlement form in this part of Gayle. The landscape setting of the West End neighbourhood is an attractive, gently rolling traditional pastoral landscape of walled pastures, small stone barns and narrow lanes within the valley of Gayle Beck and a minor tributary, which flows eastwards to the north of the site. Expansion of the settlement across this site would continue the traditional pattern of growth within the valley but would represent a relatively large scale of built development within the context of the existing village. However, it could be accommodated without causing damage to the landscape setting of Gayle at important gateway to the village and could provide an opportunity to enhance the existing harsh interface between buildings and farmland to the west of Gayle Lane.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

There are exceptionally attractive views across the site to the drumlin of Cross Rigg, with the historic field pattern and rolling topography accentuated by the undulating network of low stone walls,the sinuous line of trees along the minor tributary beck to the north of the site and a small traditional stone barn forming a local landmark. Development of this site would lead to the loss of these views, but they are from a back lane that is already strongly influenced by built development. The site is also prominent in long views south eastwards from Mossy Lane in which the village of Gayle is seen within its wider landscape setting. Development on the site would be visible in these views and also from the public rights of way that connect Mossy Lane with Garris and Gayle Lane. It would increase the perceived scale of the built settlement in these views. The Pennine Way promoted long distance route crosses the site diagonally and would need to be diverted if this site is developed for housing. However, there is an alternative attractive route along existing public rights of way and village lanes, which would offer superb views to Gayle Beck and Gayle Mill, so this is not considered to be a significant constraint.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

This is a relatively large site within a small village and there is a risk that it could feel over-scaled. However, existing development in this part of Gayle is compact, relatively dense and at a distance from the principal gateway routes and views. It does not have a particularly distinctive character and there is an opportunity to enhance the existing built edge to the Gayle Lane housing estate.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site does not have any specific historic or cultural interest, but forms part of the network of roads and fields on the fringes of the village of Gayle. Garris is a back lane which connects the ‘West End’ part of the settlement to the historic core of Gayle village and evocative views across the site to the stone barn and walled pastures have a strong time-depth.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate

This site is relatively well contained by existing housing and, although development here would be prominent in local views from Garris, Mossy Lane and public rights of way to the west of Gayle, it would not dominate the principal gateways to the village or detract from the way this historic mill village is experienced. It would require the diversion of the Pennine Way. A large development could be integrated here if the layout incorporates stone wall boundaries and groups of native trees that ‘knit it’ into the surrounding field pattern.

Hawes

HAW 1 — Land rear of Woodburn, Burtersett Road, Hawes

Physical and natural character — Moderate

The landscape setting of this eastern part of Hawes is structured by the steep slopes and rounded summit of a long drumlin, which is between the A684/Burtersett Road (to the north) and Old Gayle Lane to the south, and by dramatic long views northwards across Wensleydale to the bare summits of Hearne Top and Abbotside Common. The site is a walled pasture on the lower slopes of this drumlin at a point where the slope is drained by a minor tributary beck, which meanders northwards across the site towards the road. The natural pattern of this small stony beck, defined by a scattered line of trees, provides a distinctive contrast within a landscape context that is structured by a regular network of walled fields. It is a focus in the framed views southwards (between adjacent buildings) from the road. Development would need to be set back from this beck and a layout designed to minimise cut and fill on the slightly undulating landform, which rises to the south.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate

This site contributes to the scenic landscape setting of Hawes at the eastern gateway to the settlement along the Burtersett Road/A684. The slightly more elevated slopes, to the south of the site, contribute to the stunning long views northwards across the undulating ‘barns and walled pastures’ landscape of Wensleydale; the views in all directions are enhanced by a dramatic backdrop of fell summits. However, in the immediate context along the A684, the view is to the linear corridor of built development that lines the road through the centre of Hawes. This is not a pristine, undeveloped gateway to Hawes; the site would be seen within the context of a mix of dwellings and commercial buildings. However, this built settlement context is balanced by the visibility of the eastern site boundary in gateway views from the road and by the gap between the buildings where the site meets the road. This gap provides a valuable break in the linear roadside strip of buildings, with a local view upslope to the fell slopes to the south.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

There are long views from the Burtersett Road/A684 across the site to the south west, framed by the slope of the local drumlin and with a backdrop of Dodd Fell and Sandy Hill. There are also scenic long views north westwards across Wensleydale from the well used (paved) public right of way which leads diagonally across the field to the north east of the site, connecting Old Gayle Lane and Burtersett Road/A684. The quality of these views could be eroded by built development on this site and it requires a sensitively designed scheme, which integrates buildings and native tree planting to create a soft, attractive interface between settlement and countryside, continuing and complementing the existing pattern of field boundaries to the east. The gap in the line of roadside built development, where the site meets the road offers a view along the minor tributary beck to the fell slopes to the south. This narrow framed view breaks the line of roadside development and provides a strong connection to the surrounding natural landscape. Built development on this site would fill this roadside gap and remove the opportunity for this natural visual and landscape connection.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

The existing settlement edge is relatively nondescript and this eastern gateway to Hawes is distinguished by its scenic views rather than its built form. The eastern edge of the site contributes to the rural character of the settlement and built development here could be integrated with tree planting. The small meandering beck is an evocative and distinctive landscape feature and the view southwards from the road along the beck forges a valuable connection to the physical natural landscape setting of Hawes.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site does not have any specific historic or cultural interest, but forms part of a wider rural landscape which is characterised by a lower fell farmland landscape with traditional stone barns, farm buildings and undulating walled fields.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate*

This is a sensitive site at one of the principal gateways to Hawes. It contributes to the scenic views of the landscape setting of the settlement, including views from the A684/Burtersett Road and a public footpath that connects Old Gayle Lane and Burtersett Road. The small meandering beck is also a locally valuable natural landscape feature which contrasts with the regular pattern of farmland and settlement. A development scheme that conserves the beck intact, avoids the more elevated slopes to the south and incorporates native tree planting to soften and integrate built edges could potentially be integrated within this site.

HAW 2 — Land west of cemetery and south of Burtersett Road, Hawes

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

The site is on the lower slopes of Mid Wensleydale on the southern margins of the River Ure floodplain. The local topography in this part of the dale is shaped by glacial drift deposits which have been moulded into smooth, undulating landforms and drumlins. The landscape setting of this eastern part of Hawes is structured by the steep slopes and rounded summit of a long drumlin, which is between the A684/Burtersett Road (to the north) and Old Gayle Lane to the south, and by dramatic long cross-dale views (both northwards and southwards). The site has an undulating landform with elevated land to the south and a rippling slope down towards the road. It comprises two fields, divided by walled field stone walls, which curve up and over the slope to express the local landform. Belts of mature trees along these north-south field boundaries divide and structure the land into well defined landscape units. Built development across this site would mask the natural ‘flow’ of the local landscape and disrupt the intact network of field stone walls and tree belts on the upper edge of the River Ure floodplain.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

This site defines the eastern gateway to Hawes along the Burtersett Road/A684. It is an exceptionally scenic approach, with stunning long views northwards and north-westwards across the undulating ‘barns and walled pastures’ landscape of Wensleydale. Straight ahead, along the A684, the view is to the linear corridor of built development that lines the road through the centre of Hawes, although the peaks and summits of the fells beyond are a visual backdrop, framed by the existing buildings. This is not a pristine, undeveloped gateway to Hawes; the site is between the cemetery and the settlement. However, it is a large site and development across it would extend the linear form of Hawes’ traditional settlement pattern further along the road corridor, particularly as perceived in the long cross dale views from the north. It would also erode the distinctive and dramatic quality of the local multi-layered views across the local drumlin landforms to the backdrop of the surrounding fells. The views that define this eastern gateway to Hawes are scenic but not unique within the settlement and a high quality, sensitively designed development that is confined to the western part of the site may offer opportunities for a permeable residential scheme that provides housing and open space away from the main road.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate-high

The site is at an exceptionally accessible gateway to Hawes, where the sequence of views across Wensleydale is enjoyed by very large numbers of people. It therefore has a role in conserving the special qualities of the YDNP, including the traditional pastoral landscape, expansive views and striking contrasts between sheltered dales and exposed fells. There are long views across the site to the south west, framed by the slope of the local drumlin and with a backdrop of Dodd Fell and Sandy Hill, and exceptionally scenic long cross dale views northwards across Wensleydale from the A684 and the well used (paved) public right of way which leads diagonally across the site and southwards from the lanes in the Sedbusk area. Development across this site risks an urbanising effect which would damage these valuable views.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate-high

The site spans two fields and the eastern of these seems distant from and unrelated to the principal settlement of Hawes. It is a large site and development on this scale would be perceived as a significant change. However, the existing built from on the eastern gateway to Hawes is a mix of house types and large scale commercial ‘barns’ and there may be scope for a positive frontage and built gateway on the western and less elevated part of the site, which integrates residential development with local landform, field patterns and views.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site does not have any specific historic or cultural interest, but forms part of a wider rural landscape which is characterised by a lower fell farmland landscape with traditional stone barns, farm buildings and undulating walled fields.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high*

This is a sensitive site at one of the principal gateways to Hawes. It contributes to the distinctive undulating topography and scenic views of the landscape setting of the settlement, including the long cross dale views from the Sedbusk area to the north and views from the A684/Burtersett Road and a public footpath between Old Gayle Lane and Burtersett Road. It is also a large site, where built development could easily seem over-scaled in relation to the linear roadside corridor form of the existing settlement (particularly in the long views from the north of Wensleydale). This is therefore a challenging site for built development from a landscape and visual perspective. It could be successfully integrated to create a positive new gateway to Hawes, but this requires a high quality scheme which conserves the eastern part of the site (adjacent to the cemetery) and the more elevated slopes to the south. The layout should incorporate native tree planting and indented built edges to form a soft interface with the drumlin slopes and frame views northwards from both the A684 and the public footpath across the site.

HAW 3 — Land east of Northgate House, Burtersett Road, Hawes

Physical and natural character — Moderate

The small site is on the lower slopes of Mid Wensleydale on the southern margins of the floodplain of the River Ure. The landscape setting of this eastern part of Hawes is structured by the steep slopes and rounded summit of a long drumlin, which is between the A684/Burtersett Road (to the north) and Old Gayle Lane to the south, and by dramatic long views northwards across Wensleydale to the bare summits of Hearne Top and Abbotside Common. The site is on the lower slopes of this drumlin, with a sweeping slope downwards towards the road. It is part of a walled pasture on the edge of the settlement and is alongside an existing group of roadside dwellings. The fields fronting the road are enclosed by low stone walls and (north-south aligned) belts of mature trees which divide and structure the land into well defined landscape units. Built development here would extend the existing settlement along the road; it would reduce the rural and scenic quality of the local landscape but would not change the overall structure and character of the existing landscape pattern.

Settlement form and setting — Low-moderate

This site defines the eastern gateway to Hawes along the Burtersett Road/A684. It is an exceptionally scenic approach, with stunning long views northwards and north-westwards across the undulating ‘barns and walled pastures’ landscape of Wensleydale. Straight ahead, along the A684, the view is to the linear corridor of built development that lines the road through the centre of Hawes. Built development on this site would extend the existing linear settlement form at one of the principal gateways to Hawes, eroding the quality of its landscape setting. However, this is not a pristine view; the existing development is a mix of houses and commercial buildings and the existing settlement edge has an abrupt character which could be enhanced. The views that define this eastern gateway to Hawes are scenic but not unique within the settlement and the characteristic long views between and to the south of the existing roadside buildings, to the peaks and summits of the fells beyond, could be conserved.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

The site is at an exceptionally accessible gateway to Hawes, where the sequence of views across Wensleydale are enjoyed by very large numbers of residents and visitors to the YDNP. There are long views from the Burtersett Road across the site to the south west, framed by the slope of the local drumlin and with a backdrop of Dodd Fell and Sandy Hill, and also scenic long views northwards across Wensleydale from the well used (paved) public right of way which leads diagonally across the field to the north of the site, connecting Old Gayle Lane and Burtersett Road/A684. The quality of these views could be eroded by built development on this site and it requires a sensitively designed scheme, which integrates buildings and native tree planting to create a soft, attractive interface between settlement and countryside, continuing and complementing the existing pattern of field boundaries to the east.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

The existing settlement edge is relatively nondescript and this eastern gateway to Hawes is distinguished by its scenic views rather than its built form. There is a strong, regular rhythm to the pattern of field stone walls, which curve up and over the drumlin landforms, along the sequence of gateway views travelling west along the A684 and development on this site could be integrated within this landscape and visual context because the site is small in relation to the scale of the surrounding landscape. Nevertheless, this is a sensitive landscape edge, which merits a carefully designed frontage to the road and ‘gateway elevation’ to the east.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site does not have any specific historic or cultural interest, but forms part of a wider rural landscape which is characterised by a lower fell farmland landscape with traditional stone barns, farm buildings and undulating walled fields.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate

This is a sensitive site at one of the principal gateways to Hawes. It contributes to the scenic views of the landscape setting of the settlement, including views from the A684/Burtersett Road and a public footpath that connects Old Gayle Lane and Burtersett Road. Built development here would continue the existing characteristic linear form of Hawes along the A684 and would fit within the wider landscape context without compromising the quality of the characteristic long views across Wensleydale. However, a sensitively designed settlement edge is required, with a positive built frontage to the A684 and a soft eastern ‘gateway elevation’ to the east, which incorporates native tree planting to complement the existing rhythmic pattern of field boundaries between the site and the cemetery to the east.

HAW 4 — Land off Kirkbrides Way and west of Gayle Lane, Hawes

Physical and natural character — Low-moderate

The site is on the lower slopes of Mid Wensleydale on the southern margins of the River Ure floodplain. The local topography in this part of the dale is shaped by glacial drift deposits which have been moulded into smooth, undulating landforms and drumlins. The site is on land to the west of a road which is aligned between two of these drumlins (‘Cross Rigg’ to the west and ‘Stony Haw’ to the east); it is on the lower eastern slopes of the drumlin known as Cross Haw and adjacent to a recent housing estate. The undulating landform on the site is its most distinctive natural characteristic. The site fits within the local large scale field pattern and is partially enclosed by field stone walls. There are no significant constraints to development and the existing (recently constructed) access road is already a dominant landscape feature and precedent for the development of the site.

Settlement form and setting — Low

The village of Hawes developed along the A684, with a network of public rights of way and back lanes connecting to the neighbouring mill village of Gayle to the south and to the River Ure to the north. Historic maps show that there were individual properties and clusters of cottages along some of the back lanes and, over the past 20 years, development along and off these lanes has increased the physical links between the two villages. However, the twin settlements remain separated by the undulating drumlin landforms that define their landscape setting. The site is part of an existing half-developed residential plot at Kirkbrides Way and its completion would be logical and appropriate within the context of Hawes. Development here would result in some loss of the rural character of Hawes’ landscape setting and would increase the perceived coalescence between the two settlements along Gayle Lane. However, Gayle Lane is already a core link between the two villages with a semi built-up character and completion of the existing residential development (Kirkbrides Way) would fit well within the mix of houses, commercial and tourism related development that is characteristic of this part of the village.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

Development on this site would be visible in views from the network of lanes and public rights of way to the west of Hawes, including Mossy Lane and the footpath over Cross Rigg to the west; the footpath which connects the YHA (on the B6255) with Gayle Lane along the field boundary to the west of the site; and the footpath that connects Gayle Lane and St Margaret’s Church (over Stony Haw) to the east of the site. However, the undulating landform would ensure that longer views are partially screened by the local topography and development here would form part of the existing characteristic mix of buildings, stone walls and undulating fields that is characteristic of the west Hawes neighbourhood. Development on this site would close down the existing attractive southward view to the slopes of Cross Rigg from Gayle Lane but this part of Gayle Lane is dominated by a mix of houses, a public car park, the local primary school and commercial premises associated with the Wensleydale Creamery. Development at Kirkbrides Way could be integrated within this context, but should be recognised that the village of Hawes (and its Creamery) is an important YDNP tourist destination and the site is highly visible from the village car park and Creamery Visitor Centre entrance and forms part of an important gateway recreational experience.

Perceptual qualities — Low

This part of Gayle Lane is already relatively built up and development on this site would be perceived as part of the existing Kirkbrides Way development. It would result in the loss of a rural view to the south west of Gayle Lane and it would increase the sense of coalescence between the settlements of Hawes and Gayle along Gayle Lane. However, the existing mix of development and views along this back lane ensures that there is a logical context for development in this location.

Cultural and historical associations — Low

The site does not have any specific historic or cultural interest, but forms part of the network of roads and fields on the fringes of the villages of Hawes and Gayle. Gayle Lane is a connecting route between the two villages which has been the location for clusters of development (residential, educational and commercial) over the past 20 years.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Low-moderate

Development on this site would be perceived as a logical completion of the existing Kirkbrides Way development and would be well integrated within the existing mix of buildings that front this northern part of Gayle Lane. Built development here would reduce the rural character of this western part of Hawes, but it could be integrated within the existing loose-knit character of the settlement in this area, which is structured by undulating drumlin landforms. However, this site is visible from Gayle Lane and multiple footpaths within and on the western fringes of Hawes and it would also be visible within the context of the arrival experience for visitors to the village of Hawes and the Wensleydale Creamery Visitor Centre so this is a relatively visible location within the wider context of the YDNP and merits a high quality architectural scheme.

Askrigg

IMAGE: Map showing the assessed sites ASK 1, ASK 2, ASK 3 and ASK 4 around Askrigg, including Leyburn Road, Station Road, Abbey Works and the former Carrs Billington depot.

ASK 1 — Land between Stoneybank and Garnon, Leyburn Road, Askrigg

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

The site is part of an open walled pasture on the north eastern fringes of Askrigg. The local topography on the northern slopes of Mid Wensleydale is strongly influenced by mounded glacial deposits and the site is on the lower slopes of one of these rounded mounds (‘Stony Bank’). The smooth, rolling landform, which rises quite steeply from the road, and the intact regular gridded pattern of field stone walls are the site’s distinctive and most sensitive landscape characteristics, which connect it to the rolling fields on the open fell slopes to the north of Askrigg. However, the site is bordered on three sides by a variety of houses, gardens and built land uses, including a car park, modern farm barn and a pumping station along Leyburn Road. The principal constraint is the relatively steep slope and there is a risk that proposals would require a layout that integrates vehicular access and parking alongside and at the level of the road, resulting in a suburban layout which would damage the distinctive relationship between village and drumlin landform.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

The village of Askrigg has a compact form, with the historic core of the settlement concentrated around the Market Place and along the Main Street, which curves as it climbs up between the rounded landforms on the dale slope. The site is on the periphery of the historic village and forms part of the gateway to Askrigg from the east. Leyburn Road is aligned along a flat route (close to Askrigg Beck) between two drumlin landforms. It has a prominent built frontage to the south, where traditional buildings line part of the road. However, the built form to the north of the road (including the site) has a more disjointed character, with a car park and modern housing (a block and individual houses) set back from the road. A development with a traditional built frontage to Leyburn Road could be successfully integrated here but, given the slope, a scheme with a flat roadside parking area and houses at a higher elevation to the rear is more likely and this type of ‘surburban’ layout would be damaging to Askrigg’s settlement character and form, particularly at an important gateway to the village.

Views and recreational experience — High

The upper slopes of the pasture containing this site are prominent in views from elevated public rights of way on the slopes of the drumlin landforms to the north and south of Leyburn Road. This rising land forms a scenic backdrop to views of the historic village and makes a strong contribution to its landscape setting. New built development on the lowest part of the site, directly alongside Leyburn Road, would sit relatively low in the landscape and could be integrated alongside the existing buildings. However, the slope of the land suggests that development here would be likely to require earthworks and infrastucture that would be damaging and intrusive in views from the public rights of way on the elevated drumlin slopes to the north and south.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate-high

This walled pasture, which extends right up to the road, contributes to the rural character of the eastern gateway to Askrigg and forms part of the landscape setting of the village. However, the quality of the local townscape is degraded by the adjacent (and prominent) suburban buildings and car park and the overall impression is of a fairly nondescript village gateway. There is a risk that another sizable development with parking alongside the road would create an extensive relatively suburban environment, further degrading Askrigg’s distinctive character and identity.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site is designated as part of the Askrigg Conservation Area because it is a component of the open farmland that forms a backdrop to views to and from Askrigg. At a broader scale, the walled pasture forms part of the historic network of drystone walls and barns that extends throughout Wensleydale.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high

Development on this gateway site could only be successfully integrated the layout provided a high quality built frontage to Leyburn Road, integrating parking infrastructure to the rear. However, this sensitivity score acknowledges that such a scenario is unlikely because the sloping landform would result in a scheme with vehicular access and parking alongside the road. This could not be integrated here without causing significant damage to Askrigg’s townscape and landscape setting at this important gateway to the settlement.

ASK 2 — Land at the former Carrs Billington depot, Station Road, Askrigg

Physical and natural character — Low

This brownfield site comprises two large industrial/commercial buildings and extensive hardstanding to the south of Askrigg’s historic village centre. The land slopes southwards and the shape of the site tapers towards the south where it adjoins the embankments of the former railway line and is close to the village’s sewage works. A surfaced public right of way/track runs along the eastern margin of the site. This industrial plot is separated from the adjacent houses to the east by a high stone wall and from farmland to the east by a lower boundary stone wall; the public right of way is inside these walls and is open to the site. The remaining site boundaries are unenclosed and the industrial buildings, parking and storage areas are open to view from Station Road to the north and the surrounding farmland to the west and south. There are no relevant landscape sensitivities and a residential development here would provide an opportunity to enhance the local townscape on a site that is close to the village centre.

Settlement form and setting — Low-moderate

This industrial site is just to the south of the historic village centre and its entrance, off Station Road, is to the south of one of the entrances to the graveyard adjoining St Oswald’s Church. It is also alongside one of the historic tracks (a public right of way) that connects Askrigg to the settlements and farmland on the south side of the River Ure. This is therefore a prominent, central brownfield area that offers an excellent opportunity for a new residential development with a built frontage that would contribute to the western gateway to the historic village from Station Road. However, development here would also be a component of Askrigg’s historic village centre and a high quality scheme would be essential in this sensitive townscape setting.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

This is a visually sensitive site. The existing industrial buildings are prominent in cross-dale views from the A684 and from public rights of way on the river floodplain meadows and the slopes of Addlebrough to the south. However, these buildings are a distracting influence, which do not contribute positively to these attractive views and new residential development here would offer opportunities for enhancement. These long views towards Askrigg from the south (and west), in which Askrigg’s built form ‘steps up’ the dale slopes, form a valuable component of its landscape setting and it is important that the layout, massing and design of new buildings proposed for this site are considered in relation to the wider massing of buildings within Askrigg’s historic village centre, and in particular in relation to the historic Church of St Oswald, which is the centre piece and focus of the views.

Perceptual qualities — Low

This industrial area is perceived as a relatively degraded environment, with large shed-like industrial buildings, areas of hard standing and extensive under-used space; it is visible from the village centre and from the farmland to the south of Askrigg. The public right of way along the side of the site connects it to the village centre and, although the industrial buildings seem over-scaled and unattractive in this village/pastoral farmland setting, the site does not seem unsafe. A high quality new residential development here could integrate this site within the wider village public realm, enhancing the experience of using public right of way and reinforcing the connections between Askrigg and its landscape setting.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site forms part of Askrigg’s designated Conservation Area and, given its prominence in the long cross-dale views to Askrigg from the south, it contributes to the landscape setting of the Church of St Oswald, a grade 1 listed building in the centre of the village. The public right of way along the eastern boundary of the site is part of a historic cross-dale route connecting Askrigg to a stepping stone crossing point over the River Ure to settlements and farmland on the southern side of Wensleydale. Development on this site would potentially enhance the historic landscape setting of the Church of St Oswald and could contribute positively to Askrigg’s Conservation Area.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Low-moderate

A new residential development on this industrial brownfield site would provide an opportunity to enhance a relatively degraded part of Askrigg’s townscape. However the site is close to the historic village centre and is a part of the designated conservation area which contributes to the Askrigg’s landscape setting and to the setting of the grade I listed church of St Oswald. A high quality scheme would therefore be required, with a layout, massing and design which complements and does not compete with the overall composition of buildings and landscape in the scenic cross-dale views to Askrigg.

Remaining assessment sites

The document continues with the same assessment structure for the following sites:

  • ASK 3 — Land between The Mew and former Carrs Billington depot, Station Road, Askrigg
  • ASK 4 — Land west of Abbey Works, Station Road, Askrigg
  • CAR 1 — Land west of the village hall, Carlton
  • CPY 1 — Land at East End Farm, Carperby
  • CPY 2 — Land between Manor Farm Cottages & The Old Stables, Carperby
  • CPY 3 — Land west of Hillgarth Cottage, Carperby
  • EWT 1 — Land north of Low Thorpe Farm, Lowthorpe, East Witton
  • NEW 1 — Land east of Millbeck Bridge, Newbiggin
  • NEW 2 — Land between Bishop Brook and Stone Flagged Cottage, Newbiggin
  • THO 1 — Land rear of Village Hall and The Grange, Thoralby
  • THO 2 — Land between Chapel Garth and Prospect House, Thoralby
  • WWT 1 — Land south of Coachman’s Loft, Grassgill Lane, West Witton
  • WWT 2 — Land between Wynbury Cottage and Chatsworth Cottage, West Witton

IMAGE: The remaining settlement maps identify the assessed housing sites with labelled coloured site boundaries. The maps cover Carlton, Carperby, East Witton, Newbiggin, Thoralby and West Witton, and show the relationship of each site to roads, fields, buildings, watercourses, woodland, public rights of way and surrounding landscape features.

IMAGE: The final page is a plain report back cover with the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority logo and no additional textual content.