Skip to main content

Please be aware the content below has been generated by an AI model from a source PDF (opens in new tab) .

Report to Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority

By Malcolm Rivett BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI

an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State

Date: 11th June 2026

Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 (as amended) and as applied by the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 (Commencement No. 11 and Saving and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2026

Report on the Examination of the Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40

The plan was submitted for examination on 20 August 2025.

The examination hearing sessions were held between 3 and 11 December 2025.

File Ref: PINS/C9499/429/4

Contents

  • Abbreviations used in this report
  • Non-Technical Summary
  • Introduction
  • Context of the plan
  • Public Sector Equality Duty and National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act
  • Assessment of Legal Compliance
  • Assessment of Soundness
  • Issue 1 – Whether the plan's housing target, settlement hierarchy and spatial strategy are positively prepared, justified and consistent with national policy
  • Issue 2 – Whether the housing site allocation selection process is robust and whether the plan is justified and effective in respect of the housing site allocations, the housing development boundaries and the likely supply of housing
  • Issue 3 – Whether the plan's Core policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy
  • Issue 4 – Whether the plan's Community policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy
  • Issue 5 – Whether the plan's Economy site allocations and policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy
  • Issue 6 – Whether the plan's policies in respect of Infrastructure, Access/Connectivity and Archaeology/Built Heritage are positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy
  • Issue 7 – Whether the plan's policies in respect of Landscape and Natural Environment are justified, effective and consistent with national policy
  • Overall Conclusion and Recommendation
  • Schedule of Main Modifications

Abbreviations used in this report

AbbreviationMeaning
dpaDwellings Per Annum
MMMain Modification
NPPFNational Planning Policy Framework
PPGPlanning Practice Guidance
SASustainability Appraisal
1949 ActNational Parks and Access to the Countryside Act (1949)
2004 ActPlanning and Compulsory Purchase Act (2004)

Non-Technical Summary

This report concludes that the Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40 provides an appropriate basis for the planning of the National Park provided that a number of main modifications (MMs) are made to it. The Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority has specifically requested that I recommend any MMs necessary to enable the plan to be adopted.

Following the hearing sessions, the Authority prepared a schedule of the proposed modifications and, where necessary, carried out sustainability appraisal and habitats regulations assessment of them. The MMs were subject to public consultation over a six-week period. In some cases I have amended their detailed wording and/or added consequential modifications where necessary. I have recommended their inclusion in the plan after considering the sustainability appraisal and habitats regulations assessment and all the representations made in response to consultation on them.

The Main Modifications can be summarised as follows:

  • Changing the Baliol School, Sedbergh site to an allocation for housing, instead of employment development which is unlikely to be deliverable;
  • Removing from the plan the housing allocations at The Warehouse, Newbiggin-on-Lune and Ashfield Court, Orton because of flood risk;
  • Including in Appendix 4 of the plan a number of specific requirements in respect of development of the Baliol School, Sedbergh and Threshfield housing site allocations;
  • A range of other modifications to ensure that the plan is positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Introduction

  1. This report contains my assessment of the Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40 in terms of Section 20(5) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 (as amended) and as applied by Regulation 4 and paragraph 2 schedule 1 of the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 (Commencement No. 11 and Saving and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2026. It considers whether the plan is compliant with the relevant legal requirements (including in terms of the Town and Country Planning (Local Planning) (England) Regulations 2012, also as applied by Regulation 4 and paragraph 2 schedule 1 of the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 (Commencement No. 11 and Saving and Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2026) and whether it is sound.

  2. The National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) 2024 (paragraph 36), to which I have had regard, advises that in order to be sound, a local plan should be positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

  3. The starting point for the examination is the assumption that the local planning authority has submitted what it considers to be a sound plan. The Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40 (Submission) submitted in August 2025 is the basis for my examination. It is the same document that was published for consultation in March 2025.

Main Modifications

  1. In accordance with section 20(7C) of the 2004 Act, the Authority has requested that I should recommend any main modifications (MMs) necessary to rectify matters that make the plan unsound and/or not legally compliant and thus incapable of being adopted. My report explains why the recommended MMs are necessary. The MMs are referenced in bold in the report in the form MM1, MM2 etc, and are set out in full in the Appendix.

  2. Following the examination hearing sessions, the Authority prepared a schedule of proposed MMs and, where necessary, carried out sustainability appraisal and habitats regulations assessment of them. The MM schedule was subject to public consultation for six weeks. I have taken account of the consultation responses in coming to my conclusions in this report and in this light I have made some amendments to the detailed wording of the main modifications and added consequential modifications where these are necessary for consistency or clarity. None of the amendments significantly alters the content of the modifications as published for consultation or undermines the participatory processes and sustainability appraisal/habitats regulations assessment that has been undertaken. Where necessary I have highlighted these amendments in the report.

Policies Map

  1. The Authority must maintain an adopted policies map which illustrates geographically the application of the policies in the adopted development plan. When submitting a local plan for examination, the Authority is required to provide a submission policies map showing the changes to the adopted policies map that would result from the proposals in the submitted local plan. In this case, the submission policies map comprises the set of plans at 2025 - Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40, Policies Maps - Yorkshire Dales National Park : Yorkshire Dales National Park which includes 53 Ecological Network Maps (A1 – K6), 53 Overview Maps (A1 - K6) and around 120 small area inset maps.

  2. The policies map is not defined in statute as a development plan document and so I do not have the power to recommend main modifications to it. However, a number of the published MMs to the plan’s policies require further corresponding changes to be made to the policies map. In addition, there are some instances where the geographic illustration of policies on the submission policies map is not justified and changes to the policies map are needed to ensure that the relevant policies are justified and effective. These further changes to the policies map were published for consultation alongside the MMs.

  3. When the plan is adopted, in order to comply with the legislation and give effect to the plan’s policies, the Authority will need to update the adopted policies map to include all the changes proposed in 2025 - Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40, Policies Maps - Yorkshire Dales National Park : Yorkshire Dales National Park and Policies-map-changes-schedule.pdf

Context of the Plan

  1. The submitted plan is intended to replace in its entirety the Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2015-2030 and policies of various development plans for Eden, South Lakeland, Lancaster, Lancashire and Cumbria insofar as they relate to the Yorkshire Dales National Park.

  2. The National Park was designated in 1954 in recognition of its extraordinary natural beauty, the diversity of its wildlife habitats, its cultural heritage and its opportunities for outdoor recreation. The boundary of the Park was extended in 2016 and this local plan is the first to cover the extended Park as a whole. The area is deeply rural, generally comprising remote moors and sheltered valleys, with a population of less than 23,000 living across a very extensive expanse of North Yorkshire, Westmorland and Furness and, in small part, Lancaster. The most populous settlement is Sedbergh with a parish population of around only 2,800 residents.

Public Sector Equality Duty and National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act, 1949

  1. I have had due regard to the aims expressed in S149(1) of the Equality Act 2010. This has included my consideration of several matters during the examination including homes for the elderly and vulnerable and gypsies and travellers.

  2. In examining the plan, and as required by S11A(1)A of the National Parks and Access to the Countryside Act (1949), I have sought to further the purposes of (a) conserving and enhancing the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the Yorkshire Dales National Park and (b) of promoting opportunities for the understanding and enjoyment by the public of its special qualities. Moreover, where it has appeared to me that there is conflict between these purposes, I have attached greater weight to the purpose of conserving and enhancing the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the area.

Assessment of Legal Compliance

  1. The plan has been prepared in accordance with the Authority’s Local Development Scheme of December 2024.

  2. Consultation on the plan and the MMs was carried out in compliance with the Authority’s Statement of Community Involvement. Whilst it did not necessarily respond individually to everybody who submitted a consultation response, this is not evidence of the Authority ignoring consultation comments; and not agreeing with a comment (and thus not changing the plan in accordance with the comment) is not synonymous with ignoring it.

  3. At key stages in the preparation of the plan the Authority carried out a sustainability appraisal (SA), prepared reports of the findings of the appraisal, and published these reports along with the plan and other submission documents under regulation 19. The appraisal was updated to assess the main modifications.

  4. It has been argued that the SA is deficient in not appraising a revision to the strategy for meeting housing needs between the Preferred Options and Submission stages of the plan. Whilst page 7 of Consultation No 5 stated the housing requirement was “to be met primarily on newly allocated housing sites (to be determined)” this was simply a brief summary of the relevant policy at that stage in plan preparation (CP9, as set out on page 19 of the same document). This stated “The majority of this target [ie the housing target of 50 dwellings per annum] will be met through the development of allocated sites on the edge of towns and larger villages (to be determined) and through the completion of sites with existing planning consent”. This policy was renumbered CP3 in the submission plan and states “Most of this target will be met through the development of allocated sites on the edge of Local Service Centres and large villages (in Table 1) and through the completion of sites with existing planning permission.”

  5. Consequently, bearing in mind that the “towns” identified at Preferred Options stage were simply retitled “Local Service Centres” in the submission plan, and that completion of sites with existing planning permission was referenced at both stages, there was no change in the strategy for delivering the housing target. Moreover, it was not ever suggested that the strategy would involve the allocation of sites at all larger villages. Thus, that the submission plan does not include housing site allocations at Embsay when it did at an earlier stage in the plan preparation process is also not evidence of a change in the strategy for meeting housing needs. Therefore, I conclude that there is no deficiency in the SA in this respect.

  6. I also consider that it is not a material failing of the SA to have appraised options for the housing target of 50 and 70 dwellings per annum (dpa), but not the 55 dpa which is the housing target of the extant Local Plan: at the strategic level at which the SA is appropriately undertaken, it is highly unlikely that any difference between the sustainability effects of 50 and 55 dpa would have been identified. Overall, I am satisfied that the SA provides an appropriate basis to inform my determination of whether or not the plan is sound.

  7. The Yorkshire Dales Local Plan: Habitats Regulations Assessment (October 2024 and July 2025) and Addendum of March 2026 undertook an Appropriate Assessment but went on to identify that, subject to mitigation measures which have been secured through the plan as proposed to be modified, there are no likely significant effects.

  8. The plan includes policies to address the strategic priorities for the development and use of land in the local planning authority’s area, these priorities being detailed in paragraph 3.3 of the plan.

  9. The plan includes policies designed to secure that the development and use of land in the local planning authority’s area contribute to the mitigation of, and adaptation to, climate change. These include policies which seek to reduce the need to travel and to minimise the impacts of flooding.

  10. The plan complies with all other relevant legal requirements, including in the 2004 Act (as amended) and the 2012 Regulations, subject to MM46 which is necessary to clarify in Appendix 2 of the plan that the listed existing development plan documents will be replaced only insofar as they apply in the Yorkshire Dales National Park.

Assessment of Soundness

Main Issues

  1. Taking account of all the representations, the written evidence and the discussions that took place at the examination hearing sessions, I have identified seven main issues upon which the soundness of this plan depends. This report deals with these main issues. It does not respond to every point, issue, site or boundary raised by representors. Nor does it refer to every policy, policy criterion or allocation in the plan.

Issue 1 – Whether the plan’s housing target, settlement hierarchy and spatial strategy are positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy

Housing Target

  1. NPPF advises that to determine the minimum number of homes needed, local plan strategic policies should be informed by a local housing need assessment, conducted using the standard method in national Planning Practice Guidance (PPG). However, PPG states that where strategic policy-making authorities do not align with local authority boundaries, such as in National Parks, an alternative approach may have to be used. It goes on to identify that such authorities may continue to identify a housing need figure using a method determined locally, but that in doing so authorities should take into consideration the best available evidence on the amount of existing housing stock within their planning authority boundary, local house prices, earnings and housing affordability [PPG, Paragraph: 014 Reference ID: 2a-014-20241212].

  2. NPPF also makes clear that “great weight should be given to conserving and enhancing landscape and scenic beauty in National Parks……. which have the highest status of protection in relation to these issues” and that “The scale and extent of development within all these designated areas should be limited.” Moreover, as detailed above, there is a statutory duty on me, under the 1949 Act, to seek to further the purposes of conserving and enhancing the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the Yorkshire Dales National Park.

  3. Policy CP3 of the plan identifies an average target of 50 new dpa over the 2025–2040 plan period. This is informed by the 2024 Strategic Housing Market Assessment which, as an alternative approach to the standard method indicated by the NPPF, credibly concludes that this level of new housing provision would be likely to assist in reversing the projected decline in population in the National Park, resulting from out migration and a low birth rate in the period 2001 to 2021. Moreover, by enabling the delivery of a significant number of affordable homes, this target would be likely to attract and retain younger households, thereby helping to slow the trend towards a disproportionately aged population in the Park.

  4. It is the case that in contrast to earlier iterations of the document, the 2024 update of the Housing Market Assessment identifies that the population is likely to remain broadly stable to 2040. However, I agree with the Authority that this is likely to be the result of the extant local plan’s success in delivering new housing in recent years and that a housing target for the period to 2040 of materially less than 50 dwellings per year would be likely to reverse the progress made to date in stabilising the population.

  5. The extant plan has a slightly higher target of 55 dpa and covers a smaller area/population, the National Park boundary having been since expanded by around a quarter in area and population in 2016. Moreover, although a standard method housing need figure has not been published for the National Park, an estimate of this figure of 175 dpa has been calculated. In accordance with the PPG this is an appropriate consideration in determining the housing need figure for the Park. As detailed in Issue 4 below, it is also the case that there is an identified annual need for around 157 affordable homes.

  6. However, having reviewed the approach by which the Authority selected and rejected potential sites for housing, and subject to the modifications which I conclude are necessary (as detailed in Issue 2), I am satisfied that all those available sites which would not have unacceptable impacts have been allocated in the plan. On this basis, it would not be feasible to deliver an average of 175 new dwellings a year without significantly compromising the conservation and enhancement of the Park’s landscape and scenic beauty, contrary to the 1949 Act. Furthermore I conclude that such a level of new housing development would not be limited in scale and extent as required by the NPPF. On this basis the 50 dpa target figure for new housing is justified.

  7. It has been cogently argued that, given the overall size and internal transport limitations of the Park, the provision of new housing in one part of the plan area may not meet the needs of people living, or wanting to live in another area – eg between Wharfedale and Wensleydale and even between Wharfedale and Malhamdale. The National Park is not unique in this respect, although I accept it may be a more dominant feature here than it is in many local plan areas.

  8. In theory this could support the case for a separate housing target figure to be produced for each part of the National Park albeit, other than the standard method (which would be a share for each part of the park of the total 175 dpa figure set out above), it is not clear on what justifiable basis such figures could be produced. I consider that it would not be appropriate to disaggregate the minimum 50 dpa target figure of the submitted plan into maximum target figures for each part of the plan area. This is because the 50 dpa target is based on the legitimate aim of reversing population decline across the National Park as a whole whilst ensuring that the Park is conserved and enhanced. If the single target figure for the plan area reverses population decline but results in a greater increase in population in some parts of the Park than others, then as long as the new housing conserves/enhances the National Park this approach is a justified one. In contrast, and as detailed below as part of my consideration of the plan’s Spatial Strategy, a maximum target figure for each part of the local plan area would be likely to run the risk of not achieving the aim of reversing the decline in population across the Park as a whole.

  9. The new homes built in the National Park will contribute towards meeting the housing needs, as determined by the standard method, of the local authorities which are constituent parts of the Park – North Yorkshire, Westmorland and Furness and, to a small degree, Lancaster City.

  10. Taking account of existing planning permissions, the plan’s housing allocations and ‘windfall’ housing development (including within expanded housing development boundaries as proposed in the plan), it is likely that an average of around 70 dpa can and will be delivered. I consider this would remain limited in scale and extent, in line with national policy. In recognition of this, MM2 is necessary to make clear in policy CP3 that the 50 dwellings per year target is a minimum figure. However, given the fundamental importance of ensuring that great weight is given to conserving and enhancing the Park’s landscape and scenic beauty and the threat to that which inappropriate housing development could cause, it would not be appropriate to set the plan’s formal housing target figure higher than 50 dwellings per year. Moreover, for the plan to be justified it is necessary for MM2 to make clear in the supporting text that the minimum housing target figure is not an unending requirement and that policies throughout the plan guard against a level of housing growth which would significantly conflict with National Park purposes.

Settlement Hierarchy and Spatial Strategy

  1. Paragraph 4.19 of the plan makes clear that the majority of new development is to be located within or on the edge of the towns and villages within the Park where most of the area’s services and facilities are located and where new development can help support those services and facilities. This approach is eminently sensible and accords with the NPPF’s statement (paragraph 11) that plans should promote a sustainable pattern of development. Table 1 of the plan sets out a detailed hierarchy of settlements: local service centres (in effect the towns), large villages and small settlements. This hierarchy has its origins in the 1990s, but has been subject to comprehensive review as part of the preparation of this plan, including taking account of the Park’s recently expanded boundaries. The Authority’s Matter 2 statement details the methodology employed which, to my mind, was robust and thorough. Whilst there will always be debate as to the appropriate categorisation of some “borderline” settlements, I conclude that the hierarchy set out in Table 2 is justified.

  2. As detailed above, the supply of developable sites for housing across the plan period is around 70 dpa – 1,106 new homes in total. Of this around 73% are forecast to be built on new sites allocated in the plan or on ‘windfall’ sites, many of which are anticipated to take place on land newly included, through the plan, in the housing development boundaries of a number of settlements. In terms of the plan’s housing site allocations as proposed to be modified, it is the case that these are not proportionally distributed across the National Park in line with the existing population of the towns and villages. There is proportionally significantly more housing development proposed on new site allocations in the south of the Park than in the north. Moreover, within the southern part of the Park, a large proportion of housing on the site allocations is proposed in Threshfield, whilst none is proposed in Embsay.

  3. As proposed to be modified around 83% of housing on new site allocations would be within or adjoining towns or service centres. I consider this proportion to be appropriate, bearing in mind the services the towns offer and that a much larger proportion of ‘windfall’ housing developments is likely to take place in the villages and small settlements, particularly where the plan proposes expansion of the housing development boundaries.

  4. However, it is the case that some of the local service centres have more constraints to new housing development than others: development at Reeth and Hawes is limited by river floodplains, whilst there are conservation areas at Gayle, Grassington, Reeth, Sedbergh and Settle. Several local service centres also have steep topography. In contrast, Threshfield does not have these constraints.

  5. The Authority has indicated that it would have liked to have been able to allocate more housing site allocations in the north of the Park. Moreover, at the hearing it stated that, notwithstanding the constraints of the northern service centres, it was aware of land in the north of the Park which it believed would be likely to be, in principle, suitable for new housing but which landowners/developers were not interested in developing for new homes. As detailed in Issue 3 below, it is also the case that housing development in the northern dales is generally less viable than in the south of the Park. Ultimately, it would not be a justified or effective plan which allocated sites for housing to meet a desired spatial strategy, which have little or no chance of actually being developed.

  6. The plan includes all the site allocations which were deemed suitable for development through the site selection process which, as set out in Issue 2 below, I conclude to have been robust. Through this process several potential housing allocations at Embsay were identified to be unsuitable. This fundamentally explains the lack of new housing allocations in this village, rather than a deliberate spatial strategy decision to direct new housing to Threshfield instead. That said, a significant amount of new housing development has taken place in recent years in Embsay whilst only a handful of new homes have been built in Threshfield since the late 1990s. I consider that, all other things being equal, it is an appropriate planning objective to share new housing around settlements over the long term.

  7. Overall, the plan’s aim to locate the majority of new homes in or adjoining the service centres and large villages is a sensible one and consistent with national policy. The housing site allocations in the plan may not, in themselves, result in the perfect spatial strategy. However, having regard to the constraints of many of the settlements and individual sites promoted for housing, the importance of ensuring that great weight is given to conserving and enhancing the Park’s landscape and scenic beauty, the variations in viability and demand for building new homes across the area, and the new housing likely to be delivered as a result of extant planning permissions and ‘windfall’ development, I conclude that the plan’s spatial strategy is justified and effective.

  8. However, as submitted, policy CP3 does not clearly distinguish between overarching spatial strategy principles and policy in respect of the development, housing and non-residential, which will be permitted within and outside housing development boundaries. There is also some inconsistency in terminology with other policies of the plan which creates ambiguity and uncertainty. Consequently, for the plan to be justified and effective, MM2 is necessary to address these shortcomings.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to MM2 as detailed above, the plan’s housing target, settlement hierarchy and spatial strategy are positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Issue 2 – Whether the housing site allocation selection process is robust and whether the plan is justified and effective in respect of the housing site allocations, the housing development boundaries and the likely supply of housing

Housing site selection process

  1. The housing site selection process commenced with a “Call for Sites” in 2021 and all potential sites submitted in response to that, and others of which the Authority itself was aware, were assessed through the Housing Land Availability Assessment. This assessment is an extremely comprehensive one and is consistent with the thrust of the relevant guidance set out in the PPG. Moreover, site promoters were given the opportunity to address or rebut the initial conclusions of the assessment and the contested sites were subsequently formally reconsidered along with a number of alternative and new sites which had emerged.

  2. Each site was considered against consistent assessment criteria (Suitability, Availability and Achievability) and the first of these was informed by an independently prepared Landscape Sensitivity Assessment and a comprehensive assessment of other possible constraints, informed by evidence from site promoters and consultees. The Appendices of the Housing Land Availability Assessment detail in some depth the evidence and the Authority’s conclusions. The Land Availability Assessment also considers the potential for suitable ‘windfall’ housing developments to come forward, including all developments of less than 5 dwellings.

  3. As a result of this Assessment the Authority concluded that 23 sites, with an estimated capacity for a total of 369 dwellings, were suitable, available and achievable for housing development and should, thus, be allocated in the plan. Additionally, it is forecast that 422 dwellings on ‘windfall’ sites are likely to come forward during the plan period, together with 300 dwellings in respect of existing planning permissions. The overall total of 1,091 dwellings, subsequently revised to 1,106 as a result of the proposed modifications to site allocations, would comfortably exceed the housing target figure of 50 dpa.

  4. Unsurprisingly, a number of conclusions of the Housing Land Availability Assessment have been challenged by both those in support of and opposed to the development of specific sites. This is almost inevitable given that many of the conclusions involve, often finely balanced, planning judgements. However, based on my analysis of this Assessment, having given careful consideration to the critiques of it and in light of my visits to all the sites proposed for allocation and a number of those which were not deemed suitable for allocation in the plan, I am satisfied that, other than in relation to SED4 (Baliol School site) as detailed below, the conclusions reached are justified and credible ones.

  5. Rightly, matters raised in public consultation were taken into account in the judgements made, but I am not persuaded that public opposition in itself, as distinct from relevant planning concerns raised by local residents, inappropriately influenced the Authority’s conclusions. In view of this, the extremely comprehensive nature of the assessment and the fact that it identifies more than sufficient site allocations in the plan to ensure that there is a realistic prospect that the housing target figure will be met, I am satisfied that the housing site selection process is robust.

Housing site allocations

  1. The plan is unusual in not including a specific policy or policies for any of the individual site allocations. However, in this respect it is the same as the extant plan and there is not any evidence of this having caused any significant problems. Moreover, none of the sites are large ones, in comparison with those included in most local plans, and many are very small. Having regard to this, the comprehensive nature of the plan’s development management policies and the requirement that the development of site allocations has regard to a development brief, I conclude that a specific policy or policies for all or even some of the individual site allocations is not necessary for the plan to be sound.

  2. Moreover, notwithstanding that, in the light of the development briefs to be prepared and consideration of specific planning applications, the appropriate number of new dwellings on these allocations may differ, to some degree, from the indicative capacity identified in Appendix 4, there is not the evidence in respect of any of the sites to justify altering the indicative figures at this stage. However, as detailed below, there is a need to include in Appendix 4 a limited number of specific requirements for a small number of the sites.

THR4 and THR5 and THR8

  1. Conjoined sites THR4 and THR5, with an indicative total of 75 dwellings, and THR8, indicatively 60 dwellings, are the largest housing site allocations in the plan. I have considered the, in principle, suitability of this amount of new housing in Threshfield in Issue 1 above and there is no substantive evidence to support the view that THR4/THR5 are required for expansion of Upper Wharfedale School, that local facilities/services would be overwhelmed or that unacceptable traffic impacts would be likely to result. Moreover, I am satisfied that, subject to appropriate detailed design at the planning application stage, unacceptable harm in respect of wildlife or dark skies would be unlikely to be caused.

  2. Their size and location mean that these developments would inevitably alter the character and appearance of Threshfield to some degree. However, whilst they would materially expand the population and built-form of the settlement, I consider that their size would not be disproportionate to Threshfield as it currently is.

  3. The new developments would be seen in a number of views within the settlement and out of and into Threshfield from the surrounding landscape. The impact of this will depend on the precise layout, design and landscaping of the developments and emphasises the importance of high priority being given to the proposals being designed to minimise this impact. However, in most of the views of these allocations, the new housing would be seen immediately adjacent to existing built development. Importantly, the plan provides for gaps between the new housing and the existing built development. I conclude that, subject to careful detailed design and layout and appropriate mitigation, the overall impact of the development of these allocations on the landscape would be a moderate one.

  4. The estimated dwelling capacity of these sites is indicative, subject to detailed design. However, in view of the importance of minimising the landscape impact of these developments, and in particular the need to maintain gaps between the new houses and existing built development in Threshfield, it would not be justified for the plan to assume that more than the currently stated indicative capacities for these sites could be delivered.

  5. The boundaries of these site allocations as shown on the proposed policies map are, in effect, the anticipated extent of built-form of the developments. However, the written evidence, the discussions at the hearing session and my visits to the area demonstrate the fundamental need for land around these boundaries to be used for open space, landscaping, habitat creation and, in the case of THR8, access to the site and a short link road between the two separate parts of the allocation. Consequently, for these allocations to be justified and effective it is necessary for the boundaries of the allocations to include the land likely to be required for these purposes.

  6. Given the sensitivity of these allocations, the policies map also needs to specifically identify the “housing footprint” within these expanded site allocation boundaries. Furthermore, for the allocations to be justified and effective, it is necessary for Appendix 4 of the plan to explain that the proposed residential buildings and gardens will be restricted to the identified “housing footprint” (MM47).

  7. In the light of consultation comments I have adjusted MM47 to ensure consistency of wording and to make clear the roads from which the sites must be accessed.

  8. Whether or not a proposal constitutes major development in the National Park, and if so whether the exceptional circumstances necessary to justify it exist, is fundamentally a test for the planning application stage. However, clearly for these allocations to be sound, there needs to be a reasonable prospect that they will be granted planning permission and delivered.

  9. The setting and scale of these allocations are such that, at this stage, I consider it is not possible to reach a view as to whether or not the resulting housing proposals would be likely to constitute major development in the National Park. Much will depend on the precise design and layout of the proposals and the careful assessment of their likely impact.

  10. However, were one or both of these proposals determined to be major development, consideration would have to be given at the planning application stage to the need for the development, the scope for the development being located outside the National Park and the extent to which detrimental effects could be moderated.

  11. National planning policy gives significant weight to the provision of new housing. Within the Yorkshire Dales National Park itself there is need for new homes to provide affordable housing for existing residents and to help reverse population decline. These needs would not be met by providing new homes outside the National Park. Furthermore, the evidence indicates that they could not be located elsewhere within the Park without causing more harm. Moreover, these allocations would be likely to deliver more than 60 affordable homes, located in one of the Park’s local service centres and in close proximity to shopping facilities, a secondary school and bus stops.

  12. I consider that if one or both of the proposals for these site allocations were to be determined to constitute major development in the National Park then there is a reasonable prospect that the exceptional circumstances necessary to justify the proposals would be identified to exist.

  13. Consequently, subject to MM47 and the identified policies map changes, I conclude that site allocations THR4, THR5 and THR8 are sound.

HAW1, HAW2 and HAW3

  1. These sites, which adjoin each other, are situated adjacent to the housing development boundary at the eastern end of the Hawes/Gayle local service centre. Together the sites would indicatively provide for 28 dwellings. It is almost inevitable that development of greenfield sites will have some adverse impact on the character of the area and the landscape but it is the case that there are simply not sufficient brownfield sites in the Park on which the area’s housing needs could be met. I conclude that their overall effect on the landscape would, at most, be a moderate one.

  2. The flagged path is an attractive historic feature of the HAW2 site, the setting of which would be substantially altered by the development of the land for housing. However, it appears to be feasible that it could be retained in some form and this is a matter appropriately addressed by the forthcoming design brief.

  3. The overall scale of new housing proposed on new site allocations in Hawes/Gayle is such that it is highly unlikely that it would result in overdevelopment of these settlements. Instead, I envisage they would be likely to have a modest benefit in supporting the viability of their services and facilities.

  4. In summary, I conclude that the benefits of these allocations would outweigh the harm they would be likely to cause and, thus, they are sound.

CPY1

  1. This site, partly within and partly immediately adjacent to the housing development boundary, is allocated in the plan, as submitted for examination, for six dwellings. Since publication of the plan some redevelopment of the site has taken place and, in the light of this, the Authority argued that the allocation should be deleted.

  2. At the hearing session the landowner’s/site promoter’s intentions were plain: they still intend to develop the site for housing and, based on my visit to the site, this appears to be feasible. Whilst use of the site for housing would be likely to displace its current agricultural activity, I conclude that the benefits of a small number of new dwellings within or immediately adjoining the large village of Carperby would outweigh any such harm. On this basis the allocation is sound.

ORT1 and NLU2

  1. Broadly simultaneously with the publication of the plan, the Environment Agency published updated modelling which identifies a greater than previously modelled risk of fluvial flooding at these two sites. In terms of ORT1, access to the site from the B6261 crosses an area now within Flood Zone 3. In terms of NLU2, 80% of the site is now modelled to be within Flood Zones 2 or 3.

  2. NPPF paragraphs 172–175 are clear that plans should, where possible, avoid flood risk to people and property, including access routes. The sequential test would not be met and, thus, these site allocations are not sound.

  3. Consequently, for the plan to be justified and consistent with national policy MM47 is required to delete site allocations ORT1 and NLU2 from Appendix 4.

SED4 (Baliol School, Sedbergh)

  1. In the plan as submitted for examination this is an allocated opportunity site for new employment uses. However, despite also being allocated for employment uses in the extant plan for nearly a decade and advertised for such uses for around 5 years, the site has not been developed. Furthermore, the viability assessment submitted by the major landowner convincingly demonstrates that office or industrial development of the site would not be viable. I therefore conclude that the allocation in its current form is not sound.

  2. Nonetheless, given the site’s location in Sedbergh, largely surrounded by built development within the town’s housing development boundary and the presence of the attractive, but decaying, Baliol School building, there is a strong case for sensitive redevelopment of the site. I agree with both the major landowner and the Authority that if the site is not developed for employment uses then housing is the justified use for it. Fundamentally I conclude that the provision of housing arising from the site’s redevelopment and the retention or redevelopment of the historic parts of the existing building outweigh the possible use of the site for employment.

  3. Consequently, for the plan to be justified MM47 is required. This modifies Appendix 4 of the plan to delete the site’s allocation for employment uses and instead identify it as a housing allocation for, indicatively, 30 dwellings with the necessary requirements that development has regard to a development brief for the site as a whole and that the historic parts of the school building are retained and converted as part of the development. A consequent change to the policies map will also be required.

Other housing allocation sites

  1. In the light of the written and verbal evidence and, importantly, what I saw on my site visits I conclude that the other allocated housing sites listed in Appendix 4 of the plan — AIR1, BOL1, GRA5, GRA7, HAW4, HOR6, LON5, LON8, NAT2, NLU1, SED2, SED9, SED15 and SED16 — are unlikely to constitute major development, would be unlikely to result in unacceptable impacts and are in other respects justified and effective and, thus, are sound.

Housing development boundaries

  1. Housing development boundaries have been a feature of successive local plans in the National Park since the mid-1990s and are intended to provide a broad indication of the locations in which infill housing developments may be acceptable, subject to compliance with other relevant policies of the plan. The boundaries were reviewed as part of the preparation of the submitted plan, with the aim of affording additional opportunities for sensitive, small-scale ‘windfall’ housing developments at settlements and to define boundaries for settlements within the area newly designated within the Park in 2016.

  2. The logical approach of basing the boundaries on the core developed footprint of each settlement was adopted. Larger areas occupied by farm sheds, yards and caravan sites were appropriately excluded from the boundaries on the basis that the likely housing capacity of such sites would be more suitably considered through the process of identifying housing site allocations.

  3. As set out below, it is likely that the objectively assessed need for housing across the plan area will be met. Given this, and bearing in mind the need to conserve and enhance the National Park’s landscape and scenic beauty and to ensure that new development is limited, the plan would not be sound if the housing development boundaries were to be significantly expanded beyond those currently proposed.

  4. Having regard to the written evidence and that heard at the hearing sessions, I am satisfied that, overall, the review of the housing development boundaries was robust.

  5. However, in the light of the comments made in response to the Regulation 19 consultation, I conclude that the land south of Newlands, High Casterton does form part of the core developed footprint of this settlement. Consequently, for the plan to be justified in respect of the housing development boundaries, this land should be included within the boundaries and a policies map change will be needed to effect this.

Supply of housing

  1. Evidence on the likely supply of housing land has been updated during the examination. In summary, the Authority’s anticipated trajectory of dwelling completions is as follows:
2025/26–2029/302030/31–2034/352035/36–2039/40Total
Extant planning permissions12214335300
New site allocations54165165384
Future windfall supply62173187422
Total2384813871106
  1. Following the hearing sessions, the Authority prepared a note [Doc 110] which together with the Housing Land Availability Study comprehensively explains the evidence and assumptions used in determining the likely number of new dwelling completions across the plan period.

  2. The proportion of overall housing supply arising from future ‘windfall’ developments is relatively high, around 38%, but that is not surprising given the preponderance of very small schemes in the National Park where national policy requires new development to be limited in scale.

  3. The Housing Land Availability Assessment sets out a compelling case that an average of 39 new ‘windfall’ dwellings per year is likely to be completed during the plan period.

  4. From the above it is clear that, with there being ‘headroom’ of housing supply over and above the plan period housing requirement figure of around 47%, confidence can be had that the housing requirement figure will be met across the plan period. However, for consistency with national policy MM18 is required to include in the plan’s supporting text a trajectory illustrating the expected rate of housing delivery over the plan period.

  5. Based on the most recent data and applying the relevant buffer, the Authority cannot quite demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing land — the figure being around 4.5 years. However, there is a realistic prospect that, at the point of adoption of the plan, a supply of at least 5 years would be demonstrable.

  6. Nonetheless, the realistic supply of housing over the plan period as a whole substantially exceeds the requirement for new housing and all potential housing sites which have been demonstrated to be suitable have been allocated in the plan. Furthermore, national policy is clear that development in National Parks should be limited in extent. I conclude that it would not be appropriate to seek ways for the plan to provide for even more housing.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the housing site allocation selection process is robust and the plan is justified and effective in respect of the housing site allocations, the housing development boundaries and the likely supply of housing.

Issue 3 – Whether the plan's Core policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy

  1. Core policies CP1–CP10 are the plan’s strategic policies which apply to all development and set the overarching context for the other policies in the plan.

  2. Consistent with the NPPF as a whole, policy CP1 (Sustainable Development) identifies that development which is sustainable will be permitted and details a wide range of criteria against which sustainability will be assessed. However, to be justified MM1 is required to include criteria in respect of land instability and crime/fear of crime reduction. MM1 also rewords criteria in connection with transport and reducing the need to travel, removes the ambiguous reference to “avoidable” travel, and includes reference to “cultural heritage” in line with the provisions of the 1949 Act.

  3. Policy CP2 concerns National Park purposes and sets out that development will be refused if it significantly conflicts with the statutory National Park purposes. The “significantly conflicts” wording is appropriate given that the 1949 Act requires the Authority to seek to further these purposes whilst, at the same time, to also seek to foster the economic and social wellbeing of communities within the Park.

  4. Policy CP3 (Spatial Strategy and Housing Target), and the need for MM2, is largely addressed elsewhere in this report, in particular in Issues 1 and 4. A minor adjustment to MM2 is required such that policy CP3 makes clear that the sites allocated for new employment development are listed in the plan’s Appendix 4.

  5. Policy CP4 details how development will be assessed to minimise flood risk. MM3 is required to make clear that all the policy’s criteria must be met by development in areas at risk of flooding and to clarify the application of the sequential test where flood risk only relates to surface water.

  6. MM4 is necessary in respect of policy CP5 (Sustainable Drainage – Foul and Surface Water) to make explicit that all development must make appropriate provision for foul and surface water management and to detail requirements in relation to nutrient neutrality and the relevance of the Water Framework Directive and River Basin Management Plans.

  7. Policy CP6 (Design) is consistent with section 12 of the NPPF. Nonetheless, MM5 is needed to explicitly reference landscape/townscape character and visual amenity, to make clear that development should “have regard to” the local Design Guide and to make clear that development briefs will be prepared for all of the allocated sites.

  8. In respect of policy CP7 (Energy Requirements) MM6 is required to clarify that use of decentralised sources of energy and measures to mitigate disruption in energy supplies and communications are encouraged rather than being a requirement. The modification also includes a necessary reference to consideration of archaeology and built heritage.

  9. Policy CP8 (Landscape Character) is key to conserving and enhancing the natural beauty of the Yorkshire Dales National Park in line with the 1949 Act. MM7 is required to replace ambiguous wording and to provide necessary flexibility concerning the visual and perceptual impact of development.

  10. Policy CP9 (Biodiversity Net Gain) seeks to summarise statutory requirements. MM8 is required to remove this summary. It remains justified and consistent with paragraph 187(d) of the NPPF for the policy to require development to include measures such as swift bricks and bat roost boxes.

  11. Policy CP10 details how major development within the National Park will be assessed. MM9 is required to delete the bullet point concerning carbon emissions and to replace supporting text which is not consistent with footnote 67 of the NPPF.

  12. Given that the NPPF is clear that its major development test concerns specific applications for development in National Parks and that it is for the decision maker to determine whether or not a specific proposal is major development, it is inappropriate for the local plan to detail what would and would not constitute major development.

  13. Proposals for new development in the plan would be unlikely to be deliverable if there were not a realistic prospect that they would comply with policy CP10, as proposed to be modified. Accordingly, Issue 2 assesses the plan’s proposed housing site allocations in this particular respect.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the plan’s Core policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Issue 4 – Whether the plan's Community policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy

Principal residency, affordable and local occupancy homes

  1. Central to the plan’s strategy for housing is that all new homes should be the occupant’s principal residence, that as many as possible are affordable and that a small number should be for local occupancy only.

  2. Currently around 20% of dwellings within the National Park are in use as holiday lets, second homes or are otherwise vacant. Whilst holiday lets and second homes are not without benefit, the market for holiday lets and second homes has significantly restricted access to housing for local people and has eroded community vitality.

  3. There appears to be widespread, albeit not unanimous, support for the plan’s requirement that all new dwellings should be occupied as a principal residence. I consider this to be, in principle, a justified approach to help attract and retain people who need or wish to live permanently within the Park.

  4. The Strategic Housing Market Assessment identifies an annual need of around 157 affordable homes within the National Park. This situation strongly supports the plan’s approach of seeking to maximise the proportion of new homes which are affordable within the constraints of financial viability.

  5. There may need to be some flexibility in the application of the affordable housing requirements on a case-by-case basis. However, if the affordable housing requirements were to be set at the “lowest common denominator” level, it is almost certain that in many developments less affordable housing would be delivered than was actually viable. Such an approach would not be justified given the level of identified need for affordable housing in the National Park.

  6. The likely supply of an average of around 70 dwellings per year, in comparison with the requirement of a minimum of 50, should assist in maximising the delivery of affordable homes. However, given that, at most, it is viable for 50% of new housing to be affordable, the total number of new homes would need to be at least double the annual requirement for affordable homes in order to fully meet the requirement for affordable housing. It would not be possible to do so whilst also conserving and enhancing the natural beauty of the National Park.

  7. Given that for the foreseeable future the demand for affordable housing is likely to outstrip the availability of it, the plan justifiably seeks to restrict affordable housing to those who work or have another specific need to live in the National Park.

  8. There is little evidence to suggest that the local occupancy requirement has had a significant adverse effect on the delivery of housing. I conclude that the plan’s requirement that certain schemes should be restricted to local occupancy only is justified.

  9. A number of detailed modifications are required to ensure that the plan is justified and effective in relation to principal residency, affordable and local occupancy homes:

  • MM2 – to include in the supporting text for policy CP3 brief justification for the affordable and local occupancy homes requirements and a table setting out the requirements for principal residency, affordable and local occupancy homes in respect of each of the plan’s policies which provide for new housing.
  • MM16 – to make clear in policy AB2 that conversion of traditional buildings to dwellings will be subject to local occupancy restrictions, whilst indicating in the supporting text that the Authority will consider the appropriateness of an element of affordable housing provision instead of local occupancy.
  • MM18 – to make clear that principal residency applies to all new dwellings, to ensure consistency of wording across the plan in relation to local occupancy requirements and to include a more comprehensive justification of the requirements.
  • MM19 – to modify policy C2 to ensure consistency of wording across the plan in respect of principal residency housing.
  • MM45 – to ensure that the wording of the plan’s Glossary is consistent with the rest of the plan.
  • MM48 – to make clear in Appendix 7 how requirements for fractions of a dwelling to be affordable should be addressed and to provide for some limited cross-boundary flexibility.
  • MM49 – to remove from Appendix 8 text which justifies the principle of local occupancy restrictions.
  • MM50 – to expand the requirements in Appendix 9 for demonstrating compliance with the principal residency restriction and to identify that the restriction will be secured by planning obligation.

Other housing issues

  1. Policy C1 includes requirements in respect of the size of dwellings. MM18 is required to change the requirement for one- and two-bedroom homes to 50%, while permitting a different proportion where specific evidence is submitted to justify an alternative figure.

  2. Policy C1 also requires all new build dwellings to be constructed to M4(2) accessible and adaptability standards. I am satisfied that there is sufficient evidence of need and viability to justify this requirement. A policy requirement in respect of M4(3) dwellings would not be justified. MM23 is required to clarify policy C7.

  3. MM19 makes clear that policy C2 only concerns new-build housing, conversions being addressed by other policies of the plan.

  4. MM20 is necessary to address the clarity of policy C3 (Rural Exception Sites) and to make clear that dwellings on rural exception sites should remain affordable “in perpetuity”.

  5. Policy C4 stipulates that rural workers’ dwellings should be limited to 120 sq m, unless otherwise specifically justified. MM21 is required to make clear that the size limit relates to the internal floor area of the dwelling.

  6. Policy C5 sets out requirements in respect of shared housing, subdivision of dwellings, residential annexes and replacement dwellings. MM22 is required to redraft the policy to address confusion and ambiguity.

  7. Policy C6 identifies that residential caravans for Gypsies and Travellers will be permitted where there is evidence of need in the plan area. This approach is justified given that the relevant evidence identifies no need for new pitches or plots within the National Park.

Important Open Space, Community Facilities and Waste Management

  1. Important Open Spaces have been a longstanding designation in development plans in the National Park and it is clear that there is a strong level of support for them. In my judgement the designation of these spaces, and their protection by policy C9, is justified.

  2. The Authority comprehensively and robustly reviewed the land to be designated as Important Open Space. I agree with the Authority that only the highest quality spaces are appropriately designated.

  3. I consider that Hallgarth field, Airton, residential gardens and grass verges at Cracoe, and the verge in front of Dacre/Sargill Cottage and Sunny Holme, Sedbusk, are appropriately designated as Important Open Space.

  4. Conversely, I conclude that land off Fell Lane/Back Lane, Cracoe, and the verge on Station Road, Threshfield, do not warrant designation as Important Open Space.

  5. An objection was made to the designation of part of the grounds of the Reeth Medical Centre as Important Open Space. The land is used as a community allotment and has recreational value which justifies its designation.

  6. The designation would not prevent development of the land if the allotment no longer existed, was no longer needed or if it was to be relocated or replaced as part of development.

  7. MM24 is required to ensure that policy C9 is effective, replacing “designated” with “important” in the policy’s second sentence.

  8. Policies C8 (Community Facilities) and C10 (Waste Management) are consistent with national policy and are justified.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the plan’s Community policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Issue 5 – Whether the plan's Economy site allocations and policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy

  1. The plan does not identify a required amount of additional land for employment development. This is justified given the dominance of agriculture in the area, the preponderance of very small other types of business and the national policy requirement for the scale and extent of development in the National Park to be limited. However, Appendix 4 details sites for new employment development, selected on the basis of specific, available opportunities.

  2. As detailed in Issue 2, the Baliol School, Sedbergh site is not justified as an employment allocation and MM47 deletes its allocation as such. The other identified employment sites are justified and effective.

  3. Policies E1–E15 are a suite of policies addressing employment, retail and tourism uses, home working and rural-based enterprises and rural estates. In principle they are consistent with the objectives of the NPPF.

  4. MM25 is required to make clear that new employment development will be permitted within, as well as on the edge of, local service centres.

  5. MM26 is needed to redraft policy E2 to make it clearer and to make plain that development and diversification of rural land-based enterprises is supported subject to the stated criteria.

  6. MM27 is required to introduce a criterion concerning traffic movements and to replace ambiguous wording in policy E3.

  7. MM28 and MM29 are needed to refer to “services for residents and visitors” in policy E4 and to “land and buildings currently or last used for employment or tourism uses” in policy E5.

  8. Policy E6 concerns Rural Estate Plans. The Authority considers that Rural Estate Plans have a significant role to play in the conservation of the landscape and development of a sustainable rural economy.

  9. As originally drafted, policy E6 indicates that development conforming with a Rural Estate Plan will be permitted, where the plan has been agreed by the Authority and is in conformity with the Local Plan and National Park Management Plan. This would give the Rural Estate Plan inappropriate development plan status.

  10. MM30 is required to state that the Authority will endorse Rural Estate Plans which accord with the objectives of the Local Plan and the ambitions of the National Park Management Plan and which are informed by appropriate stakeholder consultation.

  11. An endorsed Rural Estate Plan will be a material consideration in the determination of proposals covered by the plan.

  12. MM30 also modifies the supporting text accordingly.

  13. There is no need for policy E7 and MM31 deletes it and its supporting text.

  14. MM32 is required to ensure that policy E8 is justified and to set out appropriate criteria for live/work units.

  15. Policies E9 and E10 concern campsites, touring caravans and motor homes. The effectiveness of the policies is compromised by the lack of definition of camper vans and motor homes.

  16. MM33 and MM34 merge the two policies as one and define camper vans and motor homes.

  17. Policies E11–E15 are positively prepared and justified approaches to supporting tourism. The policies require modifications as follows:

  • MM35 modifies policy E11.
  • MM36 ensures consistency in policy E12.
  • MM38 corrects cross-references in policy E15.
  1. MM37 is needed to clarify that policy E14 relates to the Core Visitor Area at Bolton Abbey, identified on the policies map.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the plan’s Economy site allocations and policies are justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Issue 6 – Whether the plan's policies in respect of Infrastructure, Access/Connectivity and Archaeology/Built Heritage are positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy

Infrastructure, Access and Connectivity

  1. The plan appropriately seeks to encourage travel other than by car, requiring new development to provide facilities for active and sustainable travel appropriate to the nature and scale of the development.

  2. MM10 is necessary to make clear that infrastructure provision need only cater for the demand likely to be generated by the development. The requirement that all dwellings on allocated housing sites connect to gigabit-capable broadband should be removed.

  3. MM11 is necessary to make clear that proposals with an adverse impact will need special justification.

  4. There is considerable overlap between policies AC3 and AC5. MM12 and MM14 are required to combine the two policies and their supporting text as one.

  5. MM13 is necessary to modify the supporting text concerning the former Wensleydale railway line and to make clear that development may be permitted along the safeguarded former railway line where use of the line as a recreational route would not be significantly prejudiced.

Archaeology and Built Heritage

  1. The National Park’s heritage assets and traditional buildings form a very important aspect of its character and appearance. Through policies AB1–AB4 the plan appropriately seeks to conserve and enhance these.

  2. MM15 is required to ensure that policy AB1 is consistent with the relevant parts of the NPPF.

  3. MM16 is necessary to substantially rewrite policy AB2 and its supporting text to address complexity and confusion. Modification of the definition of a traditional building is also required through MM45.

  4. MM17 is required to make clear that development should “have regard to” the Design Guide.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the plan’s policies in respect of Infrastructure, Access/Connectivity and Archaeology/Built Heritage are positively prepared, justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Issue 7 – Whether the plan's policies in respect of Landscape and Natural Environment are justified, effective and consistent with national policy

  1. Policies L1–L6 and NE1–NE2 concern minerals and building stone, the open upland, dark skies and protection of wildlife and habitat. In principle they are supportive of the NPPF’s objectives.

  2. The following modifications are necessary for the plan to be sound:

  • Policy L1 (Crushed Rock Quarrying) – MM39 is required to make clear that all aspects of the first sentence relate to crushed rock quarries and to remove supporting text concerning what would or would not constitute major development.
  • Policy L2 (Building Stone) – MM40 is needed to refer to “accordance with” rather than “conformity with”.
  • Policy L3 (Re-working Mineral Waste) – MM41 is necessary to refer to agreed after-use schemes and to include an exemption where there is a need for the mineral which cannot reasonably be met by alternative methods.
  • Policy L6 (Dark Night Skies) – MM42 is required to make clear that development will only be permitted if it maintains or enhances the Yorkshire Dales Dark Sky Reserve and that mitigation should “have regard to” the Authority’s lighting guidelines.
  • Policy NE1 (Protecting Wildlife Sites, Species and Networks) – MM43 is necessary to ensure that the policy accurately reflects the requirements of the Habitats Directive and that its supporting text sets out guidance on its application.
  • Policy NE2 (Protecting Irreplaceable Habitat, Trees, Hedgerows and Walls) – MM44 is required to make explicit the requirement for development to protect, conserve and where possible enhance irreplaceable habitat, and to clarify requirements concerning replacement trees and arboricultural guidance.

Conclusion

  1. Subject to the MMs detailed above the plan’s policies in respect of Landscape and Natural Environment are justified, effective and consistent with national policy.

Overall Conclusion and Recommendation

  1. The plan has a number of deficiencies in respect of soundness and legal compliance for the reasons set out above, which mean that I recommend non-adoption of it as submitted, in accordance with Section 20(7A) of the 2004 Act. These deficiencies have been explained in the main issues set out above.

  2. The Authority has requested that I recommend MMs to make the plan sound, legally compliant and capable of adoption. I conclude that with the recommended main modifications set out in the Appendix the Yorkshire Dales National Park Local Plan 2025-40 satisfies the requirements referred to in Section 20(5)(a) of the 2004 Act and is sound.

Malcolm Rivett

Inspector

This report is accompanied by an Appendix containing the Main Modifications.