Natural Flood Management Measures – a practical guide for farmers
[Image: Cover page featuring a long-exposure photograph of a rushing river with white water flowing over dark rocks, framed by green and yellow autumn leaves in the foreground. The Yorkshire Dales National Park logo is at the bottom left.]
Yorkshire Dales National Park: one of Britain’s breathing spaces
[Image: A waterlogged field next to a rural road, showing a large puddle of standing water reflecting the sky. A wooden fence runs alongside the road.]
This guide has been requested by the farmers and land managers of the Yorkshire Dales National Park to provide simple, clear advice on the provision of natural flood management measures.
The pack has been put together by the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA), Yorkshire Dales Rivers Trust (YDRT) and North Yorkshire County Council (NYCC), with support from our partners in the Environment Agency (EA) and Natural England (NE).
Cover image: Aysgarth Falls © Dave Higgins
All information contained in this publication – including links to websites and further reading – is believed to be correct at the time of going to press.
If you have any comments or need further information about this publication, please contact Helen Keep, Senior Farm Conservation Officer, on 01756 751600 or helen.keep@yorkshiredales.org.uk.
[Image: Two photos: one shows a tractor pulling a red mechanical aerator through a green field; the second shows a wide, shallow stony river bed with water flowing through a green valley.]
Introduction
Floods are nothing new. Humans have lived with extreme weather for thousands of years. However, climate change science predicts an increase in occurrence and severity of high rainfall events. Subsequent increases in extreme flooding will follow suit.
Within the UK, our flood defence system includes large-scale, hard engineered solutions in and around major cities, flood banks and small scale engineered solutions for rural communities and farmland, and coastal engineering. There is increasing political and public interest in how the management of the wider countryside can contribute to the UKs flood defence system, with particular reference made to natural flood management (NFM).
[Image: A photo showing a flooded field where water is overflowing over a low earth embankment or "bund."]
What is natural flood management?
Natural flood management aims to reduce the downstream maximum water height of a flood (the flood peak) or to delay the arrival of the flood peak downstream, increasing the time available to prepare for floods.
This is achieved by restricting the progress of water through a catchment using a range of techniques. These techniques work with the natural features of the catchment to slow down or store flood waters. They rely on one, or a combination, of the following underlying mechanisms.
- Increasing soil infiltration: free-draining soil will make saturation less likely, potentially reducing surface runoff.
- Evaporation from vegetation and soil can also make space for water.
- Slowing water: by increasing resistance to its flow – for example, by planting floodplain or riverside woods, or blocking grips on moorland.
- Storing water by using, and maintaining the capacity of, ponds, ditches, embanked reservoirs, channels or land.
- Reducing water flow connectivity by interrupting surface flows of water – for example, by planting buffer strips of grass or trees.
[Image: A wooden "leaky dam" or in-channel barrier made of horizontal timber slats installed across a small stream, allowing some water to trickle through while holding back the bulk of the flow.]
Why land management in the Yorkshire Dales National Park can play its part
The main rivers that rise within the Yorkshire Dales National Park flow through a number of our region’s larger towns and cities, and, on occasion, cause significant flood damage.
Within the National Park, the rivers cause flooding to communities and farmland, causing main roads to become blocked and properties to flood. High rainfall events can cause damage to farm property – for example, prolonged inundation of farmland, soil loss, erosion of farm tracks, and flooding of farm buildings.
Whatever your focus is, as a farmer and land manager you may be in a position to help contribute to reducing flooding, locally or regionally.
Research carried out by Leeds University in Coverdale indicates that a combination of simple flood management measures over 10% of the catchment area can help slow down the flow of water during high rainfall events by up to 12%. This is a significant effect and is something that can be achieved from a farming and land management perspective without sacrificing production levels or greatly altering land management practices.
Natural flood management structures have been designed so that they do not significantly impact on farming, are typically small in size, and can be considered an extension to the farm’s land drainage system.
Each structure or technique performs a small amount of runoff storage or attenuation, gradually releasing flood water over 12 to 24 hours. It is the collective network, rather than individual features, that aims to provide flood mitigation in the immediate vicinity and further downstream.
Natural flood management is not the complete solution to flooding, but is one of many tools needed to manage flood events. These tools are more effective at reducing the frequency of flooding for high probability fluvial events (for example, less than a one in twenty year return period) compared to extreme events (for example, a one in 200 year return period). Used in conjunction with other flood management solutions, like hard engineering, natural flood management will have a beneficial impact on slowing the flow of flood water downstream. Research at a number of small-scale catchments has shown this to be the case.
[Image: A moorland landscape where a narrow drainage ditch (grip) has been blocked, and young trees in plastic protection tubes have been planted nearby.]
Using the guide
This guide has been developed to provide the advice and key information needed to aid decision-making, should you wish to install flood management features on your farm. We have included funding sources to support the work you may want to undertake.
The various measures have been grouped into three different levels of intervention:
Level 1
Measures requiring minimum or no consultation with authorities such as the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority (YDNPA) or Environment Agency (EA). These measures are usually low cost and simple to install, but extremely effective.
Level 2
Measures requiring a certain level of consultation and possibly consent of authorities (see summary of consents section). These measures are a mix of low to medium cost and may need contractors’ help to install them.
Level 3
Measures involving a level of design that is targeted to certain locations within the catchment, requiring planning permission and consents from authorities, and, in most cases, involving professional water management consultant advice. These measures are usually high cost and need contractors to install them.
Each measure is described in terms of its flood management effectiveness, its benefit to agricultural production, and its overall cost. Set up and maintenance costs have been colour-coded:
Set up costs
- High (Red): Requires significant raw materials, specialist equipment, or expert involvement.
- Medium (Orange): Requires some raw materials, specialist equipment, and/or expert involvement.
- Low (Green): Land manager can implement system with minimal advice, equipment, and specialist material.
Maintenance costs
- High (Red): Expert advice or equipment required to be brought in frequently (e.g. < 5 yrs).
- Medium (Orange): Expert advice or equipment required to be brought in occasionally (e.g. < 10 yrs).
- Low (Green): Mostly involves routine inspections and low-grade management, which can be undertaken by the land manager.
Help us keep track
Please keep us updated! If you choose to implement a natural flood management technique on your land, let us know:
- the date of construction
- which treatment was implemented
- the size and number of treatments implemented.
This will help us monitor the use of natural flood management in our area, and enable us to evaluate the success.
Contact details
Farm Conservation Team Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority 01756 751600 farming@yorkshiredales.org.uk
[Image: A detailed hand-drawn landscape illustration of the Yorkshire Dales, showing a valley with various NFM measures labelled. These include: Targeted new native woodland planting (on high slopes), Blocking drainage grips (on moorland tops), Woody debris dams (in high streams), Riverside woodland planting, Interception of runoff pathways (grass strips/bunds in middle fields), Soil management, Flood water storage (swales/ponds in lower fields), and River bank buffer strips.]
Intervention treatments: Level 1
[Image: A tractor in a green field pulling a mechanical sward lifter to aerate the soil.]
Increasing soil permeability – reducing soil compaction
Compaction is where soil has been squashed into a solid, impermeable layer, either at the surface or within the topsoil. This band restricts the movement of air, water and nutrients down through the soil profile.
The effects of soil compaction can be detrimental to grass and root growth, reducing the ability of grass to pick up nutrients, particularly nitrogen and water, from the soil. It creates conditions for waterlogging and poaching and increases the risk of runoff, leading to soil and nutrient loss. Runoff from compacted soils is 50-60% higher than on aerated healthy soils.
Natural flood management purpose
- Managing soil compaction is one of the most effective treatments farmers can undertake to reduce overland flow and lower flood risk.
- Increases the amount of water held in the soil over a wide area.
- Improves connectivity with groundwater by promoting strong root growth.
Agricultural benefits
- Improved air exchange and soil water uptake.
- Improved fertiliser uptake.
- Reduced water runoff, soil loss and poaching.
- Stronger grass roots and more efficient crop growth.
Methods
- Dig test holes (40cm) to check for compaction/waterlogging.
- Test pH and add lime if below 6.
- Mechanically aerate using spiked aerators, sub-soiler, or sward lifter.
- Use minimal tillage and manage crop/livestock rotations.
- Avoid heavy machinery on wet soils.
Considerations
- Mechanical treatment can damage sub-surface historic features.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low
- Maintenance: Low
Creating and managing buffer strips
[Image: A wide grass buffer strip running alongside a stone wall and a small stream in a field.]
Creating a network of grass strips next to watercourses and ditches – known as riparian buffer strips – can provide a physical barrier that helps restrict the flow of storm water and nutrients from the field.
Natural flood management purpose
- Increases surface roughness, slowing runoff and increasing infiltration.
- Traps sediment and stabilises banks to prevent erosion.
Agricultural benefits
- Reduces loss of fertilisers and pesticides.
- 10m wide strips reduce sediment loss by 30%.
- Reduces frequency of ditch management.
- Creates wildlife corridors and reduces spray drift.
Construction dimensions
- Riparian strips: minimum 6m wide (may require fencing).
- In-field strips: 2m wide.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low
- Maintenance: Low
Planting and managing hedgerows
[Image: A newly planted hedgerow with young plants protected by plastic tubes, running alongside a wooden fence.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Promotes rainfall infiltration and reduces runoff volume.
- Removes water faster through increased evapotranspiration.
- Traps sediment.
Agricultural benefits
- Provides shelter and shade for livestock.
- Reduces spread of disease by creating a barrier between animals.
- Provides habitat for beneficial insects.
Construction dimensions
- Plant double staggered row (4-6 plants per metre).
- Use tree tubes (0.7m) and stock-proof fencing.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Medium
- Maintenance: High (requires annual maintenance until established).
Using trees
[Image: A hillside with many rows of young trees in protective tubes, planted to create a new area of woodland.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Increases surface roughness and slows water flow.
- Reduces runoff and increases capture/evaporation of rainfall.
- Interception can reduce rainfall reaching ground by 45%.
- Roots bind stream banks, reducing erosion.
Agricultural benefits
- Creates shelter/shade for livestock.
- Reduces flood damage on productive land.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Medium
- Maintenance: Low (for existing) / Medium (for new planting).
Winter cover crops
[Image: A close-up of a dense green cover crop with small purple flowers, covering soil that would otherwise be bare.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Reduces overland flow and increases infiltration on land otherwise left bare over winter.
Agricultural benefits
- Helps fix nitrogen and reduces fertiliser costs.
- Improves soil structure and biological activity.
- Prevents soil erosion and nutrient loss.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low
- Maintenance: Low
Cross drains in farm tracks
[Image: A farm track with a metal gate, showing a concrete cross drain installed into the ground to divert water off the track.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Diverts water away from the main pathway, reducing flow volume and sediment load.
Agricultural benefits
- Tracks suffer less erosion and last longer.
- Sediment caught in traps can be reused on the track.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low
- Maintenance: Low (requires inspection after major storms).
Intervention treatments: Level 2
Bunds and detention basins
[Image: A large, shallow pond (detention basin) created in a field to hold back water during heavy rain.]
Earth bunds work most efficiently when located across known runoff pathways. They create a detention area where water is retained and released slowly through flow control (e.g., a small pipe).
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Medium
- Maintenance: Medium
Swales
[Image: A long, shallow, grass-lined channel (swale) designed to convey and store surface water.]
Swales are linear, shallow, vegetated drainage features. The increased roughness of the vegetated channel helps to slow the flow of water.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Medium
- Maintenance: Low
Sediment traps
[Image: A small excavation in a field corner designed to catch runoff and allow sediment to settle out.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Holds excess floodwater and reduces siltation of watercourses.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low (dependent on scale)
- Maintenance: Low (requires regular emptying).
In-channel barriers (Leaky Dams)
[Image: A stream with horizontal wooden timbers fixed across it. Water is pooling behind the timbers and spilling over in a controlled way.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Slowly leaks water, draining trapped volumes after a flood peak has passed.
- Can reduce 1 in 100 year flood peaks by 20%.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: Low
- Maintenance: Low
Offline flood storage pond
[Image: A permanent pond situated in a field next to a river, surrounded by green grass and trees.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Diverts river flow during high periods into a pre-constructed storage area where it slowly infiltrates or releases back.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: High
- Maintenance: Low
Blocking moorland drainage grips
[Image: A blocked drainage ditch on a moor, where water has backed up to form a small pool, encouraging peatland restoration.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Restores the "sponge effect" of peatlands.
- Slows water flow through bare peat grips.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: High
- Maintenance: Low
Intervention treatments: Level 3
Floodplain restoration
[Image: A wide river waterfall (Aysgarth Falls) with powerful white water cascading over broad rock steps.]
Restoring the connection between a river and its floodplain allows floodwater to spill naturally onto land, providing significant storage. This requires careful planning by specialists, computer modelling, and high-cost implementation by contractors.
Restoring meanders
[Image: A river that has been allowed to follow a winding, natural "S" curve path through a grassy valley.]
Natural flood management purpose
- Increases the length of the river channel, which increases the time taken for floodwater to flow downstream.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: High
- Maintenance: Low
Reconnecting the river with its flood plain
[Image: A wide-angle view of a flat river valley where the river has overflowed its banks into the surrounding fields.]
Includes techniques like river restoration, breaching earth bunds, lowering flood defences, and connecting the river to floodplain wetlands.
Costs & Maintenance
- Set-up: High
- Maintenance: Medium
Consent and approval
Some treatments require legal consent before construction:
- Land drainage consent: Required for works in ordinary watercourses (from Lead Local Flood Authority) or main rivers (from Environment Agency).
- Planning consent: May be required for larger structures from the YDNPA.
- New woodlands: May require an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) if over 2ha and not under agri-environment schemes.
- Specialised consent: Required for works affecting Scheduled Monuments, SSSIs, or Public Rights of Way.
Consents Table Summary:
- Scheduled Monument: Consent from Historic England.
- SSSI/SAC/SPA: Consent from Natural England.
- Rights of Way/Open Access: Consent from YDNPA.
Summary of consents table
| Intervention treatments | Planning Permission | Land Drainage | Historic Env | Wildlife | Hydrological Support | Grant Available |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level 1 | ||||||
| Soil permeability | N | N | Y | N | N | N |
| Buffer strips | N | N | N | N | N | Y (CS) |
| Hedgerows | N | N | N | N | N | Y (CS) |
| Using trees | N | Y | Y | Y | N | Y (CS, FC) |
| Level 2 | ||||||
| Bunds/Basins | Y | N | Y | N | N | Y (CS) |
| Swales | Y | N | Y | Y | Y | Y (CS) |
| In-channel barriers | N | Y | N | N | N | Y (CS) |
| Level 3 | ||||||
| Meanders | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y (EA) |
| Reconnecting floodplain | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y | Y (EA) |
Sources of advice
- Rural Payments Agency: 01609 773751
- Environment Agency: Contact leads for Swale, Ure, Nidd, Wharfe, Aire, Calder, Ribble, Lune, and Eden.
- Natural England: Leads for Yorkshire/Humber and Cumbria.
- Forestry Commission: Leads for North Yorkshire and Cumbria/Lancashire.
- Rivers Trusts: Yorkshire Dales, Ribble, Lune, and Eden trusts.
- YDNPA: Development Planning (01969 652345) and Farm Conservation (01756 751600).
Published by Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority, August 2017 www.yorkshiredales.org.uk | 0300 456 0300 | info@yorkshiredales.org.uk