THE FINDINGS OF THE SENSITIVITY ASSESSMENT PROCESS
Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority
November 2006
IMAGE: Cover page displaying the title “THE FINDINGS OF THE SENSITIVITY ASSESSMENT PROCESS”, the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority name, and the date November 2006.
1. Introduction
This report presents the findings of the sensitivity assessment (vulnerability mapping) exercise conducted on routes with possible or proven rights for motor vehicles in the Yorkshire Dales National Park. The methodology for the sensitivity assessment (vulnerability mapping) was presented in Sensitivity Assessment and the prioritisation of unsealed routes in the Yorkshire Dales National Park.
2. List of Routes that have been assessed
Following the Natural Environment and Rural Communities (NERC) Act 2006:
Public rights for mechanically propelled vehicles have been extinguished over every right of way not already shown on the definitive map as a byway open to all traffic (BOAT). BOAT status means that mechanically propelled vehicular rights exist.
Public rights for mechanically propelled vehicles have not been extinguished where they exist, on ways that are not recorded on the definitive map and statement, but are recorded on the list (that local authorities are required to keep under section 36(6) of the Highways Act 1980) of highways maintainable at public expense – often referred to as the ‘list of streets’. (Inclusion of a route on the list of streets is not conclusive evidence of the rights it carries and there is no presumption that any highway shown on the list of streets carries vehicular rights, hence ‘possible’ mechanically propelled vehicular rights).
There are a number of routes, which are on the Definitive Map as footpath or bridleway, that meet the exception of subsection 67(3), that is a Definitive Map Modification application for BOAT status was received by the National Park Authority before the NERC Act cut-off date of 20 January 2005. (Each route has to be assessed on a case by case basis, and depending on the evidence there may be ‘possible’ mechanically propelled vehicular rights).
The routes that have been assessed are those unsealed routes which are believed to have possible or proven rights for recreational motor vehicles, and which were identified as having some recreational motor vehicles use, in 2005, by ranger service staff (see Table 1). There are many other unsealed unclassified county roads in the National Park which have little or no recorded use by recreational motor vehicles (see Table 2).
In summary, many routes which are currently shown on the Definitive Map, and have been used by recreational motor vehicles, and are considered ‘sensitive’ to such use, eg Occupation Road, Dent, have had any public motor vehicular rights that may have existed extinguished through the NERC Act. Therefore the list of routes that have been assessed for their ‘sensitivity’ includes few public rights of way, with the majority of the routes assessed those which are on the list of streets only. (NB this list of routes is a ‘provisional’ list at this stage – pending further cross checking with NYCC and CCC databases of the ‘list of streets’). It should be stressed that the maintenance responsibility for these routes rests with the respective county council, however, the use of these routes, particularly where it impacts on the special qualities of the National Park, is the responsibility of the National Park Authority.
Table 1. Routes, known to be used by recreational motor vehicles, with possible or proven mechanically propelled vehicle rights that have been assessed as part of the Sensitivity Assessment
| Route Name | Reference Number | Ranger Area | Grid Ref From | To | Route/Ucr Number | Current Status if known or Unclassified County Road? | Checked With Nycc/Ccc Records | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bluecaster Side | 1 | Cumbria | SD 701 963 | SD 714 978 | 303/5502 | Unclassified county road | No | |
| Garsdale Foot to Barth Bridge | 2 | Cumbria | SD 686 912; SD 697 911 | SD 695 887 | 301/5478, 303/5478, 303/5479 | Unclassified county road | No | |
| Castle Bolton to ford | 3 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 033 918 | SE 008 917 | 268/1101 | Unclassified county road | No | No through route |
| Hargill, Carperby | 4 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 007 909 | SE 009 900 | 255/1109 | Unclassified county road | No | No through route |
| Haw Lane | 5 | Malhamdale | SD 856 567 | SD 863 577 | 142/1177 | Unclassified county road | No | No through route |
| Red Way, Caldbergh | 6 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 114 819 | SE 092 852 | U938 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Part of route is outside the NP. |
| West Burton to Penhill Farm | 7 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 018 872; SE 018 870; SE 042 891; SE057 883 | SE 062 876 | U1052, U1058 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Two spur routes lead to Swinithwaite and West Witton |
| Heugh Lane | 8 | Lower Wensleydale | SD 963 917 | SD 953 922 | U246 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Deadmans Hill | 9 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 043 782 | SE 043 804 | U936 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Part of route is outside the NP. |
| Nipe Lane | 10 | Lower Wensleydale | SD 970 897 | SD 971 890 | 259/1114 | Unclassified county road | No | |
| Richmond Gate | 11 | Lower Wensleydale | SD 986 893 | SD 979 886 | 259/1116 | Unclassified county road | No | |
| Carlton to Middleham High Moor | 12 | Lower Wensleydale | SE 064 846 | SE 067 868 | U7021 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Forest Road (Pockstones Moor), Appletreewick | 14 | Lower Wharfedale | SE 077 613 | SE 090 616 | U2281 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Closed by TRO. Part of route is outside the NP. |
| Fancarl | 15 | Lower Wharfedale | SE 059 631 | SE 063 622 | U8052 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Moor Lane, Halton East | 16 | Lower Wharfedale | SE 041 542 | SE 037 555 | U2286 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Ling Chapel | 17 | Lower Wharfedale | SE 090 525 | SE 088 530 | U2318 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Hanlith to Weets Top (Windy Pike Lane) | 18 | Malhamdale | SD 903 615 | SD 923 628 | U1899 | Unclassified county road | Yes | No through route |
| Smearsbottom Lane (Lee Gate) | 19 | Malhamdale | SD 925 644 | SD 930 654 | U810 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Mastiles TRO means no through route for rmvs. |
| Mastiles Lane | 20 | Malhamdale | SD 974 678 | SD 905 656 | U808, 110/4 | Unclassified county road and bridleway | Yes | Closed by TRO |
| Arncliffe Cote | 21 | Malhamdale | SD 905 656 | SD 947 705 | U8038, 103/5, 110/16/A, 155/30, 110/16/B, 155/29, 154/31 | Bridleway and BOAT and Unclassified county road. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | Short section is BOAT |
| Dean Moor, Malham | 22 | Malhamdale | SD 893 658 | SD 888 649 | 155/6, 154/10/A | Bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | |
| Feizor Nick | 23 | Ribblesdale | SD 789 684 | SD 789 678 | 149/1077 | Unclassified county road | No | Pennine Bridleway. No through route. |
| Banks Lane, Settle | 24 | Ribblesdale | SD 821 637 | SD 823 642 | U8041 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Pennine Bridleway |
| Langber Lane | 25 | Ribblesdale | SD 841 624 | SD 861 591 | U793 | Unclassified county road | No | No through route |
| Ling Gill, High Birkwith to Cam End | 26 | Ribblesdale | SD 800 768 | SD 802 804 | 144/1, 144/10 | Footpath. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | Pennine Way and Bridleway |
| Twistleton Lane | 27 | Ribblesdale | SD 699 745 | SD 692 759 | U8045 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Moor Head Lane, Stainforth | 28 | Ribblesdale | SD 818 697 | SD 833 685 | U8039, 144/40, 144/46 | Unclassified county road and bridleway. BOAT case. | Yes | |
| Thwaite Lane | 29 | Ribblesdale | SD 775 691 | SD 746 694 | 104/13/A, 104/13/B, 118/10 | Bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | Pennine Cycleway and Bridleway |
| Lodge Road, Settle | 30 | Ribblesdale | SD 813 623 | SD 828 623 | 162/10 | Bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | |
| Tow Scar Lane, Masongill | 31 | Ribblesdale | SD 681 748 | SD 675 762 | U8032 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Edge Lane | 32 | Ribblesdale | SD 828 599 | SD 828 625 | 152/1213/A, 162/1213 | Unclassified county road | No | Pennine Bridleway |
| Long Lane, Horton-in-Ribblesdale | 33 | Ribblesdale | SD 842 714 | SD 814 695 | U8037, 144/40 | Unclassified county road and bridleway. BOAT case. | Yes | Part is Pennine Way |
| Gorbeck Road | 34 | Ribblesdale | SD 888 649 | SD 829 653 | U8040 | Unclassified county road and BOAT | Yes | Pennine Bridleway |
| Harber Scar Lane (Birkwith Moor) | 35 | Ribblesdale | SD 808 727 | SD 822 784 | U8034, 144/12 | Unclassified county road and bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | Yes | Pennine Way |
| Goatscar Lane | 36 | Ribblesdale | SD 822 673 | SD 839 664 | U814 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Pennine Bridleway |
| Stockdale Lane, Settle | 37 | Ribblesdale | SD 836 630 | SD 892 639, SD 880 649 | BW 162/3, 154/12, 154/11 | Bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | Pennine Bridleway |
| Turbary road | 38 | Ribblesdale | SD 675 763 | SD 706 790 | U695 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Foxup road & Hesleden Bergh | 39 | Ribblesdale | SD 823 742 | SD 871 767 | 135/4, 144/25 | Bridleway. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05 | No | |
| Cam High Road, Far Gearstones to Cam Houses | 40 | Ribblesdale | SD 785 803 | SD 821 827 | 144/4, 144/1 | Unclassified county road and footpath. BOAT case. | Yes | Pennine Bridleway and Pennine Way. Very short section of UCR |
| Long Lane Clapham to Selside | 41 | Ribblesdale | SD 751 695 | SD779 755 & SD 788 747 | 118/9, 104/3, 104/1, 144/15/A, 144/16 | Bridleway and footpath. BOAT application received pre 20.1.05. | No | Pennine Bridleway |
| Fremington to Hurst | 42 | Swaledale | SE 045 989 | NZ 043 007 | U429 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Route continues beyond Park boundary |
| Low Lane, Low Whita to Low Houses | 43 | Swaledale | SE 004 983 | SD 983 974 | U254 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Dubbing Garth Lane | 44 | Swaledale | SD 962 977 | SD 949 977 | U255 | Unclassified county road | Yes | No through route |
| Arten Gill Moss to Widdle Foot | 45 | Upper Wensleyda;e | SD 824 878 | SD 792 862 | U169 | Unclassified county road | Yes | No through route |
| Cam High Road, Fleet Moss to Bainbridge | 46 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 862 853 | SD 925 895 | U228, 252/103/A, 252/103/B, 256/103 | BOAT | Yes | |
| Marsett Bottoms | 47 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 903 862 | SD 917 859 | U230 | Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Stake Road, Stalling Busk to Cray | 48 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 919 860 | SD 943 803 | U232, 113/22, 253/3, 252/47 | BOAT and Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| Bob Lane | 49 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 917 858 | SD 917 854 | 252/1049 | Unclassified county road | No | |
| West Cam Road/Cam Road | 50 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 829 833 | SD 859 895 | U7028 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Pennine Way |
| Busk Lane, Bainbridge | 51 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 934 839 | SD 943 871 | U234, 252/48 | BOAT and Unclassified county road | Yes | |
| The Highway | 52 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 786 968 | SD 842 921 | 248/1 | BOAT | No | Pennine Bridleway. Part of route is outside the NP |
| Shaw Paddock | 53 | Upper Wensleydale | SD 784 951 | SD 787 969 | 256/6, 248/2 | BOAT | No | Link route to The Highway |
| Horse Head Pass | 54 | Upper Wharfedale | SD 879 766 | SD 889 776 | U8035 | Unclassified county road | Yes | Closed by TRO |
| Dawson Close | 55 | Upper Wharfedale | SD 855 728 | SD 898 743 | U8036 | Unclassified county road | Yes |
IMAGE: Table 1 continues across several pages and lists routes, reference numbers, ranger areas, grid references, route or UCR numbers, current status, records checks, and comments.
Table 2: Other routes with possible rights for mechanically propelled vehicles
| UCR ID | Name | Length | Ranger area | Start Grid | End Grid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 168/1031 | 0.32469 | Ribblesdale | SD663758 | SD664744 | |
| 168/1030/A | 1.00881 | Ribblesdale | SD664754 | SD660746 | |
| 168/1030/B | 0.058553 | Ribblesdale | SD664751 | SD664751 | |
| 168/1030/C | 0.066452 | Ribblesdale | SD664752 | SD664752 | |
| 168/1041 | 0.150097 | Ribblesdale | SD662757 | SD663757 | |
| 289/1258 | Sowden Beck Road | 1.78022 | Lower Wensleydale | SE145857 | SE141842 |
| 201/1082 | 0.325188 | Swaledale | NY931076 | NY929074 | |
| 301/5513 | Mill Lane | 0.180656 | Cumbria | SD660899 | SD658898 |
| 303/5296 | 0.171743 | Cumbria | SD630948 | SD632949 | |
| 303/5296 | 0.208144 | Cumbria | SD628949 | SD630949 | |
| 133/1285 | Old Moor Lane | 1.24654 | Lower Wharfedale | SE022667 | SE015658 |
| 129/1206 | 0.137606 | Malhamdale | SD946566 | SD947565 | |
| 129/1203 | 0.776514 | Malhamdale | SD936592 | SD934585 | |
| 116/1201 | Kell Syke Lane | 1.24431 | Malhamdale | SD907591 | SD915584 |
| 265/1137 | Sleight Lane | 0.284472 | Lower Wensleydale | SE085849 | SE086847 |
| 260/1254 | 0.256989 | Lower Wensleydale | SE096862 | SE096860 | |
| 291/1150 | Flats Lane | 1.22069 | Lower Wensleydale | SE059895 | SE060884 |
| 254/1135/B | 0.079315 | Lower Wensleydale | SE018867 | SE018867 | |
| 254/1130 | 0.2292 | Lower Wensleydale | SD985806 | SD986807 | |
| 258/1123/A | 0.412471 | Lower Wensleydale | SE997866 | SE995863 | |
| 258/1122 | Low Green | 0.393123 | Lower Wensleydale | SE001868 | SE003864 |
| 251/1119/B | 0.077887 | Lower Wensleydale | SE007882 | SE008881 | |
| 259/1115 | 0.953341 | Lower Wensleydale | SD972888 | SD967883 | |
| 256/1008 | Bands Lane | 0.864066 | Upper Wensleydale | SD857592 | SD865890 |
| 250/1063/B | 0.297237 | Lower wensleydale | SD949921 | SD951919 | |
| 250/1065 | High Straits Lane | 1.07288 | Lower wensleydale | SD948921 | SD938923 |
| 204/1169 | Ellerholme Lane | 0.774539 | Swaledale | SE079979 | SE085976 |
| 207/1086/B | 0.06916 | Swaledale | SE017990 | SE017990 | |
| 203/1075 | 0.123765 | Swaledale | SE003982 | SD982973 | |
| 203/1076/A | 0.942169 | Swaledale | SD963956 | SD964948 | |
| 206/1067 | 1.0031 | Swaledale | SD938963 | SD931960 | |
| 205/1071 | 0.093917 | Swaledale | SD951982 | SD952982 | |
| 206/1033 | 0.127134 | Swaledale | SD893981 | SD892981 | |
| 302/5511 | 1.01367 | Cumbria | SD770942 | SD776937 | |
| 303/5484 | Buckbank Lane | 1.44033 | Cumbria | SD680933 | SD671923 |
| 303/5489 | 1.69357 | Cumbria | SD686922 | SD700913 | |
| 303/5500 | Marsh Lane | 0.598905 | Cumbria | SD694943 | SD689941 |
| 252/1052 | bw / ucr section | 0.727993 | Upper Wensleydale | SD955894 | SD950891 |
| 252/1052 | check | 0.626598 | Upper Wensleydale | SD942889 | SD937886 |
| 249/1041 | Red Gate | 0.632072 | Upper Wensleydale | SD920912 | SD921908 |
| 204/1161 | Sikelands Lane | 0.216599 | Swaledale | SE077979 | SE077977 |
| 301/5507 | Dyke Hall Lane | 1.2784 | Cumbria | SD722859 | SD725847 |
| 301/5507 | dual status in parts | 0.351288 | Cumbria | SD725843 | SD742842 |
| 291/1149 | 0.3118 | Lower Wensleydale | SE063884 | SE060885 | |
| 248/1029 | Shutt Lane | 0.716515 | Upper Wensleydale | SD888915 | SD883911 |
| 302/5489 | 0.169345 | Cumbria | SD699914 | SD700913 | |
| 203/1076/B | Gale Lane | 0.813404 | Swaledale | SD990975 | SD982973 |
| 256/1009 | 2.01594 | Upper Wensleydale | SD865891 | SD862875 |
This gives a total of 102 routes in the National Park with possible or proven rights for motor vehicles.
IMAGE: Table 2 lists additional routes with possible mechanically propelled vehicle rights, including UCR identifiers, route names, lengths, ranger areas, and start and end grid references.
3. Sensitivity Assessment and Evidence gathering
All routes with possible or proven rights for motor vehicles were compared to geographical information system (GIS) layers for:
- National and European nature conservation designations
- Scheduled ancient monuments
- Tranquil area map
For the second group of routes which have little or no history of use it was found that one route passes through a Scheduled Ancient Monument site but this was not considered vulnerable by YDNPA staff given the nature of the route. A number of these routes were within tranquil areas but because they have little or no history of use by recreational motor vehicles the routes were not considered to be potentially sensitive. Therefore these 48 routes are not considered further in this report. For the routes which are known to have some use by recreational motor vehicles additional information was gathered through the following.
Interviews with:
- Staff at Natural England
- Staff at the Yorkshire Dales National Park Authority:
- Nature conservation staff
- Area rangers
- Senior Conservation Archaeologist
Other information from:
- Condition surveys
- Vehicle loggers
For each route an evidence sheet was compiled, which are contained in Appendix 1, together with a location map.
It should be stressed that this information is based on a desk top study and that detailed fieldwork, as part of a detailed evaluation, could well result in the changing of the assessments shown.
4. Overall findings
The following maps show the routes being assessed overlaid against nature conservation designations, heritage designations and the tranquillity map produced for the National Park.
IMAGE: Map of the Yorkshire Dales National Park showing routes with proven or possible motor vehicle rights overlaid with Special Areas of Conservation (SAC), Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI), and Special Protection Areas (SPA). The key identifies SAC, SSSI, SPA, and the routes.
IMAGE: Map of the Yorkshire Dales National Park showing routes with proven or possible motor vehicle rights and Scheduled Ancient Monuments. Scheduled Ancient Monuments are marked in red, routes are shown in black, and the National Park boundary is shown in green.
IMAGE: Map of the Yorkshire Dales National Park showing routes with proven or possible motor vehicle rights and noise buffer zones around railways, motorways, A-roads, B-roads, quarries, and settlements. Noise buffer zones are shaded grey.
The evidence sheets compiled for each route were used to assess each route against the criteria outlined in the methodology report. This leads to each route being given a sensitivity assessment against each category of:
- Nature conservation
- Heritage
- Route surface
- Tranquillity
These are graded as red (high), amber (moderate or unknown) and green (low) in each case. This then gives an overall sensitivity which is taken as the highest assessment in any of the categories.
Table 3. The Sensitivity Assessment summary results (based on the traffic light system)
| Route Name | Reference Number | Ecological Sensitivity | Heritage Sensitivity | Surface Sensitivity | Tranquillity Sensitivity | Overall Sensitivity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bluecaster Side | 1 | Green | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| Garsdale Foot to Barth Bridge | 2 | Amber | Amber | Red | Green | High |
| Castle Bolton to ford | 3 | Green | Green | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Hargill, Carperby | 4 | Green | Green | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Haw Lane | 5 | Green | Green | Green | Green | Low |
| Red Way, Caldbergh | 6 | Amber | Amber | Red | Amber | High |
| West Burton to Penhill Farm | 7 | Green | Green | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Heugh Lane | 8 | Green | Green | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Deadmans Hill | 9 | Amber | Amber | Amber | Red | High |
| Nipe Lane | 10 | Green | Green | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Richmond Gate | 11 | Green | Green | Green | Green | Low |
| Carlton to Middleham High Moor | 12 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High |
| Fancarl | 15 | Green | Green | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Moor Lane, Halton East | 16 | Green | Green | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Ling Chapel | 17 | Green | Amber | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Hanlith to Weets Top (Windy Pike Lane) | 18 | Green | Amber | Red | Amber | High |
| Smearsbottom Lane (Lee Gate) | 19 | Green | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| Arncliffe Cote | 21 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High |
| Dean Moor, Malham | 22 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High |
| Feizor Nick | 23 | Green | Green | Green | Green | Low |
| Banks Lane, Settle | 24 | Green | Green | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Langber Lane | 25 | Green | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| Ling Gill, High Birkwith to Cam End | 26 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High |
| Twistleton Lane | 27 | Green | Amber | Green | Red | High |
| Moor Head Lane, Stainforth | 28 | Green | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| Thwaite Lane | 29 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Lodge Road, Settle | 30 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Tow Scar Lane, Masongill | 31 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Edge Lane | 32 | Green | Green | Green | Red | High |
| Long Lane, Horton-in-Ribblesdale | 33 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High |
| Gorbeck Road | 34 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High |
| Harber Scar Lane (Birkwith Moor) | 35 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High |
| Goatscar Lane | 36 | Green | Green | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| Stockdale Lane, Settle | 37 | Red | Amber | Amber | Red | High |
| Turbary road | 38 | Green | Amber | Red | Amber | High |
| Foxup road & Hesleden Bergh | 39 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High |
| Cam High Road, Far Gearstones to Cam Houses | 40 | Green | Green | Red | Red | High |
| Fremington to Hurst | 42 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Low Lane, Low Whita to Low Houses | 43 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Dubbing Garth Lane | 44 | Green | Amber | Green | Amber | Moderate |
| Arten Gill Moss to Widdle Foot | 45 | Amber | Amber | Red | Amber | High |
| Cam High Road, Fleet Moss to Bainbridge | 46 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High |
| Marsett Bottoms | 47 | Amber | Green | Amber | Red | High |
| Stake Road, Stalling Busk to Cray | 48 | Green | Green | Green | Red | High |
| Bob Lane | 49 | Green | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
| West Cam Road/Cam Road | 50 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High |
| Busk Lane, Bainbridge | 51 | Amber | Green | Amber | Red | High |
| The Highway | 52 | Amber | Amber | Red | Red | High |
| Shaw Paddock | 53 | Green | Amber | Amber | Green | Moderate |
| Dawson Close | 55 | Amber | Amber | Amber | Amber | Moderate |
Overall the sensitivity assessment reveals that of the 102 routes looked at with possible or proven rights for motor vehicles 24 have a high overall sensitivity, 23 have a moderate or unknown sensitivity and 51 have a low sensitivity.
It should be stressed that these routes are considered to be potentially sensitive but that this can only be confirmed with more detailed fieldwork. Conversely routes which have been assessed as having a low or moderate potential sensitivity could still need management. The sensitivity assessment is also not intended to give any guidance on what management measures may be required in any individual case.
5. Prioritisation for further investigation
The table below shows just the 24 routes considered to potentially have a high sensitivity together with their level of use or expected potential demand which are graded as high, moderate and low.
Table 4. Routes considered to be potentially sensitive
| Route Name | Reference Number | Ecological Sensitivity | Heritage Sensitivity | Surface Sensitivity | Tranquillity Sensitivity | Overall Sensitivity | Potential Demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Garsdale Foot to Barth Bridge | 2 | Amber | Amber | Red | Green | High | Low |
| Red Way, Caldbergh | 6 | Amber | Amber | Red | Amber | High | Low |
| Deadmans Hill | 9 | Amber | Amber | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Carlton to Middleham High Moor | 12 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High | Moderate |
| Hanlith to Weets Top (Windy Pike Lane) | 18 | Green | Amber | Red | Amber | High | Low |
| Arncliffe Cote | 21 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
| Dean Moor, Malham | 22 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
| Ling Gill, High Birkwith to Cam End | 26 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Twistleton Lane | 27 | Green | Amber | Green | Red | High | Moderate |
| Edge Lane | 32 | Green | Green | Green | Red | High | Moderate |
| Long Lane, Horton-in-Ribblesdale | 33 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High | Moderate |
| Gorbeck Road | 34 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Harber Scar Lane (Birkwith Moor) | 35 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Stockdale Lane, Settle | 37 | Red | Amber | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Turbary road | 38 | Green | Amber | Red | Amber | High | Low |
| Foxup road & Hesleden Bergh | 39 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High | Moderate |
| Cam High Road, Far Gearstones to Cam Houses | 40 | Green | Green | Red | Red | High | High |
| Arten Gill Moss to Widdle Foot | 45 | Amber | Amber | Red | Amber | High | Moderate |
| Cam High Road, Fleet Moss to Bainbridge | 46 | Green | Green | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Marsett Bottoms | 47 | Amber | Green | Amber | Red | High | Moderate |
| Stake Road, Stalling Busk to Cray | 48 | Green | Green | Green | Red | High | Moderate |
| West Cam Road/Cam Road | 50 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High | Moderate |
| Busk Lane, Bainbridge | 51 | Amber | Green | Amber | Red | High | Moderate |
| The Highway | 52 | Amber | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
There are also five routes in the National Park that are currently closed to recreational motor vehicles by traffic regulation orders. A sensitivity assessment was also conducted on the four of these routes that have possible or proven rights for motor vehicles.
Table 5: routes with traffic regulation order in place
| Route Name | Reference Number | Ecological Sensitivity | Heritage Sensitivity | Surface Sensitivity | Tranquillity Sensitivity | Overall Sensitivity | Potential Demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mastiles Lane | 20 | Red | Red | Red | Red | High | High |
| Forest Road (Pockstones Moor), Appletreewick | 14 | Red | Amber | Green | Red | High | Moderate |
| Long Lane Clapham to Selside | 41 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High | Moderate |
| Horsehead | 54 | Green | Amber | Amber | Red | High | Moderate |
The section of Horsehead Pass considered in the above table is just that which is unclassified county road from Halton Gill to Horsehead Gate at the summit of the pass. This is because the bridleway section to Raisgill has had any possible motor vehicular rights extinguished under the NERC Act. This is also the reason why Starbotton Cam and Topmere have not been considered.
One possible method of prioritising further is to look at which routes were considered sensitive in more than one category.
| Route Name | Reference Number | Ecological Sensitivity | Heritage Sensitivity | Surface Sensitivity | Tranquillity Sensitivity | Overall Vulnerability | Potential Demand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carlton to Middleham High Moor | 12 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High | Moderate |
| Arncliffe Cote | 21 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
| Dean Moor, Malham | 22 | Red | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
| Stockdale Lane, Settle | 37 | Red | Amber | Amber | Red | High | High |
| Foxup road & Hesleden Bergh | 39 | Green | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
| Cam High Road, Far Gearstones to Cam Houses | 40 | Green | Green | Red | Red | High | High |
| The Highway | 52 | Amber | Amber | Red | Red | High | High |
Two of the routes on this list continue beyond the National Park boundary; these are the Red Way and the Highway. The assessment of these and other routes which continue beyond the boundary has involved less detailed information for the sections beyond the Park boundary although this is unlikely to affect the sensitivity assessment.
Other factors may also be considered important to the prioritisation of routes:
- Level of use
- Whether the route has a BOAT application or case
6. Guide to jargon
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Site of special scientific interest (SSSI) | SSSIs are the country's very best wildlife and geological sites. They include some of our most spectacular and beautiful habitats including heather-clad heathlands, flower-rich meadows, and remote uplands moorland and peat bog. |
| Special area of conservation (SAC) | This is a European designation. Compared with other designations SACs tend to be large, often covering a number of separate but related sites. Almost all UK SACs are based on Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI). In planning law, they are effectively afforded the highest possible protection. |
| Specially protected area (SPA) | This is a European designation. The EC Directive on the Conservation of Wild Birds is designed to protect wild birds, and includes selection of areas most suitable for them to be designated Special Protection Areas (SPAs). All SPAs are also SSSIs. |
| Environmentally sensitive area (ESA) | Introduced in 1987 to offer incentives to encourage farmers to adopt agricultural practices which safeguard and enhance parts of the countryside of particularly high landscape, wildlife or historic value. The scheme has now closed. |
| Limestone pavement order | This is a designation under the Wildlife and Countryside Act which protects areas of limestone pavement from damage or removal of the limestone. |
| Scheduled ancient monument | Scheduling is currently the only mechanism for legal protection specifically for archaeological sites. The word 'monument' covers the whole range of archaeological sites. Scheduled monuments are not always ancient, or visible above ground. |
| National nature reserve (NNR) | National Nature Reserves (NNRs) are places where wildlife comes first. They were established to protect the most important areas of wildlife habitat and geological formations in Britain, and as places for scientific research. This does not mean they are ‘no-go areas’ for people. It means that we must be careful not to damage the wildlife of these fragile places. It means that every NNR is ‘nationally important’ and that they are all among the best examples of a particular habitat. It also means that NNRs are carefully managed on behalf of the nation. They are either owned or controlled by Natural England or held by approved bodies such as Wildlife Trusts. |
IMAGE: Guide to jargon presented as a two-column table, with environmental and heritage designations in the left column and their definitions in the right column.