Creating a Neighbourhood Plan
2025 -2030
IMAGE: Cover slide for “Creating a Neighbourhood Plan 2025 -2030”. It includes the text “Clapham cum Newby: A strong sustainable community” and a snowy landscape photograph with a wading bird standing on rocks.
Background
- 2008 Parish Plan
- Clapham Conservation Area Appraisal
- The idea promoted through the Parish Council.
- New development and community sustainability
Timeline
- February 2018 — First Public Meeting to agree to proceed
- March 2019 — Survey and Report
- June 2021 — First Draft Plan
- September 2025 — The Plan is formerly adopted following a Referendum
Phases
- First Steps
- Developing the Plan
- Consultation and amendments
- Ratification and the Referendum
Lessons Learnt
IMAGE: Map titled “Clapham cum Newby Designated Neighbourhood Plan Boundary”, showing the designated neighbourhood plan area around Clapham, Newby and Keasden, the parish and neighbourhood plan area boundary, local planning authority boundaries, and the Forest of Bowland National Landscape. The map includes a scale, north arrow and a legend identifying Clapham, Keasden, Newby, the Yorkshire Dales National Park LPA, the parish and neighbourhood plan area boundary, the Forest of Bowland National Landscape, and the former Craven District Council LPA.
First Steps
- Open meeting and agreement to proceed
- The Steering Group
- Member of PC
- Editor / proof reader
- Financial background / treasurer
- Local historian.
- Planning knowledge
- Others within the community with skills (e.g photographer / website)
- ‘Locality’ Road Map and Grants
- Other Neighbourhood Plans
- Designation of the Neighbourhood Area
- Autumn 2018 - Community Consultation events across the Parish
- 2019 Plan Survey – you said, we did
https://www.claphamplan.net/vision
https://neighbourhoodplanning.org/
IMAGE: The “Neighbourhood Plans Roadmap: A Step-by-Step Guide, 2018 edition”, published by Locality and written by Dave Chetwyn, is shown alongside the “First Steps” content. The cover includes the text “Neighbourhood Planning”, “Neighbourhood Plans Roadmap”, “A Step-by-Step Guide”, “2018 edition”, “Written by Dave Chetwyn MA, MRTPI, IHBC, FInSFLM”, and “neighbourhoodplanning.org”.
Plan Survey
- Population has decreased from 640 in 2011 to 610 in 2021.
- 65% of CcN’s population are between the ages of 45-84.
- The proportion of people aged 65 and over has increased to 34% and is expected to increase 53%, by 2032.
- The Census indicates that housing is significantly under occupied and 72% of households now comprise of only 1 or 2 persons.
The Clapham Neighbourhood Plan Survey Results identified two clear housing need themes:
- affordable homes for young people
- accommodation for older people seeking to downsize
- the importance of linking new housing with the development of employment opportunities, and that development needs to be managed to ensure that it is appropriate for its location.
IMAGE: The slide shows a proof copy of the “Clapham, Newby and Keasden Parish Plan 2008” and a housing questionnaire headed “Housing - All Residents”. The questionnaire contains questions about affordable housing, housing costs, benefits, and preferred types of new housing. Some smaller text is not legible.
IMAGE: Screenshot of the Clapham Neighbourhood Plan website. The navigation menu reads “Home”, “About”, “Draft Plan”, “News”, “Events”, “Survey”, “Downloads”, and “More”. The page is headed “Vision” and reads: “Clapham cum Newby Parish has a strong community, a distinctive character and exceptional surrounding countryside. Our vision looks to protect and enhance these values through sensible, sustainable and sympathetic development, promoting a safe, healthy and balanced community within a high-quality landscape.
“This approach will provide appropriate and affordable homes for families, single people and older residents. It will also attract businesses to the area, encourage local employment and seek to deliver enhanced services to make Clapham a place where people, businesses, tourism and the environment thrive.
“The vision for Clapham is being developed in consultation with the community and is based on the 2018 meetings held at Newby, Keasden and Clapham. This will be refined as we progress through the process and identify key priorities.”
The page menu also includes “Vision”, “Plan”, “Why”, “Objective”, “Influence”, “Preparation”, and “Who”.
Covid
- Between March 2020 and March 2021 we were unable to hold any in person Community Consultation events.
- All Steering Group Meetings were held online.
IMAGE: Slide headed “Covid”, with a cartoon coronavirus character holding a red “STOP” sign. The image communicates the interruption to in-person community consultation caused by the Covid pandemic.
Themes and Developing the Plan
- June 2021 First Draft of the Plan
- September 2021 - Focus Groups with external facilitator to encourage honest feedback.
- Housing
- Built and Historic
- Natural Environment
- Economy and Business
- Community Facilities
- Communications Infrastructure
- Sustainable Travel
- Appendices including; Design Guide; Heritage Assets and Natural Environment and Land Classification and Local Green Spaces and Facilities
IMAGE: Three photographs illustrate the plan themes: a village with historic buildings and landscaped paths, a train at a railway station, and the interior of a traditional building containing tables and chairs.
Feedback and Amendments
- Early 2022 — Comments back from YDNPA & CDC.
- June 2022 — AECOM Site Options Assessment. Already achieved the allocation in exg. Local Plans.
- Autumn 2022 — Review of draft Plan by external planning consultants.
- Early 2023 — Amendments to the Plan following feedback from consultants.
- Spring 2023 — Pre-submission Open Consultation including public drop-in sessions.
- Early 2023 — Further amendments following feedback from consultation.
- Nov/Dec 2023 — Formal consultation period, followed by further amendments.
- 2024 — Assessment Screening by YDNPA and Review by Inspector.
- 2025 — Final adjustments and Referendum
IMAGE: Aerial map showing proposed or assessed site areas around Clapham, marked with red outlines and labels including CNP1, CNP2, CNP3, CNP4, CNP5, CNP6, CNP7, CNP8, CNP9, CNP10, CNP11, CNP12, CNP13 and CNP14. A referendum poster reads “Clapham cum Newby Neighbourhood Plan Referendum - 18 September 2025”, “and around Clapham Village”, “To find out more: Google: YDNPA Clapham Plan Telephone: 015242 51862, or email: parishclerk.claphamcumnewby@gmail.com”, and “Vote YES to help make Clapham even better!”
Costs and Consultants
- Grants available through Locality (national membership network for community organisations in England) with the option of grants or technical support.
- Financial help for the community develop the plan themselves, with technical support funding for external consultants.
- 4 rounds of grants applied for at different stages with £19,588 awarded, £15,169 used.
- Basic costs for printing, promotion, room hire etc.
- Other costs - Website
- Consultants – Facilitator / Planning Consultants / Design Guide / Heritage Assets
- Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government NOT commissioning new neighbourhood planning support services from 2025
IMAGE: The Locality logo is shown with the words “Locality” and “the power of community”.
Lessons Learnt - Challenges
- Neighbourhood Plan Area over two separate Planning Authorities (and two separate local plans).
- Not all issues were planning related matters. (Aspirations).
- Whilst it was a ‘Neighbourhood Plan’ it had to conform with existing legislation in the form of Planning Authority Local Plans and National Plan Policy.
- Discovered that supported affordable housing schemes are only available for project having a minimum size of 10 dwellings. Clapham does not have the space for such a project, despite the Survey suggesting the need.
- Resist the pressure to designate sites, with emphasis on defining need.
- Difficulty in connecting with younger demographic.
- Priorities change over the period of developing the Plan.
- Frustration at some slow response from external bodies, but at a number of important stages YDNPA provided important assistance with the process, HER team, maps etc.
Lessons Learnt - Recommendations
- The importance of engaging the Community.
- Policies should be informed by the Community ‘You said - We did’
- Help with the facilitation and consultation early-on (survey)
- Need to study and understand existing Local and National Plan Policy.
- What is it that makes it locally distinctive.
- “The Policy on designated heritage assets really stands out. The plan identifies buildings and other heritage assets which are not listed or scheduled but which are important to the heritage of the parish and which local people want to protect from harmful development and ideally enhance.”
- The Local Design Guide
- Keep a log of activities and changes to the plan.
- Missed opportunities - Community Energy
- “The NP identifies some of the main threats to community sustainability such as the aging population and the lack of affordable housing. The weakness in the Plan is not offering any specific solution. But neither is anyone else directly and these are long term and systemic issues that affect a much wider area of NY and which ultimately require solutions that go a long way beyond local Planning policy.”
IMAGE: A page from “Appendix 1 | Clapham cum Newby Design Guide” is shown. The page discusses materials and surface finishes, new build, walls and existing buildings, and includes photographs captioned “Flush pointing limestone”, “Semi-dressed and coursed gritstone with sandstone dressings”, “Left: lime roughcast render & sash window Right: rubble stonework & casement window”, and “Smooth render lined out to imitate stonework”.
Timeline
- 2008
- February 2018 — Open Meeting in Village Hall and establishment of Steering Group
- Spring/ summer 2018 — Start up meeting of Steering Group / Stand at Clapham Village Fete
- October / November 2018 — 3no. Community Consultation events across the Parish
- March 2019 — Parish Survey questionnaire (60% response rate) and analysis of survey results by external facilitator
- September 2019 — Formal approval Parish Council area as a Neighbourhood Planning area
- 2020 — Further development of a plan, but Covid prevents public consultation.
- June 2021 — First draft of Plan
- September / October 2021 — 3no. Focus Group days run by an external facilitator
- Early 2022 — Comments back from YDNPA & CD
- May - June 2022 — AECOM Housing Needs Analysis
- Autumn 2022 — Review of draft Plan by external planning consultants (Stephenson Haliday)
- Early 2023 — Amendments to the Plan following feedback from consultants
- March to May 2023 — Pre-submission open consultation in including public drop in sessions
- September 2023 — Submission of Documents for consideration
- November/Dec 2023 — Formal consultation period, followed by further amendments
- May 2024 — YDNPA Strategic Environmental Assessment Screening Report
- September 2024 — External Examiner’s Report on the Plan
- 18 September 2025 — Referendum - majority of 153 to 13 votes