Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Search for potential housing sites: landscape sensitivity study

Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority

Part 3

South Lakeland & Lancaster District

Eden District

Contents

  • Introduction — 3
  • Study scope and objectives — 3
  • Fit within the overall development allocation process — 3
  • Methodology — 4
  • Landscape sensitivity assessment — 4
  • Judging landscape sensitivity — 4
  • Summary landscape sensitivity scores — 8
  • Overall landscape sensitivity scores per settlement — 8
  • South Lakeland and Lancaster: Dentdale, Garsdale, Rawthey Valley & Lunesdale — 10
  • Local Service Centres: Sedbergh — 11
  • Large Villages: Barbon — 29
  • Large Villages: Casterton — 34
  • Large Villages: Dent — 39
  • Large Villages: Millthrop — 43
  • Eden: Mallerstang, Upper Lunesdale & Westmorland Dales — 47
  • Large Villages: Crosby Ravensworth — 48
  • Large Villages: Great Asby — 50
  • Large Villages: Maulds Meaburn — 53
  • Large Villages: Nateby — 55
  • Large Villages: Newbiggin on Lune — 58
  • Large Villages: Orton — 61
  • Large Villages: Ravenstonedale/Coldbeck — 63

Introduction

Study scope and objectives

The Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA) commissioned a landscape sensitivity assessment of potential sites for residential development to inform its preliminary ‘sift’ of possible development sites. The National Park designation recognises that the scenic beauty of the Yorkshire Dales is nationally important and the YDNPA therefore places emphasis on a landscape-led approach to the process of identifying suitable development sites. Landscape sensitivity assessment enables landscape considerations to be a key component of the balance of factors to be taken into account in making decisions about where new housing should be sited.

The 139 sites assessed during the sensitivity assessment were identified by YDNPA as suitable for preliminary consideration via:

  • 66 sites submitted by landowners through a ‘call for sites’ process; and
  • a further 73 sites identified by YDNPA on a speculative basis.

Some of the 139 sites (in both of the above categories) are the subject of an existing Local Plan designation, whether that be housing, employment or open space. The objective was to consider the widest possible range of sites at the preliminary stage. The report is split into three parts:

  • Part 1 - Sites within Craven District
  • Part 2 - Sites within Richmondshire
  • Part 3 - Sites within South Lakeland, Lancaster and Eden Districts.

Fit within the overall development allocation process

This report presents the results of the landscape sensitivity assessment. It is the first step in the sequential process of identifying possible sites for allocation in the Local Plan.

The National Park Authority will use its conclusions to inform an initial sift of the 139 sites being considered. Once the sites have been sifted, the residual number will be subjected to more rigorous assessment. This will factor in a range of other development constraints that were beyond the scope of the initial landscape sensitivity assessment, such as highways/access, archaeology, wildlife, trees and flood risk.

Further landscape analysis will also be undertaken in the form of a ‘whole settlement analysis’ of those settlements that could see the greatest development pressures. This will consider the wider landscape setting and townscape of these settlements and will take account of the potential housing development sites identified following the sifting process. It will be presented as a separate report, but will rely, in part, upon the work undertaken during this first phase of landscape sensitivity assessments.

Methodology

Landscape sensitivity assessment

Landscapes can be described and understood in terms of their physical characteristics, their land uses, their ecological habitats, their heritage and also by the way they make us feel. The combinations of these different landscape characteristics and qualities contribute to our perceptions of local identity and sense of place. An assessment of landscape sensitivity seeks to identify the aspects of landscape character that we value so that we can measure their resilience to change. It is typically undertaken when there is a need to judge the potential effects that could result from a defined type of change and this study has been commissioned to consider the sensitivity of a selection of specific sites in relation to residential development. It will be used by the YDNPA to understand the potential changes to the landscapes of the YDNP if development were to take place.

National guidance for landscape sensitivity assessment¹ explains that the process of sensitivity assessment requires an assessment of the susceptibility of landscape and visual character (the baseline) to a specific change (in this case residential development) in combination with an assessment of the values of the landscape and its visual characteristics.

The assessment provides a consistent, systematic score for the landscape and visual sensitivity of each of the assessed sites to residential development. It is a high level judgement which has been undertaken without detailed topographic data and which assumes a mix of residential development across the whole area of each site. It does not take account of the potential influence of design (ie. the layout and form of buildings and landscape) and assumes that the height and density of buildings would vary depending on whether the site has an urban or a rural context.

The landscape sensitivity assessment will guide and inform the YDNPA’s strategic allocation of sites for new housing in the YDNP by helping to direct development to areas where it would be least damaging to valued landscapes. In general, sites with a relatively low landscape sensitivity score can be expected to accommodate housing development without the loss of valued landscape characteristics whereas those with a relatively high landscape sensitivity score would not.

The landscape sensitivity scores for each site can contribute to this decision-making process and identify opportunities and constraints for development, but they do not provide a direct judgement of suitability for development. This is because there are many other factors to consider including socio-economic benefits, vehicular access, drainage, provision of utilities (electricity, water, gas, sewerage) and archaeological or heritage constraints. It is also because the assessment does not take account of the influence of design and management, which may in some locations enable successful housing development in sites which are assessed as having relatively high landscape and visual sensitivity.

The study has been undertaken in two stages. The first stage (Dec 2021-March 2022) was a desk-top exercise which made reference to Ordnance Survey base mapping, aerial photography (Google Earth), the YDNP Landscape Character Assessment, historic maps, biodiversity and heritage designations and mapping of heritage assets provided by YDNPA. It was also informed by a selection of site photographs supplied by YDNPA. The first stage assessment was tested through fieldwork during June-July 2022, which led to some adjustment of the landscape sensitivity scores.

Judging landscape sensitivity

The criteria selected for judging landscape sensitivity are based on the attributes of landscape that are most likely to be affected by residential development. They take account of both ‘landscape’ and visual’ characteristics and aspects of landscape value, including the special qualities of the YDNP. The five landscape sensitivity criteria are set out in Table 2 (page 6). For each criterion Table 2 also identifies indicators of relative susceptibility to the changes associated with residential development by describing how the landscape, visual, and value related criteria may be affected to a greater or lesser extent by the key attributes of residential development.

Using the criteria and susceptibility indicators in Table 2 as a constant reference, the landscape sensitivity of each site to residential development was assessed against each criterion on a five point scale (as shown in Table 1). The sensitivity scores reflect the degree to which the landscape of each site would be susceptible to change. An overall sensitivity judgement is also included, recognising that some attributes or elements of the landscape may be more important in defining character than others and may be more sensitive.

Table 1 – Criteria for judging landscape and visual sensitivity

SensitivityDefinition
HighResidential development would be very likely to give rise to significant adverse landscape and/or visual effects.
Moderate-highResidential development would be very likely to give rise to adverse landscape and/or visual effects, and there is some potential for these to be significant.
ModerateResidential development would be likely to give rise to some adverse landscape and/or visual effects, but these may be limited in extent.
Low-ModerateResidential development may give rise to some minor adverse landscape and/or visual effects, but these would be unlikely to be significant.
LowResidential development would be very unlikely to give rise to significant adverse landscape and/or visual effects.

It is important to note that the criteria for judging landscape and visual sensitivity set out in Table 1 are on a relative scale which is applied within the context of a national park landscape that is inherently highly sensitive to development.

The judgement is based on transparent professional analysis rather than a mechanical process of addition. This enables the assessment to highlight any particularly sensitive landscape features or qualities, and factors that would need to be taken into account should the site be developed.

This is a high level assessment and the overall landscape sensitivity scores apply to the whole of the site that has been submitted for assessment. However, it does take some account of the scope to mitigate potential adverse landscape and visual impacts of development, as follows:

  • Where relevant, the narrative within the assessment tables incorporates advice on how the design and/or layout of development schemes could mitigate potential adverse landscape and visual impacts and the sensitivity scores take account of this mitigation potential.
  • The overall landscape sensitivity scores for some sites are marked with an asterisk* to indicate that a carefully designed layout that focuses built development on part of the site would reduce the risk of adverse landscape and visual effects and would reduce the overall sensitivity score (which is based on the whole site assessment).

Maps are indicative. Please note that there is a discrepancy between the mapping of the potential housing sites and the OS base because the site boundaries were digitised at a more detailed scale.

¹ An approach to landscape sensitivity assessment - to inform spatial planning and land management, June 2019, Christine Tudor, Natural England

Summary landscape sensitivity scores

Overall landscape sensitivity scores per settlement

The table below provides a quick reference summary of the overall sensitivity scores for each of the assessed settlements within the districts of South Lakeland & Lancaster and Eden.

Note that these scores are based on the Stage 1 desk-based assessment part of the study and are subject to review when the judgements are tested on site during the stage 2 field survey part of the work.

District / Sub areaSettlementREF.Overall landscape sensitivity
South Lakeland & Lancaster — Dentdale, Garsdale, Rawthey Valley & Lunesdale — Local Service CentresSedberghSED 1Moderate
SED 2Moderate-high*
SED 3Moderate-high
SED 4Low-moderate
SED 5Moderate-high
SED 6Moderate
SED 7Low-moderate*
SED 8Moderate-high*
SED 9Low-moderate
SED 10Moderate-High
SED 11Low
SED 12Moderate
SED 13High
SED 14Moderate*
SED 15Moderate*
SED 16Moderate-high*
SED 17Moderate
South Lakeland & Lancaster — Dentdale, Garsdale, Rawthey Valley & Lunesdale — Large VillagesBarbonBAR 1Moderate*
BAR 2Low-moderate
BAR 3Moderate-high*
BAR 4Moderate-high*
CastertonCAS 1Moderate-high
CAS 2Moderate-high*
CAS 3Moderate
CAS 4Moderate-high*
DentDEN 1Moderate-high*
DEN 2Moderate-high*
DEN 3Moderate-high
MillthropMIL 1Moderate-high
MIL 2High*
MIL 3Moderate-high*
Eden — Mallerstang, Upper Lunesdale & Westmorland Dales — Large VillagesCrosby RavensworthCRV 1Moderate-high*
Great AsbyGAS 1High
GAS 2Moderate-high*
Maulds MeaburnMME 1Moderate
NatebyNAT 1Moderate-high
NAT 2Moderate
Newbiggin on LuneNLU 1Low-moderate
NLU 2Low
OrtonORT 1Moderate-high*
Ravenstonedale/ColdbeckRAV 1Moderate

South Lakeland & Lancaster District

Landscape Sensitivity Assessment

Dentdale, Garsdale, Rawthey Valley & Lunesdale

Local Service Centres
Sedbergh
Location of assessed sites

IMAGE: A map of Sedbergh showing the locations of assessed sites SED 1 through SED 17. The sites are marked around the town, with “New build” shown between SED 3 and SED 15.

Possible site allocations identified via ‘Call for Sites’Possible site allocations identified by YDNPA
SED 1 — Land south of car park, Loftus HillSED 11 — Land east of Vicarage Lane
SED 2 — Land south of Station Road and east of Busk LaneSED 12 — Land south of Tollbar Workshops, Station Road
SED 3 — Land north of Tollbar Workshops, Station RoadSED 13 — Land south of A683 at Borrett Tollbar
SED 4 — Land at the former Bailiol School, Cautley RoadSED 14 — Land south of PFS, Station Road
SED 5 — Land west of Vicarage LaneSED 15 — Land north of Queen’s Drive, Station Road
SED 6 — Land at Birksholme, Birks LaneSED 16 — Land west of Sycamore Avenue
SED 7 — Land at Guldrey Workshop, Station Road
SED 8 — Land between Robertson House and Winder House
SED 9 — Land at King’s Yard, Bainbridge Road
SED 10 — Land rear of Guldrey Terrace
SED 17 — Land adjacent to Mountain View

SED 1 — Land south of car park, Loftus Hill, Sedbergh

Physical and natural character — Low-moderate

This brownfield site comprises two adjacent plots, each with an existing single storey building. The land and buildings are part of the Sedbergh School complex but the existing buildings are nondescript and do not make a positive contribution to the local townscape. The site is widely visible and has an important role in framing local views at the threshold to the historic town centre (see below). There is an opportunity for high quality built development with a dense urban form, which creates a positive frontage to Loftus Hill (road) and attractive elevations to the north (facing the Loftus Hill Car Park) and east (overlooking the school playing field).

Settlement form and setting — Low-moderate

The site is an important location just south of the historic town centre and at the gateway to the Loftus Hill neighbourhood, which forms the core of the Sedbergh School buildings. The linear band of development along Loftus Hill connects the historic town centre with the school, aligned directly up and over the summit of the drumlin to the south of the historic town centre and connecting Sedbergh with the mill village of Millthrop to the south east of the town. The site is on the relatively flat land just before the road rises to cross the drumlin and is right at the cusp of the transition between the historic town centre to the north and the school parkland to the south. It is an important site within the local townscape and there is an opportunity for a sensitively designed built form which reflects the local vernacular in terms of architectural form and building materials.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

The buildings and mature trees fronting Loftus Hill frame views across the valley - northwards to Winder Fell and southwards to the Frostrow Fells. The spire of Sedbergh School Chapel (to the south) and the facade of the former Sedbergh Grammar School (to the north) are important focal points and landmarks within these views. Given their low (single storey) form and set back from the road, the existing buildings on the site do not contribute positively to these views but nor do they detract; the car park to the north of the site means that the northern facade of the built development in this location would be prominent in views southwards from the town centre along Loftus Hill. It is therefore critically important that new development on this site is designed to complement the views along and to Loftus Hill.

In addition, the site has an important role in supporting Sedbergh’s local tourist economy because it is adjacent to one of the town’s most accessible central car parks; the north facade of development on the site would overlook the car park and so would be prominent within the arrival experience for visitors to the town.

Perceptual qualities — Low-moderate

The site reads as a slight ‘lull’ in the densely built-up form of the town centre. This is because it is surrounded on two sides by open playing fields and on one side by a car park and because it is at the threshold between the historic town centre and the school parkland landscapes. Housing development on this site would be widely visible and a sensitively designed built form is critically important.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site is part of the Sedbergh Conservation Area and is a highly visible and accessible location within Sedbergh’s townscape. It also contributes to the historic setting of the former Grammar School, a Grade II* listed building which is now the library for Sedbergh school.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate

This brownfield town centre site is at an important location within Sedbergh’s townscape. Its northern and western elevations are prominent in views northwards and southwards along Loftus Road and the eastern elevation is visible in views south westwards from Back Lane. It is also at a car park gateway to the town. However, the existing buildings are relatively nondescript and there is an opportunity for a sensitively designed housing development that complements the local townscape. It should create a positive frontage to Loftus Hill and particularly the facade of the listed former Grammar School building to the north.

SED 2 — Land south of Station Road and east of Busk Lane, Sedbergh

Physical and natural character — Moderate-high

Site has a complex local topography, with smooth (drumlin-type) slopes rising directly from Busk Lane to the south and south west. There are also groups of mature trees which make an important contribution to local landscape and townscape character, including the double line of mature trees along the northern part of Busk Lane (close to its junction with Station Road) and the large group of mature trees in the centre of the site, which shelter and screen the existing buildings adjacent and to the south east of the site. It is particularly important that the integrity of the egg-shaped drumlin landform is conserved and retained intact, as a prominent local landscape feature, which contributes to the distinctive identity of Sedbergh. However, the northern/central part of the site (currently a formal sports pitch) has good potential for development fronting Station Road and (set-back behind the stands of mature trees) Busk Lane.

Settlement form and setting — Moderate-high

The site is at the western gateway to the historic town centre (and Sedbergh’s Conservation Area). It is a sensitive location which demands an architectural facade that is carefully integrated with the surrounding townscape and historic settlement pattern. The latter has been shaped by the undulating glacial landforms that define this part of Sedbergh; it is characterised by tight groups of dense built development interspersed with undulating open greenspaces, which often have a textured ‘rough’ character that contrasts with the formal built terraces and courtyards. There is an opportunity for development here that continues and interprets this historic settlement form, fronting Station Road, set-back behind the mature trees along the north part of Busk Lane and overlooking the Rawthey Valley to the south. However, the slopes of the drumlin landform to the south of the site should be retained as informal grassland and woodland as development here would require an engineered, artificial landform that would not be appropriate within Sedbergh’s distinctive and historic settlement form.

Views and recreational experience — Moderate

The site is prominent in views along Station Road and Busk Lane. There are no long views across the Rawthey Valley to the south and a high quality built frontage onto Station Road would potentially enhance local views at an important gateway to the historic town. However the existing views to the grass slopes of the drumlin landform from Busk Lane in the southern part of the site should be conserved. Filtered views through the existing mature trees to new development from the northern part of Busk Lane (to the west of the site) would be appropriate within the local townscape.

Perceptual qualities — Moderate

The northern part of the site, fronting Station Road, seems fairly nondescript within the overall townscape as the artificial character of the grass tennis courts is perceived as a quiet ‘green gap’ within a neighbourhood that is dominated by trees and gardens. The houses on the north side of Station Road are relatively low and the townscape here seems one-sided, with houses and walled gardens facing the groups of larger buildings, mature trees and open spaces within the extensive grounds of Sedbergh School. By contrast, the meadow on the drumlin slopes and mature trees in the southern part of the site are perceived as part of the Rawthey Valley and the Sedbergh school grounds that drop away to the south of the town and which have a textured, parkland character. This part of the site should be conserved.

Cultural and historical associations — Moderate

The site is designated as part of Sedbergh’s Conservation Area and forms part of the landscape setting of the historic town. However there are no listed buildings or notable heritage features on or adjacent to the site. The existing mature trees and the natural sweep of the drumlin landform, which has been a significant constraint for built development over the past 200 years, contribute to the sense of time-depth.

Overall landscape sensitivity - residential development — Moderate-high*

There is wide variation in the sensitivity of this extensive town centre. Built development on the northern part of the site (the sports pitch and the flatter area fronting the junction end of Busk Lane) could contribute positively to Sedbergh’s townscape although it is important that the double stand of mature trees along Busk Lane in the north west part of the site is conserved, with development set back behind these trees. However, the southern part of the site, which is dominated by the drumlin landform, should remain undeveloped; the steep drumlin slopes to the south of the site should be carefully conserved, along with the groups of mature trees within the centre of the site.

Image descriptions

IMAGE: Cover page for the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority report “Search for potential housing sites: landscape sensitivity study”, Part 3, covering South Lakeland & Lancaster District and Eden District.

IMAGE: Table showing the five landscape sensitivity levels from High to Low and their definitions.

IMAGE: Landscape and visual sensitivity criteria diagrams for physical and natural character, settlement form and setting, views and recreational experience, perceptual qualities, and cultural and historical associations.

IMAGE: Summary table of overall landscape sensitivity scores for assessed settlements in South Lakeland & Lancaster and Eden.

IMAGE: Map of Sedbergh showing the locations of assessed sites SED 1 to SED 17, with a table listing the site names and references.

IMAGE: Site-location map and assessment table for SED 1, Land south of car park, Loftus Hill, Sedbergh.

IMAGE: Site-location map and assessment table for SED 2, Land south of Station Road and east of Busk Lane, Sedbergh.